News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by Pharmakon on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:40PM (#19392129)
It’s not censorship, it’s curating a storefront. The laws that protect us from actual censorship also protect Amazon’s right to make choices about what they sell. I don’t like that WalMart refuses to stock anything short of the nebulous American concept of “family friendly” yet I respect their right to make that choice. I have the choice to not do business with them.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by 50656E6973 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:04PM (#19393048)
>censorship: the suppression or prohibition of any parts of books, films, news, etc. that are considered obscene, politically unacceptable, or a threat to security.

Friendly reminder that the definition of censorship is not limited to the government.

The books they've banned may indeed be misinformation, but lets not push even more misinformation by denying simple dictionary definitions that seem politically unacceptable.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:08PM (#19393094)
Then every website in the world censors information by filtering out spam. Why does nobody weep for the poor spammers who just want to sell you cheap Viagra? No doubt Amazon has been "censoring" their reviews in this way since the beginning. Where's the outrage?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by spaginal on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:28PM (#19393320)
Removing books from a "book" marketplace, that do not break any laws, aren't lewd or pornographic, and simply present alternative information on a subject, is not on the same level as spam.

Censorship is censorship. It doesn't need to be a political body to make it so.

In the 80's, the idea of the corporate ran dystopian future where a megalomaniac controlled society through his mega corporation was seen as scary future.

Now we get the usual boot licking going on every time this topic is brought up as Amazon, Twitter, Facebook, and Google (Alphabet) actually put into practice real censorship and attempt to control the majority of online communication, ideas, and a good piece of all information over the internet.

What a turn for the worse we've taken as a society.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:33PM (#19393374)
Cry me a river. If the authors want to sell their books, they can open up their own website, set up a table at the local flea market, rent a store space and stock it with all the quackery they want. Amazon is not the only sales outlet in the world. Nobody is stopping them from selling anything.

Amazon is not obligated to carry their merchandise any more than they would be obligated to carry any Amazon branded products in their own stores.

If anything, whenever Amazon is mentioned here, people come in to complain that they need to do more to remove garbage products from their website. Here's a garbage product that literally kills people when they use it. If it were a toaster, it would be yanked from the shelves and the manufacturer would be getting sued for wrongful death.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by spaginal on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:47PM (#19393529)
I don't disagree in the slightest that they should explore all avenues for sale.

Answer this question to satiate my curiosity, what if Stripe and Paypal refuse to process credit card payments for these authors?

What if Square refuses to swipe cards at the flea market for the author?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by jpindar on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:55PM (#19394220)
Paypal already refuses to allow itself to be used for sales of various legal but controversial products.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by ryanwaggoner on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:05PM (#19395165)
As does Stripe
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by Corrado on Friday March 15, 2019 @07:24AM (#19398618)
I have friends who run a 100% legal horse racing “fantasy” site and they can’t get a CC processor to work with them at all. This includes Stripe and PayPal. I’m sure that adult entertainment has the same problem. Your question inst new at all and many industries have been fighting that same battle for years.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by tuesdayrain on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:45PM (#19395402)
> Answer this question to satiate my curiosity, what if Stripe and Paypal refuse to process credit card payments for these authors?

I believe this will always be a concern unless cryptocurrency becomes widely accepted. Any centralized payment processing system will likely cause certain people to be excluded.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by exolymph on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:10AM (#19396998)
Correct. The incentives and pressures on centralized payment processors are never going to change.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by _trampeltier on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:55PM (#19393611)
It does already happen. There are many cases like Fetlife etc ...
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by thefounder on Thursday March 14, 2019 @07:24PM (#19394933)
Stripe and Paypal along with Braintree and many others refuse to process credit cards for all kind of products(i.e sale of kodi boxes).

This on top of Visa and Mastercard ban policies.

Something like Youtube would never be allowed to process credit cards if it didnt't have a big corporation/money behind.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by zeckalpha on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:47PM (#19394669)
Stripe and PayPal choose to work with certain credit card networks, not all.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:55PM (#19393619)
Paypal (and probably Stripe?) are notorious for freezing customer accounts with little to no explanation, so to answer you question to what if they did that...probably nothing? Paypal or Stripe or Square are not any more obligated to do business with a particular customer than anyone else is.

