News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by smallnamespace on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @11:50AM (#18979892)
I think a little context here is in order: from a 10000-foot high level, the particles that can be seen depend on the amount of energy present in the system, which is why we spend billions of dollars accelerating basic particles (protons in the case of the LHC) to high energies and literally SMASH them together, so we can see what flies out.

We see four distinct, different forces in the universe: strong and weak nuclear forces, electromagnetism, and gravity. Our Standard Model predicts that these forces become more unified at higher energy levels:

1. Electromagnetism merges with weak nuclear force at 246 GeV

2. Electroweak force merges with strong nuclear force at around ~10^16 GeV ('grand unification')

3. Finally, quantum mechanics predicts these forces become unified, which is to say indistinguishable, at the Planck energy, around 10^19 GeV.

As we get closer to predicted unification energies, we see different mixes of particles, and the Higgs boson is in fact the particle responsible for electroweak symmetry breaking, with a mass of around 126 GeV.

The problem is that the LHC produces collisions of around 10^4 GeV, so from our current energy scale up to the next unification, with the strong force, we're off by a factor of 10^12.

Back of the envelope estimate is that a supercollider that can reach grand unification energies with our current technology would be around the size of the solar system.

Hence the article: particle smashing is a brute-force approach to investigating new physics, but now there is an extremely wide gulf between what we have discovered, and what we think lies next, hence we need to be more clever than using brute force.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by auntienomen on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:17PM (#18980889)
This explanation needs a couple of major caveats: The Standard Model does predict unification at ~250 GeV, but it does NOT predict unification at either 10^16 GeV or 10^19 GeV. Those predictions come from particular extensions of the Standard Model (grand unified theories or various quantum gravity models, respectively) which have been studied by particle theorists for their simplicity.

Which is to say: Those unification scales come from speculative models, not from tested physical law. We do not know with any certainty what lies beyond the energy scales we've tested. You should take with a generous grain of salt any claims that we have physical models that work across an additional 14 orders of magnitude. Consider the range of phenomena that we've discovered in moving from the ~1 cm scale of a glass of water to the 10^-14 cm scale where quantum chromodynamics kicks in.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by cft on Thursday January 24, 2019 @12:24AM (#18986213)
The Plank scale (Grand Unification scale) comes from the simple dimensional analysis, that combines the gravitational constant with the Plank constant (and the speed of light). It doesn't not really depend on the details of a grand unified theory. It was fist calculated to be 10^19GeV in 1899 by Max Plank, well before any quantum field theory (well before quantum mechanics for that matter). Because it combines the Plank constant with the Gravitational constant, we know that it corresponds to the energy scale at which quantum phenomena unify with the gravitational phenomena. Currently the only theory that describes this unification is String theory, but as the op correctly noticed, it's far from any possible experimental confirmation.

I was at a seminar of Alexander Polyakov, one of the founders of string theory, who compared the string theory to the knowledge of Democritus about atoms. He said that even though the atomic theory of Democritus was essentially correct, it was about 2,000 years ahead of any possible experimental verification. In his opinion this is how long it will take us to verify our Grand unified theory experimentally.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by auntienomen on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:26AM (#18989434)
I've never quite believed this argument. It's worked in a lot of circumstances, I agree, but it requires the dimensionless constants to be of order 1. This is usually a reasonable assumption, but it's known to be false in gravity! The cosmological constant ought to be the leading order term in the EH action, but it's too small by ~100 orders of magnitude.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by cft on Thursday January 24, 2019 @11:18AM (#18989995)
The argument that dimensionless constants are of the order 1 works well for the theories that have been tested experimentally so far. We don't know the value of the cosmological constant. I am not even certain that it is not exactly zero. But it's not dimensionless, it has dimension length^-2, and is usually expressed in the units of Planck's length (currently thought to be 10^-122 I think). If it indeed turns out to be not zero, it is a new fundamental constant, much like the gravitational constant or the speed of light.

I didn't not understand your statement about EH action: the cosmological term there has a dimensionless coefficient of the order 1. Are you talking about some effective action, arising from a string theory model?

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by Iwan-Zotow on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:43PM (#18985545)
Mmm... Particulars of unification depends on how you extend SM, but general idea about unification at 10^16 GeV based upon EM/Weak and QCD coupling constants energy dependence taken directly from SM. Basically, if you plot those coupling constants vs log(E), you'll get their merge at circa 10^16 GeV. That's baseline and it is pretty much pure SM, details are filled differently from different GU theories.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by auntienomen on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @10:47PM (#18985798)
Yes, but you need to assume there's a desert to get that result. Otherwise the renormalization flow is different.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by Iwan-Zotow on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @11:31PM (#18985988)
Yes, I stand corrected, thanks
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by stronglikedan on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:45PM (#18980512)
I usually just use the upvote button, but in this case, I must join some other commentors in expressing explicit gratitude for your easy-to-understand explanation.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by walrus1066 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:07PM (#18981514)
Minor clarification. The standard model does not describe gravity. It ignores it, which is fine at LHC energies because it's orders of magnitude weaker than the other three forces.

