News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by ace_of_spades on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @05:15PM (#19435968)
To make this discussion maybe a little bit more solution oriented, what would be your solution to problems of labor mistreatment? Or do you suggest that nothing like that exists?

I recently came across an interesting talk by Richard Wolff at Google [1] which suggests that a great solution would be the democratization of the work place in the form of worker coops. It’s actually a tried and true model that works well in a variety of contexts. It would probably solve the problem you outline as well as make labor mistreatment a lot less common.

1: https://youtube.com/watch?v=ynbgMKclWWc

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by tomohawk on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @06:22PM (#19436670)
Start a "consulting" business that provides really good pay and benefits to all of the workers. Be very selective about who you let in.

You're now in the business of providing workers for companies that produce stuff. If they want access to your workers, they sign a contract with your company. If some workers don't like working for some particular company, transfer them to places where they like to work.

You've now created a private union that operates on a consensual basis rather than a coercive / adversarial basis.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by bluntfang on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @06:41PM (#19436847)
Some of my peers have thrown around the idea of team hires. Interviewing as a team and working as a team. The team is hired and quits together and is generally a collective that works within itself.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by erklik on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @11:45PM (#19438741)
Isn't that now essentially a company that work gets subcontracted out to? or am i missing the joke?
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by drb91 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @10:56PM (#19438497)
I really like this idea.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by ekanes on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:06PM (#19437523)
Love it. I'd be interested in hiring such a team.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by drb91 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @09:04PM (#19437883)
Just to point out the obvious, that doesn't serve the main purpose of the union at all: collective negotiation with the employer.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by crdoconnor on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @06:43PM (#19436872)
You haven't described a private union. You've described a co-op - a solution to an entirely different problem - how to deploy capital and labor in an egalitarian way.

Unions exist to counter an existing adversarial and coercive economic relationship with counter-coercion.

It's kind of like saying that instead of using tanks to fight a war you should use really persuasive arguments because then you don't have to use "coercion".

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by ace_of_spades on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:07AM (#19439953)
Sure that was the whole point, to broaden the discussion beyond tending the symptoms and trying to get at the causes.

An interesting idea could be to use a union or similar vehicle to start a co-op. Or start to strive for more democratic practices in companies. I actually like the comparisons to consulting companies in the sibling comments which seem to be an attempt at doing something like the outlined, however, with more of a traditional paint on top and probably more vulnerable to coercion in the long run.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by crdoconnor on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @03:31PM (#19445933)
Co-ops don't address the causes of coercive economic relations though. If they did they'd be much more common - Walmart and John Lewis both exist but they simply can't compete effectively in the same market. The only way to counter a Walmart is with a union - and a really aggressive one, too.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by ace_of_spades on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:21PM (#19473755)
If you look at the video I posted at least one professor seems to think otherwise and I kind of find his arguments at least worthy to consider. Corporations will by nature have place an emphasis on pleasing owners, which in the case of coops are the workers. So, it doesn’t dispense with competition in general but aligns interests better with workers which should have a profound effect on “coercive economic relations”.

If you just mean that coops just cannot really compete, I would say that’s a myth. Look at Mondragon for example [1] or some large German coops. They also run successful competitors to walmart at leasr in europe. I think that one reason that they are just not as common is a general need to raise capital quickly, general availability of capital and a lack of education. But you are right that none of that is likely to counter an existing monopoly with access to huge capital baring some kind of legislative changes. There is certainly a place for unions.

1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by intended on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:41AM (#19439329)
You just described a body shop.

Heck this is what is done in India and other countries as well, to get around worker protection rules.

Keep several rota of workers, employ them at firm X. When the 9.999 years of work are up, “switch” the workers to a new firm.

Thus dodging the legal test which states that any worker who has worked at a role for more than 10 years at a single company, is a de facto employee and should be given pension and other recognitions.

