News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by timkpaine on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:16AM (#19183108)
It's funny how no major CS curriculum at a major University includes a legitimate ethics course. In the modern era, programmers are akin to lawyers or politicians; we wield immense, and often implicitly trusted power over hundreds of millions of opinions. It's long past due that programmers be required to adhere to ethical codes, maybe even to the extent of bad-style licensing.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by ISO-morphism on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:48AM (#19183214)
I recently graduated from a middle tier state school in CS/Math. The CS portion required an ethics course, I believe its inclusion had something to do with an ACM mandate. Out of over 100 enrolled juniors/seniors I don't believe attendance ever reached double digits outside of 2 tests.

Sure, there was a "requierment," but I wouldn't really consider it legitimate. It took concerted effort to "earn" any grade lower than an A. I wasn't personally acquainted with any other student who seriously considered the social and ethical implications of computers during or after taking a 400 level course titled "Social and Ethical Implications of Computers."

On the bright side, I heard through the grapevine that rigor, or at least workload for the course, has increased since I took it.

Although anecdotal and perhaps specific to my institution, every recollection of my University career makes me feel deeply thankful that I ended up eventually pursuing a double major in mathematics. The quality and dedication of the instructors wildly surpassed that of the CS department. Mathematics professors were there to share knowledge. CS perfessors were pressured by hiring statistics into "preparing us for the workforce" by essentially quizzing specific interview questions like "what's the difference between interfaces and subclasses in Java."

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by dgzl on Sunday February 17, 2019 @03:55AM (#19183441)
A counter-example: I also attended a middle tier state University for CS, and our single term required Ethics in Computing course was all but easy. That said, it certainly didn't capture the attention of students.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by gre on Sunday February 17, 2019 @10:26AM (#19184877)
My one hour exam final prompt was “Networking is useful, but explain the ethics involved in networking.” I answered with an essay about conflicts of interest in business while my friend wrote about file-sharing.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by vtbassmatt on Sunday February 17, 2019 @09:09AM (#19184514)
This matches my experience. In addition to taking the course as an undergrad, I was the graduate TA for three semesters. While it wasn't super deep on any one topic, the course was far from easy and required to graduate.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by pepijndevos on Sunday February 17, 2019 @01:58PM (#19186133)
Another data point: My university has a mandatory ethics course, and it also has a reasonably low attendance, light workload, pass on a short essay.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by arcticbull on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:28AM (#19183152)
My Canadian software engineering degree included a substantial engineering ethics course shared with the rest of the engineering flavors (including mechanical and aerospace). At the time, I thought it was a waste, but the further down my career I go the more valuable it was in retrospect. I also can't call myself an engineer in Canada without joining a provincial engineering organization (like the PEO in Ontario).
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by mgbmtl on Sunday February 17, 2019 @09:34AM (#19184616)
I agree for engineering classes, but those completing a computer science (CS in a science or arts faculty) degree in Canada usually do not have any regulatory oversight of any kind and no ethics classes.

However, in the Quebec system (and presumably the equivalent in other provinces) we have 3 philosophy classes (humanities, world-view etc) in college/cégep (somewhat mandatory before university). I also had a mandatory ethics class since I completed a technical degree, which I also did not appreciate at the time, but it helped me develop more critical thinking later on.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by frobozz on Sunday February 17, 2019 @08:00AM (#19184252)
The global nature of software development limits the utility of licensing.

You can't go overseas to get a bridge built across the river in your town. You can't get a foreign barrister to represent you in court in your country.

You can easily get a new social media website or IoT server built and hosted in any country you want.

The scenarios where the effects of bad ethical decisions most often make the news are not things that lend themselves well to being subject to local licensing regulations, like embedded avionic or medical devices or internal banking systems. Problems do happen in those spaces, but they are rare.

None of this even touches on usability and the difficulty of restricting tool use to the "good guys". The jslint licence got a lot of stick for that.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by jowiar on Sunday February 17, 2019 @11:57AM (#19185383)
The framework for regulation of these sorts of systems will almost certainly come down to “possession of data”.

