News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by userbinator on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:04AM (#19318556)
A Tesla representative, in a statement to the Globe, said “there are significant safety concerns when salvaged Teslas are repaired improperly or when Tesla parts are used outside of their original design intent, as these vehicles could pose a danger to both the mechanic and other drivers on the road.”

It seems Tesla is deliberately ignoring or trying to squash the aftermarket/custom-car culture which has basically existed since cars existed... and in contrast, Chrysler/Ford/GM are happy to sell you parts like engines and transmissions without caring whether they'll even be used in a car, and have been doing so for literally decades, so obviously they're aware of and not worried about any legal liability issues.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by xondono on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:21PM (#19322377)
As someone who both tinkers with cars and bikes, and has designed and tested drives for various kinds of electric motors (brushless, AC,...):

- The perception that people have of how dangerous gasoline is, is greatly over exaggerated.

- The perception that people have of how dangerous high voltage drives and lithium batteries are, is greatly under exaggerated.

With 15 minutes I can give you enoguh pointers to have you tinkering your gas engine safely.

No such confort exists if you are going to tinker with your EV

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by aphextron on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:56PM (#19322695)
You're basically sitting on top of a giant bomb in an EV when it's fully charged. Shoot a bullet through a full gas tank, and nothing will happen. Shoot a bullet through an EV battery pack and it will burn to the ground. Liquid electrolytes are the real problem here, not battery tech as a whole. Fortunately solid state batteries are only a few years out, and that will totally change the safety equation.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by jsight on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:36PM (#19323086)
I'm not sure that bomb is the right analogy. Maybe thermite would be a better analog? EVs will burn long and hot (though not as hot as some imagine), but do not tend to be explosive.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by vvanders on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:45PM (#19323180)
They may not explode but contacting a 400V bus that can dump ~1200 amps produces a similar effect on the human body.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by clouddrover on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @07:34PM (#19324536)
A demonstration of the safety benefits of solid-state batteries:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9-cNNYb1Ik

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by robbiep on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @06:05PM (#19323917)
You do realise the safety profile of a large tank of petrol right?
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by jpatokal on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @06:42PM (#19324145)
It's actually much better than Hollywood would have you believe: a shot fuel tank will not explode.

http://prometheus-fs.co.uk/articles/hollywood-lies-to-you/

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by m463 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:37PM (#19324859)
I agree with you in principle, but I hope that things will change as people develop an awareness of things.

There are several dozen other companies that manufacture electric cars, and they will sell you shop manuals to service things, including the main battery pack.

As an intellectual exercise, searching for "leaf evb pdf" might lead to manufacturer procedures for diagnosing and servicing an electric vehicle battery system (with safety recommendations).

I know this isn't tinkering per se, but maybe tesla will someday do the same.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by xondono on Thursday March 07, 2019 @03:11AM (#19326377)
I’m not saying the’re unserviceable, just that the amount of training and safety concerns are a whole other level.

Even well trained engineers get zapped sometimes with capacitors that should be discharged by actually aren’t.

Power electronics can be very unintuitive because most people are used to tinker first with low voltage electronics like PCs, arduinos and things like that.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by m463 on Thursday March 07, 2019 @11:53PM (#19335188)
I do agree with you.

And I would go further to mention magnetism. I think the model S with its ac motor might not rely on magnets, but the model 3 and other cars probably have powerful permanent magnets that require a completely different kind of caution.

I just hope we can forge a path now rather than later. We need future scientists and engineers to be safe but creative.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by rjplatte on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:47PM (#19333397)
Yes, and safety protocols have existed for a long time. My Prius has a nastily powerful battery inside it, and I can work on it all by myself, since I don't open the pack, usually, and I know how to disconnect it. It's remarkably easy.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by twothamendment on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @09:30AM (#19319142)
"Chrysler/Ford/GM are happy to sell you parts like engines and transmissions without caring whether they'll even be used in a car"

Ancedata says some of the big 3 do care. A guy down the road from me ordered 500 engines from Ford. They followed up on the order and when he explained they were for airplanes, they cancelled it, saying they didn't want to be liable for an automotive engine in a plane.

His plan to turn his custom plane into a kit stopped at a beautiful one-off that sits in his museum when he isn't flying it.