They can always accept cash, checks, Bitcoin, barter.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by banachtarski on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:24PM (#19393924)
Well said
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by banachtarski on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:25PM (#19393936)
Why do you distinguish lewdness and pornography from fake science. Your metric for classifying various forms of content honestly just renders your argument rather hypocritical.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by baddox on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:15PM (#19393813)
> Removing books from a "book" marketplace, that do not break any laws, aren't lewd or pornographic, and simply present alternative information on a subject, is not on the same level as spam.

Huh? Why would you make an exception for pornography in your definition of censorship? Porn is like the most obvious textbook example of censorship.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by Mikhail_Edoshin on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:57AM (#19397564)
At least this is a blanket category, not hand-picked example.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by driverdan on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:51PM (#19393570)
> aren't lewd or pornographic

What's wrong with something that's lewd or pornographic? It's far better than quackery.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imtringued on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:12PM (#19393768)
Payment processors will cut you off and it doesn't fit with their Family Friendly™️ image.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by anigbrowl on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:25PM (#19394475)
You're sort of missing the point here, which is that the poster above considers sexy sex perfectly legitimate grounds for censorship while claiming to deplore the phenomenon.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by Pharmakon on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:40PM (#19394067)
Are you sure the bigger issue isn’t actually the rate of fraud and chargebacks?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by meruru on Thursday March 14, 2019 @07:12PM (#19394843)
It's still taboo for a lot of people unfortunately.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by wlesieutre on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:29PM (#19393338)
> present alternative information

Like shouting "fire" in a crowded auditorium that is in fact not on fire? Let's call it what it is: we're talking about lying about things that can and will literally kill people.

Why should Amazon be expected to provide a platform for that?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by wowzap on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:36PM (#19393411)
You can do that if you want, "fire in a movie theater" was an argument in an overturned Supreme Court ruling.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by wlesieutre on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:40PM (#19393454)
You can do that, but if you feel entitled to the theater's help in doing it then I don't know what to tell you.

And if you expect the theater to let you in when you come back to watch a movie the next day, you're going to be disappointed.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by int_19h on Thursday March 14, 2019 @07:22PM (#19394908)
It's also worth reminding that it was a ruling which put a prominent politician in prison for campaigning against WW1 and encouraging people to resist the draft.

Which is to say, it came preassembled with a slippery slope.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by lr4444lr on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:01PM (#19393670)
Lying and fraud requires intent to deceive. You need to prove that.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by wlesieutre on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:31PM (#19394527)
Be right back, I’m going to run screaming into this crowded building which I definitely believe is on fire based on no particular evidence, and no one can prove otherwise.

In fact, it’s not just this building, every building is on fire. Right this second! And it’s your civic duty to join me in warning people.

I’ve written a book explaining all this and if Amazon won’t sell it in their store I’m going to cry foul.

If you can’t say I’m lying, is there a better word for it?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by spaginal on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:43PM (#19393492)
What literally kills people when they get an alternative opinion or simply information about vaccinations... which is the raison du jour, but the not the only information being blocked by these companies.

What happens when the prevailing opinion in the future becomes that raising boys as boys is dangerous for their health? Girls as girls? Promoting religion to your children seen as dangerous to popular thought? Do we continue down this path and start banning literature on how to raise children properly, the bible? After all, it may disagree with YOUR OWN held opinion, so it must be removed, for the safety of the children, right?

We are entering the territory of cheering on the thought police, where you disregard your own faculties and off load all of your exposure to information and decision making to a highly select group of people, with their own biases, much of it monetarily motivated.

Do you understand what I'm saying to you?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:31PM (#19393995)
> What happens when the prevailing opinion in the future becomes that raising boys as boys is dangerous for their health?

So, a store deciding not to carry a book is the "thought police" but raising your child to eschew any behavior or, dare I say, thought that you deem insufficiently "boy-like" is....not the thought police?

