News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by Gravityloss on Friday February 22, 2019 @03:49AM (#19223964)
Space resource usage could first happen with asteroids, not on the Moon or Mars. Propellants mined from asteroids can be transferred anywhere with very low delta V and low thrust. It just takes time.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by zaarn on Friday February 22, 2019 @04:06AM (#19224021)
The moon would be acceptable and Mars is simply the next big thing.

Esp. the moon because you can use a cannon to launch spacecraft so you don't need to use fuel on it (if you'd do it with a magnetic cannon you could do it entirely with solar arrays).

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by mirekrusin on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:50AM (#19224404)
Escape velocity is more than 2km/s, roughly the speed of bullet, that's a bit too much to "launch spacecraft" or am I missing something?

ps. it's actually interesting concept, you could have something similar to medieval catapult on the Moon and throw rocks on Earth which would be equivalent to nuclear explosions, no?

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by wongarsu on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:59AM (#19224616)
Accelerating from 0 to 2km/s at 3g (suitable for humans) takes about 60 seconds, and a barrel that's about 70km long (40 miles). That's no easy feat, but certainly achievable. You can get around the barrel length by building a circular barrel (with it's own set of problems).

Just launching cargo is a lot easier, we already know how to accelerate things to the speed of a bullet in a variety of ways. Scaling up a railgun to handle heavier bullets is comparatively easy.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pjc50 on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:27AM (#19225042)
A single long metal rail would suffice, with a maglev acceleration system. Lack of atmosphere makes it easier too. Could probably manage up to 10g with a bit of scaling at the ends, although might be bad for people who'd been on the moon for a while.

Cargo could be made to go much, much faster.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by VikingCoder on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:26AM (#19226587)
For payloads, I suspect a Slingatron on the moon would work well...

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/391496725/the-slingatro...

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by zaarn on Friday February 22, 2019 @01:06PM (#19227507)
For non-alive payloads you can accelerate at >10g and get a comfortably short rail to fire the bullet from.

For alive payloads, the rail becomes longer.

The advantage is that on the moon the low gravity and no atmosphere make megastructures like this easier to build. Energy is also no concern either, you have pure unfiltered sunlight for about 15 days each month on each side of the moon.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by mirimir on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:53AM (#19224593)
See Heinlein's The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by RegBarclay on Friday February 22, 2019 @03:03PM (#19228625)
RIP NORAD
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by steve_musk on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:58AM (#19224422)
No/little air resistance and plenty of space mean that you could accelerate the spacecraft over a longer period of time
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by gandutraveler on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:41PM (#19227258)
Shouldn't the escape velocity be way less when firing from moon to earth ?
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by sisu2019 on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:16AM (#19224473)
It sounds cool sure, but what resources do we even want from asteroids? We have plenty rocks and ice on earth and even something like iron ore is just 0,08$ per kilo. Getting that kilo to LEO is 2200$ and getting cheaper every year. We have all the resources and infrastructure we need right here on earth while absolutely no one has any idea how to manufacture things in space.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by whiskers08xmt on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:34AM (#19224773)
A lot of heavy rare earth metals can only be found in very limited concentrations in the earth's crust, with the largest concentrations all being from asteroid impacts. As a consequence, these metals are incredibly valuable. A single high-concentration asteroid, could provide more of these metals than has been mined in the history of the earth, in high concentrations, and may be able to make a host of applications economically viable, which previously weren't.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by sisu2019 on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:30AM (#19225076)
The rare earth scarcity scare is already receding: https://www.theverge.com/2018/4/17/17246444/rare-earth-metal...

Yeah, heavy REMs are still expensive but there is really no reason to believe that they'll stay that way. New sites will be found, new extraction techniques will be tried and new processes developed and then the problem will go away. Sure, it could happen in space but it's so much easier to do here on earth that it might never be worth it to go to space for it.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by Brakenshire on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:48AM (#19226772)
The guy's misusing "rare earth", in that phrase rare refers to the concentration in the ore, not the abundance in the crust.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by metalliqaz on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:52AM (#19225231)
but it would be, by far, the most expensive mining operation in the history of mining operations
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by mr_overalls on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:23AM (#19225522)
Yes, but if several thousand tons of iridium, platinum, or various rare-earth metals could be captured & towed to Earth orbit, the payoff could be astronomical.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by HarryHirsch on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:36AM (#19226671)
Suddenly there would be so much of a supply that the sale won't be profitable any longer. That's probably the reason why no one is extracting rhodium from nuclear waste, where it is a common fission product.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by bluGill on Friday February 22, 2019 @04:57PM (#19229499)
I've been told that the trucking industry needs every year more platinum than has been mined in all of history. Since there obviously isn't supply they instead use alternative means to achieve their emissions goals.