If he was going to put the engines in a tractor, I bet they would have sold them, but they didn't want to be liable for something in a plane.

*Edit - it was 1000 engines, not 500. Also found a link some might find interesting: http://stonehengeairmuseum.org/1992-montaniar

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by OldFatCactus on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:12AM (#19319437)
The regulations around airplane engines are nuts (for good reason). I would've been wary as well
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by ryandrake on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:29AM (#19319563)
If he was building an experimental amateur-built (E-AB) category airplane, then there was likely no regulatory issue. Just lawsuit-scared lawyers. Not passing judgment--If I had lawyers I would want them to be conservative and cautious too.

You can put pretty much any engine you want in an airplane you build yourself, as long as you comply with the (reasonably light) homebuilt regulations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homebuilt_aircraft

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by al2o3cr on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:58PM (#19322716)

    If he was building an experimental amateur-built (E-AB) category airplane,
    then there was likely no regulatory issue.
I have no idea how much these particular engines cost, but even at $100 a pop buying hundreds of them at once puts the applicability of "amateur" under some strain (or that of "experimental", TBH).

OTOH, something about this story doesn't entirely make sense: who would get to the point they were ready to drop six figures on buying engines without, y'know, checking the regulations?

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by jsight on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:40PM (#19323137)
The story is that they would be sold as kits. I agree with you that this makes the story strange, though.

While his plan involved extensive modification to the engine and resale, the easiest workaround is to have the customer order the engine and freight it to him for modification. It would be expensive, but I do not see how it would have been impossible. This kind of aircraft would have been expensive in any case.

It sounds like other issues may have been just as big of a factor here as Ford's lack of interest.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by twothamendment on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:49PM (#19324913)
"who would get to the point they were ready to drop six figures on buying engines..."

Right, what kind of guy is this? The kind who built a full size, accurate working Stonehenge just for fun.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by Phillipharryt on Thursday March 07, 2019 @07:43AM (#19327526)
Working Stonehenge? Is it possible to have an accurate but not working Stonehenge?
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by sneak on Thursday March 07, 2019 @08:40AM (#19327894)
Those won’t open portals to the ancient alien homeworld, they just sit on the ground on Earth and look cool.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by jshevek on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:30PM (#19323023)
For people on mobile, the quoted section is:

> If he was building an experimental amateur-built (E-AB) category airplane, then there was likely no regulatory issue.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by kbenson on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:34PM (#19322482)
> If I had lawyers I would want them to be conservative and cautious too.

For good reason. I imagine if a few people dies because the engine as sold didn't perform well/stalled under certain aeronautical conditions (upside down, low air pressure, etc) then it wouldn't take long for the lawyer hired by the kit maker to start pointing at the big auto maker at every chance they got, even if it ultimately was something the kit maker did.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by m463 on Thursday March 07, 2019 @11:55PM (#19335198)
They are nuts when you carry passengers for hire. Experimental planes have less regulation.

What I wonder is how well all the various car engines work upside down :)

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by 0xfaded on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @09:59AM (#19319347)
There was a weird time in the 80s when lawyers figured out they could sue light aircraft manufacturers after a plane crash, and almost killed general aviation.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by microcolonel on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:07AM (#19319931)
> they cancelled it, saying they didn't want to be liable for an automotive engine in a plane.

Honda is working with some small aircraft makers on fitting their automotive engines for air uses, if your neighbour is still looking.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by Infernal on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:54PM (#19322136)
Flat six Subaru engines are also popular in experimental aviation.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by bluedino on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:30PM (#19322446)
So are Chevy Corvair engines (from the 60's)
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by dver on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:06PM (#19322249)
Never heard of this project. I would think it was influential on the development of the Falconer V-12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falconer_V-12 for the Thunder Mustang https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Papa_51_Thunder_Mustang
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by fjp on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @07:38PM (#19324557)
This is kind of an extreme case, to be fair it doesn't really disprove the statement which was about normal aftermarket car part markets.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by userbinator on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:31PM (#19324838)
A very extreme case indeed, aviation is so highly regulated that any mention of it outside of the usual context is going to ring alarm bells. But I bet if he was putting them in custom racecars or such, they wouldn't mind --- because that's the whole reason they're selling those engines in the first place.