How do you feel about Christian bookstores? Should they be forced to carry the Koran, satanic literature, atheist books, and everything else they might disagree with? Or is it ok for them to exercise "censorship" since they're not censoring any ideas you like?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by zeckalpha on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:51PM (#19394691)
A search for “dead autistic kid” finds many examples of ignorant mistreatment.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by lancesells on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:20PM (#19393876)
> We are entering the territory of cheering on the thought police, where you disregard your own faculties and off load all of your exposure to information and decision making to a highly select group of people, with their own biases, much of it monetarily motivated.

Can't you really say this about the anti-vac community and the ones publishing and selling these books? Or am I reading your statement wrong and that's who you're speaking to?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by jsight on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:38PM (#19393434)
> Now we get the usual boot licking going on every time this topic is brought up as Amazon, Twitter, Facebook, and Google (Alphabet) [...]

That's funny, because every time that I'm here lately I seem to see a pile of upvoted stories and comments about how [insert big company here] is committing [atrocity here]. Sometimes its true, but often its backed by little evidence other than someone's opinion.

I'm not convinced that things are nearly so imbalanced as you are making them sound.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by anigbrowl on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:26PM (#19394483)
Of course they're not, that's why the poster is resorting to such hyperbolic language and emotional anchoring.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by wcarron on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:22PM (#19394442)
> Removing books from a "book" marketplace, that do not break any laws, aren't lewd or pornographic, and simply present alternative information on a subject, is not on the same level as spam.

From the Article: 'Wired magazine noted that Amazon is crowded with titles promoting unproven treatments for autism that include “sex, yoga, camel milk, electroconvulsive therapy, and veganism.”'

Removing books that contain outright lies isn't censorship. It's simple denying a platform for bald-faced liars to profit off misleading the public.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by drngdds on Thursday March 14, 2019 @09:48PM (#19395743)
>alternative information

The phrase your looking for is "dangerous lies"

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by crooked-v on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:27PM (#19395278)
Claims that forcing children to drink bleach will cure autism are far beyond "alternative information".
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by kevinh on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:08PM (#19393731)
Removing a book for breaking a law is censorship. Removing a book for being lewd or pornographic is censorship. What makes those instances of censorship acceptable, and removing books peddling harmful claims masquerading as science unacceptable?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by Mikhail_Edoshin on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:04AM (#19397597)
Removing a book is censorship. Not carrying a broad category of books is a policy. E.g. if they didn't carry any book on autism, this would be a strange decision, but within their competence. Judging a single book is not.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by tuesdayrain on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:41PM (#19395373)
I'm not seeing why censoring lewd material is fine, while censoring books that falsely claim to cure autism is wrong. They all seem like arbitrary places to draw the line.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by js2 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:07PM (#19394326)
> What a turn for the worse we've taken as a society.

Perhaps it's a game of whack-a-mole and censorship trying to suppress vaccine misinformation, but the anti-vax movement is an actual real danger to society, and misinformation was cited as one of the problems in recent testimony before Congress by a teen who defied his parents’ anti-vaccination beliefs: "The sources which spread misinformation should be the primary concern of the American people." [1]

Fortunately this teen learned to think on his own ("learning to find credible research and information is fundamental to finding truth in a world of misleading facts and false views").

Ideally, I'd want everyone to learn to think critically, and to combat misinformation with information. I don't like the slippery slope of censorship either. But I also can't stand the fact that my children live in a world with kids who aren't vaccinated.

So I hesitatingly applaud Amazon here.

[1] https://www.help.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Lindenberger.pdf

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by 50656E6973 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:55PM (#19394214)
Because scale matters
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by killjoywashere on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:05PM (#19395166)
No one lives a purely deontological or purely consequentialist life. At some point, senior members of a society are responsible, indeed accountable, for using their influence to impose standards for the good of that society.

I operate a Little Free Library that is a net source of books (people in the neighborhood drop off boxes of books). This has had a number of effects I didn't foresee:

1) we have learned who visits seeking books (usually kids and their moms), a demographic I certainly want to encourage reading in, so we load the stock toward that demographic.

