Re:Particle physics may have reached the end of the line
by xelxebar on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:14PM
(#18985421)
Which is probably why it's hard to convince String Theory haters to re-evaluate their opinions, i.e. non-testable explanations.
One, the claim that string theory makes no testable predictions is just plain false. The predictions are just out of reach of current technology.
Two, we should probably be more suspicious of explanations that rely on folk (interpretations of) psychological effects. How strong is the Sunken Cost fallacy? Is it sufficient to overcome the motivation to shift subfields? At what rate should we expect theorists transisioning out of String Theory, under the assumption that Woit is right?
Three, String Theory has been very useful already. It's development has provided us with novel tools for mathematical tools for studying a plethora of applied quantum phenomena.
One, the claim that string theory makes no testable predictions is just plain false. The predictions are just out of reach of current technology.
Two, we should probably be more suspicious of explanations that rely on folk (interpretations of) psychological effects. How strong is the Sunken Cost fallacy? Is it sufficient to overcome the motivation to shift subfields? At what rate should we expect theorists transisioning out of String Theory, under the assumption that Woit is right?
Three, String Theory has been very useful already. It's development has provided us with novel tools for mathematical tools for studying a plethora of applied quantum phenomena.
Disclaimer: I'm not a String Theorist.