Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by tomc1985 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:56AM
(#19536234)
The downside of accessibility -- now, everyone has a voice, even if they shouldn't. I never thought I'd be saying this but I am beginning to miss the curation created by high costs of entry.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by balfirevic on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:54PM
(#19536615)
> now, everyone has a voice, even if they shouldn't
Can you elaborate on this? I mean the part that someone shouldn't have a voice. By what mechanism should we take or deny someone a voice?
Perhaps you meant it as nothing more than a casual remark, in a "I just wish the world was somehow magically different" way. But I think it's really important to think about what actual mechanisms are we desiring be implemented in that world, and what such a world would look like.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by tomc1985 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:17PM
(#19538455)
Then we are in disagreement. For every worthy, previously unvoiced opinion, there are five more that would not spread beyond a room full of kooks had the internet (Twitter, Facebook) not given then a global platform. You had to work a lot harder to encounter those sorts of fringe; now every idea, good or bad, is shoved in our faces regardless of its merit. Algorithmic curation is doing a terrible job of containing that
I'm not mentioning names since I'm sure everyone's list of "ideas that should have stayed dead" is different, but you get the idea. The commonalities amongst that list between different people can form the basis for a metric for which ideas should be rebroadcast and which should be allowed to die
To rephrase my point, we are denying ourselves a beneficial natural selection by giving everyone a potentially global voice
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by balfirevic on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:29PM
(#19538529)
> Then we are in disagreement
What disagreement? I did not even make any statements or expressed opinion on whether it's good (whatever that might mean) that everyone has a voice (at least in my reply to you). I simply asked:
> By what mechanism should we take or deny someone a voice?
Without that we are simply daydreaming about how everything would be better if only things were better. Which is OK, just not very useful if you stop there.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by kuzimoto on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:50PM
(#19537001)
Not OP so I can only speculate, but perhaps something like in order to get content online you had to either have the ability and know-how to run a website yourself, or work for an organization like newspaper, journal, etc. I think traditionally, news organisations are able to output higher quality of information backed by research, reputable sources, etc.
Today anyone can post any random thought on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, etc and have that viewed and shared anywhere from dozens to millions of times regardless of how accurate, insightful, truthful it really is.
Now the onus is more on the reader to double-check and verify what they are reading since there is simply so much garbage.
Certainly there are benefits as well, where people who have something important to share can do so easily, unfortunately I think it's easy to be drowned out by all the noise.
It's certainly hard to argue that you should take away any "one" voice as that would be unconstitutional, but maybe there should be better ways of filtering information for each individual so they don't have to see stuff they don't want to.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by balfirevic on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:05PM
(#19537098)
> It's certainly hard to argue that you should take away any "one" voice as that would be unconstitutional, but maybe there should be better ways of filtering information for each individual so they don't have to see stuff they don't want to.
Yeah, I think it's hopeless (at best) or totalitarian (at worst) to try to stop people from putting stuff online. You mention that the filter used to exist before (such as working for news organization or being able to run a website), but that's an unstable state of affairs - as soon as someone creates Twitter you have to either accept it's existence or take it down.
So only possible way to improve things is to create tools and know-how on information consumer side - filtering tools, easy way to check references and a habit to actually do it, good discussion platforms, etc. Anything else is a cure far worse than disease.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by AstralStorm on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:51AM
(#19540600)
The thing is, how do you prevent stagnation? People equate good platforms to ones where they have a degree of control, which results in atomic communities. Self reinforcing if you let them.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by balfirevic on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:03AM
(#19540641)
When you say atomic communities, do you mean something like echo chambers? Yeah, it happens. It's OK for it to happen to some degree - there needs to be some amount of shared common understanding between participants to have a useful discussion [0].