I'm not an emissions system engineer so I can't evaluate the truth of the statement. If it is true, and supply existed: it would create demand, potentially it could even drive up price as potential users quit using less desirable alternatives.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by mr_overalls on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:55AM (#19226830)
That's why I suggested orbit, where the supply could be parceled out (or its true extent even kept secret) so as not to crash the market.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by HarryHirsch on Friday February 22, 2019 @04:03PM (#19229092)
The demand is mostly in chemical industry and very inelastic. No one is going to put another plant on line because platinum group metals are cheap (but plants may be pulled off line because the economy is in the dumps, as happened in 2008 and 2017). Even small increases in supply will lead to great drops in price. You can only hope that a plentiful supply would encourage new uses.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by cwkoss on Friday February 22, 2019 @03:54PM (#19229015)
Orbital piracy is going to be a great subject for action films.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by elsonrodriguez on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:58PM (#19227425)
Counter example: De Beers.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by whiskers08xmt on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:54AM (#19225260)
No doubt. It'd be incredibly expensive and risky, but with a huge potential pay-off.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by dnautics on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:16AM (#19225990)
Rare earth metals are a bit of a misnomer, they're not that rare at all.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by haldora on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:02AM (#19226388)
At first it is not about metals, but water. Water is the oil of space. You can use it to make propellant, human/plant consumables, radiation shielding, and for further chemical processing. Once you have cheap water in cis-lunar space, it becomes 'easy' to move payloads around the Solar System and start the process for other resource utilization.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by wongarsu on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:09AM (#19224645)
> absolutely no one has any idea how to manufacture things in space.

That's a bit of an overstatement. We have a 3d printer on the ISS and me make great strides in producing fiber optics in space that are superior to what we can do on earth at similar price points [1].

1: https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/experime...

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by codeulike on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:48AM (#19224580)
Resources that arent stuck at the bottom of a gravity well is the attraction. Whether anyone can make it work is what we're trying to find out.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pjc50 on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:29AM (#19225066)
Fuel is the big one. A fully-loaded Space Shuttle is about 2 million kilograms; getting one to orbit and then refuelling it up there would cost several billion by your metric. This requires either finding watery asteroids or comets, or experimenting with metal-oxygen rocketry systems.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by fernandopj on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:30AM (#19225073)
There's the advantage of not having to mine _the Earth's ecossystem_ for resources, which is what we've been doing so far, impacting the environment. Mining a rock which has been drifting to space is basically getting an eco-friendly resource stream.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by kamaal on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:02AM (#19225325)
>>what resources do we even want from asteroids?

Once you have capabilities to build in space, going down gravity wells makes zero sense.

Want to build a factory or physics lab in space. You just mine things there and build them there. After a while you are looking at permanent colonies and then it's useful there.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by lmm on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:41AM (#19225139)
Iron is the most abundant element on Earth. The likes of platinum or gold are significantly more expensive (and not just because of scarcity: they have useful electrical/thermal/mechanical properties).
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by magduf on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:53AM (#19226810)
>Iron is the most abundant element on Earth.

No, it's not. I'm pretty sure it's silicon. Iron is relatively rare (but not as rare as platinum or gold of course).

Iron is the most abundant element in the Earth, but not on it. The core is full of iron. But that doesn't help us at all, because we can't get to that. We can only access materials in the crust, and there isn't much iron there.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pdonis on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:28PM (#19227141)
> I'm pretty sure it's silicon

If you include the biosphere, it's carbon. If you include the oceans, it's hydrogen (the hydrogen atoms in water).

Even if you just include inorganic materials in the crust, I believe oxygen is more abundant than silicon (oxygen is part of silicate rocks).

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by magduf on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:36PM (#19227213)
Yeah, you're right about oxygen, I should have said silicon is the most abundant mineral. But you're wrong about the rest:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_the_chemical_elem...

Oxygen is #1, silicon is #2, aluminum is #3, and iron is #4 (though far less than O or Si). Carbon doesn't even rank in the top 9.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pdonis on Friday February 22, 2019 @02:34PM (#19228373)
> you're wrong about the rest

It says "in the Earth's crust". That indicates to me that the biosphere and the oceans are not being counted. Also, it's giving abundances by mass, which is not the only way to do it (I was actually thinking of abundance by atom count).

