News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by petermcneeley on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:44PM (#19229837)
This looks to be a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor and is a very common hobby fusion project. A very powerful electric field drives the fusion. No positive energy output from this style of device has ever been reported.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by atemerev on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:59PM (#19229944)
It is “common” (as in not unique), but assembling a fusor and getting actual neutrons from it is still a very big deal, especially for a 12 years old. I am a nuclear engineering enthusiast at 35, I know a lot about these devices, but I doubt I could build a fusor on my own at home. It is a big engineering project.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by mrob on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:39PM (#19231006)
Note that a lot of "fusors" are actually "demo fusors", i.e. they run at too low energy to produce detectable fusion even if you did fuel them with deuterium. A "demo fusor" just produces plasma that looks similar without doing real fusion.

This article is about the real thing, which is substantially more difficult to build.

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by Florin_Andrei on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:22PM (#19231380)
The key is - does it make neutrons or not?

If it does, it's fusing. If not, it isn't.

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by agumonkey on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:34PM (#19230616)
Yeah the age is probably the news here. I remember older teens (HS junior) doing the same.. but 12 .. that's young. Kudos to him.

Hopefully mother nature decided he would be the chosen one to make fusion reactor net positive

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by solarkraft on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:14PM (#19231150)
Then again: Why would he?; There are are thousands of very smart people working on this. While this is an excellent demonstration of his ability, I doubt he could actually outbid professional researchers.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by aaomidi on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:25PM (#19231190)
A lot of science has been dumb luck and doing some random thing at the right time.

I mean I hope for all of us this is one of those cases.

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by coldtea on Saturday February 23, 2019 @07:41AM (#19233082)
It was just a kind comment to applaud his ingenuity at such a young age. It wasn't meant to be interpreted as a factual statement.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by agumonkey on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:28PM (#19231199)
Nothing serious man, part of me just want fusion energy to exist (although humanity will probably abuse it ..)
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by hiyer on Saturday February 23, 2019 @04:17AM (#19232483)
Humanity already knows how to abuse fusion energy.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by agumonkey on Saturday February 23, 2019 @08:11AM (#19233187)
I tend to say that we're not using it enough :D
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by mikeash on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:12PM (#19230439)
And to clarify, no net energy is expected from such a device.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by mrfusion on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:06PM (#19229999)
There’s really no reason positive energy output should be impossible though? I guess it’s just a really inefficient design?
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by wahern on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:26PM (#19230150)
It is impossible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor#Radiation The issue is bremsstrahlung radiation. I only have high-school physics education, but AFAIU basically because the charged particles are constantly turning inward, the constant negative acceleration radiates energy away. The faster the particles move in the device, the harder the deceleration, the more energy they give up relative to the input energy. These losses overcome the system before the break-even point. The same process limits the energies that can be achieved in non-linear particle accelerators, like the Large Hadron Collider; it's why the accelerator ring diameter has to grow to achieve higher particle energies. The LHC has a circumference of 27 kilometers. Fusors are... slightly smaller. You don't really need to do the math or understand the physics to appreciate that Fusors are a dead-end.

It's worth reading the whole article. The Fusor design has a long and fascinating history. One of the original inventors, Farnsworth, invented television.

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by JamesBarney on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:59PM (#19230798)
Your highschool physics education was way better than mine.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by cpb on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:25PM (#19230543)
> bremsstrahlung radiation

Oh that familiar rascal... Always getting the better of positive energy output.

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by pontifier on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:59AM (#19238104)
My understanding is that grid collisions, and a region of cool gas that forms in the center are the main limiting factors in this design. Bremsstrahlung is there, but is it the main source of loss?
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by coolaliasbro on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:51PM (#19230748)
"...it's why the accelerator ring diameter has to grow to achieve higher particle energies. The LHC has a circumference of 27 kilometers."

Please humor me. Does this mean that if the LHC had x diameter, it would perform the same if it was 1km in circumference?

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by wahern on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:14PM (#19230885)
Bad choice of phrasing on my part as diameter is ambiguous. Also I could only find a reference for the circumference and was too lazy to derive the diameter from the circumference to avoid the ambiguity by making it clear which diameter I was referring to. (EDIT: Diameter is ~8.6km: `echo "pi=4*a(1);27/pi" | bc -l`.)

It's not the diameter of the tube but the diameter of the circular path the particles follow through the ring. The greater the circumference the less the relative angular acceleration (i.e. shallower curvature). To accelerate particles even faster without giving up most of the extra input energy to bremsstrahlung radiation you must increase the circumference to maintain the same relative angular acceleration.

It's Friday and math[1] and physics is not something I can do off the top of my head so at this point it's better if someone else step in. I won't be able to describe it correctly without relearning half of this stuff myself.

[1] I mean... the algebra and geometry is rather trivial but it'll take some effort for me to correct and make more precise the terminology and formulas.

