News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by peteretep on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @05:29AM (#19151974)
ITT: people who live in countries that aren’t ravaged by malaria share their vague feelings of doubt about whether or not getting rid of mosquitos is a good idea
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by fiblye on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:59AM (#19152386)
In a world where total insect population collapse is a very real possibility, there exist people who think calling out people who want to not exterminate a cornerstone insect species is a good idea.

Before anybody says "well actually there was a study that said nothing bad would happen", the horribly flawed studies about wiping out mosquitoes being harmless acts under the assumption that animals that feed off mosquitoes will find other insects to live off of. With insect populations dropping to tiny fractions of what they were years ago, it's incredibly short-sighted to think that's feasible. It's the same as saying "all the rice in the world could vanish and humans would just eat something else." Technically, yes, but taking away a large portion of so many people's daily calories isn't a good idea. And looking at how fish, amphibian, bat, and bird populations are lower than ever, getting rid of a readily available food source that links entire ecosystems together is pretty selfish. Work on treating the diseases instead of taking the easy way and just destroying things.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by astazangasta on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @10:22AM (#19153711)
If you're referring to this[1] article that I love to hate, it is not a study, it is a news item by some Nature journalist who whimsically interviews some folks.

https://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by rincebrain on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:43AM (#19152576)
TBF to humanity, we're also trying to develop effective malaria treatments, but AIUI:

- there are several parasites that fall into that umbrella

- none of them give you permanent immunity or even permanent resistance to reinfection, so we can't crib from those metaphorical notes to find a good vaccine

- the parasites are developing drug resistance/immunity

So while I agree we should be extremely careful about even considering wiping out a species on purpose, it's not for lack of exploring other options that we're at this point.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by nkozyra on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @05:55AM (#19152107)
If you've been personally affected by malaria your immediate impulse is do whatever it takes to stop it.

But we know nothing comes for free, no good human deed goes unpunished.

There's a lot of debate about whether destroying malaria-carrying mosquitoes would have any side effects whatsoever. Alternately, it may have some.

I don't think your characterization is fair, in other words. Those of us in areas not immediately affected are insulated against that emotional response, but we must be aware of the reality of malaria's toll. But destroying an entire species is a draconian approach that should require a great deal of thought.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by krageon on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:55AM (#19152360)
> But we know nothing comes for free, no good human deed goes unpunished.

We know nothing of the sort. Perhaps this is something you know.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by ivanhoe on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:32AM (#19152542)
Pretty much all projects of large-scale human ecological interventions ended up with some unexpected side-effect. It's extremely hard to take into account all the variables and often you fix one issue, but create 10 new ones. Just think of using myxomatosis to control rabbit population, or introduction of cane toads in Australia in attempt to control sugarcane pests.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by andrepd on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:38AM (#19152913)
Erradication of smallpox?
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by ivanhoe on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:26PM (#19159164)
Well, it's a bit different with viruses as they're not directly part of the food chain for complex organisms - unlike mosquitos that are important food source to many insects, fish and birds. For instance for some fish and their fry the mosquito larvae are the primary food source, so if you destroy the complete population of mosquitos you might also severely affect some fish species. Some spiders and birds will also be left hungry. That can then affect other ecological niches up the food chain, perhaps even cause a collapse of the whole biotop system.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by krageon on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:05AM (#19153143)
Okay, I'll bite: Vaccination (and near or total eradication) of Polio.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by nkozyra on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:15AM (#19153213)
I'll say this - a less than 100 year timeline is probably not long enough to evaluate this.

That said, I think it's possible, but I'm very skeptical that eliminating a species will be free of indirect effects.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by nkozyra on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:05AM (#19152402)
Let's just say it's been pretty reliably proved over time.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:14AM (#19152450)
Wiping out smallpox seems to have no negative side effects. In any case, side effects that might exist are hugely less problematic than millions of human deaths!
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by fiblye on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:18AM (#19152782)
There's a difference between wiping out a virus that pretty much only affects humans, and wiping out an animal that's been present for millions of years and is firmly established as a food source for countless other animals.

