Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by UnpossibleJim on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:13PM
(#19230446)
Thermonuclear bombs work on nuclear fission not fusion, just to clear up any confusion. Nuclear power plants also achieve power from fission, which is the breaking of nuclear bonds.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by robotresearcher on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:18PM
(#19230487)
No, the defining characteristic of thermonuclear bomb is a second stage fusion device. The first stage fission device sets off the second stage.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermonuclear_weapon
Edit: just acknowledging the funny set of identical replies!
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by UnpossibleJim on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:07PM
(#19230856)
Oh! My bad =) I should have looked it up first. I always thought it was take the unstable uranium isotope and surround it with a horrible amount of explosive material which was set at a controlled time to pressure the uranium into a cascading reaction. Turns out, I'm running on the 1940's Popeye cartoon explanation =[
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by robotresearcher on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:04PM
(#19231118)
You're right but for the name. That's how the fission nuclear bomb works. Then you combine it with a heavy hydrogen fusion stage to get a thermonuclear ('hydrogen') bomb.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by neutronicus on Saturday February 23, 2019 @03:51PM
(#19235391)
No, the person you're replying to is right, the bulk of the energy is from fission. What the fusion does is serve essentially as a "tamper" - it's in a ring around the fissile core and as it explodes it compresses the fissile core. Since the fission rate increases exponentially this tamping dramatically increases the overall energy yield.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by grkvlt on Sunday February 24, 2019 @10:41PM
(#19242710)
No, that is NOT what the 'tamper' is or does. See my (or various other) nearby comments where I describe the actual process, or just read the Wiki article linked in another comment...
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by robotresearcher on Saturday February 23, 2019 @06:00PM
(#19235971)
I think we all agree that fission AND fusion are involved in a thermonuclear weapon.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by Yetanfou on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:18PM
(#19230484)
No, thermonuclear bombs [1] are fusionbombs. Nuclear bombs can be of both types but the term thermonuclear specifically means (partly) fusion-powered bombs. These bombs always use a fission reaction as a starter for the fusion reaction, depending on the type of bomb the power output can be anywhere from mostly fusion to largely fission.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by Denvercoder9 on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:21PM
(#19230509)
No, thermonuclear bombs actually work on nuclear fusion (started by a smaller fission bomb).
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by msds on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:54PM
(#19230763)
Well, GP didn't mean this, but most thermonuclear bombs derive a large amount of their yield from fission of a U238 "tamper" and "sparkplug", driving by neutrons from D-T fusion.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by blackflame7000 on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:18PM
(#19230901)
Technically, there is no pure fusion bomb so I guess in a way you could say everything is fission powered, but that's like saying your gasoline car is battery powered because that's what started the engine.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by msds on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:43PM
(#19231454)
Nope! Essentially all modern large thermonuclear devices are fission-fusion-fission devices, where the last fission stage (again, driven by fusion neutrons) produces the majority of the yield. You can omit that stage, by using a non-fissile material, for easier testing (...do you really want to test a 100MT device?...) with less fallout, but in actual use, they would all have fissile tampers.
Re:12-Year-Old Claims to Have Achieved Nuclear Fusion at Hom...
by grkvlt on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:20PM
(#19231595)
Except that in a thermonuclear bomb, fission also occurs at the end as well as the start... The initial fission explosion starts off a fusion reaction, and then neutrons from the fusion process carry on to start another fission reaction, usually of the LEU 'tamper' encasing the bomb. In fact, a large proportion of the energy output is from this third stage fission reaction.