You can build/host things anywhere, but something centered around “if you generate profits in the USA, and hold the data of Americans, these requirements exist for your system” makes sense. In particular, liability needs to rest somewhere, such that someone gives enough of a shit to do things right.

A civil engineering firm could outsource the design of a bridge anywhere, but in the end, somebody’s neck is on the line if it fails.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by majewsky on Sunday February 17, 2019 @12:54PM (#19185747)
> something centered around “if you generate profits in the USA, and hold the data of Americans, these requirements exist for your system” makes sense

This is exactly the stance taken by GDPR. Most devs don't like it from what I've seen on HN. (Saying this without any judgment. I am personally very much in favor of what GDPR does.)

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by frobozz on Sunday February 17, 2019 @01:31PM (#19185940)
> “if you generate profits in the USA,

This sort of thing already gets dodged by international companies who "generate profits" in countries with lower taxes and "incur costs" in countries with higher taxes.

>" and hold the data of Americans"

GDPR? System requirements is one thing, requiring a licensed engineer from multiple jurisdictions is another. Bear in mind that because software changes constantly, this has to be a senior staff position, not a one-time sign-off like it could be for a bridge.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by jhauris on Sunday February 17, 2019 @08:34AM (#19184363)
I really liked my university's required ethics course. It was taught by a CS professor with a law degree, and in addition to covering law included philosophy and ethics of what you should do with technology, and when an engineer should refuse to build something. Participation was about on par with other courses of the term.

I assumed all universities had a similar program, if they don't students are really missing out.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by SkyPuncher on Sunday February 17, 2019 @06:51AM (#19184005)
I had an ethics course as a part of my curriculum. It was an extremely interesting course, but completely inapplicable to my professional career.

The main problem is there is not a certifying organization that standardizes ethics (and includes licensing). A single developer refusing something on ethics is pretty meaningless. A company will just find someone else who will do it.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by jules on Sunday February 17, 2019 @03:44AM (#19183392)
Does following an ethics course actually encourage ethical behaviour?
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by blunte on Sunday February 17, 2019 @04:31AM (#19183568)
It may or may not encourage ethical behavior, but it certainly may make students aware of ethical concerns that they might have not yet considered.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by fromthestart on Sunday February 17, 2019 @04:32AM (#19183573)
I'm wondering how someone can even go about teaching ethics when they're a purely cultural artifacts.

Isn't it just subtle propaganda? Good, bad, just, unjust - what's ethical in China, for example, or Saudia Arabia is not the same as what's ethical in the US or even Europe.

Nevermind the thought of relatively centralized institutions acting as arbiters of ethics and, by extension, core aspects of culture.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by dragonwriter on Sunday February 17, 2019 @04:34AM (#19183580)
> I'm wondering how someone can even go about teaching ethics when they're a purely cultural artifacts.

Cultural artifacts are quite teachable; that's generally how they are transmitted. Why would that be difficult?

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by fromthestart on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:35PM (#19186348)
>Why would that be difficult?

How do you decide which brand of ethics to teach? Especially if your class is represented by a range of nationalities?

Look at this thread and how oblivious everyone is to the variability of the definition of ethics. We take the subject as some kind of absolute, but really we're just viewing the rest of the world through priveleged western lenses.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by dragonwriter on Sunday February 17, 2019 @07:47PM (#19187896)
> How do you decide which brand of ethics to teach?

There's two common options chosen:

(1) broad multi-system survey rather than a single system or narrow set, and

(2) teach the system or systems most connected to the target legal system (for cases where ethics is being taught largely to create a safety buffer around legality and anticipate legality in adopting to address where legality had not yet settled.)

When you know why you want to teach ethics, it's fairly trivial to choose the approach.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by darkpuma on Sunday February 17, 2019 @03:56PM (#19186854)
> "How do you decide "

Do you earnestly believe that Harvard University will be paralyzed by the choice between a modern western ethics system in which women have all the rights of men, or (to use your example) a Saudi ethics system in which women are property?

