Interest is the ultimate rent seeking activity. The fed funds rate is a form of price fixing for banks whereby they collectively decide how much interest they can extract from the economy without killing it. Why must this be the case, the economy should be allowed to run much hotter for much longer.
Inflation is less of a risk now because of technology + globalization, right now we are experiencing significant deflationary pressure as products and labor converge towards global pricing/wages.
Our economy and government will be in very serious trouble if we have to pay higher interest on our significant national debt, so the government has a big interest (pun intended) in keeping rates low to protect its own financial solvency.
Finally, high interest rates imply money is scarce and that's far from the case now. Having large sums of money is not what it used to be, you're competing against a lot of other people and organizations seeking to deploy that money productively for a return. This generates downward pressure on market interest rates as evidenced by European Central banks going below zero to negative rates.
Certainly it can be done, but if 2008 proved anything it was the theory that lowering interest rates would provide Keynesian stimulus and mitigate the impact of a recession. One of the perks of controlling the interest rate is that you can use it to apply counterpressure to the business cycle, pushing down bubbles and pulling out of recessions. If the interest rate is stuck near 0, you can't really do that, so it's in the interest of economic stability to bring it back up again.
The fed and other banks didn't just help the credit market grow (via lowering interest rates), they quite literally bought it to keep money flow up. There was a substantial credit freeze, and many parts of the financial system were on death's door. So governments and banks quite literally just went "take this huge wad of cash, please stay in business." And by huge wad of cash, we're talking about $12 trillion dollars of bailouts, stimulus packages, debt bonds, etc. Twelve. Trillion. In one year. The entire GDP of the U.S in 2017 was about $20 trillion.
Wages at the time were too low (oh, imagine that) to mitigate any kind of credit stasis on the monetary system. It would have had a compounding effect. No credit, no consumption, no consumption, no economy.
We "fixed" two of those. But we did it in a manner that requires us to pay for it at some point. So here we are.
Bring wages up. Allow the credit to be repaid. And not just consumer credit, corporate credit as well. Allow the federal reserve to finally increase interest rates. Make the economy truly robust again, instead of just "letting the good times roll" and creating another crisis.
Companies have to start paying workers more for us to get out of this mess.
We have socialized risks and privatized profits.
Source? Typically this doesn't actually happen. In fact there is very little evidence for tax cuts "injecting" (whatever this actually means) cash into the economy.
>It occurs to me that the tight labor market is forcing wages higher naturally.
It's a well understood fact that labor markets actually don't equalize in a supply/demand fashion. I want to know why you think this is the case?
Where does that $500 go? One or two places. You either 1) spend it on something or 2) invest it in something (which will result in that getting spent by the entity "borrowing" it).
> I want to know why you think this is the case?
I have had to raise the wages paid by my business to retain employees due to other businesses in my industry raising their wages.
No research needed for these two thoughts. Direct observation and application of logic.
My favorite piece about this issue was from This American Life and NPR News: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/355/the-giant-pool-of-money
Because that violates a big part of the dual mandate of the federal reserve. Lowering interest rates indefinitely makes borrowing money super easy, and you essentially cause a credit cascade. At certain levels, borrowing money means the fed is able to print more money. But if no one can really pay that money back, that bubble pops. And if you keep lowering interest rates to correct for that you'll get inflation. Lots of inflation. To the point where the money becomes useless.
>Inflation is less of a risk now because of technology + globalization
I have quite literally never heard this thought before, and at face value it doesn't make a lick of sense. you can't just vaguely pay lipservice to two very broad terms and act like it's going to make inflation irrelevant? What?
>Finally, high interest rates imply money is scarce and that's far from the case now.
No it means that the economy shouldn't/isn't/can't really borrow more. The first one tends to be the primary reason for increasing interest rates. You can't just keep borrowing indefinitely. Because again, that makes money useless.