2) rarely we acquire some really great books.

3) Occasionally we get books that give me unintended insight about who's in my neighborhood, not in a good way. I throw them out. I have no problem with Mr. Bezos doing what amounts to the same.

We're not talking about censorship of valid information. It's censorship of invalid information. That's just good methodology.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by 50656E6973 on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:06PM (#19404766)
>We're not talking about censorship of valid information. It's censorship of invalid information.

Might be a good idea to stock more history books in your library because that is precisely the same hubristic logic used by authoritarians throughout all time.

Ever so many of mankind's greatest scientific discoveries and moral progressions were deemed "invalid information" by "senior members of society", which is why the great thinkers of the Enlightenment fought for freedom of speech, thought, and information. It seems we no longer truly value those things as we are increasingly relying upon corporations to decide for us what is true and what isn't.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by killjoywashere on Saturday March 16, 2019 @02:43AM (#19406675)
We're not throwing anyone in jail, no one's liberty is being compromised. As for the great thinkers of the enlightenment, I think you would find them squarely in the camp of both not putting people in jail, while at the same time supporting the actions of private citizens to suppress scientifically invalid information.

* "We are all born ignorant, but one must work hard to remain stupid." ― Benjamin Franklin

* "Science is the great antidote to the poison of enthusiasm and superstition." - Adam Smith

* "Being ignorant is not so much a shame, as being unwilling to learn." ― Benjamin Franklin

* "It is difficult to free fools from the chains their revere." - Voltaire

* "We swallow greedily any lie that flatters us, but we sip only little by little at a truth we find bitter." - Diderot

* "That Politics may be Reduced to a Science" - title of 1741 essay by Hume.

* "One unerring mark of the love of truth is not entertaining any proposition with greater assurance than the proofs it is built upon will warrant." - Locke

* "The supreme mystery of despotism, its prop and stay, is to keep men in a state of deception" - Spinoza

Shall I go on?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by 50656E6973 on Saturday March 16, 2019 @11:18AM (#19408233)
None of those quotes imply tacit support for mass censorship, and if you were aware of their actual historical context you'd realize it's quite the opposite. You are clearly ignorant of how many of those thinkers were persecuted and censored by "senior members of society" because their ideas were deemed "invalid information"-- which is why so many people had to give their lives so that we could inherent their wisdom. Allowing people to say things we disagree with is essential to real intellectual progress.

Here's a good starting point if you'd like to learn more:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voltaire

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by roel_v on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:57PM (#19395464)
"I operate a Little Free Library that is a net source of books (people in the neighborhood drop off boxes of books)."

Quite OT, but I've thought about doing this - how do you do this, practically speaking? Do you have a cupboard in the front of your house or do people actually come inside? Have you ever had to deal with vandalism? In what climate do you live, and what sort of infrastructure do you have?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by killjoywashere on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:27PM (#19396188)
Well, they have a good site for starters:

https://littlefreelibrary.org/build/

We live in Southern California and even we get rain. So using a plan is a good idea simply for the value that they've thought of things like eaves and sills. You need to commit to repainting every year or so, maintaining the caulk, etc.

it's the details and maintenance that make it. Ours looks good years on. One in the area is starting to look janky because they were too fancy with their first paint job and now it is in the dire need of paint. Another is just collection of rotten plywood at this point.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by philistine on Thursday March 14, 2019 @09:41PM (#19395704)
Go inside your house! Letting the neighbours in your house to grab books. You are the most generous, kindhearted person in the world if you really are thinking of doing it this way.

It's a very big bird house on a pole in front of your house, just in front of the sidewalk. It's got a door with a window on it, so people can see the books. I live in a region with a cold climate and there are 7 or 8 exactly like what I'm describing in my neighbourhood. I don't personally have one but my wife wants to build one in the spring. Doesn't seem to be much of a vandalism magnet when they look so gosh-darn cute.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by roel_v on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:43PM (#19395984)
"Go inside your house! Letting the neighbours in your house to grab books."

