News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by Simulacra on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:23PM (#19219156)
Can we just have a social network that doesn't target anyone, for anything, and just lets us communicate, and build relationships without trying to manipulate us or violate our privacy?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by craigsmansion on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:01PM (#19219579)
Sadly we already have such a thing. It's the Internet itself.

It's quaint how in movies people easily identify with the underdog/resistance, e.g. a "Neo" in the "Matrix", and would see themselves taking the same direction if a similar scenario would ever play out.

Yet here we are, and at the first hint of inconvenience it's blue pills all around.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by fixermark on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:05PM (#19219614)
If it helps the understanding, it's worth remembering that life outside the Matrix was a hardscrabble garbage existence---so much so that a character was willing to kill to get back in.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by bilbo0s on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:38PM (#19219326)
Any social network that has people posting any personal data at all, will be mined. For one purpose or another. (And probably for one purpose AND the other.) Almost the only way to stop it would be to make it explicitly illegal, and even then they would still allow mining for certain purposes. There's just no way to get away from it at this point. (Other than just not using social networks at all I suppose?)
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by munk-a on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:54PM (#19219510)
Putting personal data out there means... putting personal data out there, advertisers mining that data is a hard problem to solve. So can we re-orient the need for a solution to the injection of advertising into the platform? Lets solve this problem one step at a time and first stop those advertisers from leveraging the platform to distribute advertisements, instead only allowing them to mine the data to support ad campaigns. Once that's done we can look at salves for the data mining of social media, though I can't see that being possible without really resilient privacy enforcement.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by beamatronic on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:29PM (#19219219)
Yes, but you would have to pay for it. And convince your friends to also. Actually maybe the subscription model would let you pay for their subscriptions as well.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by unclebucknasty on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:38PM (#19219328)
It's funny because the idea of paying for it reads like a non-starter. Maybe it is. Crazy times when we'd trade away so much for so little vs just paying some nominal amount.

But I sometimes wonder if it's just as much a convenience thing as it is the actual money. That is, if the sign up process was just as easy with payment as it is now, would a lot more people go for it than assumed (at some price point)?

In any case, I don't think that pay or have your privacy co-opted are really the only paths to a viable social network business model.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by WilliamEdward on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:41PM (#19219378)
Signing up or putting in financial information is not the hard part, the hard part is the anxiety of constantly having a stream of money leaving your account every month bit by bit. We try to avoid this as much as humanly possible.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by unclebucknasty on Thursday February 21, 2019 @05:43PM (#19221265)
>the anxiety of constantly having a stream of money leaving your account every month bit by bit

I don't know that this is true writ large. Monthly budgeting is, essentially, how most people operate, whether for expenses of necessity or choice. That is, much of our financial lives are oriented around (largely monthly) cash-flow management.

So, we prioritize what's necessary or important to us, then add it to the mix. I don't know why a subscription to a service like FB would be any different than, say, Netflix (if the price were "right").

OTOH, there's an ease in just slipping into something with an e-mail address. So, I believe the friction of going from no payment to any payment is the much bigger leap to overcome (again, provided the price in question is reasonable).

But, there is also now the notion to overcome that some things (like a social network) "should" be free. But, that's another topic.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by WilliamEdward on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:41PM (#19231254)
Netflix fits what i'm saying exactly.

1- many people on here have said they don't want to keep track of any more streaming/subscription services beyond netflix (showing even netflix is too much)

2- netflix makes it as easy as possible to sign up and let other people join via family profiles because they know this is a true problem.

The reason people budget in the first place is precisely because they have an anxiety at the back of their mind about where their money is going.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by fixermark on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:29PM (#19219220)
Email never stopped existing.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by madrox on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:54PM (#19220000)
I don't understand why this isn't the top comment.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by anigbrowl on Thursday February 21, 2019 @05:31PM (#19221164)
Because email does not do as good a job as social media for most people. If it were so great, how was there sufficient demand for social networking companies to grow large? Even in the 1990s people used usenet because social discover and public conversation over email is cumbersome.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by gravy on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:25PM (#19219167)
Real life?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by Simulacra on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:25PM (#19219177)
Ha! Touche, and a very good point.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by overcast on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:33PM (#19219256)
Phone, email, texting, real life activities? Where did the obsession come from with having to be in real time constant contact with a ton of people who we didn't care about staying in contact with before? Other than a common place to share photos, which existed prior, why?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by Gokenstein on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:25PM (#19219170)
we had that. It was called livejournal. And everyone stopped using it.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:28PM (#19219202)
Wasn't that exodus predicated by the same sort of "undesirables" reputation? Though I'd much rather have a thousand Harry Potter erotic fan fiction authors than a handful of neo-nazis sharing my website.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by pjc50 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:41PM (#19219369)
.. because it was bought by a Russian parent company who brought in restrictive policies. And, obviously, surveillance.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by broth on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:44PM (#19219408)
Don't these exist already? [1] Other than that, I can relate to the other comments of just doing away with social networks on the web and replacing it with real-life communication via talking, phone calls, emails, or text messaging. As I get older I realize how much I miss the traditional ways of communicating without being inundated and distracted by constant notifications from present day social networks.

