News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by amelius on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:04AM (#19152136)
Frightening question: what if this technology could be targeted not at species, but at races?
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Tade0 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:30AM (#19152265)
You mean humans?

AFAIK human "races" are largely superficial biologically - there are some correlations, but weaker than the variability between individuals.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by system2 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:02AM (#19152692)
By the time DNA wars begin, we will be already very mixed as a planet.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by hopler on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:20AM (#19152476)
You are conflating the existence of races with their similarity. Racists are focused on the latter for their racist activities
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by krageon on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:59AM (#19152385)
I've seen very few countries of note (aside from the US) that use "race" as any kind of indicator. This has a very good reason: It's not a clear biological separation and it also otherwise has little bearing on reality. It's an old, obsolete carry-over that was kept from the days when racism was still an accepted practice and it needs to die the death that it deserves as soon as possible.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by skolsuper on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:47AM (#19152602)
I'm really struggling to understand your first sentence. Are you saying people generally aren't racist outside the US? Because my experience has been very, very different (and that's as a white male)
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by lm28469 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @10:27AM (#19153747)
I think he references the fact that in the US you get official forms from the gov that asks (as far as I remember):

Race:

- white

- black

- hispanic

- other

Like when you get your driver license or open a bank account. Coming from Europe I was surprised by such a question. Racial issues run very deep in the US.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by krageon on Thursday February 14, 2019 @03:17AM (#19160411)
This is what I was referring to.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by skolsuper on Thursday February 14, 2019 @05:07AM (#19160810)
Ah, I understand now. As some anecdata: here in Singapore (a country I think is renowned for it's multiculturalism, but correct me if I'm wrong), practically every important form, from opening a bank account to renting a condo to filing taxes with the government, requires me to select my race from a list of "Chinese", "Malay", "Indian" or "Other". In Thailand, it's normal for people to specify their race and religion on their resume.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by throwaway9d0291 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:42AM (#19152941)
There's certainly racism in other countries but it's not based on skin colour like in the US. For example some people in the UK have an aversion to Eastern Europeans, who are white but have no problems with black Britons.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by hopler on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:18AM (#19152468)
For the purposes of CRISPR, races exists when defined as "people carrying a certain genetic marker". There are various genes that are highly correlated to racial/ethnic groups (like Tay-Sachs disease),and mass murderers generally don't worry about collateral damage.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by krageon on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:14AM (#19153202)
Any response I can make to this will just read like me saying "no" when you say "yes". In this case, I think it might suffice to say that the burden of proof lies with you: The person making a large claim that is not (as far as I understand it, which admittedly could be better) something that everyone knows to be true beyond a shred of doubt.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by bgaluszka on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:41AM (#19152306)
You may find interesting this presentation from John Sotos on DEF CON https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKQDSgBHPfY "Genetic Diseases to Guide Digital Hacks of the Human Genome".
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by dotancohen on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:47AM (#19152329)
It probably already can. I'm not an expert, but from what I understand CRISPR targets specific DNA sequences. Race can be determined by DNA testing, therefore I think (again, I'm not an expert) that there would be certain sequences that are specific to a race.

Now CRISPR alters the specific sequence that it targets. In fact, CRISPR only cuts the DNA at that sequence, other proteins must be employed to change and then fix the DNA. It may be well enough to simply cut up a specific race's DNA and leave it at that. Or if those cells die off too fast, splice in some garbage DNA that will at least let the cell reproduce.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by runako on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:16AM (#19152772)
> Race can be determined by DNA testing

Wading into a minefield here, but is this even remotely true?

My understanding of DNA testing is that it can only tell you what genes a person has. I wasn't aware of any reliable way to cluster genes into racial groups. (The 23 & me stuff is all probabilities, wide percentage ranges, etc.)

Further, I thought it was the case that science has basically abandoned the concept of race specifically because it couldn't be reliably measured, even by DNA analysis. Is this not the case? What am I missing?

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by zozbot123 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:24AM (#19152820)
There are measures of genetic distance that happen to correlate quite nicely with perceived ancestry, even though most genetic variation is not necessarily related to it. It's just one of many genetic "signals" that barely rise above the background noise. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_distance
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by SmellyGeekBoy on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:54AM (#19152648)
Interesting thought - CRISPR could be used to create a baby of an entirely different "race" to its parents just by changing these DNA markers.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Phenomenit on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:33AM (#19152274)
There is no biological basis for the word race.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by easshvsh on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:42AM (#19152316)
Colour of skin, epicanthic fold, and a thousand more designating traits of race are biologically encoded in DNA.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by stochastic_monk on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:52AM (#19152347)
They aren’t, however, so uniform that an attack based on presence or absence of a handful of polymorphisms together could form anything like a perfect classifier and therefore target. Race and genetics are related, but not so closely as to facilitate this.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by k__ on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:25AM (#19152503)
Sure, I can have more DNA in common with people that have a different phenotype than me, but does this mean you can't group the last few genes that make them black, or let them get sicklaemia?
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by runako on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:22AM (#19152806)
> last few genes that make them black, or let them get sicklaemia

Popular understanding of race (it's a social construct, so this is the relevant metric) has little or nothing to do with susceptibility to a given disease. Similarly, dark skin != what we commonly think of as "black" (think dark-skinned people from Asia, for example).