Well I was thinking more of a 'we're open Saturday mornings only' kind of deal, I can assure you I am far from the most generous, kindhearted person in the world :)

"I live in a region with a cold climate and there are 7 or 8 exactly like what I'm describing in my neighbourhood."

Does it work OK in rain and cold? It only gets to -10 C here so not even that cold, but it seems it would be hard to build the cute ones (like, all the results when Google Image searching 'little library') in a waterproof way.

Then again, I'm probably overthinking it and getting stuck in analysis paralysis like I usually do...

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by anigbrowl on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:22PM (#19394444)
Friendly reminder that the definition of censorship is not limited to the government.

This isn't a reminder, it's an assertion that uses rhetoric to make itself sound more factual.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by 50656E6973 on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:52PM (#19404663)
Why do you think censorship can only be done by a government?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by baddox on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:13PM (#19393152)
That is a very broad definition, of course. Am I engaging in censorship by selecting only a small handful of books to have in my home?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by educationdata on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:19PM (#19393230)
I think Amazon's action concerns people bc it's strong position in the book market. It's very different from your own private action. I'm not saying Amazon should be forced to sell the book.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by baddox on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:13PM (#19393795)
That is precisely my point. The extremely broad definition cited above is far too broad to match people's actual usage of the word "censorship."
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by applesplatz on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:11PM (#19393136)
they're also pulling "political" books. Mostly alt-right types.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by rhizome on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:36PM (#19393413)
Yes, by refusing to watch a certain TV show or listen to some band you think is good, that is a kind of censorship, but not one really significant enough to transcend the concept of taste.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by tomatotomato37 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:57PM (#19392338)
I think the thing that irks people is that they are doing a whole show and dance about how they pulled the books. If they just kept silent and pulled it using the same qualifer it uses for janky cellphone chargers and contaminated dog food, no one would care. The problem is that Amazon's marketing department would very much so prefer that you do care, enough so that you keep using them for toilet paper and HDMI cables.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by jdsully on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:52PM (#19392281)
It may be curation - but let’s not forget Amazon started with the premise that they could serve the long tail. Bezos used to talk about how terrible it was that a physical book store would have such limited selection.

They doubled down on this strategy with their on demand printing service - bypassing traditional publishing gate keepers.

When someone dispenses with long-standing policy it is noteworthy.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by tzs on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:05PM (#19392418)
When Bezos talked about the limited selection of physical bookstores, I doubt that he was lamenting them not having enough garbage books available. I assume he was referring to there being way more good books than would fit in a physical bookstore.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by jdsully on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:08PM (#19392453)
Then why start a self publishing service for people who couldn’t get past the editors of even the trashiest publishers?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by notahacker on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:30PM (#19392690)
There's a difference between being willing to help people writing stuff too awkward to market to earn them advances find their audience and helping people help other people to die...
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by jbigelow76 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:33PM (#19392721)
Because why have scale if you don't leverage it.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by fixermark on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:00PM (#19392371)
You can support the long-tail without facilitating people harming themselves or their children with demonstrable misinformation.

There's long tail and long tail. Amazon can still sell books about how to repair and maintain a 1936-era WLW Crosley Radio without also selling books informing the unfortunate gullible about how to "treat" their children's autism by DIY at-home electoconvulsion therapy.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by jdsully on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:06PM (#19392434)
Sure - but they didn’t have editorial review before. This is a dramatic change of policy for them.

Due to a long history - books in particular are seen as a bellweather of a societies attitudes towards censorship.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by rlt on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:48PM (#19393543)
I agree it's not censorship in the First Amendment sense, but as a large corporation approaches monopoly status I think we should be less tolerant of "curation", even if we happen to agree with it in specific cases.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by bencollier49 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:42PM (#19394089)
I'm with you on this one - Amazon is approaching the status of a public utility, at which point it should be subject to higher standards.