Since this whole Tesla parts thing came up, I've always found it ironic that you can easily buy an entire powertrain based on the stereotypical half-century-old American V8 design and put it into a not-so-safe hot-rod, register it and drive it on the road (not that I'm saying that's a bad thing --- I'm a car enthusiast myself), but Tesla will refuse to sell you even minor cosmetic parts and quote "safety" as one of the reasons (and meanwhile, their misleading advertising for "autopilot" continues to generate deaths.)

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by twothamendment on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:39PM (#19324869)
It is extreme, but Ford cares about liability in all cases, but most cases don't cross wherever line their lawyers have drawn. The idea that they don't care is all I was going for. That and it is a story someone would enjoy.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by GhostVII on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @09:26PM (#19325082)
That sounds reasonable. If a company knows their engines aren't reliable enough for airplanes I think it is most ethical for them to refuse to sell them to people they know will use them in airplanes. I definitely wouldn't want to fly in an airplane with a car engine at least.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by ams6110 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:02PM (#19322219)
Why not sell the kit sans engine, and include specifications on which engine to buy?
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by jacquesm on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:59PM (#19322722)
If he was going to sell the plane as a kit why not simply sell it sans engine for the buyer to order individually? Beautiful plane by the way.

edit: I see someone else had the exact same question with almost the exact same word choice too!

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by sunstone on Thursday March 07, 2019 @09:24AM (#19328179)
My understanding is that Subaru engines are the most popular auto engine used in custom small aircraft. Maybe he can knock on their door.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:11AM (#19318590)
>It seems Tesla is deliberately ignoring or trying to squash the aftermarket/custom-car culture which has basically existed since cars existed...

Plenty of people are willing to aid them. Go on Reddit and you'll find that it's impossible to have an adult discussion of repairs or modifications more involved than parts swapping without being drowned out by people screaming "hurr durr, muh public safety" or just down-voted into oblivion. You'll find no shortage of people willing to tell you that industry standard modifications (like lengthening truck frames), repairs (like welding cracks in steel wheels) or anything that modifies how a vehicle handles compared to stock configuration (like a lift kit on a Jeep) are fundamentally a danger to the public.

Edit: I dunno why I was optimistic that HN would be any better.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by chrisdhoover on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:43PM (#19322016)
Why be optimistic, in this thread a poster insults blue collar workers. The poster is classist, elitist, and ignorant. Its not surprising to see appeals to authority, it is surprising to see the post not downvoted and the poster called out for what he is, an asshole.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by mcguire on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:23AM (#19319524)
When the "right to repair" comes up, for cars or farm machinery, or the Magnuson-Moss act, or the costs of code scanners for most vehicles, the manufacturers are universally hated.

But this is Tesla and Tesla doesn't have the same rules.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by adrianN on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:32AM (#19318733)
For any other kind of machine that can kill people, you are solely responsible for any accidents that could have been caused by your modification. I don't think that it's so unreasonable to want to apply this to cars too.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:40AM (#19318788)
Being responsible if you screw something up is how the world normally works. Just because something can be unsafe if done wrong doesn't mean the thing you are doing is fundamentally unsafe when done properly. Many people don't seem to understand this.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by majewsky on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @09:33AM (#19319154)
But that's exactly the reason why there is a lot of regulation of potentially hazardous activity. The likelihood of "when done wrong" is implied to be higher for backyard mechanics than for licensed mechanics in a garage.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by ghettoCoder on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:00AM (#19319866)
Like most things in life there's a wide range of skill even in licensed mechanics. Add to that the current trend of paying auto techs by the job instead of hourly in many dealerships and you have licensed techs rushing through jobs or low-dollar jobs done by apprentices.

That's how you get wheels falling off from not being torqued, bearing failing prematurely, brakes improperly adjusted or pads popping out, and the list goes on.

Unless you have a tech you know and trust (preferably an independent garage) do not rely on the fact they are licensed to guarantee safety. I could spend the next hour listing off instances of shoddy or incomplete work by licensed folks.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:58AM (#19320436)
> But that's exactly the reason why there is a lot of regulation of potentially hazardous activity.

Almost all of this as applied to hobbyists is corruption.