We're already in a bit of a pickle at the moment. And we're seeing signs that the economy is starting to slip -- but we can still reverse and put an end to these signs. Consumer and corporate credit is at an all time high. Just last quarter, the number of people that are delinquent on their car loans spiked. Car payments are something people typically let slip during a financial squeeze, because it's hard for the bank to recoup it in a timely manner. But not paying your credit card or electric bill, those kind of services get shut off immediately.
Lower interest rates allowed the current credit spike we're seeing. But at some point it has to be paid back. But if people don't have the real wages to pay back those loans AND keep spending money, you're going to see a squeeze on the service sector. And that's not going to be good for the American economy.
I don't mean this to sound harsh, but then you haven't been listening.
Its a well known established fact that technology causes 'good' deflation. The number one cited example of this is the printing press, but honestly the internet has probably been a bigger effect.
globalization has also been very commonly cited as a source of lower inflation / deflation. you may disagree with it, but you should have heard about it.
I'm just going to be nice and tell you that you are severely conflating multiple issues here. Technological advancements have played literally no part in the monetary policy of the last decade. Monetary policies have largely been focused on making sure cash flow is first and foremost, present, and secondly consistent.
if monetary policy is implemented by a magic 8 ball, that remains true.
The motivations and effects of monetary policy? To sit there and say that a fiat system isn't subject to inflationary pressures, or even are less burdened by them, brought about changes in interest rates because of technological advancements is a hilariously misplaced idea and thing to bring up.
I feel like I want to call this economic bike shedding? The tiniest detail has no sway on anything when you're talking about policies actively affecting trillions of dollars of cash and credit. We're talking in a time scale of a year, not half a century.
2ndly, interest rates were not very effective in these last recessions, the common metaphor is that its like pushing rope. So maybe its better for the fed to fight recessions with QE (or something else) and leave interest rates to 'fight' inflation.
And with debt now is better than later.
I very much agree on this.
To me, it seems like the Fed left rates too low for too long coming out of the recession in 2000, which set up the bubble of 2008. They don't want to do it again.
And when 2008 hit, they wound up against the "zero bound" of interest rates, where they couldn't lower any further, and they don't want to do that again, either. If they want some distance away from the zero bound, they have to raise rates sometime.
"But we can't raise them now! The economy is too fragile!" Yeah, we've been hearing that for a decade. And, as the parent said, we can't sit there and leave interest rates low forever.
Maybe low interest rates are the new normal, they've been on an overall downward path for decades so it's not entirely a recent thing.
I don't really get raising interest rates to have more ammunition in a recession either. Sure, you have more room to cut later, but raising interest rates itself slows the economy down. Unless the stimulating power you get from cutting is more than slowing effect from raising, it doesn't seem like it gets you anywhere, since you're just digging a deeper hole that you need to get out of.
It's another thing if it's in conjunction with fiscal policy (looser fiscal policy, which then leads to raising rates, after which there's more room to cut in a recession). But then I think that's mainly an argument for having different fiscal policy and not just about raising rates.
Central bankers seem to be aware that not being able to lower interest rates is going to be problematic in the next recession (along with diminished QE effectiveness etc.). They aren't completely out of options to fight deflation (there's always helicopter money etc.) but we do seem to be in uncharted territory.
If you keep inflating the balloon, it's going to bulge out somewhere. And last time was bad.
I don't think there is any evidence at all that the Fed raising (or not raising) the interest rates is an attempt to dictate the minimum wage level. The Fed's mandate from Congress is to aim for three goals: "...maximum sustainable employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates."
https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/what-economic-goals-does...
Let's not use Fed policy in trying to achieve their mandates as a pretext for some other policy someone wants to promote.
Like, rates in the 70s used to be around 20%. And now, the fed doesn’t have the balls to raise it 500 bips. It’s ridiculous.
Yes and yes - but how? The interest rate is only monetary policy, not fiscal. Traditionally, low rates were expansionary. Maybe we need lower rates?
That's not true at all. There is no dataset that supports this position. And we have data against it. Mainly every time we've forcefully increased the minimum wage.
