They making the probably-fair assumption that these hypothetical people want to live at least close to where they're rooted their lives.
So, the ivory tower remark seems appropriate.
Neither here nor there. The GP was responding to "$1M is not enough for most people to retire on."
i.e. "$1m is not enough for most people in the US to never work again assuming they want to live to the standard that I have become accustomed to."
Which very likely does not apply to "most people". We do pretty well for ourselves and it's easy to forget that "most people" live paycheck to paycheck on far less.
To put my feelings bluntly, get out of your bubble.
[0] https://statisticalatlas.com/United-States/Household-Income [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=us+number+of+households
In Seattle Washington? You'd have an extremely hard time making ends meet on $75K, it certainly isn't "generous." For example median home value in Seattle is $725K.
Fixed costs per month:
* $5K mortgage
* $1.2K health insurance
* $300 life and disability insurance
* $800 utilities
* $2K home services: nanny, sitter, cleaner
* $800 school / preschool and kids activities
* $2K groceries, essentials, etc
I have a family, two small kids (4 and 2), and live a comfortable life in Seattle. I could obviously adjust my standard of living, move somewhere cheaper, etc, but I didn't want my family to have to change anything from this experiment I'm doing with my life.
If I moved into my neighborhood now it might be closer to $5k (without a bigger down payment) but I wouldn’t recommend it.
A lot of the things in your post resonated with me, but seeing this in the comments really got me curious about your math.
Good luck with your endeavor!
My mortgage interest rate is 4% and I've put the cash I've withdrawn in short term US treasures at 2.5%, so that cash is only costing me 1.5%.
Another reason I did a refinance was that when I bought my house I had only been in the US for 2.5 years and my credit score wasn't great (in the 600s IIRC). I could only get an 5/1 ARM loan that was about to start becoming variable at a higher interest rate.
Renting an 1800 sq ft 3 bedroom house is $40K/year. That leaves $35K. Per month that's almost $3000.
If you are having an "extremely hard time" paying for everything else with $3000, you may want to reevaluate your lifestyle.
I'm not saying it's a fantastic lifestyle, but it's not a poor lifestyle. You'll still be able to afford a lifestyle better than most of the country.
I suppose bare minimum essential is probably $1000/mo but if you set needle to little above middle class but way below “rich” (which is not same as median) then $3000’for “everything else” is not sufficient.
That isn’t much less than the median income in Seattle.
Why's that?
The problem there is you’re just responding to whims, and everything will start to feel the same.
Even for simple things. I grew up without A/C in an apartment with leaky windows that would get way too cold at night. Never bothered me. I was used to sweating a lot in summer and using a lot of blankets or standing by the oven while we were making dinner in winter.
Today? The moment the temperature is a little off I WANT TO DIE. I can't get any work (or anything really) done, and I'm likely to get sick. Im a wuss now. Central air/heat (or heated floors if we're gonna get fancy) or I'm sad. My young self from 30 years ago would laugh his ass off at how useless my current self is. Wealth can spoil you really quickly.
The big issue however is that returns are averaged over long duration and so on some years you can end with as little as 2-3% or even negative. So you need to have 25-50% cushion to ride out bad turns in economy where you will be eating up principal itself. This is also important for any unforeseen circumstances such a medical issues that might rack up huge out of pocket (especially in US). Or children leaving for college needing to pay as much as $50K in tuitions. You also need at least 6 months of buffer ($50K) in case some bad event triggers losing your investment, for example, someone trying to to sue you. Given all these more practical investment asset size is $3M for financial independence.
>What is out there that I could do that would make me excited waking up every day for the next 45 years that could also earn me enough money to cover my expenses?
At $500k, with UK tax rates (probably higher than US), you'd have $275k net. If you remove generous expenses, you have $200k a year in savings. Five years working would get you $1M.
With $1M, you would probably never have to work again (~$40k in safe withdrawal per year).
Then you'd have the ability to pick any job, irrespective of pay. Go help charities, help with research, spend all your time on open source projects, whatever you want.