But if common ground is only thing that's left, you have an echo chamber. How to dial this in? I have no idea. HN seems to do this better than most, although some topics fare better than others.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by WillPostForFood on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:40PM
(#19536930)
Things aren't worse now, the author even acknowledges things are the same as they always have been:
it was in the arts section and it was about a group of black artists who were suddenly being recognized in their 70s and 80s. It was a frustrating read, a sort of too-little-too-late scenario because, sure, it’s always nice to get half a million dollars for your work, but where was the money when you were actually producing the work, while supporting a family and paying a mortgage, with many decades of life ahead of you? When you could run to speaking engagements instead of rolling to them? “The kind of elation I may have had back 30 years, I’m past that point,” 75-year-old artist Howardena Pindell said. Where was all of this back in 1989? Oh, right, Robert Mapplethorpe, Jean-Michel Basquiat, Jeff Koons — guess they took up the allotted spots.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by MrEldritch on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:02PM
(#19548774)
I'm not sure that's true. From my perspective, it seems like the golden age of creation may have been a few years ago - peaking around, say, the 2009-early10's-ish region. When stuff like Flash was big, but the Internet was still pretty experimental and not quite as cordoned off into walled gardens and laser-guided algorithmic ad-friendly-filtered channels, and the really big-budget content creators and networks hadn't quite rolled in yet. You had tons of people making absolute crap, but it was inventive crap, and some of it wasn't crap at all.
When was the last time you saw anything as weird, experimental, and creative as, say, Homestuck? (Which was a huge multimedia webcomic...thing combining art, music, Flash animations, small interactive games, and a deeply ridiculous story centered around time travel and the meaning of online friendships.)
Or something like Homestar Runner?
What's the best webcomic you've found that was started in the past 5 years? The best new blog?
YouTube's been getting increasingly dry and filtered as ad scare after ad scare forces people to tone down their content - even things like science channels have been getting hit for seeming too dangerous. The move off of forums and blogs to content platforms means that the kinds of expression that are even possible is increasingly restricted. Across the whole web, the rise of higher-budget and more-professional stuff has been discouraging and driving out weird amateur crap from getting started in the first place - meaning that it never develops into higher-quality stuff that would bring those novel ideas to a shine.
It's easier than ever to find polished content, but the diversity of that content is usually less, and still shrinking.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by fzeroracer on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:24PM
(#19537719)
The downside of living in a 'golden age of creation' is that said creation is also taken advantage of by unscrupulous actors looking to take advantage of users by flooding content gateways with scam artist level content.
Steam for example has had to deal with people embedding miners in their games, asset flips and games designed for the sake of selling cards on the digital marketplace.
Youtube has auto-generated videos designed to take advantage of their recommendation algorithm to reach people that are less capable of curating content themselves like kids. Not to mention the algorithmic rabbit hole you can be taken down leading into extreme conspiracy theory territory and viewbots which push non-popular content out of the way.
And I could talk at lengths at how companies abuse the various app stores by creating keyword spaghetti such as 'Fortnight Battle Royale Mini Battleground Survival' designed in order to fool people while making money off of a barrage of in-game ads. Without curation, you're accepting that a certain portion of your users are going to be scammers and that some users will be scammed. Whether it's through gaming the views, the search engine or the recommendation algorithms.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by i_am_proteus on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:01PM
(#19536269)
I have similar sentiments; I wonder if there's any future for paid, curated content given society's invention and use of pejorative terms (paywalls!) for publishers who restrict their content to paid subscribers. It's not like we were just paying for the ink and paper back in 1993.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by MrEldritch on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:07PM
(#19548818)
I've heard a theory that the very idea of paid, curated media content was kind of a relatively recent invention, and that what we're seeing is just the move back to the same model that had previously funded art of all kinds throughout history - patronage. (Or to be precise: Patreonage.)
I've seen a lot of people discovering that Patreon-model support can be way more successful for them than ad support. People don't like to pay for free shit - in the age of Zero Marginal Cost, paying for digital goods always makes me feel like a bit of a sucker, but I suck it up and do it because I don't want to break the incentive structure by not rewarding the creator for their work. And I do want the creator to be rewarded.
Divorcing the two - giving out free stuff, and also providing a way to directly toss someone a continuing stream of money to help them make this stuff based on how much I value making that happen - would seem to be the perfect compromise.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by CM30 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:24PM
(#19537718)
Hard to say. There's definitely a future for curated content; Hacker News, Reddit etc are basically that. As are numerous newsletters, blog articles and videos listing interesting or underrated resources and creators.