Your design degenerates to this situation. The same way Uber degenerated from ride sharing and using surplus resources to people barely squeezing by.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by baddox on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:40PM (#19437732)
But I mean, how different is that really from any normal corporation that offers its services to other corporations? The issue is still how the workers protect themselves from you (the employer).
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by arcticbull on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @11:06PM (#19438545)
This is actually called a PEO (professional employment organization) and is often used for small companies looking to hire workers in foreign countries. The PEO becomes the employer of record and the employee is assigned 100% of the time to the foreign company. It’s pretty neat.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by Angostura on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:52PM (#19437438)
And suddenly you've created Accenture
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by Aeolun on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:10PM (#19437538)
They literally provide ‘stuff’. Not sure whether it’s actual solutions.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by nerder92 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @06:48PM (#19436926)
You are basically describing ThoughtWorks.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by zaksoup on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:30PM (#19437651)
Except afaict the big agile consultancies underpay relative to tech industry big names.

Source: fmr pivotal labs

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by fphhotchips on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @09:11PM (#19437915)
Sure - there are overheads in running a company where people like to work, and there's only so much that can come from the top line in a consulting business.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by zaksoup on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @03:59PM (#19446226)
Parent to my comment was responding to somebody suggesting that consultancies provide "really good pay and benefits" and I was suggesting that this isn't true, currently, in the tech industry.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by fphhotchips on Thursday March 21, 2019 @01:33AM (#19449468)
Yeah, I missed that the parent was suggesting good pay and benefits. My point is that the consultancies generally pick one or the other, because otherwise they'd be priced out of the market - even for really good staff that are hard to find elsewhere.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by TheLuddite on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @06:30PM (#19436753)
Wasn't this the way the Guilds were operating in the Medieval era?
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by president on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:04PM (#19437512)
My friend from Europe explained that this is how companies get around labor laws (for example, laws that restrict the number of hours a given employee can work). Companies essentially hire contractors who are paid higher wages which results in fewer actual positions hired by the company. Now there are fewer positions hired directly by the employer so in-effect, the labor laws haven't impacted much. At least that's how he explained it to me.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by falcor84 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:32PM (#19437669)
I don't understand. What you're describing is individual contracting, no?

The comment above described contracting a company with employees. These employees would than drop be bound by the labor laws.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by president on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @07:29PM (#19448017)
To my understanding it happens with both individual as well as company based contracting. Unsure which is more prevalant though.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by JamesBarney on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @10:52PM (#19438470)
The problem of course is if you give your employees really good pay and benefits you price yourself out of winning any jobs.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by frogperson on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:04PM (#19437056)
This model already exists and does really well in practice. Both clients and employees love it.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by sonnyblarney on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @11:29PM (#19438658)
That's all fine and good, but now you have to find contracts and compete/bid competitively on RFP's for work.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by conanbatt on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:51PM (#19437428)
Why would you pay workers above what they are willing to work for you?
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by falcor84 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:34PM (#19437689)
To be able to hire them for a particular unit of work and then let them go once the project is over, without having to worry about labor laws. This kind of flexibility and optionality can be very valuable.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by conanbatt on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @11:44PM (#19438736)
And expensive.

Firm theory has studied this subject in the field of economics. There's a reason there are employees in the world, and not everyone is a contractor.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by JamesBarney on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @10:54PM (#19438482)
For tech workers specifically a organization like the AMA that can fight for certain contractual safeguards against death marches, non competes, and abusive IP practices.

For workers in general a UBI that decreases the supply of workers thus increasing their bargaining power.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by ace_of_spades on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:50AM (#19440154)
Yeah, thank you for bringing up UBI! I think UBI is an interesting development and seems like a good part of the solution given our current situation. However, it adresses inequality mostly in terms of redistribution of resources and not really in terms of power.

For example, to finance a UBI large companies like would maybe be taxed more but that money would be evenly distributed across the company, thus, only marginally affecting Sergeys and Larrys position relative to their workers or society. They still remain in control, even though the population at large may have a little more wiggle room. Thus, UBI seems like a great way to make the status quo more tolerable but it wouldn’t really threaten accumulated power. That’s why basically everone in silicon valley is for it. Something like co-ops on the other hand bake in a lot more accountability and checks and balances into companies. This would also affect the distribution of power. But I wouldn’t say that this would be the obvious thing to push for or any kind of silver bullet. As I wrote in another comment, there are multiple sides to these problems (e.g., company and society level).