At the planck energy scale, this is no longer the case, the relativistic mass of particles becomes so big that gravitational interaction is too strong to be ignored, and the SM loses it's ability to predict how particles interact, decay, combine etc

So you're guaranteed to then see 'new physics'.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by pdonis on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @03:22PM (#18982437)
> the relativistic mass of particles becomes so big that gravitational interaction is too strong to be ignored

It's not relativistic mass that's the key factor: relativistic mass is frame dependent, and it's not the source of gravity. The relevant factor is stress-energy: energy density, momentum density, pressure, and other stresses. The key factor at the planck energy scale is that the density of stress-energy is high enough that we can no longer have confidence that classical General Relativity is an accurate description of gravity; we expect to see quantum gravity phenomena at that stress-energy density.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by walrus1066 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @04:18PM (#18983068)
I always understood that the Stress–energy tensor in general relativity has a momentum component, so two electrons whizzing past each other at near the speed of light would exert a stronger gravitational pull between them, in all frames of reference, than if the electrons were 'at rest', relative to each other? I admit I didn't study GR so happy to be corrected!
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by pdonis on Saturday January 26, 2019 @12:04AM (#19004860)
> I always understood that the Stress–energy tensor in general relativity has a momentum component, so two electrons whizzing past each other at near the speed of light would exert a stronger gravitational pull between them, in all frames of reference, than if the electrons were 'at rest', relative to each other?

The stress-energy tensor does have a momentum component, but remember that all components of a tensor are frame-dependent. So is "gravitational pull". Obviously the trajectories of two particles passing each other at relativistic speeds will be different from the trajectories of two particles at are at rest relative to each other at some instant; but the difference is not quite as simple as "more gravitational pull", although the two particles having relativistic velocities does mean that the center of mass energy of the system is larger than it would be if both particles started out at rest.

(Actually, the electromagnetic interaction between electrons is so much stronger than the gravitational that the gravitational effects are negligible in the scenario as you state it; but we could eliminate that issue by considering, say, two neutrons instead. My comments above assume that the scenario has been modified accordingly, which is why I said "particles" instead of "electrons".)

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by mrfusion on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:20PM (#18980913)
The solar system is already close to a vacuum. Makes me wonder if a new solar system sized accelerator could just be a series of nodes orbiting far out to aim and accelerate the particles around.

Still way too hard for us but also way easier than building a tube going around the solar system.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by archgoon on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @08:43PM (#18985268)
The tube isn't just to provide a vacuum; it's there to provide continuous acceleration of the particles while keeping the charged particles in the particle beam from dispersing.

There's another issue though.

The reason that accelerators are circular is so that you can keep applying an electric field to accelerate the particles. The catch is, that when you accelerate a charged particle, it emits a bit of radiation, and this radiation increases with the amout of acceleration it's undergoing. The problem is that while you can keep nudging the particles faster and faster tangentially to the track, the circular track requires you to increasingly pull the particles back to the center of the track (i.e. apply a greater centripetal force).

This means that you increasingly lose energy what is called 'synchrotron radiation'. This means that you have a maximum speed (or energy) that you can accelerate particles to with a given radius. Hence if you want more energetic particles in your collisions, you need bigger colliders.

So if you had just a bunch of point to point satellites, you'd lose the benefit of having a greater radius (which doesn't actually apply anymore because you're not doing continuous acceleration anyhow), because you have to increase the amount of acceleration you have to apply at each satellite to pass it to the next one.

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Particles/synchro...

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by wincy on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:06PM (#18985378)
What if we just built a really long, straight particle accelerator in space, and we just shot all our highly accelerated particles outside of the solar system? Aside from really ruining someone aliens day in a billion years, what’s the disadvantage of doing this?
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by archgoon on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:09PM (#18985392)
That's a linear accelerator.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_particle_accelerator

Presumably, you want to actually see the results of your collision.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:23AM (#18989412)
The nice thing about rings or other methods like racetracks etc is that the particles come around and go through the same accelerator structure multiple times. Secondly, if you want to collide two beams, the advantage of a ring is that each particle has multiple chances of scattering of the other beam, as it "comes around" to the intersection region millions of times. That being said, linear accelerators are a thing, as they have other advantages.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by dpq on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:08PM (#18981527)
> The solar system is already close to a vacuum