Charging for that seems like it could theoretically work, though the key would be that you'd have to A: have a solid audience in mind who'd be likely to consider decent curation valuable enough to pay for and B: be extremely good at selecting resources to show people, to the point there's no way in hell they could find all the stuff shown off themselves.
It'd be a challenge, but I think it could be possible. Hell, I think something like this could probably work quite well in the SEO or digital marketing world, just because of how much bullshit there is online and how hard it can be to find the good stuff.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by AstralStorm on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:53AM
(#19540610)
Are they really curated? What they actually are is a reflection of community of people inhabiting then, posting and upvoting.
Being a curator implies a degree of objectivity and skill more than getting votes. Including building a cohesive whole.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by tomc1985 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:21PM
(#19536376)
I'm thinking more of Youtube, or Instagram, which dramatically lowered the cost of publishing visual media, or Spotify and other digital download stores, which helped make the cost of publishing music almost nothing (Tunecore, etc). Youtube in particular seems to be flooded with crap
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by malvosenior on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:53PM
(#19537021)
Youtube is filled with amazing content. You can learn how to do almost anything by watching Youtube videos. It's probably the most amazing content library created in all of human history. Would you really rather go back to "57 channels and nothing on"? More Emeril and Wheel of Fortune?
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by ams6110 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:24PM
(#19537716)
It's both. There's lots of great stuff on YouTube and there's lots of crap on YouTube. I think the same was true with record stores, bookstores, and libraries in the physical world.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by AstralStorm on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:55AM
(#19540619)
Specialty libraries do get curated by librarians who are at least versed in the subject matter.
Not sure about general ones, probably too. That's the difference between archives and libraries.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by briga on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:07PM
(#19536300)
The problem is that there's just too much out there--too many books, movies, TV shows, news articles, blog posts. No one has time to keep up with it, so some sort of cultural selection process is necessary. The only content that can stand out is content that can get views, and it just so happens that a lot of that content is the same. Until we have more platforms that don't rely on ads to keep those engagement rates high I think we're stuck with this situation. Maybe it's just an inevitable by-product of a world where anyone can produce anything and instantly publish it for the whole world to see.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by ip26 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:45PM
(#19537883)
I would argue that the infrastructure we have could do a much better job of discoverability & catering to a variety of interests. Selection is good & necessary, but none of the big news players have been able to figure out that I'm far more interested in Tommy Caldwell than Kim Kardashian, so to this day pop entertainment headlines I never visit continue to scroll past. Tailoring to interests could broaden the range of useful content that generates views.
I eventually went back to RSS, picked feeds from twenty or so minor news sources focused on my interests, and in general I'm much more satisfied. I eventually started using Pocket as well to retain a small trickle of "best of", which has the best ratio of interesting headlines (to me) I've encountered in an aggregator.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by doctorpangloss on Sunday March 31, 2019 @07:45PM
(#19539253)
Discoverability has long ago reduced to collaborative filtering.
It works because it services majority tastes specifically at the expense of minority ones.
Put another way, imagine you’re a PM trying to make a chart go up and to the right. Here’s a magic algorithm that gives you best users more of what they want, and ones for whom the product doesn’t work no reason to stick around so they leave.
An increasing numerator with a decreasing denominator. That’s a hyperbolic upwards curve! Promote that PM! You let the prisoners run the asylum in this case, choosing which metrics they will be evaluated on, that totally runs counter to the whole point of building platforms.
As long as your inbound user count exceeds churn due to booting out people with minority tastes—which a PM EXTREMELY RARELY had anything to do with—the PM’s career takes off.
No dude, discoverability as it is defined by every tech company is killing culture. And it’s Product Management that’s holding the knife.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by MrEldritch on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:46PM
(#19548641)
I don't buy this argument - specifically, I don't buy that there are normbie pleb users with "majority tastes" as opposed to the patricians with refined, elite "minority tastes."
Everybody has some minority tastes. Everyone's got their own long tail of stuff they like. Obviously there's stuff that's more popular than other stuff - otherwise they wouldn't be majority tastes - but it's not like someone who watches Jimmy Kimmel on Youtube therefore doesn't also enjoy, like, woodworking channels.
