Ask HN: Company is firing all employees – should I still exercise my options?
About 2.5 months ago I left my executive position at a promising blockchain startup. As I am nearing the end of my 90 day period for option exercising, i've come to know that the company sent out prior notice to all employees a few days ago, as it is struggling to raise money. All 3 founders are at work trying to raise capital in the upcoming month before money runs out and they are also planing on continuing to do so after all employees leave.
On one hand, I am very hesitant to exercise because of the current status. On the other hand, the company has a remarkable product (which they might decide to sell) and the industry is still very much in it's diapers, meaning there is tons of true potential.
i have a lot of faith in the founders but the recent news really threw me off. Would love to hear your thoughts!
More information: -Company size: 15 employees -Exercise price: $20 (679 options/2.3% of the company) -Company raised from several VC's and also via ICO. -I still hold company's digital currency. -Status: recently launched product (fully functional) after 1.5 years of development with very few customers but high growth rate.
(
91 comments
| 60 points
| on HN
)
1) The company just fired all of its employees
2) The company just fired all of its employees
3) The company just fired all of its employees
That's a really bad sign. Even if they raise additional money, it likely won't be on good terms. With the price of bitcoin way down from it's peak, and much of the "fools" money in this space dried up, I can't imagine that a company who is so close to the edge that they have to fire all of their employees is going to get great fundraising terms.
But take my advice with a grain of salt, as you obviously know and understand the company better than I do.
As an aside, the fact that you are asking here likely means that you have an emotional investment in the company. I get it. If you really have FOMO, you can always split the difference and maybe exercise half the options, or whatever amount you wouldn't mind losing. I once exercised a few thousand dollars of options knowing that it was a bad investment, but also knowing that if I was wrong and the company did well, I'd have a terrible regret. And it's purely because I worked there for a few years... it's not like I obsess over the fact that I didn't make an early investment in Amazon (where I never worked), even though logically that's the same thing.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/crammeddown.asp
If you can find objective metrics that justify investing, great. But if the majority of your decision is emotional it's probably not a great choice.
I would look at what they're doing not what they're saying. They're playing up their opportunities, but firing everyone. The actions speak louder than their words.
Almost every startup has a great idea, a great product and a great team (and if they don't they will still sell you on the idea that they do have all these things).
What great startups have is all of those things plus great market fit plus great adoption plus great investors.
If it's all show it's a no go.
If the founders were the only engineers maybe there's still some chance that they can manage an acquihire for themselves, but it would be worth pennies, and any transaction will likely be below your option execution price.
Firing all the employees is a rather transparent signal that liquidation events (or any financial events) are off the table, and founders are simply debulking expenses to kill the company.
Also, the simple and straight forward solution to your problem is simply to ask them. These might be hard times for the founders but a short and candid message asking about the situation wouldn't hurt. They probably don't want you or anyone spending their money in a dead company.
I have a friend who was first 50 at Amazon and let 50,000 Amazon options expire. He still did well but... FOMO is a real thing. $1000 is probably my cap in this situation however.
4) The company just fired all of its employees
/s. An amusing and thoughtful response!
In the end it's a question of how dear that $13k is to you. If you've got millions in the bank, do it. If gathering that $13k would require you to max out a couple of credit cards and call in your last couple of favors, then don't do it.
Wherever you lie on that huge section in between is going to determine your decision, I think. There are a couple of companies that even for nonpublic stock will buy your exercised units, so if they value each unit/share at $200 then this is a simple decision: exercise and sell (some or all).
Alternatively, you might be able to stretch that $13k a lot further by investing in the next round. Get a good finger on the pulse of the ask price and see how low they'll go before they give up. Your $13k may be the lifeline that buys the company the 15 days it needs to not die, and should be valued accordingly.
I'm mostly kidding, but also not really -- I would seriously put some thought into whether any part of you thinks that this is really a unique investment opportunity, if you're really on some "inside edge" or discounted price given the admittedly subpar position of the company, and if this really differs in any marginal way from any other more liquid form of speculation or downright betting. I don't have the details but this screams "poor financial decision" from where I'm sitting.
Unless I'm inter-line-reading incorrectly, the company raised $1m giving away 50% of the cap table. They ran out of money and pivoted. Loaded labour rate of about $150K initially I guess... Then raise money from an ICO -- must have been something around $3-4M given the 15 employees now. That money is gone. Originally 2 founders, now 3 (cap table is shrinking). I think there is no way at all that they will be able to raise money. Even if they sell the IP, it will be a fire sale.
