Re:Distributism
by tonyedgecombe on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:00AM
(#19542099)
I would have assumed for it as the EU is clearly another form of centralised government and favours businesses that trade across borders so are larger. But when it comes to Brexit all bets are off.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I run a 200,000€ revenue company that sells physical goods across the EU. Large companies have the resources to do the paperwork to sell across customs borders, I don’t.
In this sense, the EU is more helpful to small companies than large ones. It effectively removes borders.
On the other hand, without the unified market, governments can engage in protectionism, and if they do, there's less of a chance that a small business will be crushed by a giant global competitor.
Re:Distributism
by bobthechef on Monday April 01, 2019 @03:03PM
(#19546887)
That's too simplistic. There are large differences between countries in the East and the West. Western corporations have had a field day in the EU's Eastern members precisely because of the relative economic advantages they have built up over 50 years following WWII and the massive restructuring of the economies of the Eastern members following the fall of communism. Free trade really only works when countries have some kind of parity (something Friedrich List argues). However, to the East's advantage, their economies are much more dynamic and the West is increasingly stagnating.
Re:Distributism
by vanderZwan on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:57AM
(#19543249)
> favours businesses that trade across borders so are larger
You are right about the first part of that sentence, but wrong about the second. In many contexts the EU makes the international market more accessible for small businesses - it greatly reduces overhead that large companies can afford and small companies cannot.
For example, having one central safety or health standard for all countries is a lot cheaper than qualifying for each country on an individual basis. That benefits every business involved, but for smaller ones this fixed overhead is a much more significant hurdle than for big ones.
While this is all true, there is a tendency that big markets create big players. Eg. in the 1950s/60s, many European countries had several independent car manufacturers. The cheap car in your country may have been worse than a cheap car of your neighboring country, but it cost less for the lack of tariffs. The local manufacturer had your business. When the borders came down, the smaller companies could no longer compete.
The general pattern is that big markets create big players, but also increase the amount of "effective" diversity and competition at the local level. The smaller automakers of the 1950s and 1960s were essentially monopolies in their own countries; whereas with the borders coming down, manufacturers are incented to both compete and diversify in a meaningful way, so that some fraction of them can hold on to their share of the bigger, unified market.
Re:Distributism
by heavenlyblue on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:11PM
(#19545563)
>> Eg. in the 1950s/60s, many European countries had several independent car manufacturers.
The chance is that your point has nothing to do with the borders being open though.
Borders were certainly not the only factor. As car development became more expensive, only bigger players had the capital to do it. But different national regulations (eg in France head lights had to be yellow instead of white) and tariffs played a role.
Not sure that was necessarily a good thing. Were I a consumer in a country with a crappy car manufacturer, I'd definitely not be pleased that I couldn't buy a better car simply because my government was protecting the crappy car manufacturer's business.