Thank you for engaging with this question, hope you find some value in my response!

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by solidasparagus on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:48AM (#19439376)
There was an article that I can't find right now about European union practices. Create a union for an entire industry and then leverage union scale to push for government regulation that impacts the entire industry. I'm sure it would be imperfect, but you have to do a solution like that because if you don't, companies will see unions as a competitive disadvantage and prevent them.

The biggest problem is that I and many others see unions as short-sightedly protecting workers while their companies and industries die around them. The last real bastion of union workers in the US is the government and no one is calling their employment model effective.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by ace_of_spades on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:20AM (#19440019)
I totally agree that there are two sides to this coin. On the one hand, you need to involve or support people who are negatively affected by changes (e.g., unions, co-ops, etc.) and, on the other hand, there needs to be effective regulation and decision making in the interest of the overall system of people (e.g., countries or the world).

It’s important to look at both of these sides when considering solutions, I guess I didn’t really do this in my comment. So thank you for this important insight!

To offer some additional thoughts on this, I can recommend the thought provink book Radical Markets by Eric Posner and Glen Weyl. They present quadratic voting (next to some other ideas) as one means of arriving at better regulatory outcomes. To me it’s not a complete or perfect solution but certainly interesting and maybe one piece of the puzzle :)

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by cambaceres on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @03:53AM (#19439894)
The solution to problems of lablor mistreatment is to quit and get a job at another company that treats their employees better.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by ace_of_spades on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:32AM (#19440093)
I would argue that today there are many oligopoly type situations where there is actually not too much choice to go around, especially if you are limited in terms of moving about. In these cases unionization or other types of collective action seem more appropriate.

In general, I would argue for more diversity in company structures and better education about alternative organizational models (i.e., talk more openly about the pros and cons of all forms of organization - not only from a profit making but a societal perspective). It seems to me that there is a strong dogma of how things need to be done in start ups. But maybe I am wrong, I am still working at a German University so maybe I am misrepresenting the situation in your country.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by repolfx on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:13PM (#19444327)
Kickstarter is a software firm based in New York. There's no shortage of firms hiring in New York. Kickstarter employees who are unhappy would be able to easily get jobs elsewhere.

However, observe that their goal is not to tackle abusive working practices but apparently to take over the firm and impose a "social justice" agenda on it:

enrich Kickstarter’s charter commitments to creativity, equity, and a positive impact on society

promote our collective values: inclusion and solidarity, transparency and accountability; a seat at the table,”

"equity" means equal outcomes e.g. 50% of all jobs being reserved for certain genders, races, etc. "Inclusion" is a codeword for the same thing.

Obviously the goal of forcibly converting Kickstarter into using identity politics based management isn't something they can achieve by just going to work elsewhere, as would be the case if they were being mistreated, because Kickstarter would just hire replacement employees.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by trhway on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:55PM (#19437456)
>problems of labor mistreatment

i don't think there have been times in tech when employees were paid and overall treated better than today (maybe the boom 20 years ago comes somewhat close). Even more, I think tech employees situation today beats any other mass employment situation in the history of humankind.

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by swiftcoder on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:44PM (#19437758)
This is generally true for full-time engineers. It isn't true for the vast legions of contract workers that stoke the fires of large tech companies.

See, for example https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-tn-apple-contract-wor...

Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by trhway on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @09:01PM (#19437859)
yes, the companies are happy to shaft anybody they can (it is just right now they cant do that to tech employees). And i'm all for rising tide for everybody, for [significant] minimum wage increase, for more protections for contractors, for single payer, safety net and universal college education (and for higher taxes to cover all of it), etc. What i'm saying is that tech employees complaining should understand how much better they are off than everybody else, otherwise it becomes just a self-entitled whining.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by Apocryphon on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:59PM (#19465756)
Tell it to the tech employees in the game industry.
Re:Kickstarter’s staff is unionizing by perfmode on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:19PM (#19437595)
There’s the issue of TVCs.