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by thaumasiotes on Saturday February 23, 2019 @02:35AM (#19232228)
> Also I could only find a reference for the circumference and was too lazy to derive the diameter from the circumference to avoid the ambiguity by making it clear which diameter I was referring to. (EDIT: Diameter is ~8.6km: `echo "pi=4*a(1);27/pi" | bc -l`.)

...is the LHC track a circle?

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by rnestler on Saturday February 23, 2019 @04:53AM (#19232565)
Not a perfect circle. It consists of multiple arc segments and the detectors which are straight. See also https://home.cern/science/accelerators/large-hadron-collider
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by DennisP on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:18PM (#19230082)
It'e been proven that this particular design can't achieve net power, but other designs probably can. Scientists are especially confident about the tokamak, for example. (And of course, thermonuclear bombs definitely achieve net power.)
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by UnpossibleJim on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:13PM (#19230446)
Thermonuclear bombs work on nuclear fission not fusion, just to clear up any confusion. Nuclear power plants also achieve power from fission, which is the breaking of nuclear bonds.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by robotresearcher on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:18PM (#19230487)
No, the defining characteristic of thermonuclear bomb is a second stage fusion device. The first stage fission device sets off the second stage.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermonuclear_weapon

Edit: just acknowledging the funny set of identical replies!

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by UnpossibleJim on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:07PM (#19230856)
Oh! My bad =) I should have looked it up first. I always thought it was take the unstable uranium isotope and surround it with a horrible amount of explosive material which was set at a controlled time to pressure the uranium into a cascading reaction. Turns out, I'm running on the 1940's Popeye cartoon explanation =[
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by robotresearcher on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:04PM (#19231118)
You're right but for the name. That's how the fission nuclear bomb works. Then you combine it with a heavy hydrogen fusion stage to get a thermonuclear ('hydrogen') bomb.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by neutronicus on Saturday February 23, 2019 @03:51PM (#19235391)
No, the person you're replying to is right, the bulk of the energy is from fission. What the fusion does is serve essentially as a "tamper" - it's in a ring around the fissile core and as it explodes it compresses the fissile core. Since the fission rate increases exponentially this tamping dramatically increases the overall energy yield.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by grkvlt on Sunday February 24, 2019 @10:41PM (#19242710)
No, that is NOT what the 'tamper' is or does. See my (or various other) nearby comments where I describe the actual process, or just read the Wiki article linked in another comment...
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by robotresearcher on Saturday February 23, 2019 @06:00PM (#19235971)
I think we all agree that fission AND fusion are involved in a thermonuclear weapon.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by Yetanfou on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:18PM (#19230484)
No, thermonuclear bombs [1] are fusionbombs. Nuclear bombs can be of both types but the term thermonuclear specifically means (partly) fusion-powered bombs. These bombs always use a fission reaction as a starter for the fusion reaction, depending on the type of bomb the power output can be anywhere from mostly fusion to largely fission.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermonuclear_weapon

Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by Denvercoder9 on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:21PM (#19230509)
No, thermonuclear bombs actually work on nuclear fusion (started by a smaller fission bomb).
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by msds on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:54PM (#19230763)
Well, GP didn't mean this, but most thermonuclear bombs derive a large amount of their yield from fission of a U238 "tamper" and "sparkplug", driving by neutrons from D-T fusion.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by blackflame7000 on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:18PM (#19230901)
Technically, there is no pure fusion bomb so I guess in a way you could say everything is fission powered, but that's like saying your gasoline car is battery powered because that's what started the engine.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by msds on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:43PM (#19231454)
Nope! Essentially all modern large thermonuclear devices are fission-fusion-fission devices, where the last fission stage (again, driven by fusion neutrons) produces the majority of the yield. You can omit that stage, by using a non-fissile material, for easier testing (...do you really want to test a 100MT device?...) with less fallout, but in actual use, they would all have fissile tampers.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by grkvlt on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:20PM (#19231595)
Except that in a thermonuclear bomb, fission also occurs at the end as well as the start... The initial fission explosion starts off a fusion reaction, and then neutrons from the fusion process carry on to start another fission reaction, usually of the LEU 'tamper' encasing the bomb. In fact, a large proportion of the energy output is from this third stage fission reaction.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by hutzlibu on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:10PM (#19230025)
Well, you are free to provide a better design. Problems are many, mostly the very high temperature and pressure needed to achieve fusion ... no material can stand that so you need to have your fusion happening floating which needs energy etc.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by webkike on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:07PM (#19230006)
Doesn’t that answer your own question?
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom... by blackflame7000 on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:06PM (#19230844)
Apparently one of the problems with this device is that much of the energy is lost when the ions strike the inner electrodes and that got me thinking. What if there were a way to construct a sort of thin inert buffer on the electrodes with say a noble gas, to facilitate ion collisions over ion conduction?