Not trying to disagree with you but I think this isn't a fair comparison.
Erectile dysfunction is a medical issue in the sense that you're actually broken. Birth control is different in that you can (mostly) live your life without birth control.
I say mostly because there are women that need to be on birth control for actual medical reasons in that they have complications with PMS and this mitigates things.
A more fair comparison would be male vs female sterilization or condoms.
If condoms were free for men but not for women then that would be a great point.
Again. Not saying I disagree with you just that this isn't an apples to oranges comparison.
I do want to suggest, however, that a change of language is warranted around this issue.
You write: "there are women that need to be on birth control for actual medical reasons in that they have complications with PMS and this mitigates things."
These women do not need to be on birth control. They need to receive hormone therapy, which happens to be, in a lot of cases, the same medication used for birth control.
I know it sounds like a distinction without a difference, but it's actually quite a meaningful distinction.
I would not say that a newborn girl with chronic pulmonary hypertension needs to be on erectile dysfunction medication. Rather, I would say that she can be treated with sildenafil, which happens to also be the active ingredient in Viagra.
Similarly, a woman might use hormone therapy to avoid menorrhagia, and a side effect might be that it decreases her ability to become pregnant, and she may or may not be happy with that side effect.
When you make this language shift -- "birth control" applies to contraception, which disrupts the body's natural fertility, and "hormone therapy" applies to treatment of medical conditions and dysfunctions -- it helps resolve some hot-button issues.
For instance, if a woman works for a religious employer that does not cover contraception, I would imagine that employer would have no issue with her receiving appropriate hormone therapy for a medical condition such as menorrhagia, even if a decrease in fertility is a known side effect.
If a woman makes 2/3 what a man makes, he makes 1 1/2 times what she makes. If it takes 90% of what she earns to just scrape by and only 10% of her income is discretionary funds, he has many times as much discretionary money as her. If she has a child out of wedlock and has to raise it alone, childcare will be far more than her current "fun money." So having a child out of wedlock can ruin a woman's life, even before we get into potential medical complications, what if the child has special needs? etc.
If you have a one night stand with a stranger and a pregnancy results, he may never know he fathered a child. She may find herself pregnant out of wedlock with no means to contact the father, thus no hope of even asking for child support.
Women generally worry quite a lot about unintended pregnancy because it can so completely derail their lives in an unrecoverable fashion. (IIRC) Getting pregnant unexpectedly is one of the three biggest risk factors for plunging a woman into poverty, even if she's always been middle class, is well educated, etc. The other two are divorce and widowhood.
"Okay" is a curious word to choose. There is a good reason why almost every culture on Earth has shamed female promiscuity: women get pregnant and men do not, making premarital sex far more risky for women than for men. Culture hasn't caught up with the invention of the birth control pill, but that does not mean that it's all part of a patriarchal scheme (as people imply).
Men are also shamed to a lesser degree depending on the culture for rampant premarital sex but also get respect for it too, which makes sense. A male's sexual success is very closely tied to his status, wealth, and position in a social hierarchy (this is observed across diverse cultures). You can take it as an indicator of a male's success in his society.
>Did not cover female birth control
Erectile dysfunction is a medical dysfunction. Not wanting to have children is not a medical dysfunction. It's more complicated than the stories people are told.
Never in my life has this been acceptable to anyone I know.
Maybe if you met more people like me, you would not be so incredulous. The catholic church has several groups and iniatives dedicated to young mens chastity
In private society, we encourage our own particular vices and virtues as long as they don't lead to a critical point of instability and dissolution.
Total opposite in Canada across public and private plans.
Never saw a private or public plan refuse to cover BC. Many would pay several hundred for an IUD as well. Rarely saw a plan cover ED drugs outside of self-insured or executive plans.
I only doubt the birth control assertion for the most American of all reasons; Corporate Profits. Insurers would(do?) save BILLIONS in coverage for pregnant women by giving out the pill. It's against their own self interest.
No, sildenafil was discovered _while_ trying to find a cardiac medicine.
The primary indication for Viagra is sexual dysfunction, per the manufacturer. So much so that they market the pulmonary anti-hypertensive focused variant as Revatio.
And even in that, it's not shown to be amazingly effective:
"Sildenafil therapy lasting 12 weeks improves multiple clinical and hemodynamic outcomes in patients with PAH, but it appears to have no effect on mortality or serious adverse events." -- "Respiratory Medicine" journal
That doesn't follow. I mean, many prescription drugs have death as a known potential side effect, and it's generally accepted that people have a right to life, but that doesn't mean that the drugs aren't covered. Being entitled something doesn't justify third party insurers denying you coverage for something which might interfere with that entitlement when you have voluntarily accepted that risk to acheive some other end.
> Last time I checked its not like sex where one could get pregnant was no longer fun
Your idea of fun is, I suspect, not universal.
Your take on the situation also wasnt a direct logical entailment. We both gave our interpretation of the unwillingness to covwr birth control. I gave mine as a counterinterpretation to yours to avoid ideological hegemony.
> Your idea of fun is, I suspect, not universal
But it is substantially more fun!
No, I think you have fallen into the “anyone who responds to me other than in agreement must be the same person I responded to” error.
Your other remarks here suggest you are Catholic and saved yourself for marriage. If you have only ever had one sex partner and have only ever had sex without birth control, then you seem rather unqualified to make a comparative statement of this sort.
Luckily, we have large scale surveys to cover the gap: https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/paeekv/why-conservati...
Since a lot of women don't even want to have sex without birth control, it could be argued that you will have more fun if you use or allow for birth control. As far as I know, the term "conservative" does not mean "people who universally refuse to use birth control." Correct me if I'm wrong.
If you want to argue that sex without birth control is more fun than sex with birth control, you will need to find a study pertinent to that claim, not pertinent to the claim that socially conservative people have more fun in private.
I'm happy to concede that socially conservative people who are picky about who they sleep with and other details that serve as protection against serious regret following sex probably enjoy sex more. But that was not the claim.
Among other things: Society is generally okay with men having sex outside of marriage. It is much less okay with women doing the same. Men are generally not subjected to criticism for being working fathers. Quite the contrary: they are criticized if they are unemployed and have children. Women are routinely expected to choose between career and family.
I have in the past commented on the fact that insurance typically did not cover female birth control, but often did cover Viagra. The subtext there: Fertile young women aren't entitled to sex, but men are, even if they are so old they need help performing. Such observations were typically met with open hostility and dismissal, not like the observation held any water.
The ACA changed that some. From what I gather, most policies are required to cover some sort of female birth control, unless it falls under religious exception iirc. So this is mostly no longer true, but was at one time.
My understanding is the current administration is trying to repeal this and stop covering female birth control, so such gains cannot be assumed to be permanent. It's all too easy to reverse them and reinstate historical "barefoot and pregnant" style gender norms for women.
Edit: For context, I'm American and 53 years old. So I'm talking about (historical, before the ACA) American insurance practices here.