The amount of danger you can put yourself or others in without any involvement of automobiles is immense.

If you build an electrical device improperly it may catch fire and burn down your house and your neighbor's house and spread from there.

If you mix the wrong chemicals together you can cause an explosion, or produce poison gas, or create a large volume of something difficult to safely dispose of. These chemicals include things like propane and household cleaners that are available to anyone.

If you maintain unsanitary conditions where you live you can contract diseases that are communicable to others.

What prevents this from being more common is by and large not regulations and inspections of private citizens. It's the fact that people don't want uncontrolled fires or poison gas or staphylococcus and are generally cautious when doing things that are potentially dangerous.

And people don't want to destroy their $30,000 car or kill anyone either.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by rplst8 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:01PM (#19322210)
Common sense you say? We can't have that ruining our government-corporate oligopolies!
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by BenjiWiebe on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:20PM (#19322905)
Maybe, maybe not. There's plenty of horror stories about mechanics. There are some things on my car I wouldn't trust other people to do, even if they were licensed, certified, trained, etc. I just want to be able to be picky about each little thing, and know it's done right.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by almost_usual on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:24PM (#19322954)
I honestly have found the opposite. There have been times when I've taken my truck to a "licensed mechanic" and they failed to even torque my wheels to spec.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by thatcat on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @09:40AM (#19319199)
That doesn't preclude people from responsibly modifying cars or building their own planes or whatever.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:30AM (#19320129)
> That doesn't preclude people from responsibly modifying cars or building their own planes or whatever.

That's the point.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by sacheendra on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:32AM (#19318732)
I don't know about other things, but using a lift kit is more dangerous to pedestrians that might be hit. This stems from pedestrians being hit closer to the center of their body as opposed to their legs.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by SilasX on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @01:54PM (#19321495)
The people who raise up their cars also seem to never make the corresponding adjustments to the headlights, and end up blinding other drivers.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by ryandrake on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:35AM (#19319609)
Times have changed. Nowadays, when you talk to a random person about car repair, you're probably talking to someone who has never so much as changed their own oil or brake pads! They see auto repair as arcane wizardry that only government-licensed professionals can do safely.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by sokoloff on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:01PM (#19322207)
I trust myself (or the average DIY enthusiast who elects to perform the task) to correctly change their oil or brakes than I do a randomly selected ASE-certified technician. I know me, my wife, and my kids are going to be riding in that car and it's not coming off the jack until it's right.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by jdsully on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @05:04PM (#19323362)
The real scary part is when you only sometimes work on your car. You get to see all the mistakes the "pros" made. Missing bolts, over/under torqued lugs, and my current pain: replacing the battery 3 times when there's clearly a parasitic load that needs diagnosis.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by colanderman on Thursday March 07, 2019 @08:57AM (#19327998)
That's nothing. I once had a "pro" put my (clearly-marked asymmetric) tires on backward. That was a hella wobbly ride away from the shop. Another "pro" once inflated my tires to 80 PSI.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by jdsully on Thursday March 07, 2019 @04:32PM (#19332695)
Tires are always done by the most junior guy in the shop. I always double check those.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by crushcrashcrush on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:20PM (#19321746)
When you modify a truck lifting it, it's bumpers no longer "mate" to car bumpers and may not trigger an airbag system or worse, intrude into the cabin of a sedan. It's selfish and ridiculous.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @07:00PM (#19324278)
Light truck bumpers do not 'mate' to car bumpers at stock ride height. No lifting required.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by bertil on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:14AM (#19319452)
Why do you believe that Tesla’s assessment (One guy in his garage without any specific training might not have proper quality controls) isn’t authentic?
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by ryandrake on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:10AM (#19319964)
Well, their attempt to stop owner-conducted maintenance and aftermarket repair is authentic!

Assuming their assessment is correct, that a non-Tesla employed mechanic doesn’t have the training or quality controls, then my response to Tesla would be: “Document these quality controls and release sufficient information to allow a mechanic to become trained and qualified.”

In my view making this kind of information available should be required by law for any product.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by microcolonel on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:12AM (#19319976)
> In my view making this kind of information available should be required by law for any product.