One has the sole effect of making humans healthier. The other is linked to far too many things to predict the outcome of. Considering dragonfly nymphs have mosquito larvae as a stable food source, it's safe to say that knocking them out will probably affect them. Then follow that food chain up (and down) and things start to get complicated.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by rincebrain on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:50AM (#19152625)
One could argue that the rise of people arguing against vaccination of children is directly related to those people not having direct experience with the horrific realities of the diseases in question.

That aside, millions of human deaths (annually or in total) is a horrific tragedy, but if we, say, managed to render a large area of land uninhabitable through ecological collapse for a generation or more, it might be far worse, both in some imaginary absolute scale, and for the people directly displaced.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by TheHypnotist on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:34AM (#19152546)
The discussion isn't about wiping out a disease, it's about wiping out a species to wipe out a disease. Smallpox was eliminated in large part due to vaccination, not wiping an animal or insect from the face of the planet.

Now, if you can eliminate the malaria within the mosquito, that's something else entirely.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by sampo on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:44AM (#19152585)
Smallpox was a species, too. If we allow viruses to be species.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by TheHypnotist on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:31AM (#19152867)
Fair - and you are probably right. But I'd rather not get into semantics. You know what I meant.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by krageon on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:06AM (#19153151)
If everyone knew what you meant we wouldn't be having the discussion that we are definitely having.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by TheHypnotist on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @11:04AM (#19154024)
Did you not read the OP? It makes the discussion pretty clear.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by fsloth on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:20AM (#19152480)
"Let's just say it's been pretty reliably proved over time."

Perhaps this is observational bias from your part? Human brain detects negatives far easier than positives.

The world is a complex place, and any action that has externalities likely creates both negative and positive ones - and for some people even same effects can be negative for some and positive for others.

Yes, bad things can happen for anyone. Generally, though, I would say deeds of compassion breed compassion.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by vinniejames on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:29AM (#19152523)
It's one of the tenets of physics, every action has an equal reaction. This isn't really in dispute
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by jessaustin on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:34AM (#19152545)
This is sloppy thinking. Physics has nothing to do with punishment for human deeds.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by vinniejames on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:08PM (#19155736)
This isn't in regards to punishing humans, it's the effect of wiping something out of existence that plays an un/known role on Earth's ecosystem
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by nkozyra on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:44AM (#19152963)
But Earth's biology is a naturally-balanced system.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by ekianjo on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:32AM (#19152273)
> There's a lot of debate about whether destroying malaria-carrying mosquitoes would have any side effects whatsoever. Alternately, it may have some.

There's nothing to be lost in doing a trial in an isolated area. The world is vast, we don't need to eradicate mosquitoes at the same time everywhere...

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by azthecx on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:03AM (#19152398)
Life find a way, it doesn't really matter how isolated the area is. Once its out there, especially if its a gene that's very likely to be passed down the chances of it spreading are ridiculously high. I imagine even more as we are talking about insects which reproduce very quickly and are generally hardy.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Haga on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:14AM (#19152181)
Can't we at least have backup plan to reintroduce?
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by sampo on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:45AM (#19152594)
Reintroduce malaria?
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Haga on Thursday February 14, 2019 @06:12AM (#19161054)
Moscitos, but now that I think about it.. If a whole population shows massive allergic reactions because the imuno system fights on after the threat is gone..
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Filligree on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @05:31AM (#19151987)
One particular species of mosquito, even.

The ongoing insect apocalypse is a problem, a potentially civilization-ending one. But wiping out malaria wouldn't be, and at this rate we'll probably do it by accident even if we don't implement this.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by chesterakos on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:00AM (#19152122)
Why ITT since no one but you has commented yet.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Angostura on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:15AM (#19152184)
Absolutely! Let's not let decisions about irreversibly altering an ecological web raise even vague feelings of doubt.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by wuschel on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:11AM (#19152160)
Classical ad hominem argument. Attack the people who make the immoral choice of thinking about the fact instead of blindly going forward and doing it, regardless of the cost. Perhaps it is worth to consider carefully before eradicating a species by any means?