The difference is, I guess, what you're willing to settle for - if the algorithm discovers you like a thing that's easy to find more of, it will really start shoving that in your face, because it's easy, and if you're not persistent enough to keep seeking out specialty content despite the tide, then the popular stuff is what you're going to get.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by tarsinge on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:02PM
(#19537084)
There always was too much out there in the last decades, and a majority of people looking for "universally good" things, reassured by knowing that everyone else approves it and enjoys it. Now it's just more optimized, we get similar content that get the most clicks, the majority of people is perfectly happy with that, and for people looking for more original content there is an endless supply on the indie side for their favorite niche. I'm not sure I see the problem.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by briga on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:05PM
(#19537572)
The way I see it, when everybody consumes the same media everybody starts to have the same thoughts. Which isn't a bad thing, per se, but it's the sort of thing that leads to political polarization and close-mindedness. Groups of people make better decisions when they have different ideas and can come up with better solutions for problems. Strong democracies and economies are made by independent individuals, not identical crowds of people.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by gerbilly on Sunday March 31, 2019 @06:32PM
(#19538862)
>The problem is that there's just too much out there--too many books, movies, TV shows, news articles, blog posts. No one has time to keep up with it, so some sort of cultural selection process is necessary.
I understand, but it’s more than that.
I mean pretty soon, if you ask a kid to describe what a movie is, they might say a long video with eight to ten superheroes in it.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by 3xblah on Sunday March 31, 2019 @07:18PM
(#19539116)
It is an inevitable byproduct of a world that has access to a free copy/fax machine where anyone can reproduce anything that can be digitized and the whole world can receive a copy.
The "sameness" makes the technical burden easier for anyone who develops a search engine. If more searches had to be treated as "unique" this would require more resources and more time to complete. Sameness allows results to be returned faster.
Thus Google and others providing "search" are invcentivized to facilitate what you call the "cultural selection" process, i.e. selection by popularity. This article reflects a common view that this process is not adequate for all type of "content".
In the early days of web search engines, sites like AltaVista or later Google, would include a line on the results page boasting about the number of returned results and the number of pages searched, drawing attention to the size of their database and presumably the variety it would contain.
The irony of this is that we see now that Google, and any other who followed their lead, does not want nor expect people rapidly digging deep into search results. The majority of queries they receive are repeat queries. They would prefer and they expect that users be content with a "top search result", never moving beyond "page one". This not only lessens the technical burden, it can be presented as "what people want", they can portray this as the optimal "experience" for the user. Whereas someone who keeps digging and digging for more would draw suspicion and be blocked. Genuine curiousity, often a hallmark of intelligence, is not accounted for.
The system is geared toward delivering the sameness that purportedly all (e.g., 80% of) users want, as efficiently as possible. They offer no option (for the remaining 20%) to sort all results alphabetically, by date, or some other field or to download a list of all results to do this offline. Even sorting by "relevance" is a non-transparent process. It is not a disclosed algorithm and we are not allowed to do our own relevance filtering on raw results. What we get has already been pre-filtered. Advertisers pay the bills.
If the majority of users never reach page two, then an ad at the top of page one can command a higher price. The order of results is all-important. The user is not allowed to control the order.
"Everything is on the web" and yet doing "real" research -- as, e.g., one would using a databse in a library - is, 30 years on, still nigh impossible. Advertising is the problem, as the Google founders published in their search engine paper announcing Google in the 1990's. Alas, they later found advertising was the solution... to commercializing what was originally meant to be academic.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by rchaud on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:41PM
(#19536513)
You know how every couple of months there's an article posted on HN about why web design feels so generic today? The responses are usually of the "people want a familiar UX" and "design that doesn't convert isn't worth anything".
That same assumption is playing out in the world of web content strategy. What is the incentive to write about obscure topics when keywords like "Netflix", "Marie Kondo", "Trump" etc will near-guarantee more shares, more clicks and more ad impressions?
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by egypturnash on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:16PM
(#19536342)
I'm thinking about end of this piece, where it briefly discusses some artists who are finding some measure of fame and fortune in their seventies and eighties.
And I'm thinking about a story I saw here a little earlier this morning about a guy who built his gleefully stupid idea of "a dating site for fans of Kanye West" into something that got him a meeting with that star. [1]
And I'm thinking about The KLF's "The Manual: How To Have A Number One The Easy Way" [2] and how much that Kanye-dating story reminded me of the parts of that which weren't specifically about the nuts and bolts of making a pop song for eighties Britain.