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by easshvsh on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:27AM (#19152835)
Dark skinned people from Asia are from a different race than dark skinned people from Africa.

For example if you have a dark skinned person with epicanthic fold, chances are that's a person from Indonesia or its whereabouts.

Race is not ONE trait, it's a set of traits, and all of them are encoded in DNA.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by runako on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:14AM (#19153200)
> dark skinned person with epicanthic fold, chances are that's a person from Indonesia or its whereabouts.

Or South Africa, or east Africa, etc. Or since we're talking about people and not geographic features, we could be talking about a person in the e.g. Americas who is the product of many "origin" regions of the world.

> Race is not ONE trait, it's a set of traits, and all of them are encoded in DNA.

The problem is the "set of traits" is squishy and often defined in the moment. This, plus the importance we assign to race in all affairs, has led many societies to try to codify what is meant by race. Racial distinctions are different in the context of different communities (e.g. in the US it's very important to know who is "black" vs who is not).

For example, in the US we long practiced the One-drop rule [1], which lead to absurd racial classifications [2] that required you to know a person's entire ancestry back 3 or 4 generations in order to identify her race (obviously, this is recursive).

The trouble is we start from a position of knowing how we want to classify a person, by seeing them or knowing where they come from ("I know she's black, so my classification scheme needs to ensure she's black."). We then need to apply tools (one-drop rule, etc.) to make sure that person fits the classification.

Gene clusters are a clumsy way to accomplish the same thing using modern tools. Obviously some populations share some traits. But saying "race" is something that can be objectively identified for every given individual is naive.

Back to your original point -- there's no such thing as the "last few genes" that make a person black. That's approximately like saying the last few quanta of pigment in a person's skin change their race. Or that a person's race can be determined by calipers [3]. It's ridiculous.

1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-drop_rule

2 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadroon

3 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrenology

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by runako on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:20AM (#19152790)
Millions of people from many different origins have any given set of those traits (e.g. [epicanthic fold, pale skin] or [epicanthic fold, dark skin]. The phenotypes presented are divided into any number of social "races".

QED there's no biological basis for race.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by taneq on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:57AM (#19152375)
Ssh you're not allowed to say that!
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by atq2119 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:51AM (#19152629)
I find this meme annoying because it so often misses the point (as I'd argue it does in this particular discussion).

Yes, races are largely a social concept. However, once society has defined races based on whatever phenotypes that are in fashion at the time, it turns out that yes, there is a biological and genetic basis for those phenotypes. It's conceivable that this biological basis could be targeted by some gene-based technology. Probably not very accurately, but based on past observations I'd say that racist mass murderers are not particularly likely to care about such subtleties. And that's what matters for the GP's point.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mercer on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:48AM (#19170854)
Not disagreeing per se, but I think we often underestimate how much of our definition of 'race' is based on context, separate from our genes, such as:

- where we see a person - who this person is with - what clothes the person wears - what a person smells like - body language - spoken language - the manner in which they speak (loud, soft, etc.) - the way they walk - all sorts of other cultural markers (like stance, eye contact, etc.)

I suspect that all these contextual, largely non-biological factors play a huge role in how we decide a person's race. Possibly so much so that the biological markers we do have available are mostly useless.

Please correct me if I'm wrong though; I am far from an expert in this area!

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Phenomenit on Thursday February 14, 2019 @02:28AM (#19160251)
I understand what you are saying and there is definitely a difference in phenotype but from what I've read the it's not possible to make a distinction because the interrace variance is smaller than the intrarace variance. It might be hard targeting a specific race with biological tools when it's hard to specify race biologically. But yeah there is difference in people appearance depending on location of origin.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:57AM (#19152666)
Frightening why? The only way this system can "target" race is to make certain skin colors and such superdominant. That's a dumb effect but not really harmful to anyone.

I assume your worry is that it might selectively activate in some race to do a bad thing? But that's not how it works. It always activates, and the only thing keeping it within the mosquito species is that they physically can't breed with anything else. And obviously no such barrier exists with races.

So we could worry about a completely different and theoretical technology, but not so much this one.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by fabian2k on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:46AM (#19152327)
Not that frightening for this specific case. A gene drive is distributed by reproduction, and the major effect is that it is passed down far more efficiently than any trait subject to the usual genetic rules.

Humans reproduce far slower than mosquitoes, and if someone managed to modify a few humans, there would likely be plenty of time to detect it and fix or contain it in some way.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by greenhatman on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:28AM (#19152258)
They'd have to abduct hundreds of thousands of people (or clone a bunch), edit their genes, and release them back into their countries of origin. And then it would take a few generations.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by unlikelymordant on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:16AM (#19152197)
what if you could target specific dna i.e. a specific person?
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by taneq on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:56AM (#19152373)
There are plenty of ways already to target a specific individual if you're gonna poke them with something biological.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by darkpuma on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:40AM (#19152303)
e.g. FOXDIE