Most people in the real work are not so ridiculous that they allow themselves to be paralyzed by knowledge of ethical relativism.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by fromthestart on Sunday February 17, 2019 @04:21PM (#19186983)
This isn't some trivial difficulty with choosing a narrative. It's the implied cultural supremacy in arrogantly believing that YOUR perception of what is moral is so correct that it should be taught in university.

The same reason that government shouldn't be legislating religion. I went to college to learn science, mathematics, liberal arts, so that I could learn to make decisions for myself-not to be indoctrinated with someone else's idea of what is right and wrong.

Edit: imagine a Saudi funded institution in the U.S. offering courses on ethics. Would you be ok with that? Why are you even sure that the particular ethics courses in Harvard agree with your own cultural norms? When you mix subjectivity with education, you get propaganda. Sure, some of it is unnavoiable because ultimately there are only so many topics one has time to learn and all educators/authors are biased humans, but the topic of ethics does not even allow for the possibility of objective treatment. It does not belong in school.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by darkpuma on Sunday February 17, 2019 @06:40PM (#19187624)
It's a solved problem. Every major university teaches ethics. If your university CS program didn't have an ethics course, that is the exception rather than the rule, and your university did you a disservice.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by rhizome on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:33PM (#19186332)
What isn't a cultural artifact, outside of nature?
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by fromthestart on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:50PM (#19186425)
The problem is that people treat and teach ethics as though they are absolute. Further, ethics as a field of study is unique because it is supposed to directly influence behavior. What no one seems to realize is that ethics lessons are a form of social conditioning with administrators deciding on the content.

Here's a quick illustrative example: what do you think passed for ethical to the average citizen at the height of Nazi Germany? Or Cold War era Soviet Union? To CCP members during the great leap forward? Supporters of Dutuerte? Liberals vs Conservatives in the U.S.?

So which brand is your University picking and choosing to offer in class? The whole idea is dangerous - colleges should not be in the business of teaching ethics, because in order to do so they must decide on what is ethical.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Sunday February 17, 2019 @05:29AM (#19183740)
> Good, bad, just, unjust - what's ethical in China, for example, or Saudia Arabia is not the same as what's ethical in the US or even Europe.

That's bullshit. Just because some places have unethical norms, doesn't mean their norms are ethical. Just because some places have a norm to mistreat some people, doesn't mean those people suddenly don't feel mistreated.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by fedorareis on Sunday February 17, 2019 @03:18AM (#19183308)
I attended a pretty well known university in California and we had a professional ethics course where we analyzed case studies and current events in tech using the IEEE/ACM code of ethics. A number of states in the US have professional licensing requirements to be considered a Software Engineer so maybe that is a step in the right direction.

I do agree with your pretense though that programmers have a tendency to not think about ethics and should be held to some sort of code in the same way doctors and lawyers are supposed to be.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by codetrotter on Sunday February 17, 2019 @03:36AM (#19183360)
The University of Oslo has a course on philosophy and ethics that is obligatory for all to pass in order to receive a bachelor’s degree.

https://www.uio.no/studier/emner/hf/ifikk/EXPHIL03E/index.ht...

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by frobozz on Sunday February 17, 2019 @05:33AM (#19183755)
Examen philosophicum is common in Norwegian universities.

It is worth noting that this is common to all first degrees, and may or may not be tailored to your particular subject area, so it's often up to the learner to work out apply the theory to their own scenarios.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by tomjen3 on Sunday February 17, 2019 @06:55AM (#19184020)
That is just another required course to pass though? I mean unless the teacher is especially good (which they practically never are if for any part of a non lap course there is compulsory attendance) you regurgitate the subject and forget everything the day after the exam, right?
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by ConceptJunkie on Monday February 18, 2019 @10:50AM (#19191488)
You've got a good point, but do you really think an ethics class is going to stop Microsoft or Google? Do you really think an ethics class will make Facebook respect privacy?

I totally support the idea that all professionals need to be ethical and moral, and I definitely try to do so in my life, but I've given up hope that society at large is interested in this. I think individuals generally are, but any company, once it becomes powerful, seems to also become evil.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by ancarda on Sunday February 17, 2019 @08:08AM (#19184273)
Do you know of any good resources for learning more about ethics (in the context of CS) online? I can't really imagine what an ethics course would look like; would it just be "don't build stuff that can be abused"? I'm genuinely asking because I don't know much about this. What would the end result look like?
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by Kalium on Sunday February 17, 2019 @12:41PM (#19185664)
An ethics course is mostly about familiarizing you with several frameworks that can be used to make decisions about ethics.