This is not financial advice. I am not any kind of financial expert. I can't tell you what to do. I might be entirely wrong, but I don't see recovery at this stage, no matter what the business is.
If you believe in blockchain and want to make an extremely risky, but potentially high payoff, bet, I'd personally just split the 13k across BTC and ETH. Those can also go to zero, or grow another 10x+, but you are at least exposed to the entire industry, rather than a single startup. The investment would also be far more liquid, and you could sell at anytime. Even the most successful crypto startup (Coinbase) hasn't done as well as an investment in BTC.
Don't get trapped into overvaluing the options because you already own them. If you had never worked at the company, and they called you today asking to buy 2.3% for $13k, would you do it over buying BTC?
Past performance is no automatic guide to the future, but speculating on Bitcoin has often turned out pretty well. Sounds like speculating on the company you used to work for, by contrast, will have reliably turned out poorly.
> - struggling to raise money
> - tons of true potential
Run.
From promising startup to out of money in 2.5 months? As an executive, did you not have insight into these things?
Don't kid yourself into thinking this is a good bet. It is a huge gamble that most likely will not pay off. If you can accept that and still want to do it, go ahead. If you don't want to take the risk, don't.
1: Would you be willing to invest $13K into the company right now with your own money in exchange for 2.3%?
2: What are the most extreme odds you are willing to take for
[ X % -> $50K+ , Y % -> $13K , Z % -> $0 | X+Y+Z = 100%]
Then figure out what others are saying the chances of X and Y are.
P.S. My (generous) uninformed bet would be X=1-5% and Y=30%
If the company eventually unicorns, you will regret having been a part of it but not benefiting financially at all. Even a single share could be a consolation and may actually end up valuable.
If you max out all your options, assuming that's more than your 'play money' budget, you may much sooner regret the decision if the company tanks in a month or two which seems like a definite possibility.
Generally the companies that have done turnarounds after a firing round have done it respectfully. Often morale floors after a bad round, smart people leave, remaining people are unproductive. Combined with whatever reasons triggered the firing, most companies don't recover.
When a startup is trying to survive they’ll give up a tremendous amount of equity because the alternative is 80% of nothing or 40% of something.
Does that $13k hurt you to pay out? If it’s not that painful, you can weigh that.
For what’s its worth, I didn’t exercise my options when leaving the last two companies and I felt so sick to my stomach when the last one sold for a couple hundred million but then I looked & saw they sold for less than their last valuation so my shares would’ve been even more watered down in value.
2. You no longer have a seat in the company (much less at the deal table).
3. Their desperation will be apparent, and they will accept very bad terms in the round (firing your staff = no leverage).
Even if they manage to stay in business, your investment is unlikely to be worth anything. As someone else said, would you really want to invest in this company if not for your history? Why not put that $13k into another investment?
Everybody else, including all the spectators, lose. After all, those coal fired power plants dump a lot of crap into the air to power the energy hog that is Satoshi's Blockchain.
This can't be a serious post
I agree with the latter
If the former, please provide examples. I am all ears
I wouldn't bother, you're going to lose your money. If the company pulls through, or finds a buyer for their product, it's highly likely they will play games and essentially extinguish your shares.
I’d stay in touch with the founders.
And that's exactly where I stopped reading.
The simple answer is no. Run away. There's no such thing.
>Baron Rothschild, an 18th century British nobleman and member of the Rothschild banking family, is credited with saying that "the time to buy is when there's blood in the streets."
But I don't think even he meant all the blood. :) If your company is firing all of its employees, then I would say it's not pining, it's passed on. It's no more - ceased to be. Expired and gone to meet its maker. Bereft of life. R.I.P. Kicked the bucket. Shuffled off this mortal coil. Joined the choir invisible.
This is an ex-company.
You are buying common. The investors have preferred. You won't get a cent from a sale of the company.
Additionally, the founders will not be able to raise money in this situation even though VCs coffers are overflowing right now.
I’d run away OR buy 50% just for fun.
The fired all their to leave an impression (to existing employees) there is no point of exercising the stock and then after 2 months re-launched as Slack.
Food for thought.
Yeah... sure. You kinda shot yourself in the foot here.
The only other situation where I think it could make sense is if you plan to write it off to offset capital gains elsewhere.
Investment loses aren't tax credits. You don't magically get all the money back. You'll only "get back" whatever your marginal tax rate is. You'll still be out the remainder of the cash you forked over.