[1] https://diasporafoundation.org/

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by meko on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:01PM (#19219583)
I deleted my fb+twitter several months ago. It was lonely at first. I realized I had let social media 'automate' my social life away. Since then I've been trying to foster actual friendships through the 'normal channels' like talking, hanging out (when I can make the time) and sms. It feels a bit Luddite in a way, and I feel less like I have 600 friends, and rather like I have 6 friends.

It hasn't been some relevatory experience like some would suggest; social media does make things easier and life without it feel quieter. But like anything else, it's a trade off. biggest positive I've noticed was that I find myself less dopamine-addled. I no longer waste hours on my phone scrolling in order to relax. It took some adjustment time, but I find it easier to get my dopamine fix from more productive hobbies.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by wsgeorge on Friday February 22, 2019 @03:33PM (#19228863)
I quit FB and Twitter nearly 4 years ago. Now I waste that time on WhatsApp, reddit and 4chan. I figured the problem was more with me than with the media I was consuming.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by spinach on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:32PM (#19219248)
That would at the very least, mean that users would pay a fee to use their product. As of now, as a free product that is the only way to monetize. The internet loves it's free, open products but at the same time, ironically, loves to build products whose founders are billionaires and even raises them to near hero status. It culminates in the users having a pretty terrible experience in the way of manipulation and privacy.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:36PM (#19219298)
Commercial radio and broadcast television worked without fine grained metrics on the users. There's nothing special about the internet that makes invasive tracking a necessity.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by floatrock on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:54PM (#19219511)
"Worked."

How are they doing now?

It's a cats-outta-the-bag situation. What DOES makes invasive tracking a necessity is it works so much better than the free models that came before it. If you're not doing it, your competition is, and they're getting one up on you.

I don't think we have a free model that monetizes more efficiently than invasive tracking, so the only option you're left with is a not-free model. And for consumer-social, "not free" is a small niche (eharmony comes to mind as making it work, but even they bought all the free dating companies because the free ones were eating the market...)

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by phil248 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:34PM (#19219289)
Really though? Advertising supported multi-billion dollar industries for decades without mining our personal info. Just because they can doesn't mean they have to. If companies want to advertise to Facebook's hundreds of millions of users, they will do so without targeting if that's their only option.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by sveme on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:42PM (#19219380)
Why can‘t ads (again) be targeted to content and not users? If I‘m reading an article on a Tesla I might be interested in what VW is offering instead - and might not be interested in that headset I looked at a week ago.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jonas21 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:35PM (#19219295)
And, if your friends are anything like mine, only a small fraction would be willing to pay, making it a pretty lousy social network.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by WilliamEdward on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:40PM (#19219350)
"at the very least"? No i think the third option is having an advertisement model that simply feeds users ads without having to abuse their data for 'optimization'.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jacobush on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:42PM (#19219384)
Or they'd have to run the software on their own machines.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by chongli on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:34PM (#19219286)
How about Mastodon? [1] It's free, open source, and federated like email.

If you're hoping for a commercial, centralized social network, then you're always going to have to deal with perverse incentives.

[1] https://joinmastodon.org/

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by bilbo0s on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:39PM (#19219343)
It can still be mined. That's the crux of the problem is the mining. If you can mine it, then you can use that data to target ads, you can use it for law enforcement purposes, you can use it to stifle dissent, etc etc etc. Could also use the mined data for a myriad number of good things as well. Really is just up to the miner.

Point is, it's the mining that lays the foundation for the dangers, and there is little that prevents facebook, or twitter, or whatever entity that wants to mine mastodon instances from doing so.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by chongli on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:28PM (#19220727)
With Mastodon you can run your own server, so you can make it invite-only and disallow data miners from joining.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by anigbrowl on Thursday February 21, 2019 @05:34PM (#19221192)
The more secure and exclusive your server the less utility it provides to the network at large. Great for privacy, useless if you wish to connect with a broader community. Also assumes that both internal and external security are solid. They're probably not, and covert mining isn't that hard.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by chongli on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:51AM (#19224857)
wish to connect with a broader community

This is no longer in the realm of technical problems. If you want to connect with a "broader community" (i.e. people you don't know) then you don't get privacy. To say you do want privacy while also getting to connect with strangers is to insist upon the trustworthiness of strangers.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by anigbrowl on Friday February 22, 2019 @01:54PM (#19227992)
Yes, I'm inclined to agree. Seems like this is the only way to instil awareness in people what the tradeoffs are.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by twblalock on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:33PM (#19219258)
Even in a decentralized/federated network there will always be people trying to mine data for the purposes of advertising and political campaigning. It's human nature to try to take advantage of others for personal and financial gain.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by chabes on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:50PM (#19219466)
“It's human nature to try to take advantage of others for personal and financial gain.“

Is it? Or is it the perverse financial incentive structure that leads humans to put financial gain over all other priorities?