As much as I'm pained to be standing up for these anti-vaccination nuts, it's the thin end of the wedge.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by pjc50 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:57PM (#19394233)
Note that in the UK making false claims about cancer cures is a criminal offence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer_Act_1939
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by mirimir on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:16PM (#19393186)
IANAL, but I don't believe that there are any US laws that would require Amazon to sell a product. If they sold real estate, or operated restaurants or whatever, they couldn't discriminate over race, gender, religion, etc. But I believe that they could decline to sell products that catered to some protected class.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by CodeMage on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:38PM (#19393433)
Precisely. Maybe we shouldn't be focusing on Amazon's alleged "censorship", but rather on what makes us react to it in a rather similar way as if the government did the same thing.

The choice of not doing business with someone ceases to be a meaningful choice when it's the only viable alternative. One could argue that Amazon is not the only viable alternative and that argument is, strictly speaking, correct. However, this isn't a binary situation -- one day we have plenty of equally viable alternatives and the next day it's just Amazon -- but rather a continuum.

TL;DR: Amazon pulling stuff from their store is only a bad thing when taken together with not having a meaningful alternative. The latter is a bigger problem than the former.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by golemotron on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:12PM (#19393780)
> It’s not censorship, it’s curating a storefront.

When your storefront is 83% of the market[1], and you restrict choice, it's time for you to be broken up.

[1] - https://www.retaildive.com/news/apple-takes-a-page-out-of-am...

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by ameister14 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:40PM (#19392793)
It is definitely censorship. They are making a moral decision about what content they will allow to be sold through their system. If you own movie theaters and decide not to show films linked to Communists, you are censoring.

Wal Mart censors people too - if you don't comply with their morals, you can't promote yourself in their stores.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:11PM (#19393139)
While it is the definition of censorship, does that mean it has the negative connotation of the term? I don't see Wal Mart selling any pornography either, and I can't remember the last time I saw a Bollywood film or a 2 man student art film in my local movie theater - are those censorship's negative?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by Mikhail_Edoshin on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:19AM (#19397688)
Definitions are useless, what one needs is a notion: a smallest working model of censorship. If a store doesn't have a particular book, it can be to a multitude of reasons. But what if one removes an existing book from a library? The book is not physically different from others, nor does it carry some unusual associated costs, it could be standing happily there for many more years. So why it's singled out? Because of what it contains? This is where we call it censorship. (Note that what exactly it contains is irrelevant.)

In this case the book as a product is not different from a trillion of other Amazon products. What makes it different is its content. So yes, this is censorship.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by ameister14 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:25PM (#19393293)
The Bollywood/2 man student films aren't censorship - they're a lack of perceived audience. If there was an audience for those, the theaters would show them. The pornography thing - maybe? There's an argument to be made that allowing freedom of choice would be a net positive.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by _red on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:36PM (#19392756)
Yet, when a bakery wants to "curate" what cakes they bake, thats a civil rights infringement, isn't it?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by mintplant on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:50PM (#19392904)
If there were an extensive history of phony-Autism-cure-peddlers kicked to death on the pavement by assailants screaming phony-Autism-cure-related slurs into the cold night air, while the responsible authorities looked the other way or even took part in the brutality... then, perhaps, these situations would be comparable.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:51PM (#19392918)
That was not what cakes they bake, that was which customers they sell to. They were happy to sell wedding cakes to straight couples.

If Amazon started saying "we won't sell these books to gay people" then, yeah that would be a problem.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by educationdata on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:24PM (#19393271)
No, in the cake lawsuit the owner was happy to sell the cake to the gay couple. He just refuses to make a customized cake for the wedding.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colo...

"Masterpiece's owner Jack Phillips, who is a Christian, declined their cake request, informing the couple that he did not create wedding cakes for marriages of gay couples owing to his Christian religious beliefs, although the couple could purchase other baked goods in the store. "

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:39PM (#19393444)
All wedding cakes are customized cakes. Most people don't buy an off-the-shelf generic cake for a wedding. A wedding cake is understood to be made especially for the occasion.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by noobiemcfoob on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:12PM (#19393774)
"Most people don't buy" <- until that says "all people", you've shot your own point in the foot.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:22PM (#19393906)
Not at all. If you walk into a bakery and say "I want a wedding cake" they will immediately sit you down to discuss what type of custom cake you want. You would have to explicitly specify that you wanted a pre-made, off-the-shelf cake if that is what you were looking for.

