Only 15%? I'd guess it's way, way more. Like 90%.
News today is primarily headline-driven. You don't have to sit down and watch the evening newscast anymore, you can just scroll through Facebook and see headlines and comments, which almost always drop context and nuance in a way that's engineered to make people upset.
In a way, it's probably the most irresponsible aspect of journalism today. The media's ethical priorities are incredibly outdated: if a writer makes a mistake twelve paragraphs into a fifteen paragraph article, it's a major problem requiring a correction. But if an editor appends a headline that actively misleads 100x as many people, no one has any problem with it.
The news, in this way, probably misinforms as much as it informs. This is why you get the wildly divergent realities on the right and the left. There's simply no professional awareness of the unbelievably damaging power of headlines that--from a consequentialist perspective--are frequently abject lies.
News orgs are basically functioning as info amplification nodes on the network. The talking heads have assumed greater importance, than the journos who are painstakingly digging up info. This needs to be revered.
The metrics (likes/clicks/views/retweets/upvotes) that drive this behavior of the news orgs have to be rethought.
Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Reddit etc could get together and propose a standard of what metrics are optimal to cause that reversal and then put them into effect.
It always was. Newspapers were sold off the newstands via the headline. That's why headlines were large - so passersby could see them. That's why newsboys would yell out the headlines.
Some would say this is by design and not just on the part of newsmakers but actual politicians on both sides of the spectrum. For the system to work as efficiently as it does a bimodal distribution is probably the best way to achieve that. Every one may be better off at the end thinking both they have a voice, someone taking care of their issues, and elected representatives don't have to struggle to satisfy a never ending range of diversely opinionated electorates.
I doubt the efficiency of this system.
I suggest that the incentives are mostly politically oriented, in the sense that editorial staff truly feel aligned with something they feel important to them, in addition to the 'money' incentive, which is severe in the world of news; they are always going out of business, and in a constant fight for ratings / viewers. There's a very serious and existential push to 'make money or die'.
Both of those elements combine to create a market orientation. If you consider news to be simply a product like any other, then you have 'customers' within specific 'demographics' and the editorialists to be 'product managers' with a 'P&L' ... when then they are incented to hustle the kind of information that fires those customers up and gets them clicking.
Taking a completely culturally secular view, one could argue the papers are just carving out their customer segments, just as any competing brands would.
BTW, I think it is not unreasonable to expect that different models of funding or engagement are differently represented on the left and right sides of politics. Contrary to certain views, the left and the right are not two equal, symmetric, graceful wings of a bird, keeping society in balance: they're two different worldviews and sets of fears and priorities. It's not inherently surprising that one would find their business more profitable with a smaller pool of paying customers, and the other finds more profit in a larger pool of casual visitors to whom to show ads, or that one finds more funding from the rich, or that one's worldview requires deeper and more nuanced storytelling than the other to support its conclusions.
For every other aspect of government, it’s one man one vote. For the Senate, Wyoming has the same representation as New York, even though the population is less than the Rochester metro area.
When the text says that Reuters published an article about a topic they actually link to it. I wish other news sites did the same.
If I said what that was, it would appear that I was trying to start a political flame war on HN, so I won't. But most people here know what it is anyway.
Eventually, Bezos, Slim, and the Sulzbergers will have to decide what business they're in, just as Murdoch already has. Paywalls are not going to play a role in that business, and I frankly don't understand why they're bothering with them now.
You reacted, however trivially, so you'll now get more of it. You'll get more of it even if you reshare with a comment along the lines of "this is complete rubbish".
So the more outrageous rises to the top.
Facebook doesn’t sell catheters and old people scooters, so I would guess that their audiences are more diverse.
The Washington Post recently tightened up their paywall, too.
If you want some more on the list for balance there are plenty of left wing Breitbarts you could add. Those are free too.
BTW I think fear porn / anger porn is an appropriate term. It releases brain chemicals that can be addictive just like sex porn. This explains some of its virality.
Its not because of a FB algorithm - that's for certain.
I can ask everyone in my family if they've heard of Breitbart and 99% will say yes. If I ask if they've heard of Rachael Maddow.. maybe 40%? This is despite both of them engaging heavily in anger porn
Contrast this with Fox News, where the last time I tuned in to that channel 3 angry people were screaming across a table at each other about how liberals are going to outlaw hamburgers. The camera is flying around like a sportscast, and there's graphics and animations blaring in the background. The people in the room seem to have no relevant credentials as to the topic at hand. Are there any environmental experts at the table? Food science experts? No, there's just "political analysts" and "strategists".
I think the commonality is that Rachel Maddow and the talking heads at Fox News aren't journalists. They spend their time telling their audiences how to think. They just do it differently.
If you want the news rather than someone telling you how to think you don't need either.
Btw Glenn Greenwald has reported about the biases of Rachel Maddow quite a number of times.
https://www.youtube.com/user/TYTComedy/search?query=Rachel+M...
Jimmy is a Bernie guy by the way, not a Trump guy. I recommend any Democrat who is confident in their beliefs to spend some time watching him to see if your information feed might be overlooking some information or perspectives.
EDIT: it's interesting, although not surprising, that simply offering an alternative perspective results in downvotes.
She was spinning a huge web of conspiratorial possibilities.
She's a brilliant advocate, well informed, and never 'crosses the line' - but she's definitely an advocate.
I'd listen to her more if she moved over to NPR or something along those lines.
* Wall Street Journal: Subscription needed
* Bloomberg: See this article for $1
* Fox News: Completely free
* Breitbart: Completely free"
But BBC, Huffpo, CNN, NBC/MSNBC et. al. are free, and they actually dominate the list, i.e. those entities and a few others add up to something considerably bigger than Fox. Or Fox + the Mail + Breitbart, for the most part.
I think the headline was unnecessarily biased to the extent it doesn't paint the picture we see presented in the actual data, which is actually interesting and not quite so black and white.
has the biggest army in the world
Actually, the seventh biggest. (IISS, quoted in Wikipedia)> Not very reassuring.
You left out 8 years of Obama somewhere in there.
Bush and Trump on the other hand have been raising a lot of concerns. The first one for lying to his people to get to war and tell the UN to go to hell. The second one has just too many red flags to even begin with.
If you look at "content with the most shares" not surprisingly Reuters and Patch tops the list.
OP's headline presumes any algorithm should achieve left/right balance - this is just impossible.
There was a good tweet the other day something along the lines of
If I Google a headline the results are:
* New York Times: Your number of free articles is 0
* Wall Street Journal: Subscription needed
* Bloomberg: See this article for $1
* Fox News: Completely free
* Breitbart: Completely free
Seeing this its no stretch to understand why media struggles