Would humans still make decisions to take advantage if the incentive structures were built differently?

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by twblalock on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:53PM (#19219506)
> Would humans still make decisions to take advantage if the incentive structures were built differently?

Human history proves that yes, they still would.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by anigbrowl on Thursday February 21, 2019 @05:38PM (#19221220)
That seems way too general of a conclusion to be adopting as a premise. At the very least it ignores the distribution of behavior in a population.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by munk-a on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:51PM (#19219476)
The network effect is strong and if your family is on facebook it can seem rude to post about your life elsewhere where they lack access to it. I'd love to see a government mandate forcing cross pollinization of these networks (perhaps using diapora's node approach) that would allow smaller hosts to compete with the big guys by letting people pull feeds in from other networks. Basically we need XMPP for social media but none of the social media companies have any motivation for implementing it so... ideally the government does sometime.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by bilbo0s on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:53PM (#19219500)
???

How does any of that stop the data mining?

It's the data mining and the ad targeting that people want to stop. And the FB competitors could be mining data just as easily as FB can.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by munk-a on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:55PM (#19219532)
It doesn't directly stop the data mining, it stops the profitability of allowing that data mining to the social network... and making that data mining less profitable reduces the value of allowing that to the network host.

If people can jump ship they'll slowly migrate to ad free platforms, then we can attack the issue of data-mining with regulations at the government level to force a cessation of private data collection.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by bilbo0s on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:07PM (#19219635)
>If people can jump ship they'll slowly migrate to ad free platforms...

Here's the problem, ad free, does not mean mining free. These other platforms could still be mining your data with you none the wiser. In fact, it's a virtual certainty that they would, at minimum, for law enforcement purposes. (Which would entail stifling dissent in certain nations.)

One of the only ways to cut down on mining is to make it explicitly illegal. And again, even then there will be exceptions carved out by congress. But that would at least provide most people a bit of privacy in their personal data just as HIPPA provides us a bit of privacy in our health data.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by munk-a on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:12PM (#19219676)
Again, I absolutely don't disagree with you. I'm just putting on my project management hat and saying "We've got two problems, one is hard and will fix everything, the other is easy and will fix 95% of the stuff, let's do the easy one first" I'm all for GDPR like protections (but ideally a bit better thought out) in the US, but given the entrenchment of these social media networks I think it'd be hard to pull off politically.

Zuckerberg has yet to try and mobilize facebook for a political end, when he tries it I hope it backfires and he ends up shooting himself in the foot, but it may work. Attempting to make data mining and resale may unleash a torrent of angry voters that rally against anyone associated with pushing it forward and get them voted out of office - or cowe them into submission. Either way I think the best first step is to force the platform open and deride the network effect that facebook currently controls, then let them lose power and enact stricter privacy laws when the public is ready for them.

If I were King of America though, I'd totally just go your route.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by ravenstine on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:50PM (#19219462)
How is that supposed to impress stakeholders?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by disease on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:33PM (#19219270)
Mastadon?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by zxcvvcxz on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:29PM (#19219214)
Nothing like this can exist without some money for the owners to maintain and create it. Nothing's free. Why can't people understand this?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jjulius on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:30PM (#19219227)
OP didn't say it had to be free. You could also have a social network that just displayed ads without any kind of targeting and user-tracking whatsoever.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by fixermark on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:38PM (#19219332)
... it's just that in the marketplace of ad channels for advertisers to invest their budget in, that network loses out to networks with targeted ads.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jjulius on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:09PM (#19219650)
Who's to say that if the general public were presented with two free (to the user) social networks, one that targets ads and one that doesn't, that people would opt to use the targeted one over the non-targeted one?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by fixermark on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:19PM (#19219726)
My snarky answer is "Google vs. DDG's usage numbers," but a more serious answer is that yes, that'd be a possibility (but I'd sadly put it on the low end of probable outcomes given what we know about both the stickiness of existing social networks vs. newcomers and how much concern for privacy users actually tend to demonstrate).
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jjulius on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:29PM (#19219792)
Fair! :)
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by anigbrowl on Thursday February 21, 2019 @05:41PM (#19221246)
Available evidence suggests that enough people want to be on whatever the biggest platform is for that to give it a decisive advantage over the competition.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by luckylion on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:31PM (#19219236)
Who would pay for that though? And why shouldn't it manipulate? I'm fine with manipulating people. Nudging is okay in my book if you're benevolent and aiming to make people's life better. It's just shit when all you want is to make them buy some product to fill the void you've helped create.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jjulius on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:33PM (#19219257)
>And why shouldn't it manipulate?