No. Not at all. You can expect particle density to be anywhere from 5cm^-3 to 80cm^-3 if you stay within 1 astronomical unit distance from the Sun. Besides, all that plasma is accompanied by frozen-in magnetic field, plus you have energetic particle events, recurrent fast solar wind emerging from coronal holes and plethora of other effects and structures which are terribly interesting to study but which will ruin your high energy physics experiment even if you somehow acquire god-like powers and build a huge non-contiguous accelerator.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by CamperBob2 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @04:10PM (#18983000)
With a space-based facility, it seems like we'd be able to observe the types of collisions we're talking about without bothering to build an accelerator at all, if we only knew when and where to look for the events.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oh-My-God_particle

It's possible that forward progress in the post-LHC era will come from better sensing technology, rather than larger accelerators.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by rwallace on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @08:38PM (#18985241)
I was under the impression the best artificial vacuums here on earth are nowhere near as empty as space. Is that not the case?
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by d-sc on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @10:58PM (#18985845)
People can get slightly better vacuum pressures in elaborate lab settings than are present on the moon. With trivial amounts of effort (and non-trivial sums of $), you can get within a couple orders of magnitude. Source: have done so myself.

The difference is that space is filled with lots of other stuff that makes running experiments less than ideal.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by imjustsaying on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @06:01PM (#18984097)
>5cm^-3 to 80cm^-3

had to look this up to see what you mean. I think you mean 5g(cm^-3) to 80g(cm^-3)

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by BentFranklin on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @06:26PM (#18984300)
Um, water weighs 1g/cm3. He means 5 particles.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by garmaine on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @06:29PM (#18984319)
No he means 1 particle per that volume, or maybe that many particles per cm^3. The numbers you suggest are more dense than water.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by imjustsaying on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:25PM (#18985473)
alright, so 5 particles per cm^3 to 80 particles per cm^3, not grams (as density is normally measured).

i'm not sure why the downvotes were necessary though when I made it clear I was trying to figure out what he's saying.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by rmu09 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:45PM (#18981248)
Charged particles radiate away energy if you accelerate them (force them on a curved path), this energy loss is larger for larger accelerations / smaller radii.

To bend the particle beam you need magnetic fields. Particles with more energy need larger fields. Larger radius means less field strength for given energy or larger energy for given field strength.

So a circular accelerator needs strong magnets nearly everywhere to force the beam on a circular path. In case you would put it in outer space, it's not like you just bounce the beam between some small number of spacecraft, that wouldn't gain much if at all, you would need something very similar to the structure in the LHC.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by jandrese on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:22PM (#18980950)
It would be tricky to anchor them in place so they don't wander out of alignment.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by mrfusion on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:29PM (#18981036)
We keep gps sattelites in a very precise orbit. Maybe that can scale up?

Also maybe the nodes could have some kind of magnetic ram scoop design to cover a larger area and funnel the particles through.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by phkahler on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:08PM (#18981526)
>> We keep gps sattelites in a very precise orbit.

I think it's more like GPS orbits are precisely known, not so precisely controlled. If you have fixed ground stations the GPS sats can accurately figure out where they are (like GPS in reverse). If the GPS sats can transmit their location and time accurately, your receiver can figure out your position accurately. The only thing that needs to be well controlled in this is the ground stations locations, which are not moving.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by graycat on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @10:36PM (#18985758)
Yup, early in my career I worked in the group, at the JHU/APL, that did the satellite location calculations for the Navy's version of GPS.

One of the research projects to help with this, actually in effect to have carefully controlled orbits, was a "drag free" satellite. Basically just put the satellite in a ball. Then the ball still has drag, but the satellite does not. Sure, soon as the satellite without drag moves with respect to the ball that does, have to tweak the orbit of the ball to keep the drag free satellite at the center of the ball.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by jsjohnst on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:40PM (#18981177)
> We keep gps sattelites in a very precise orbit. Maybe that can scale up?

Source for this? It was my understanding they weren’t, hence why the almanac data is so important, but I’m not positive that assumption is valid so I’d love a source to back up your claim.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by dmckinney on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @04:28PM (#18983184)
Almanac is important for receivers to optimized what vehicles to track and when. The ground stations comment is the correct answer.

https://gssc.esa.int/navipedia/index.php/GPS_Ground_Segment#...

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by jandrese on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:50PM (#18981309)
We aren't redirecting streams of high energy particles with GPS satellites.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by empath75 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:31PM (#18985499)
There are cosmic rays many times more energetic than anything we could hope to create on earth going through space all the time, we’d just need a detector out there.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by celias on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:13PM (#18994013)
There's the ISS-CREAM cosmic ray detector on the space station that can "measure elemental spectra of Z = 1–26 nuclei over the energy range 10^12 to >10^15 eV" Given that CREAM is roughly 2x1x1m^3 and weighs 1258 kg while ATLAS on the LCH is "46 metres long, 25 metres in diameter, and weighs about 7,000 tonnes" it may not be possible to put LHC-class detectors in space

https://cosmicray.umd.edu/iss-cream/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATLAS_experiment

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by fxfan on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:16PM (#18980186)
You put everything in a way that someone with high school physics can mostly understand the issue. Would it be possible for you (or anyone else) to explain what is merging of forces? Or is it beyond high school?
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by zinclozenge on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:21PM (#18980249)
It's probably helpful to think of this as phase transitions. At the plank scale "temperature" everything is mixed together, but when the system cools and undergoes a phase transition we start seeing different behavior.