And perhaps it is worth to consider using a domain of technology - biotechnology - we have yet to understand better? Every tool comes with it's price, and so does CRISPR/Cas9. Gene drives can override and change the hereditary mechanism which makes genes propagate in populations. There are possible second order effects in place, which would be very important to rule out before applying such a method in the wild.

<irony>Unless... unless, of course, we are happy with the import of rabbits et al to Australia.</irony>

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by petters on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:16AM (#19152194)
If importing rabbits to Australia would have saved 500,000 lives annually, it would have been one of the best health-related things to happen to humanity.

(The eradication of this particular mosquito species is likely harmless, but that does not matter. We should do it even if it isn't)

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by wuschel on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:27AM (#19152248)
Sorry, there are two separate questions here:

A) the use of a technology - a gene drive - we have no full control of in the wild

B) the act of eradication of a species

to help to lower the loss of human life in Malaria affected regions.

Your statement regarding the Australian ecosystem engineering is purely hypothetic. The import of alien lifeforms always had a detrimental effect on ecosystems, and often, as a second order effect, on humans as well.

It scares me how a lot of people think that it is not worth thinking and evaluating the use of a technology. Perhaps it is because they have no experience and knowledge in this particular domain of science?

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by stickfigure on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:08AM (#19152417)
Or perhaps they have thought and evaluated and made their judgement call.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by hopler on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:16AM (#19152458)
I don't think HN is full of experts on CRISPR and African ecology.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:44AM (#19152591)
> We should do it even if it isn't

That depends on the level of risk to other species, in case these genes leak across some barrier.

Which might be fine, but you need to, uh, check.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mcguire on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:46AM (#19152972)
How many lives did industrialization save or improve? Compared to the costs?

Was it worth it? Yes, but all the consequences have not yet come home to roost.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by SmellyGeekBoy on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:50AM (#19152627)
> Unless... unless, of course, we are happy with the import of rabbits et al to Australia.

Odd that you lead with the dismissal of one logical fallacy and then in the short space of this comment fall into the trap of using another one yourself.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by wuschel on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:10AM (#19152732)
Sorry, I should have made clear that it was an ironic statement. My bad.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by marcosdumay on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:08AM (#19152144)
A single species of mosquito, that is domestic and invasive. And also carries a large variety of diseases, not just malaria.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by jmh530 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:59AM (#19152387)
Malaria and other diseases are one of the main reasons Europeans kept their African ambitions relatively contained. What is the geopolitical implication of eliminating malaria?
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Nasrudith on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:18AM (#19152779)
It has long been gone since Quinine essentially already let alone successors. Population spike maybe but also potential to stabilize more as persistent dangers cause humans to reproduce more. It would encourage more investment in children as well. No worries about "if my child dies all I spent on education would be lost and unrecoverable while say a jeep or plow would have something in the worst case".
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by easshvsh on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:10AM (#19152151)
I don't live in a country ravaged by malaria and I want to get rid of mosquitoes.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by LinuxBender on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @12:19PM (#19154658)
Same here. My bats can live off the moths. I currently have to use several measures to reduce mosquitoes in my area and it is costly and time consuming.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by vinniejames on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:26AM (#19152506)
The impact of extermination could be far greater reaching https://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_5c611921e4b0f9e1b17f097d/...

We ought to think twice before expediting this

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by vacant0 on Thursday February 14, 2019 @12:53AM (#19159899)
Plus we're already losing at least 200 species (of plant, insect and animal) every year. Might as well save half a million human lives while we're at it..
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by slackfan on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @11:58AM (#19154479)
Because we haven't fucked the environment enough.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by petters on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:13AM (#19152174)
Actually, the previous time this was discussed on Hacker News, I saw a lot of posters with reasonable opinions.