Why should it? And why not have a social network that just serves up ads that aren't based on tracking/targeting users?

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by overcast on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:33PM (#19219267)
Sure, that's possible, and won't make as much money. Now you're talking about ethical business practices. Good luck!
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jjulius on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:35PM (#19219296)
If it makes enough money for the company to sustain itself, then I feel like that's good enough for what OP is looking for. Not everything needs to be about continued growth of profits.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by overcast on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:39PM (#19219341)
It's idealistic at best. Many people say this, until you see the money come in, and are pressured to make more. You just can't grow into such a monstrosity without stepping on morals along the way. For a social network to even work, it needs to be gigantic, or why would anyone use it?
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by chabes on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:01PM (#19219584)
I think a lot of the public is getting fed up with morals being stepped on. The demand for a not-immoral social network is huge.

Btw, smaller social networks are great. Early days of reddit were amazing, and it didn’t get better when it became mainstream

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by overcast on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:33PM (#19219821)
I think the general public hasn't got a clue, or doesn't care if they do. We're vocal here, because we understand what is going on. Smaller social networks are great, for niche areas. Facebook is a glorified address book, which you need EVERYONE in to be effective.
Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by luckylion on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:39PM (#19219337)
Because manipulation is great. You can help people by manipulating them, you can measurably improve their lives. That's a big reason for me. That's like "why should we heal the sick?" You can use a scalpel for good and you can use it to hurt people. There's no use in just saying "we shouldn't use scalpels, ever" to me.

Ads that are completely random won't pay the bills, and ads that are content-based (without looking at the user) might, but will also target the user, they just won't follow them around. If I want to reach people interested in the Nazis, I'll just put my ads on pages dealing with Nazi stuff, because that's what people interested in Nazis tend to look at and other people don't.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by jjulius on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:08PM (#19219642)
>Because manipulation is great. You can help people by manipulating them, you can measurably improve their lives. That's a big reason for me. That's like "why should we heal the sick?"

Are you really comparing targeted ad manipulation to medical professionals healing people? And yes, it can help improve lives, but there's also a flipside to what it can do (read: Cambridge Analytica, Russia, etc.). There are negative connotations to manipulation that you need to keep in mind.

>Ads that are completely random won't pay the bills...

It's worked for TV and radio for decades. They're still somewhat targeted but in a far, far less invasive manner, and they're not individualized.

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by luckylion on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:37AM (#19223379)
I would've replied sooner, but the silly "oh no, you've posted two times in one hour and somebody didn't like what you said, go cool of for 12 hours" function didn't allow it. Talk about manipulating users' behavior.

> Are you really comparing targeted ad manipulation to medical professionals healing people?

No, I'm comparing beneficial targeted manipulation (notice the lacking of the word "ad") to healing people. You CAN use a knife to murder somebody, but you CAN also use it to perform life saving surgery on them. Advocating for banning all knifes because you don't want people to murder seems weird to me.

Facebook literally tested what they can do with targeted manipulation [1], and they found that they can do both good and bad with it. It freaked the public out, and so do knifes, and I get that. The problem isn't that you can use it only for evil, the problem is that FB & their customers don't want people in a good place mentally and emotionally, because you're less likely to buy things you don't need or spend hours on their site. And that's what was suggested: have a social network that isn't run from the Bay area trying to maximize profit extraction, but one that's user focused. You know, where the user is the customer, not the ad agency.

> There are negative connotations to manipulation that you need to keep in mind.

As there are to using a knife on people. I'm saying "let's ban the bad part and use the good part". Facebook, Google probably know more about their regular users than those users' family, psychiatrists, psychologists and even the users themselves. Are you aware of the potential good they could do with that? Yeah, we won't solve mental health issue by manipulating people, but we'll make it a whole lot better, and we can measure that.

> It's worked for TV and radio for decades.

Not it really didn't, because they barely used random ads. Most shows' demographics where very specific and they don't run car ads during the sunday morning cartoon hour. Hell, they created show concepts to target demographics so they could then sell ads reaching that demographics.

I suppose suggesting to use technology for good doesn't go over well with this crowd. More and more I feel that we're letting the wrong people design, build and steer the technology that will shape the future.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/02/facebook-...

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by grimjack00 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:42PM (#19219386)
> Nudging is okay in my book if you're benevolent and aiming to make people's life better.

"Better" according to whom?

Re:Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – an... by luckylion on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:51PM (#19219483)
Are there really different ideas about this? I mean, there might be some grey area, sure, but in general? Is there an argument for example that depression is great and shouldn't be touched?