It was not even a question in the lawsuit that a pre-made cake would have been an acceptable substitute.

I said "most people" because I'm sure there are people who have less formal, low-budget weddings where they grab any old cake from the grocery store. That is not what is understood when someone says "wedding cake".

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by keepmesmall on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:17PM (#19393196)
There's a distinction, the cakes are both custom-made and religiously themed.

Say a baker hand-makes dog-shaped cakes, among other cakes. The baker loves dogs. A client comes in and tells him he hates dogs and wants to order a cake for the purpose of ritually defiling it.

Would the baker be wrong in refusing to fulfill this order?

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by imgabe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:25PM (#19393286)
The difference is, "dog-hater" is not a protected class as defined by public accommodation laws, so they would not have any grounds for a lawsuit. Sexual orientation is, at least in some states.

Legally, the baker would not be "wrong" in your scenario, though in my opinion they would at least be foolish. Defiling a cake does not harm a dog and once the customer pays for, it is their property to do whatever they want with.

How about if your dog-hater were driving late at night, they got tired and pulled over into a motel. They're signing in for a room and the topic of dogs comes up for whatever reason. They mention that they hate dogs and the motel owner says "Get out, we don't allow no dog-haters in here". Are they right to do that? Legally, again, they could, though they couldn't on the basis of sexual orientation (in some states) or race, religion, national origin (everywhere).

The Supreme Court has already sided with the baker on the basis of the cake being an artistic expression, so it's a moot point now.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by keepmesmall on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:11PM (#19393132)
To the contrary, the supreme court justified the baker.

Forced creation is as bad as forced speech.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by delinka on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:49PM (#19392889)
It's entirely dependent on the reason behind the decision. Here are the limited designs we have: show book - No, we don't allow customization.

Not to mention, there's no need, as a customer, to inform the baker the purpose of the cake. Doesn't matter if you're taking it to a wedding, or using it as a prank. They make cake, you want cake.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by anigbrowl on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:32PM (#19394538)
You're equating serving a customer with buying from a publisher.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by favorited on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:58PM (#19392978)
Bakeries can and do curate what cakes they bake. If they don't want to make carrot cake, or anything with fondant decorations, they are free to do so. Which part of that confuses you?
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by gabbygab on Thursday March 14, 2019 @09:13PM (#19395562)
It is censorship. Just not government censorship. I wish people would stop trying to defend censorship with that trope. They have a legal right to sell what they want on their platform but that doesn't mean it's right. Especially when Amazon has turned itself into a near monopoly.

And considering their humble and rather "anti-censorship" beginnings, it's rather disappointing to see what amazon has become. Seems like another case of you die a hero or you live long enough to be a villian.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by tomohawk on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:57PM (#19392337)
Amazon has a monopoly. It's censorship.

If they were not a monopolist, then they could claim curation.

Once you achieve monopoly status, you can't claim to be a simple business anymore.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by mlazos on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:01PM (#19392381)
I don’t really think Amazon has a monopoly. They control 5% of all retail, and like 50% of e-commerce. It’s far from a winner take all point too, I think there will be a lot of fragmentation in the next few years with niche sellers like Etsy becoming more popular.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by tomohawk on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:12PM (#19392496)
This is an article from 2014:

https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/05/amazon-...

At that time, they controlled 65% plus of the online book market. Do you think it is less now?

They basically have no competition. A monopoly does not require 100%. For example, the Sherman Antitrust Act defines it as 75%. But, it's obvious that they are a monopolist in this area.

Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:12PM (#19393145)
This morning while looking for a book I went to 2 sites, only one of which was Amazon.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by eropple on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:01PM (#19392379)
Flag on the field: assertion without supporting evidence and with obvious counterexamples (Wal-Mart, Alibaba, etc.) close at hand. Ten yard penalty, repeat first down.
Re:Amazon Pulls Books That Promote Unscientific Autism ‘Cures’ by anigbrowl on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:35PM (#19394569)
Please stop with the football jokes, you can point out a fallacy without trying to get referee status out of it.