News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by Scoundreller on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:06PM (#19362832)
I’m not sure how universally true that is.

When governments fail to redact documents, it’s on them.

If you “accidentally” talk to a reporter about your solicitor-privileged comms, it’s not privileged anymore.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by JeremyBanks on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:11PM (#19362869)
This isn't an open question.

If you don't have a license from the copyright holder, you can't legally use it, except for fair use exemptions: perhaps you could write a blog post criticizing it.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by zaphirplane on Monday March 11, 2019 @06:08PM (#19363350)
Was there a licence attached to the files? What if there wasn’t
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by detaro on Monday March 11, 2019 @06:09PM (#19363356)
> If you don't have a license from the copyright holder, you can't legally use it, except for fair use exemptions: perhaps you could write a blog post criticizing it.
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by zaphirplane on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @01:50AM (#19365735)
To be clear, do the files contains a copyright or licence, if they do not and many companies don’t attach a copyright header to their files. Why would the assumption be that the files are not public domain or free for use
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by dodobirdlord on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @03:35AM (#19366107)
Because unless otherwise stated, they just aren't.
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by colejohnson66 on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @09:39AM (#19367989)
Copyright law in the US grants a copyright to all works without an application (so not the same as a patent)
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by benj111 on Monday March 11, 2019 @06:32PM (#19363527)
Theres nuance though, that copypasting a previous comment doesn't answer.

What about public domain works for example? Or you had a good faith belief you had permission from the copyright holder, eg someone misrepresented themselves as the copyright holder, or the copyright holder published the code in public without a copyright notice?

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by icebraining on Monday March 11, 2019 @09:03PM (#19364456)
Public domain: any software made to run on current machines is too new to have expired copyright; the author(s) may have dedicated it to the PD, but you have to find that dedication, which is equivalent to a license.

Good faith: that may affect the amount of damages the copyright holder can extract, but it's still illegal to use the software.

Copyright notices: haven't been required for 30 years.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by benj111 on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @02:52AM (#19365940)
Copyright older than 30 years still requires the notice (and this is banking software).

My underlying point though was that it was an unreasonable answer, to just copy paste the previous answer. No one here that I've seen has claimed to be a lawyer, and no one I've seen has defined what nations laws we are talking about. At that level of discourse, the question posed, deserved a reasonable answer.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by icebraining on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:49AM (#19366886)
> Copyright older than 30 years still requires the notice

Nope, only on works published over 30 years ago. This package was published only three years ago, regardless of when it was created.

There really isn't much nuance under the copyright rules almost universally agreed under treaties like Berne, UCC and TRIPS. This kind of what-ifing a clear statement just sounds like a bad movie trope.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by benj111 on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @07:30AM (#19367107)
We don't know when it was first published though. If its Cobol code, with dates from the 70s in the comments, that's different to if being JavaScript or some such.

And if you get enough money and lawyers in one place you can create plenty of nuance.

Dragonwriter reminded me of the term, implied licence in another subthread. That clearly seems arguable in this case even if it isn't considered winnable. Case law progresses through winning 'unwinnable' cases.

I think we're approaching this from completely different positions though. I appreciate the what-ifing, exploring the hypotheticals. It isn't as if we have any power to make a difference in a court of law, and I would hope no one is relying on this thread for legal advice.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by v_lisivka on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:19PM (#19364219)
I have good faith belief that all software on torrent trackers are in public domain or had permission from the copyright holder.
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by v_lisivka on Monday March 11, 2019 @10:34PM (#19364869)
As you see, it doesn't change anything: I will be downvoted, then sued, then jailed despite my beliefs.
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by benj111 on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @02:31AM (#19365880)
That isn't demonstrating a good faith belief.

Buying a Rolex from some guy in a car park is different to buying one from a jewelers. The former wouldn't protect you in any way, the later would let you demonstrate a good faith belief that it wasn't stolen, and wasn't fake.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @04:03AM (#19366195)
This is a tangent but there's nothing wrong with buying a fake. So you can have a good faith belief that it was a counterfeit, which can protect you somewhat in the case that it was stolen.
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by benj111 on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @04:14AM (#19366238)
In the copyright example you're probably right.

More generally, say if wanted consumer protections consistent with it being a Rolex, or if you wanted to sell it as a Rolex. Then whether you bought it as a fake does matter.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by Scoundreller on Monday March 11, 2019 @06:58PM (#19363710)
We're talking about code. Which is more like a recipe than a novel.

If Coca Cola writes down its proprietary recipe on their entrance "by mistake", I can definitely make use of it. Maybe I can't photocopy it for sale, but I can definitely re-use their previously-secret techniques.

I can even say I got it from them through their own error and have the exact same outputs for the exact same inputs.

Trade secrets aren't your secret anymore once you publish them.

All we know in this case is that copyright law was used as a tool to remove it.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by gowld on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:26PM (#19364256)
> Which is more like a recipe than a novel.

Courts strongly disagree with you.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by Scoundreller on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:02PM (#19365005)
Do they?

If you reverse engineer a system and write a spec using clean-room technique, it's going to be massively easier for the team to do it if they have lawful access to the no-longer proprietary source code.

And wouldn't that be the method to re-create your own copyrightable implementation of GPL code too?

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by y4mi on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:17PM (#19362915)
Thats only true for the US and the countries adhering to US copyright. It's not universally true
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by JeremyBanks on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:24PM (#19362967)
It's not "US copyright", it's several international copyright treaties, which 90% of all nations have agreed to: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention

The few exceptions are where copyright essentially doesn't exist at all. Where it does, this is how it works.

Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by HenryBemis on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:46PM (#19363151)
As someone above posted the wider "List of parties to international copyright agreements", this is one of the boxes that need to be ticked prior to signing any form of deal between countries. It's a kind of 'fundamental' in order to start doing business with that country (or for the country to be taken seriously).
Re:Major bank accidentally published a private package to th... by anticensor on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @12:04PM (#19369576)
DPRK only recognises foreign copyrights, and have no concept of IP for its own works (because everything is done to superior order, there is no creativity allowed). Micronesia does not have copyright, but has even stricter regime of creative works, amounting to a patent-like protection.