And I don't necessarily have any conclusions. Something about the role of advertising in our culture to grab attention, to tell people that hey, this thing you might like exists, and to repeatedly tell them that until they actually bother having a look at the thing [3] and maybe deciding they like it enough to tell other people about it and maybe even give you a little money for the thing, and how hard it is to keep doing that when you're focused on honing your craft and doing the best whatever-it-is you can do around the demands of keeping a roof over your head, and who the hell can find time to do all that advertising, let alone learn how to do it effectively.
And you know who has the money to pay people to do all that advertising? Mostly people working for the megacorporations that squat over our cultural landscape, making work that walks a fine line between being new enough to be different, but close enough to existing successful work to be able to get funding.
And once again I want to start that Kickstarter to dig up the corpse of Jesse Helms and do terrible things to him in vengeance for his role in gutting the NEA that I keep making jokes about lately.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by int_19h on Monday April 01, 2019 @06:00PM
(#19548764)
It can be if you want it to. The problem is that it's a library big enough that you can spend your entire life wandering, and still only see a small part of it.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness
by foobarbecue on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @01:45AM
(#19551378)
How? I want shelves full of curated but not necessarily popular material, organized by dewey decimal system so that I can physically step through subjects. The closest thing I can think of online is wikipedia, and that's a long way off.
https://bust.com/books/16795-penny-dreadfuls-and-moral-panic...
Can you elaborate on this? I mean the part that someone shouldn't have a voice. By what mechanism should we take or deny someone a voice?
Perhaps you meant it as nothing more than a casual remark, in a "I just wish the world was somehow magically different" way. But I think it's really important to think about what actual mechanisms are we desiring be implemented in that world, and what such a world would look like.
I'm not mentioning names since I'm sure everyone's list of "ideas that should have stayed dead" is different, but you get the idea. The commonalities amongst that list between different people can form the basis for a metric for which ideas should be rebroadcast and which should be allowed to die
To rephrase my point, we are denying ourselves a beneficial natural selection by giving everyone a potentially global voice
What disagreement? I did not even make any statements or expressed opinion on whether it's good (whatever that might mean) that everyone has a voice (at least in my reply to you). I simply asked:
> By what mechanism should we take or deny someone a voice?
Without that we are simply daydreaming about how everything would be better if only things were better. Which is OK, just not very useful if you stop there.
Today anyone can post any random thought on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, etc and have that viewed and shared anywhere from dozens to millions of times regardless of how accurate, insightful, truthful it really is.
Now the onus is more on the reader to double-check and verify what they are reading since there is simply so much garbage.
Certainly there are benefits as well, where people who have something important to share can do so easily, unfortunately I think it's easy to be drowned out by all the noise.
It's certainly hard to argue that you should take away any "one" voice as that would be unconstitutional, but maybe there should be better ways of filtering information for each individual so they don't have to see stuff they don't want to.
Yeah, I think it's hopeless (at best) or totalitarian (at worst) to try to stop people from putting stuff online. You mention that the filter used to exist before (such as working for news organization or being able to run a website), but that's an unstable state of affairs - as soon as someone creates Twitter you have to either accept it's existence or take it down.
So only possible way to improve things is to create tools and know-how on information consumer side - filtering tools, easy way to check references and a habit to actually do it, good discussion platforms, etc. Anything else is a cure far worse than disease.
But if common ground is only thing that's left, you have an echo chamber. How to dial this in? I have no idea. HN seems to do this better than most, although some topics fare better than others.
[0] - https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/HLqWn5LASfhhArZ7w/expecting-...
it was in the arts section and it was about a group of black artists who were suddenly being recognized in their 70s and 80s. It was a frustrating read, a sort of too-little-too-late scenario because, sure, it’s always nice to get half a million dollars for your work, but where was the money when you were actually producing the work, while supporting a family and paying a mortgage, with many decades of life ahead of you? When you could run to speaking engagements instead of rolling to them? “The kind of elation I may have had back 30 years, I’m past that point,” 75-year-old artist Howardena Pindell said. Where was all of this back in 1989? Oh, right, Robert Mapplethorpe, Jean-Michel Basquiat, Jeff Koons — guess they took up the allotted spots.
