News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by axiom on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @03:36PM (#1935248)
This is just painfully stupid. Finally an app on Blackberry actually garners some attention, and RIM kicks it off the market.

For anyone who has ever bitched about Apple being draconian, this is just another example of what the mobile app world was like before the App Store. It really wasn't all unicorns and rainbows and happy developers skipping through the meadow. It was locked down and cost absurd amounts of money to break into.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by bebeastie on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @05:04PM (#1935565)
It depends how you define 'stupid'.

I see advertisements day in and day out for BBM. Not for RIM's latest phone, not for a new RIM app, but specifically for BBM. Why? Because RIM has realized that one of the only things keeping a large % of their user base around is BBM. Their OS is horrible, their devices are nothing special, but BBM is arguably the best mobile messaging product out there (so good that Kik pretty much copied it exactly).

I have friends that won't replace their BBs solely because they feel as though they'll lose touch with their friends that use BBM (I know, SMS, email etc. all seem like fair replacements but in practice they aren't...BBM is superior for a # of reasons).

Now, what is Kik doing? It is offering a comparable messaging platform that allows BBM users to speak with their friends no matter what device they are using. If I tell my friends with BBs to get Kik and we all start to use it consistently, then eventually one of us can go get that iPhone we've always wanted. Then another one etc.

Kik is on the verge of breaking into the walled garden that is BBM and RIM is obviously not too happy about it.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by wh-uws on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:14AM (#1936571)
What exactly is so good about BBM? I've never owned or really spent much time using a blackberry because of the other reason's you've mentioned.

"Their OS is horrible, their devices are nothing special."

So what is it that users find so great about it? (Asking legitimately out of curiosity not sarcastically )

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by mbesto on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @06:09AM (#1937042)
No joke, every BB person I've ever talked to lives and dies by their BBM and plastic keyboard.

Couple of reasons people like BBM so much (observation of BB friends):

1) You can see when someone is typing

2) It's very fast and feels like your talking with someone on gchat/aim/etc

3) Most BBM users are already "locked in" with eachother via BB PIN #'s. It would be like changing your phone number if you got off BB

4) A person in the US can BBM a person in the UK for free

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by ni_nad on Thursday November 25, 2010 @06:11AM (#1939959)
Except for the plastic keyboard, I don't see any advantage. Use a decent Jabber client (I'm using Beem on Android) and you get all these features on gchat, with just your gmail address. Plus, figure out the priority thing right, and you can have all the messages delivered to the right client. GTalk broadcasts to all clients by default, but the better IM clients give you an option to send and receive.
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by nikster on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:39PM (#1936008)
^^Agree. Kik is a BBM clone. Surprisingly badly done, actually, from what I can tell - but still, it's aiming straight for BBM.

If it gains traction, it might turn into a BBM competitor which is available on all platforms, thereby removing _the_ primary reason BBs sell like hotcakes here in Asia.

I guess I should backtrack - BB in SE Asia (and probably other regions world wide) is THE must have phone for every student, college or high school. You either have one, or you want one.

The reason for this is BBM. Clever marketing and the fact that most students already have BB make it a social must have. You either have a BB or you're out. They're selling them by the bucketloads, it's quite incredible.

Without BBM, there is no way BB would sell _any_ phones over here. So clearly they must protect it. If students somehow would get turned on to Kik, and you didn't need the - let's admit it rather ugly-looking - BB to use it, Blackberry sales in the region would die overnight.

Anyone else find it deliciously ironic that BB is now blatantly doing what Apple is usually accused of doing?

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by brisance on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:58PM (#1936056)
Which part of "SE Asia"? BB is popular in Indonesia, but that's about it.

The "it" phone everywhere else has always been iPhone and shipping times have been stuck at 2 weeks as recently as early November.

Google Trends bears this out. There is not a single ASEAN country other than Indonesia where BB comes out ahead in normalized searches.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by teejae on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:06PM (#1936078)
BB is also the phone to have in Venezuela, which I just visited a few weeks ago. All because of BBM.
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by thought_alarm on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @06:56PM (#1935885)
The lock-in argument doesn't hold much water.

RIM already provides IM clients for Google Talk, Yahoo, and MSN, with pretty much the exact same UI and features as BBM. The quality of their Google Talk client is one of the things keeping me on BlackBerry.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by nhooey on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @10:49AM (#1937649)
The Google Talk client is horrible. It wastes tons of CPU when it's loading up the contact list, and still uses a bunch just while idling. If you have it on all the time, it will eat your battery away such that a Blackberry 9700 with no other apps running won't last a full day. I tested this on my own device a while ago, it might have gotten better, but I doubt it.

Blackberry Messenger (BBM) also has a typing indicator, delivered and read indicators, and it's faster than anything else out there.

Also, the fact that it's only on mobile devices and not desktop computers means that you know your message will get delivered to someone's pocket instead of the computer they may have left on. An odd side effect of its lack of portability.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by nikster on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:44PM (#1936019)
None of these are especially created for mobile. Or aimed squarely at BBM with the same features.

I had been thinking about creating BBM for other platforms simply because I'd like to have it on my iPhone.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by Ennis on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @10:34AM (#1937611)
How would you create a BBM client for other platforms? You wouldn't be able to authenticate with BB servers since you have no PIN.
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by hugothefrog on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @02:50AM (#1936802)
WhatsApp is a near approximation of BBM on the iPhone (and other devices, I believe).

Their reliability isn't great, however.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by ba217 on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @03:28AM (#1936850)
WhatsApp has better reliability, more handset clients, more features, and more users.
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by gustaf on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:05PM (#1936077)
BBM = Mobile - Mobile Messaging

GTalk/MSN etc = Mobile - Desktop Messaging

The use cases are completely different.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by LordLandon on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @10:38PM (#1936399)
What if you run gtalk on your blackberry, and I run gtalk on my android phone. Is that still Mobile - Desktop?
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by axiom on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @05:14PM (#1935599)
Fair enough, and that's quite likely what RIM is thinking.

But do you think it's a smart strategy for RIM to try to stay relevant by blocking hot apps on their platform? would it not be a more sane strategy for them to make their devices better, and to open up their platform so that others can easily develop more great apps on it?

This just seems like such a dumb short-sighted move.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by dedward on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @05:50PM (#1935705)
It's only dumb and short-sighted until you look at the amount of money at stake.

BBM truly is the only app holding a great many people back from ditching their blackberries for android or i-devices. The second we find a reliable way to transition away from the blackberry, today, we would. The blackberry has to keep a lock on it's last and only killer app while it finds a way to stay relevant.

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by nikster on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:45PM (#1936021)
^^^ Yes.
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by brianbreslin on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:23PM (#1936494)
Kik developeR was previously a project manager on bbm I believe.

Edit: someone below says he was an intern

Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by pyre on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @04:05PM (#1935358)
I think that point about Apple being draconian is that Apple's marketing department wants you to believe that Apples ecosystem is "all unicorns and rainbows and happy developers skipping through the meadow." It's not necessarily an implicit claim that we are moving backwards (though Apple as a company may seem to be moving backwards in their transition computer -> mobile).
Re:RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push by mattmcknight on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @04:51PM (#1935519)
Actually I loaded many programs onto my phone without RIM getting involved.

App World is just their attempt to copy the Apple "curated" model, with worse results. Access to the BB push infrastructure is a special case though.