News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness by tomc1985 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:17PM (#19538455)
Then we are in disagreement. For every worthy, previously unvoiced opinion, there are five more that would not spread beyond a room full of kooks had the internet (Twitter, Facebook) not given then a global platform. You had to work a lot harder to encounter those sorts of fringe; now every idea, good or bad, is shoved in our faces regardless of its merit. Algorithmic curation is doing a terrible job of containing that

I'm not mentioning names since I'm sure everyone's list of "ideas that should have stayed dead" is different, but you get the idea. The commonalities amongst that list between different people can form the basis for a metric for which ideas should be rebroadcast and which should be allowed to die

To rephrase my point, we are denying ourselves a beneficial natural selection by giving everyone a potentially global voice

Re:On Flooding: Drowning the Culture in Sameness by balfirevic on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:29PM (#19538529)
> Then we are in disagreement

What disagreement? I did not even make any statements or expressed opinion on whether it's good (whatever that might mean) that everyone has a voice (at least in my reply to you). I simply asked:

> By what mechanism should we take or deny someone a voice?

Without that we are simply daydreaming about how everything would be better if only things were better. Which is OK, just not very useful if you stop there.