Since there are quite many such places left, I cannot really emphasis with this position, to be honest. Access is a personal choice.
When was the last time you saw anything as weird, experimental, and creative as, say, Homestuck? (Which was a huge multimedia webcomic...thing combining art, music, Flash animations, small interactive games, and a deeply ridiculous story centered around time travel and the meaning of online friendships.)
Or something like Homestar Runner?
What's the best webcomic you've found that was started in the past 5 years? The best new blog?
YouTube's been getting increasingly dry and filtered as ad scare after ad scare forces people to tone down their content - even things like science channels have been getting hit for seeming too dangerous. The move off of forums and blogs to content platforms means that the kinds of expression that are even possible is increasingly restricted. Across the whole web, the rise of higher-budget and more-professional stuff has been discouraging and driving out weird amateur crap from getting started in the first place - meaning that it never develops into higher-quality stuff that would bring those novel ideas to a shine.
It's easier than ever to find polished content, but the diversity of that content is usually less, and still shrinking.
Steam for example has had to deal with people embedding miners in their games, asset flips and games designed for the sake of selling cards on the digital marketplace.
Youtube has auto-generated videos designed to take advantage of their recommendation algorithm to reach people that are less capable of curating content themselves like kids. Not to mention the algorithmic rabbit hole you can be taken down leading into extreme conspiracy theory territory and viewbots which push non-popular content out of the way.
And I could talk at lengths at how companies abuse the various app stores by creating keyword spaghetti such as 'Fortnight Battle Royale Mini Battleground Survival' designed in order to fool people while making money off of a barrage of in-game ads. Without curation, you're accepting that a certain portion of your users are going to be scammers and that some users will be scammed. Whether it's through gaming the views, the search engine or the recommendation algorithms.
I've seen a lot of people discovering that Patreon-model support can be way more successful for them than ad support. People don't like to pay for free shit - in the age of Zero Marginal Cost, paying for digital goods always makes me feel like a bit of a sucker, but I suck it up and do it because I don't want to break the incentive structure by not rewarding the creator for their work. And I do want the creator to be rewarded.
Divorcing the two - giving out free stuff, and also providing a way to directly toss someone a continuing stream of money to help them make this stuff based on how much I value making that happen - would seem to be the perfect compromise.
Charging for that seems like it could theoretically work, though the key would be that you'd have to A: have a solid audience in mind who'd be likely to consider decent curation valuable enough to pay for and B: be extremely good at selecting resources to show people, to the point there's no way in hell they could find all the stuff shown off themselves.
It'd be a challenge, but I think it could be possible. Hell, I think something like this could probably work quite well in the SEO or digital marketing world, just because of how much bullshit there is online and how hard it can be to find the good stuff.
I eventually went back to RSS, picked feeds from twenty or so minor news sources focused on my interests, and in general I'm much more satisfied. I eventually started using Pocket as well to retain a small trickle of "best of", which has the best ratio of interesting headlines (to me) I've encountered in an aggregator.
It works because it services majority tastes specifically at the expense of minority ones.
Put another way, imagine you’re a PM trying to make a chart go up and to the right. Here’s a magic algorithm that gives you best users more of what they want, and ones for whom the product doesn’t work no reason to stick around so they leave.
An increasing numerator with a decreasing denominator. That’s a hyperbolic upwards curve! Promote that PM! You let the prisoners run the asylum in this case, choosing which metrics they will be evaluated on, that totally runs counter to the whole point of building platforms.
As long as your inbound user count exceeds churn due to booting out people with minority tastes—which a PM EXTREMELY RARELY had anything to do with—the PM’s career takes off.
No dude, discoverability as it is defined by every tech company is killing culture. And it’s Product Management that’s holding the knife.
Everybody has some minority tastes. Everyone's got their own long tail of stuff they like. Obviously there's stuff that's more popular than other stuff - otherwise they wouldn't be majority tastes - but it's not like someone who watches Jimmy Kimmel on Youtube therefore doesn't also enjoy, like, woodworking channels.