Sounds possibly like an invalid analogy, but in fact there's substantial overlap in the theories. If you want to read more try reading wikipedia articles on "ising model", "spontaneous symmetry breaking", "higgs mechanism".

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by frutiger on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:47PM (#18985559)
It turns out that seemingly distinct forces are related in some clever way. The most approachable example of this (though it doesn't quite extend to the other unifications listed above) is electricity and magnetism.

Before Faraday's experiments, we understood static electricity (charged objects attract/repel charged objects of the opposite/like sign, proportionally to the product of the charge, and falling off with the square of the distance), and magnetism (magnetic poles repel).

Once we saw that moving electric charges generate magnetic fields and vice versa, we opened the door to realizing that these are both just aspects of the same electromagnetic field.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by fxfan on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @10:39PM (#18985771)
Thank you! That's probably the simplest possible explanation. "Related like electricity and magnetism are". How far is it from the "actual reality"? Would you (or anybody else) try giving a more difficult explanation?
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by high_derivative on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:14PM (#18980170)
Thanks for these insights!

Do experimental (!) particle physicists have any other way of doing research on this than colliders?

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by Balgair on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:37PM (#18980413)
One possibility is in using space based detectors. Essentially, you put the detectors up above the atmosphere in a relatively 'neutral' area of space to avoid background from other sources [0]. Then, using this floating detector, you use other sources in the universe to do the colliding for you. Something like an astrophysical jet[1] coming out of a black hole, some neutron stars colliding, some super novae collapsing, etc. Taking all these detectors together, you can then get the results you want.

The major issue is that you have nearly no idea when/where these events will occur, and they are really rare to begin with. Add the distances that these things occur at and your error bars go through the roof[2]. Still, over a VERY long time and with a LOT of these detectors spread about the Sol system (and likely a bit further out), you can get the results you'd need.

It's not cheap or easy or timely. But with 12 orders of magnitude to go, it's a lot cheaper, easier, and more timely than trying to build an accelerator with Jupiter in the way :)

[0] as in, not next to the Sun, Earth, Moon, near gravitational perturbers, etc.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astrophysical_jet

[2] http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/geoopt/lenseq.htm...

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by eanzenberg on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:48PM (#18980548)
There are particles of 10^20 eV energy or more out in space you get for free. But how to do anything with them.. that's yet to be seen.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by Roverlord on Thursday January 24, 2019 @11:35AM (#18990170)
I could have sworn I read yesterday that (I think it was Sag A*, or Cyg X-1) is literally pointing it's jets right at us.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by rmu09 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:55PM (#18981368)
Building more telescopes like LIGO, IceCube and a whole bunch of other "microphones" or "telescopes" or whatever you want to clal them.

But not sure if that qualifies as "experimental" particle physics.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by b_tterc_p on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @08:56PM (#18985327)
How does this map to the idea that we haven’t unified the fundamental forces? It sounds as if we understand exactly where and how they diverge... surely it isn’t just that we haven’t experimentally verifies this?

Apologies if I am way off base

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by frutiger on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:44PM (#18985546)
There are lots of possible models of unification (a short list of where electroweak and QCD unify are listed here[1], not to mention many more models where gravity unifies), and without experimental data, we don't know which one is correct.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Unified_Theory#Unificati...

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by dkersten on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:05PM (#18980057)
Interesting. Thanks for posting this, it really helped me understand what the issue is.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by salty_biscuits on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @10:21PM (#18985692)
Should we be looking at these a bit harder?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-energy_cosmic_ray

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by OscarCunningham on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:52PM (#18982050)
Is there some reason why new phenomena can't occur except at these energies? Couldn't there be something interesting that isn't the unification of forces?
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by mrfusion on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:21PM (#18980928)
Does point 1. imply there’s a way to control the weak force via electromagnetism? (In theory at least)

Kind of like how we create magnetic force with electric.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by seiferteric on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:04PM (#18981479)
I asked a similar question a couple weeks ago and was pointed to neutrino-lepton scatterings. If you search you will see an electron can interact with a neutrino.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by mrfusion on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @03:24PM (#18982465)
Wow and what would be really cool would be to eventually manipulate gravity electromagnetically. If all the forces are unified it should be possible.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by airstrike on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @04:38PM (#18983309)
First there's that pesky problem of finding a shitton of power to play around with