Later in the same Wikipedia article, the top eleven abundances by mass for the ocean are given: oxygen and hydrogen are the first two, carbon is #10, and silicon doesn't even make the list.

No figures are given in that article for the biosphere; my statement of carbon being the most abundant for that is based on the fact that it forms the "backbone" of all of the main types of molecules in living organisms: proteins, carbohydrates, lipids, and nucleic acids.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by magduf on Friday February 22, 2019 @02:59PM (#19228600)
Carbon may be the "backbone" of organic matter, but that doesn't equate to the Earth's crust having a lot of it. Iron is the "backbone" of our red blood cells, but that doesn't mean we actually have that much iron (by mass) in our bodies or even our blood.

As for the "crust", the definition of the Earth's crust I'm pretty sure includes the oceans, the seafloor, and everything down to the mantle, so the biosphere and oceans should be counted there. Hydrogen doesn't rank highly because it has little mass compared to other elements. Atom count seems like a pretty pointless metric; we're talking about resources available for mining, in which case mass is what counts.

Of course silicon doesn't make the list for oceans because it's mostly water, and a lot of dissolved CO2. Count the seafloor and you'll find lots of silicon (and probably some iron, aluminum, titanium, etc.).

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pdonis on Friday February 22, 2019 @04:06PM (#19229110)
> the definition of the Earth's crust I'm pretty sure includes the oceans, the seafloor, and everything down to the mantle

If the crust included the oceans, there wouldn't be different figures for the oceans in the same article.

You make a valid point about the seafloor being part of the crust; but I didn't intend to include the seafloor in "oceans".

> Atom count seems like a pretty pointless metric; we're talking about resources available for mining, in which case mass is what counts.

That depends on what we're mining the resource for. For example, if we're mining for metals to use in catalytic converters for vehicles, atom count is the relevant metric, since the catalytic effectiveness depends on the number of atoms, not on the total mass.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pdonis on Friday February 22, 2019 @04:11PM (#19229155)
> Iron is the "backbone" of our red blood cells

No, it isn't; each hemoglobin molecule has just four iron atoms in it (IIRC--each heme structure has one, and I think there are four heme structures in one hemoglobin molecule). Most of each such molecule, by either mass or atom count, is carbon. And each red blood cell is more than just hemoglobin molecules.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pault on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:28AM (#19225562)
One of the plot points in Neal Stephenson's Seveneves [minor spoiler alert] is an Elon Musk-type character that melts a nuclear reactor into an ice comet to make a thruster that uses the comet as fuel. I always thought that was really neat.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by awaaz on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:08PM (#19226948)
Don't forget Asimov's The Martian Way. First published in November 1952 (!!!), the story is about how Earth refuses to export its water to Martian colonies who are using them as reaction mass on their spaceships. The Martians, in response, fly to Saturn's ice rings and ship a huge chunk back by using it itself for reaction mass.

Asimov truly was legendary.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by zepearl on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:26PM (#19227126)
I loved his "Robots"-trilogy (actually I think that there was a 4th book but when I the first 3 again recently I haven't been able to find the 4th one as ebook on Amazon & Kobo :( ) => they definitely motivated me to learn & program my first backpropagation network :)
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by zepearl on Friday February 22, 2019 @02:42PM (#19228448)
Kind of similar characters & practical approaches used many times in John Ringo's "Looking Glass" and "Troy rising" sci-fi series:

story & characters are definitely "american-style" (very direct & aggressive), but in these cases I ended up liking quite a lot this approach (basically it fits the setup of the stories because of the fight for survival of the species).

---

---

List of books (Spoiler alert - don't read the plots):

Looking glass: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyage_of_the_Space_Bubble

Troy rising: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troy_Rising

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by adrianN on Friday February 22, 2019 @03:57AM (#19223996)
I would be really neat if we could get a demo mission that converts some local resource on an asteroid to fuel and refuels an orbiter. Perhaps electrolyse some ice to Hydrogen and Oxygen.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by senectus1 on Friday February 22, 2019 @03:56AM (#19223989)
Space mining to build more things in space has to be the next big focus.

There is very little coherent argument for bringing space resources back down to earth.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by ekianjo on Friday February 22, 2019 @04:36AM (#19224123)
how do you build things in space? Do you plan to put factories in orbit? That sounds implausible.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by ben_w on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:16AM (#19224681)
What in particular makes “factories in orbit” seem implausible? We’ve already got/had a limited one of those in the form of the 3D printer on the space station.