AFAIK in the case of automobiles, it is already required by U.S. law. It is my understanding that they are obligated to make the same materials available to third party mechanics that they do to their own.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by FireBeyond on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:03PM (#19322223)
Tesla does a few things in regards to these laws.

One, they have an online parts catalog. Except, where pricing and purchase information are supposed to be listed, they say "Contact Tesla". For everything. Down to the most inane of bolts and nuts.

So you could "Contact Tesla". Who will tell you that you are unable to order any of those parts. Down to the most inane of bolts and nuts.

Or you could go to MA, where they are required to provide servicing information. How does that work?

You call ahead, and make an appointment. You also pay a fee which, the last time I heard, was $295.

When your appointment arrives you show up at the location and are lead into a room. You are not allowed: a cell phone, a camera, or a laptop, any "audio and/or video recording device". Handwritten notes only. And you have a time limit.

That's Tesla's "commitment to corporate transparency" (the same one they quoted when they bailed out of an NTSB investigation), and their "approach to third party repair" in a nutshell.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by perl4ever on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:48PM (#19322600)
Well, I think most people buying a Tesla know it's the Apple of cars. Repairs you can make to an iPhone are pretty limited too, and you certainly don't expect it to be useful in 10 years.

How else are we going to save the environment if we don't switch to cars that are as disposable as smartphones?

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by sokoloff on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:56PM (#19322161)
If that were the case, why would there be multiple "Right to Repair" initiatives? I don't think that documentation and tooling is required to be provided currently by federal law.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by microcolonel on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:30PM (#19322449)
> I don't think that documentation and tooling is required to be provided currently by federal law.

It is, but they can charge some amount for it (not prohibitively though). The biggest problems in R2R generally in the U.S. seem to stem from misuse of the DMCA as a mechanism to prevent modification of physical goods by making those goods rely on what they can argue are copyright protection devices (and thus difficult to legally circumvent).

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by perfmode on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:21AM (#19319505)
On the surface, Tesla's statement is authentic. It's just that Tesla has a financial incentive to be disingenuous about this... and it's hard to ignore the profit motive.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by bertil on Thursday March 07, 2019 @04:52PM (#19332885)
They could easily sell training for more than it costs them. Maintenance is annoying, and often a cost centre; labelling professionals allow them to offer a better service and guarantee the value of their cars.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by kw71 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:37AM (#19319628)
> It seems Tesla is deliberately ignoring or trying to squash the aftermarket/custom-car culture

This culture ("F your emissions controls," "I the lay blue collar know better than the committes of degreed engineers who designed the thing") has never cared about safety, nor has the aftermarket ("fitness for purpose, engineering, warranty... to hell with all that, the only requirement for our product is that some idiot should buy it")

Improperly repaired and modified cars are a detriment to the safety of others on the road, but wishing the problem away like Tesla is doing is not going to help anything, they need to publish and make accessible the documentation like the real car makers do.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:28AM (#19320112)
>Improperly repaired and modified cars are a detriment to the safety of others on the road

Mechanical failure is a fart in a hurricane compared to human factors (distraction, alcohol, run of the mill stupidity) when it comes to dangerous things on the road. Regulating mechanical condition is exponentially less effective once you start caring about more than the most basic things (e.g. heavy trucks with bald tires). That's why a handful of states have created then scrapped vehicle inspection programs. I get that it bothers people but mechanical failure is a tiny edge case compared to everything else. Why bother, there's other better things to spend our resources regulating if road safety is the goal. If mechanical condition mattered more than trivially this would be reflected in insurance rated between states with/without regulation covering this (inspection programs).

In my experience shitboxes with mufflers falling off and rust holes are more likely to damage community image than anything else.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by kw71 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @12:28PM (#19320732)
In the US, yea, inspections aren't universal, but the only inspection program I know of that has been scrapped was Florida's. I think there are more operating inspection regimes than defunct ones, even if you can cheat some of them. This also seems to be an anomaly among developed countries.

Rust that's more than superficial can lead to structural failure, and improper crash repairs can cause this. These are definitely situations that leave the vehicle in a lesser state of crashworthiness.

A compromised exhaust frequently leads to more exhaust entering the cabin.