“Writing off” a investment loss only reduced your bill by the marginal tax rate of your loss. If it was a credit, you’d be marking down the tax bill by the entire amount of the loss, which isn’t what happens for investments.
To many people think that something being deductible makes it “free”. No. They basically give you a discount for the item equal to your marginal tax rate.
Note: I am not a CPA. Please see one before doing your tax if you are confusing credits and deductions.
sorry for the question, just don't know a huge amount about this stuff.
Consider that (i) based on what you've told us the original VCs have declined to put any further money in to keep the company alive and have therefore probably written off the entire investment and (ii) any buyer probably needs to hire the founders for a couple of years to actually be able to use the IP, and therefore wants to apportion a sizeable proportion of any money they're willing to pay for the IP to their earnout package rather than compensating shareholders and creditors of the dead company.
And the product apparently doesn't generate non-trivial revenue and was built in 18 months for ~$3m by a team who are all available for hire, so it's not like there's an obvious reason for another party interested in the space to pay massive amounts for the IP - remarkable or otherwise - even if there wasn't pressure to conclude a deal asap...
You'd basically have to audit and reverse engineer a ton to even get back to where the product was before firing.
Either they've already struck a deal and the buyer didn't want all the employees, or that company isn't selling, IMO.
zeroth perspective: there are many alternative assets and asset classes for investing your hard-won capital , benchmark any decision against standard alternatives, such as investing in real estate, buying into passive ETFs of the world stock market, buying options of highly-liquid public companies that run at a profit and have years of audited financial reports you can read to help you determine a fair valuation, etc.
if this was a company with a liquid options market, you could sell your options, and with the cash from selling them, consider investing in some new options with a longer expiry time and more attractive strike price -- say +12 months, not 90 days. is anyone willing to buy your options? for what price?
you could attempt to do some discounted cash flow model of the company: e.g. does the company have enough cash and resources to limp along burning cash slowly until its revenue has grown enough to run at a profit? how long might that take under pessimistic or optimistic assumptions about revenue growth? this analysis would be hugely speculative and sensitive to assumptions, but might help you come to a conclusion. to make the analysis simpler you could assume that you own 100% of the company and there are no other shareholders and try to figure out what you think the company is currently worth to you, if you were the sole owner. if there's basically no chance that the company can become profitable without taking a large amount of new investment then arguably the value of the company it its current form as a going concern is zero, although it may have some small value if the company were liquidated immediately and any residual cash left after paying off creditors was distributed to shareholders.
if your rough valuation of the current value of the entire company is less than $590k = 20 * 679 / 0.023 [1] then the intrinsic value of your options is $0 and the remaining time value of the options is rapidly approaching $0 if you are nearing the end of the 90 day exercise window. This is fine, it just means that the financial instrument you currently own, these options, are currently almost worthless and are likely to become completely worthless in the very near future [2]. There are plenty of other far less speculative ways to invest that have a far better chance of giving you a modest return on investment and not destroying your capital.
another angle: let's assume the current value of each option is approximately $0 and ignore them. if you are open to the possibility of investing some of your capital into this startup, instead of becoming a shareholder, would it be a better idea to instead become a creditor? e.g. supposing you had $20k cash you were open to investing, do you think the company would agree to terms where they get your $20k and you become a bondholder with a bond entitling you to e.g. 20% dividend payment per year for n years then full return of your initial $20k capital, and status as a secured creditor with the first claim to any remaining assets when the company goes bankrupt? Supposing the company were having a fire-sale of its assets, how much would you pay for the IP (or the desks or other physical assets with resale value...) [3]
yet another angle: on an unrelated note, you say you already hold the company's digital currency. how much is this currently worth in USD? if it is worth > $0 USD, can you sell this digital currency in exchange for cash? failing that, can you sell this digital currency back to the company to cover the cost of exercising the options?
[1] this assumes each option is for 1 share in the company not 100 shares in the company, as would be the case for options typically traded on the market ... if the latter case is true it would cost $20 * 100 * 679 = $1.36 million to exercise the options, and would only make sense if you valued the company as currently being worth more than $590m
[2] worthless in an optimistic scenario where you refrain from exercising the options. if you exercise when the strike price is above the value of the underlying share, you destroy the time value (maybe slightly more than zero), and take the immediate loss for trading $20 cash for a share worth less than $20.
[3] this is almost certainly not a sensible scenario but thinking about it provides quite a different perspective. If you are willing to invest, is there some way to structure the investment so you win or don't lose too much in the high-probability scenario where the company goes bust?