Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line
by auntienomen on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:26AM
(#18989434)
I've never quite believed this argument. It's worked in a lot of circumstances, I agree, but it requires the dimensionless constants to be of order 1. This is usually a reasonable assumption, but it's known to be false in gravity! The cosmological constant ought to be the leading order term in the EH action, but it's too small by ~100 orders of magnitude.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line
by cft on Thursday January 24, 2019 @11:18AM
(#18989995)
The argument that dimensionless constants are of the order 1 works well for the theories that have been tested experimentally so far. We don't know the value of the cosmological constant. I am not even certain that it is not exactly zero. But it's not dimensionless, it has dimension length^-2, and is usually expressed in the units of Planck's length (currently thought to be 10^-122 I think). If it indeed turns out to be not zero, it is a new fundamental constant, much like the gravitational constant or the speed of light.
I didn't not understand your statement about EH action: the cosmological term there has a dimensionless coefficient of the order 1. Are you talking about some effective action, arising from a string theory model?
I was at a seminar of Alexander Polyakov, one of the founders of string theory, who compared the string theory to the knowledge of Democritus about atoms. He said that even though the atomic theory of Democritus was essentially correct, it was about 2,000 years ahead of any possible experimental verification. In his opinion this is how long it will take us to verify our Grand unified theory experimentally.