This gets into the roots of my socialist beliefs as caring for our injured comrades brings us all down. There are always better things to send effort and resources to than dealing with the loss of productivity, the costs to deal with whatever damage, and misery of loved ones.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by ams6110 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:00PM (#19322186)
Indiana used to have safety inspections, scrapped several decades ago.

Part of the reason is probably that cars (even in rust prone areas) don't rust nearly as quickly as they used to, and everything else on the vehicle, e.g. tires, brakes, suspension are much better and (in the case of suspension components at least) require much less regular maintenance. There's just no low-hanging fruit any more. GP is right, resources are better spent elsewhere.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by Gibbon1 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:54PM (#19322131)
California had an inspections program and they got rid of it.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by toast0 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:49PM (#19325580)
When did California have a safety inspection program? I only know of the emissions inspection program, which still exists, but for most vehicles is simply does OBD-II say everything is fine, and is it not making visible smoke.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by Gibbon1 on Thursday March 07, 2019 @01:52AM (#19326056)
I think I am wrong,

https://repository.uchastings.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl...

Says vehicle inspections were considered and repeatedly rejected.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by Forbo on Thursday March 07, 2019 @12:58PM (#19330332)
Utah recently got rid of safety inspections.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by perl4ever on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:50PM (#19322633)
"This gets into the roots of my socialist beliefs"

Regulation is not socialism. And being in favor of regulation or socialism shouldn't mean that you are against intelligent regulations that take into account costs and benefits.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by rjplatte on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:50PM (#19333423)
It's common for favoring socialism and being in favor of intelligent regulation to be mutually exclusive.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by perl4ever on Thursday March 07, 2019 @06:50PM (#19333849)
I don't believe there is anybody who believes the government does useful things and wants it to be stupid.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by newnewpdro on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:29PM (#19321847)
> Improperly repaired and modified cars are a detriment to the safety of others on the road

I'll take streets full of gearheads tinkering with their cars over soccer moms ignoring grinding brakes until the rotor disc completely separates from the hat/hub any day.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by tomatotomato37 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:14PM (#19322858)
It frustrates me too that for every tuner that gets too excited with their camber there are a hundred shitboxes with bald tires and janky emission systems that stopped being effective sometime in the Clinton administration, yet for some reason the tuners are the ones commonly vilified.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by newnewpdro on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @05:39PM (#19323656)
I'm excited about EVs improving this situation.

With ICEs it's somewhat necessary to become more obnoxious in pursuit of greater performance. Faster ICE-powered cars tend to be noisier and stinkier, it's somewhat inherent.

Gearheads in the EV-era will be a lot less visible. You won't know who has upgraded their batteries, controllers, and motors. I wish Tesla would take a different stance on this and instead embrace and support the grassroots motorsports scene. GM Performance has already announced an EV crate motor, so it looks like GM might be taking the lead here.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by btilly on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:40PM (#19321988)
You have a point.

The gearheads just have their cars sitting there in non-running condition while they tinker. The soccer moms are driving around with noisy distractions in the back seat.

(Only halfway joking. I have 4 kids.)

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by rplst8 on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:54PM (#19322132)
It's much worse than you think. Some states don't require regular safety inspections. I've seen some scary stuff on the road in those states.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:00PM (#19322195)
If those states were measurably less safe wouldn't that be reflected in insurance premiums? Mechanical failure is inconsequential compared to boring old human factors (distractions, alcohol, bad decisions) when it comes to dangers on the road.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by btilly on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:52PM (#19322654)
The problem is that there are confounding factors.

States with regular inspections tend to have more expensive cars, higher wealth, higher traffic density and so on. Those factors are going to drive insurance rates up as well.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by sgustard on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @05:18PM (#19323475)
This is how every industry progresses as software replaces hardware. I don't think it's fair to blame Tesla for it. A modern car is much less accessible to the home tinkerer than a car from the 80s, because it's a chip controlling the fuel/air mixture and not a valve on a spring, and so on. As a side effect these machines are much cleaner and safer than before, so I'm willing to accept the tradeoff.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @06:42PM (#19324143)
An EV is supposed to be much, much simpler than even a decades old ICE car. Aside from the tech inside the batteries, it should be pretty easy to tinker with.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:41AM (#19319674)
E-cars are nowhere near a car culture, because of the significant innovations in every ecar that have no history, nobody you can collaborate with to learn. It may someday be a culture, but not yet. Its something new under the sun. Maybe its sensible to go slowly.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by olefoo on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:01AM (#19319887)
Some of the very first automobiles were electric vehicles. And Tesla's vehicles inherit a lot from the existing automobile industry. The fact that Tesla is trying to kill aftermarket/modder culture around their vehicles is just a sign of how strong that culture is.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by microcolonel on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:11AM (#19319966)
> E-cars are nowhere near a car culture, because of the significant innovations in every ecar that have no history, nobody you can collaborate with to learn. It may someday be a culture, but not yet. Its something new under the sun. Maybe its sensible to go slowly.