Sure, fully automated mining, refining, QA, etc. isn’t ready yet, but it’s not implausible, and those things are all still increasingly automated even down here on Earth.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by orojackson on Friday February 22, 2019 @03:10PM (#19228684)
That's right. Iteration is key. Start small here on Earth, then build a somewhat crude factory in space. Solve any unexpected challenges that may arise, rinse, and repeat. Eventually you'll have factory-producing factories.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by Balgair on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:31PM (#19227170)
Likely, the early stages of the solar economy will resemble the Atlantic Slave Trade of the 16-19th centuries[0]. In the horrific middle passage, slaves were'sourced' from Africa and sent to the Caribbean for work on the plantations. Then the cash crops of cotton, sugar, tobacco, etc were sent to the manufacturing centers of North America/Europe. These manufacturing centers then sent finished goods like guns and ammo back to the colonies. Sir John Hawkins, a pioneer of British slaving, was the first to run that route, making a profit at every stop[1].

Similarly, we can expect that the early solar economy will provide opportunities for the same, though there is a lot of still undiscovered issues at hand.

Here, Mars/Moon will make the food and other 'simple' goods that are then sent to the Asteroid Belt. This is because the delta-V to get foodstuffs and goods off Mars/Moon is a lot less than on Earth and, depending on more surveying, there seems to be a fair bit of water on Mars that you can use. It seems thus far that corn-pone and beef-steaks do not grow well in 0G, though that remains to be seen.

These simple goods and food-stuffs will then be consumed by the Asteroid Belt in the use of mining for rare-earth elements and in production of vehicles and fuel for use in the outer solar system. The mined elements and materials will then be sent back to Earth for use in highly complex machines and other things.

Highly complicated machines built by people that do not want to raise their kids in the Belt or on Mars/Moon will then be sent to Mars/Moon for use in production of simpler goods.

A company with skills in (robotic?) space shipping and landing could make a profit at every gravity well.

This triangular trade is not likely to last very long as greenhouses are set-up (if possible) in the belt, manufacturing and leisure are made easier on Mars/Moon, and as techniques and science are improved on Earth.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangular_trade

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Hawkins_(naval_commander)

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by narag on Friday February 22, 2019 @02:46PM (#19228477)
Most likely in the Moon first. It would be relatively easy (compared to alternatives) to send small crews for six months shifts. The facilities would be underground to avoid radiation and micrometeorites hits.

For really far bases you would need spin gravity in a hollow asteroid for the staff.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by comboy on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:01AM (#19224227)
That's how Bezos sees it, I'd say he has done some homework. Regardless, we need resources to build these factories first.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by pault on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:31AM (#19225592)
No, you build factories in orbit.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by the_spacebyte on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:03AM (#19224439)
How so? Can't you do it from the Moon with low delta v as well? (honest question) And I think the Moon's proximity and "static" position relative to the Earth is another great advantage.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by saagarjha on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:20AM (#19224483)
Escaping the moon’s gravity well requires a decent amount of effort.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by Tepix on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:07AM (#19224634)
1.73km/s to get into a low orbit. Another 0.68km/s to escape.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by narag on Friday February 22, 2019 @02:28PM (#19228324)
The question is not only escape velocity, if you want to fly away from the Moon, you still need to escape Earth and the Sun. The other part of the problem on Earth is atmosphere with its drag and the fact that some kind of propulsion, like ionic, is impossible.

Edit: hmmm... it seems that escaping Earth and the Sun would be easier from the Moon, since the Moon trajectory components include already the 9 km/s and 30 km/s of Moon and Earth's orbits. Once in Moon's orbit, with the right angle and a little push, you should be able to escape Sun.

Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by metalliqaz on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:53AM (#19225246)
With no atmosphere you could use ground-based accelerators
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by lmm on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:42AM (#19225155)
To my mind Phobos is the obvious starting point: all the advantages of an asteroid, but as close as Mars.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by magduf on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:54AM (#19226823)
Mars isn't close; it takes months to get there. There's lots of asteroids that cross Earth's orbit. Also, Phobos is in Mars's gravity well.
Re:Hayabusa-2: Japan Spacecraft Touches Down on Asteroid by stetrain on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:07AM (#19225380)
That gets rid of some of the delta-v advantage though since it's in Mars' gravity well.

It could make sense if you can design a spacecraft that can use Mars' atmosphere to slow down (aerocapture) without going all the way to a landing.

Being able to use the atmosphere to slow down is why in some ways it's easier to land a heavy payload (like Curiosity) on Mars than on the Moon.