Maybe if there was a way to band together and seek a unified compensation policy on a company/industry basis.
I don't think the problem is that people haven't considered unionizing, nor because of constraints put on union due collection.
Productivity up, population up. That will have an impact on wages for sure.
Outside of technology workers are still looked at as replaceable and expendable. I’m not sure what is going to break the ceiling in this climate.
I know HN users tend to have 'high horse' syndrome, but this is incredibly naiive. There are plenty of skilled jobs where workers are not easily replaced/expended. Physicians, RNs, higher education teachers/professors, many jobs related to architecture design, construction, etc.
> I’m not sure what is going to break the ceiling in this climate.
There's been recent success in the old school technique of 'striking'.
My past experience is from working in farming, then manual labor, then skilled labor, then engineering, then hospitality, then technology. In none of the fields other than technology did I feel that myself or my colleagues were viewed as anything other than a source of costs by management. Even when our contributions were praised by customers as the reason why they continued their business with the company, we were barely rewarded with more than a pat on the back. Perfection was assumed as the standard, however it was not rewarded as such.
It was not until I taught myself to program, with the help of a great number of people, and jumped over to working in the tech industry that my managers looked at me as a source of value in the company, as the reason why the company made money, and as less than disposable.
That is not to say that my experience is everyone's experience, and I didn't mean to imply such an extreme position as "only in technology can you be valued as a worker". If you work in healthcare, or law, or the sciences, or manufacturing, or construction, or education and your organization values you then I applaud you and efforts.
With that said I still feel that it's a tough road ahead to get the compensation you deserve. Even when the economy is strong, it is hard to get a raise, and people have been waiting on those raises for a long time. I sure hope they can get them.
All of those skilled jobs you speak of are full of people who don't understand what good a union does. Literally complaining that a union is worthless while reaping the benefits and job stability that only a union can provide. I don't know if it's a matter of education or if people are really just going to have to experience for themselves how horrible the working world is/will become when there are no unions to protect them...
This is a ridiculously juvenile view of how the world works. You need not look further than insert fortune 500 company who lays off highly paid sr. technical staff and replace them with jr. Claiming they provide no value to the company is asinine.
That might have worked 15 years ago, but I think it's going to take unions and government, working along near-parallel vectors, to bring the economy back into a sustainable power-balance among its various institutions.
Corporate management and moneyed elites have erected a nice little fortress full of positive feedback loops for themselves, and have been steadily plugging the holes in it for 40 solid years now. They're working on mindless, robotic slave labor in an effort to defeat the labor unions forever, but they're also still relatively open to attack by government, as buying it off with corruption has so far been sufficient to keep it at bay.
There's no more effective way for labor to throw its weight around than collectivizing in bite-sized (i.e. company-sized) bargaining units; history tells us this is so and evidence gives us no reason to think it won't work again.
They're not perfect (no democratic organization is), but the only thing more corrupt than a union is management.
Taft-Hartley banned wildcat strikes, but I think if we saw more of those (despite their present-day illegality) we'd see a ton more actions favorable to workers taking place.
Of course, we should roll back the labor-hostile parts of Taft-Hartley (like the bans on wildcat strikes and the restrictions on speech surrounding union organizing), but that'll take more time.
Well, then can sit there for as long as we aren't seeing the negative effects of low interest rates. IE, inflation. Which we aren't seeing.
> If not now, when?
When inflation starts happening. That's when. But that is not happening now, so we are good.
It's really that simple. The whole point of raising inflation rates is to prevent high inflation. But if there isn't any high inflation then there isn't any problem!
Real wages and real purchasing power must keep going up. And for that to happen the upper 1% are going to have to take a nice hit for the economy to truly correct. Both effectively need to happen at the same time. The FED is essentially signalling to policy makers that the time to up minimum wage is... was, yesterday.
I want to challenge you to really dive into your perspective and defend why you think the fed miscalculated here, and why you think leaving interest rates low isn't going to have extremely negative effects if we don't start changing course now. If not now, when?