People have been building electric cars independently for a long time, but it is a smaller culture since some of the parts (particularly the motors) are not commodities yet.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @11:30AM (#19320126)
Should we count old lead-acid carts? There hasn't been a century of ecar culture; there is a very small current population with any expertise.

Let's not be pedantic - the ICE culture is millions strong, and generations old.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by tomp on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:31AM (#19318724)
I imagine batteries are much more dangerous to handle than mechanical car parts, and software is much more important in a Tesla on the road... This is just like the "NO WARRANTY IMPLIED OR EXPRESS" that comes with basically every piece of software (open source or commercial) these days.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @12:10PM (#19320590)
> I imagine batteries are much more dangerous to handle than mechanical car parts

If you imagine batteries are much more dangerous to handle than mechanical car parts containing gasoline, you are not sufficiently familiar with gasoline.

> and software is much more important in a Tesla on the road

Doing things in software doesn't make them more dangerous than doing them mechanically. Removing the speed governor or modifications that increase power output have the same consequences whether they are implemented in software or hardware.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:17PM (#19333106)
Doing things in software doesn't make them more dangerous than doing them mechanically

I wish I could find you a reference right now, but the FDA would strongly disagree with you.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by tomp on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @01:44PM (#19321398)
Gasoline is relatively harmless unless you light it up. Batteries contain acid and can combust spontaneously.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:04PM (#19321597)
Gasoline is a flammable liquid carcinogen that evaporates into a highly explosive vapor with an ignition temperature lower than the operating temperature of many exhaust system components.

Lithium batteries typically don't contain acid.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by xondono on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @02:53PM (#19322128)
They only contain Lithium composites, that are highly reactive with oxigen (i.e. they combust spontaneously) and are fairly toxic.

If your modified gas engine seems to work, you are quite safe. If your modified Tesla seems to work, it might well explode the next second..

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by perl4ever on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @03:56PM (#19322689)
"If your modified gas engine seems to work, you are quite safe"

I think you are overstating your case. I have seen cars on fire by the side of the road...although it is possible it started with an electrical fault.

I believe that it's not that rare for a model of car I own to have a leak develop in the fuel lines and drip fuel onto a hot manifold and start a fire.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by userbinator on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @08:20PM (#19324772)
They only contain Lithium composites, that are highly reactive with oxigen (i.e. they combust spontaneously)

You're making the classic mistake of assuming lithium-ion batteries contain metallic lithium --- it's called lithium-ion for a reason. Primary lithium cells, which are basically never used for EVs, do contain metallic lithium; but lion cells contain lithium salts and a dissolved solution of lithium ions in the electrolyte.

The electrolyte is a flammable organic solvent, but not more so than petrol. Lion batteries catch fire because the massive energy they store is released when damaged, and that ignites the electrolyte.

Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @07:08PM (#19324332)
When you put out a gas fire, it's done. Try that with a lithium battery fire.
Re:A backyard mechanic who is taking on Tesla by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 07, 2019 @11:36PM (#19335121)
When you put out a gas fire, there is still gasoline everywhere, spreading and evaporating until it reaches another heat source above its relatively low ignition temperature, which frequently exist in the vicinity as a result of the recent collision and fire. This can also cause the fire to spread, since the gasoline can flow into a wider area before it reignites. And if enough of the gasoline has evaporated, the reignition can take the form of an explosion.

Battery fires can be hard to put out, but it's a solid component designed to keep the fire from spreading outside of it. If gasoline reignites you better hope you didn't get any on you.