(The eradication of this particular mosquito species is likely harmless, but that does not matter. We should do it even if it isn't)
A) the use of a technology - a gene drive - we have no full control of in the wild
B) the act of eradication of a species
to help to lower the loss of human life in Malaria affected regions.
Your statement regarding the Australian ecosystem engineering is purely hypothetic. The import of alien lifeforms always had a detrimental effect on ecosystems, and often, as a second order effect, on humans as well.
It scares me how a lot of people think that it is not worth thinking and evaluating the use of a technology. Perhaps it is because they have no experience and knowledge in this particular domain of science?
That depends on the level of risk to other species, in case these genes leak across some barrier.
Which might be fine, but you need to, uh, check.
Was it worth it? Yes, but all the consequences have not yet come home to roost.
Odd that you lead with the dismissal of one logical fallacy and then in the short space of this comment fall into the trap of using another one yourself.
And perhaps it is worth to consider using a domain of technology - biotechnology - we have yet to understand better? Every tool comes with it's price, and so does CRISPR/Cas9. Gene drives can override and change the hereditary mechanism which makes genes propagate in populations. There are possible second order effects in place, which would be very important to rule out before applying such a method in the wild.
<irony>Unless... unless, of course, we are happy with the import of rabbits et al to Australia.</irony>