The difference is, I guess, what you're willing to settle for - if the algorithm discovers you like a thing that's easy to find more of, it will really start shoving that in your face, because it's easy, and if you're not persistent enough to keep seeking out specialty content despite the tide, then the popular stuff is what you're going to get.
I understand, but it’s more than that.
I mean pretty soon, if you ask a kid to describe what a movie is, they might say a long video with eight to ten superheroes in it.
All this sameness is stunting our imagination.
The "sameness" makes the technical burden easier for anyone who develops a search engine. If more searches had to be treated as "unique" this would require more resources and more time to complete. Sameness allows results to be returned faster.
Thus Google and others providing "search" are invcentivized to facilitate what you call the "cultural selection" process, i.e. selection by popularity. This article reflects a common view that this process is not adequate for all type of "content".
In the early days of web search engines, sites like AltaVista or later Google, would include a line on the results page boasting about the number of returned results and the number of pages searched, drawing attention to the size of their database and presumably the variety it would contain.
The irony of this is that we see now that Google, and any other who followed their lead, does not want nor expect people rapidly digging deep into search results. The majority of queries they receive are repeat queries. They would prefer and they expect that users be content with a "top search result", never moving beyond "page one". This not only lessens the technical burden, it can be presented as "what people want", they can portray this as the optimal "experience" for the user. Whereas someone who keeps digging and digging for more would draw suspicion and be blocked. Genuine curiousity, often a hallmark of intelligence, is not accounted for.
The system is geared toward delivering the sameness that purportedly all (e.g., 80% of) users want, as efficiently as possible. They offer no option (for the remaining 20%) to sort all results alphabetically, by date, or some other field or to download a list of all results to do this offline. Even sorting by "relevance" is a non-transparent process. It is not a disclosed algorithm and we are not allowed to do our own relevance filtering on raw results. What we get has already been pre-filtered. Advertisers pay the bills.
If the majority of users never reach page two, then an ad at the top of page one can command a higher price. The order of results is all-important. The user is not allowed to control the order.
"Everything is on the web" and yet doing "real" research -- as, e.g., one would using a databse in a library - is, 30 years on, still nigh impossible. Advertising is the problem, as the Google founders published in their search engine paper announcing Google in the 1990's. Alas, they later found advertising was the solution... to commercializing what was originally meant to be academic.
That same assumption is playing out in the world of web content strategy. What is the incentive to write about obscure topics when keywords like "Netflix", "Marie Kondo", "Trump" etc will near-guarantee more shares, more clicks and more ad impressions?
And I'm thinking about a story I saw here a little earlier this morning about a guy who built his gleefully stupid idea of "a dating site for fans of Kanye West" into something that got him a meeting with that star. [1]
And I'm thinking about The KLF's "The Manual: How To Have A Number One The Easy Way" [2] and how much that Kanye-dating story reminded me of the parts of that which weren't specifically about the nuts and bolts of making a pop song for eighties Britain.
And I don't necessarily have any conclusions. Something about the role of advertising in our culture to grab attention, to tell people that hey, this thing you might like exists, and to repeatedly tell them that until they actually bother having a look at the thing [3] and maybe deciding they like it enough to tell other people about it and maybe even give you a little money for the thing, and how hard it is to keep doing that when you're focused on honing your craft and doing the best whatever-it-is you can do around the demands of keeping a roof over your head, and who the hell can find time to do all that advertising, let alone learn how to do it effectively.
And you know who has the money to pay people to do all that advertising? Mostly people working for the megacorporations that squat over our cultural landscape, making work that walks a fine line between being new enough to be different, but close enough to existing successful work to be able to get funding.
And once again I want to start that Kickstarter to dig up the corpse of Jesse Helms and do terrible things to him in vengeance for his role in gutting the NEA that I keep making jokes about lately.
1: https://thekanyestory.com/, hn discussion at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19523853 (such as it is)
2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Manual - the full text is one search for "klf manual" away
3: tangentially, I make nerdy comics about robot ladies with reality problems (http://egypt.urnash.com/rita/) and cartoon animals in space (http://egypt.urnash.com/parallax/) and am working on reprinting my super-stylized and nerdy tarot deck (http://egypt.urnash.com/tarot/)