For instance, "don't build stuff that can be abused" is not a good framework for ethical decision-making. "Abuse" has no clear definition, and "can be" is an incredibly high standard. By this standard, the hammer should have have been invented. It's incredibly easy to hurt someone with one! There are no safeguards whatsoever!

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by eqdw on Monday February 18, 2019 @10:44AM (#19191448)
Do you seriously think that taking an ethics course in college would be the difference between a world where programming is used as a weapon and a world in which it's not?

Man if only we could make all our political science grads take an ethics course, then there'd be no more war!

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by tomjen3 on Sunday February 17, 2019 @06:45AM (#19183972)
In the current climate of low trust in the US, how would you come up with ethics that everybody can agree to?
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by majewsky on Sunday February 17, 2019 @01:03PM (#19185798)
Studying ethics is not about "this is right or wrong", it's about "these are ways to consider what is right or wrong". It's one level higher in terms of "metaness" than you think it is.

If an ethics course teaches students which decisions actually have an ethical component in them, that's already a huge win: Whenever they encounter such a decision, they will be more likely to notice and ponder the ethical implications contained therein. This does not necessarily prescribe a particular set of ethical rules that they have to adhere to.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by RHSeeger on Sunday February 17, 2019 @10:20AM (#19184851)
Did you find the statistics for this? Mine certainly did when I studied there, and it was required.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by blitmap on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:30AM (#19183167)
So -- I am finding amusement in this -- but ethics is very labour intensive. I'm sure we all wish we could dream up new projects in a vacuum without real-world consequences (simply for the fun of it).
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by Godel_unicode on Sunday February 17, 2019 @12:25PM (#19185553)
Mine certainly required one. What's your source for this strawman?

Edit: see also https://www.acm.org/code-of-ethics

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by pjc50 on Sunday February 17, 2019 @06:22AM (#19183897)
I was taught "Law and Economics" in my Cambridge computer science course in the late 90s. There wasn't a lot of it and it was a bit erratic, but it was there.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by elyobo on Sunday February 17, 2019 @04:21AM (#19183532)
I would be very interested in that. At the time I earned my degree I wouldn't have though, so I'm not sure that I would have got much from it.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by cs02rm0 on Sunday February 17, 2019 @03:20AM (#19183315)
Pretty certain my UK one did. I graduated nearly 15 years ago though and it was mostly focused on things like copyright law.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by flurdy on Sunday February 17, 2019 @05:26AM (#19183732)
My red brick university CS course also had an ethics module. That was in the 90s and I can't remember a thing from it...
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by vintermann on Sunday February 17, 2019 @08:24AM (#19184325)
Ethics is the study of what you can get away with. University level ethics people doesn't make people a whit better than they were already.

So maybe it's best this way. Computer scientists will still do bad stuff, but at least they'll be embarrassed about it when caught, rather than come up with clever justifications.

Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by schrodinger on Sunday February 17, 2019 @08:33AM (#19184359)
That’s not how the ethics class I took in college worked. It reminded us to feel empowered to speak up rather than build something we didn’t think was right, and what the best means of doing so were.
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by timkpaine on Sunday February 17, 2019 @02:17AM (#19183113)
Bar-style licensing* typo
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by Firecracker on Sunday February 17, 2019 @06:34AM (#19183937)
Stanford requires such a course!
Re:Github restricts public Faceswap repo to logged-in users by nojvek on Monday February 18, 2019 @12:36AM (#19188826)
I graduated from UNSW in Australia. Ethics was a very popular course amongst the engineering and CS curriculum.

I first thought it was a lot of philosophical bullshit about good and bad, but the history part of things were an eye opener.

Like the census data being abused by Nazis to exterminate jews. It always starts up as good intentions.

Our job is to prevent the worst case. The worst case eventually will happen.