News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by peterlk on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @11:32AM (#18979694)
Several years ago, shortly after the Higgs discovery, I sat down with a couple CERN people, and their comment was that the current problem is that we need more theoretical physicists coming up with measurable predictions. As many of the other posters state, obviously there is more to learn, but we could learn faster if we had better (and more) predictions about what we might find.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by v_lisivka on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @11:56AM (#18979965)
It's harder and harder to do without well developed intuition. To develop good intuition, we need to make good mental model, but we got good (but incomplete) mathematical model instead.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by akvadrako on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:32PM (#18980357)
I agree and I think the main reason is the anti-realist camp in physics which has taken hold in the past 100 years.

This view probably developed because the realist models of quantum mechanics were too difficult for people to accept. It was easier to say that intuitive models are outside the scope of science than to change their set of inconsistent preconceptions.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:27PM (#18981014)
Could you expand on your comment; I thought a (small?) majority of theoreticians were, shall we say, "super-realists" such that they view the Many-Worlds Interpretation as actuality rather than merely a model?

When you say "intuitive models" do you mean ones that echo somewhat Newtonian/Classical physics?

Perhaps part of the problem is that schools follow a method of teaching physics where they teach what is easy to teach, knowing it's wrong, and then teach something a little more complex, knowing that's wrong too, etc.. Perhaps we need to start off teaching that the world is non-Newtonian, that it has Quantum weirdness and relativistic effects (according to our best models), and allow that to underlie our intuitions.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by akvadrako on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @03:41PM (#18982665)
Many worlds is one of the more popular realist models, but it's quite rare for physicists to claim they think it represents reality. It's not taught in any textbooks I'm aware of and even now papers often dismiss experiments having multiple outcomes without even mentioning that they are doing so, coming to absurd conclusions as a result.

The situation has certainly improved a lot since the days of Everett, who was basically dismissed as a crack-pot.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by pbhjpbhj on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:23PM (#18991357)
I've seen Hawking quoted as saying MWI is obviously right.

My statement was based on an IoP survey result I saw some years ago (I'm a theoretical physics graduate); I'll try and dig it up as my recollection could be wrong.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by akvadrako on Friday January 25, 2019 @07:18AM (#18997326)
Hawking said it was right but that it's "just probability". It's not clear what he really thought about all those worlds being real. He didn't seem to believe in quantum immortality, so I don't think he took it seriously.

There have been a few surveys over the years, but mostly of conference participants. The results depend heavily on which conference you attend.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by graycat on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @10:58PM (#18985844)
But Everett has a cute case of Lagrange multipliers, or if you will, non-linear duality. :-)
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by czbond on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @11:49AM (#18979883)
As a layman, from your statement, what do we have now? [meaning if we don't have enough theoretical physicists]. Is it that we have enough theoretical scientist, but the predictions are not testable? Or not enough talent?
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by dtech on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:28PM (#18980319)
> Is it that we have enough theoretical scientist, but the predictions are not testable?

Yes, much research goes into string theory, but its predictions are "not even wrong", they cannot be proven false by experiment [1].

Disclaimer: I'm a layman on the topic, this is just repeating what I've heard.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Not-Even-Wrong-Failure-Physical/dp/04...

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by Steuard on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @04:34PM (#18983260)
Disclaimer: I'm a string theorist.

Please try to be at least a little bit skeptical when a handful of naysayers claim that an entire field's worth of very smart people are all spending their careers on pointless work. Those naysayers could be right, obviously! (Even as experts we have to recognize the possibility, and to the many laymen looking on from outside it's even harder to judge.)

But if you read Peter Woit's dismissive rants and accept them as gospel truth, just remember that in doing that you're choosing to believe that hundreds (thousands?) of dedicated, passionate, deeply knowledgeable physicists are either painfully deluded or deliberately running some sort of collective scam. You're choosing to believe that either none of us have bothered to read Woit's objections or that we've all failed to accept them even though they're right.

I'm not sure what our motivation for that is supposed to be. I promise you: people who go into fundamental physics aren't in it because it's an easy road to a steady paycheck! We do this because we're driven to understand the building blocks of the universe. If I were to become convinced that my current approach to trying to understand the universe was fundamentally a dead end, I'd be wasting my life if I continued to study it! I'd be throwing away everything I've trained for, everything in science that I care about. And I have no idea what Woit thinks I'm getting in return.

So your call. Either Woit's right and we're all knowingly wasting our lives, or the situation isn't as cut and dried as Woit claims it is.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by bsaul on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @07:08PM (#18984634)
I think you forgot one case : it’s psychologically extremely hard to abandon something you’ve been working on / believing in for a huge part of your life, and start over from scratch, no matter how smart you are ( i’d say the smartest you are, the hardest it is to believe you’re completely wrong) . So teachers could be tempted to hang on to the narrowest hope their work still has meaning and keep taking new phds and this could last for a very long time.
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by xelxebar on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:14PM (#18985421)
Which is probably why it's hard to convince String Theory haters to re-evaluate their opinions, i.e. non-testable explanations.

One, the claim that string theory makes no testable predictions is just plain false. The predictions are just out of reach of current technology.

Two, we should probably be more suspicious of explanations that rely on folk (interpretations of) psychological effects. How strong is the Sunken Cost fallacy? Is it sufficient to overcome the motivation to shift subfields? At what rate should we expect theorists transisioning out of String Theory, under the assumption that Woit is right?

Three, String Theory has been very useful already. It's development has provided us with novel tools for mathematical tools for studying a plethora of applied quantum phenomena.

Disclaimer: I'm not a String Theorist.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by FuckOffNeemo on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:17AM (#18986408)
The sunk cost fallacy?
Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by paraschopra on Thursday January 24, 2019 @07:48AM (#18988157)
Yours is a fantastic, spot-on comment. It's easy to get swayed by controversial, non-mainstream opinions, especially when you're not knowledgable about the field. One trick that I'm forcing myself to use is to take evidence of what people do v/s what they say.

String theorists may not be vocal in countering the objections raised, or they may simply consider getting into a debate a waste of time. But the fact that hundreds of smart people are choosing to spend time on something is _some_ evidence that the project is not completely misguided.

Of course, the positive evidence has to be balanced with the evidence of group thinking and sunk cost fallacy.

Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line by czbond on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:00AM (#18989199)
PBS spacetime has a few great videos on the topic - Why String Theory is Wrong and Why String Theory is right:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IhpGdumLRqs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTTa9YcTe1k