News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by murph-almighty on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:15PM (#18973145)
>Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull of Australia said in July, “The laws of mathematics are very commendable, but the only law that applies in Australia is the law of Australia.”

Does math not apply in Australia? Is this where "new math" comes from?

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by hnzix on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:37PM (#18973971)
Maths is dangerous, and Australia is a nanny state. We must put a curfew on maths. Once the clock strikes 3am you may only continue a maths problem, no new maths can be commenced until 11am the next day.

You see, both terrorists and sex offenders are known to use maths. We must control maths for your own good. If you oppose us, you are supporting terrorism.

(This is just the latest episode of anti-science politicians nerfing the Australian knowledge economy. See also their mishandling of the national broadband network, the latest cybersec laws destroying remote work, and the gutting of the CSIRO.)

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by brobdingnagians on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:38PM (#18975467)
I tried looking for the cybersec laws with remote work but couldn't find a reference, I'm curious to read about it, do you have a reference handy?
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by climb_stealth on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:46PM (#18975511)
I'm not sure about the effect on remote work, but I presume this one was meant:

> Australian parliament passes encryption laws unamended

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18616303

[dead]
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by hlurhhh on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:20PM (#18974777)
They're not being rude, that's how it is - speaking as someone from AU.

We have lockout laws preventing us from entering drinking establishments after 1am (no shots after midnight!) because we cannot handle our booze, so do you think we can handle Math?? AND ENCRYPTION???

It's a nanny state. OP is correct. Don't call people nob ends, no need to be rude.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by lazyasciiart on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:54AM (#18975985)
The other commenter is also clearly from Australia, using “they” about idiot politicians.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by tokyodude on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:13PM (#18975330)
San Francisco and NYC have these too. SF (California) no drinks after 2am. NYC is 4am.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by icanhackit on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @11:28PM (#18975676)
I'm not arguing with your point that Australia is a nanny state, but for clarification...

> We have lockout laws preventing us from entering drinking establishments after 1am

Currently for a large section of the Sydney CBD and inner suburbs encompassing Kings Cross new entrants to venues are blocked after 1:30am and last drinks are 3am. This does not apply to areas of the City of Sydney like Surry Hills or Newtown, which can remain open all night. I believe the trading hours for licensed premises have been recently relaxed by City of Sydney to areas including Glebe, however I'm not 100% on that.

Still, it's pretty sad as Sydney's nightlife, particularly in Kings Cross, was a big draw-card for younger visitors and residents alike.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by rbg246 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:52PM (#18974953)
I don't think he is being rude, he is just ridiculing the stupidity of it all - whereas in your short comment you made 2 ad hominem comments
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by King-Aaron on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @09:08PM (#18975037)
What part of this is rude?
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by toufiqbarhamov on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:37PM (#18974894)
I’m totally against the Australian approach and goal here, but come off it, you know that isn’t what was meant.

Three lines of argument are especially noteworthy:

“It is impossible to regulate cryptography.” or “Banning cryptography is like banning math.”

This argument misses the point in confusing the knowledge about cryptography with the wide-spread use of cryptography - or more specifically the use of cryptography to protect confidentiality. While it would be beyond the reach of governments to remove the knowledge about cryptography from the public sphere, it is certainly not impossible to threaten those that employ “illegal” cryptography with sanction.

This is exactly what happens with most regulation: Speed limits do not prevent the thought about driving fast, instead they address actually driving fast. It is behavior that is regulated, not thought.

So, similar arguments about the futility of regulation or the impossibility of enforcement aim a bit too high. Regulation does not require perfect adherence. Often it is enough if some people adhere to the specific law, and others can be punished in case of being caught. Again, speed limits are not perfectly enforceable, but they limit the number of drivers that drive recklessly, and it allows taking action against some drivers and thus nudging other drivers into compliance.

https://opaque.link/post/fog_of_cryptowar/

Shallow arguments don’t help anyone, they just marginalize the speaker beyond a narrow audience that already agrees with them.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by lokopodium on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:58PM (#18974983)
Australia requires companies to provide backdoors. It does not (and can't) require that non-companies do the same. This means every Jihadi with half a brain will be using XMPP with OTR or something like that.

At the same time, it provides a requirement for EMPLOYEES to make backdoors when asked without letting their employers know.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by gregmac on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @09:33PM (#18975167)
> it provides a requirement for EMPLOYEES to make backdoors when asked without letting their employers know.

I'm very curious about how this will actually work, in practice, anywhere that uses any form of source control and even a modicum of process.

I mean, do you sneak this into an unrelated pull request and hope everyone reviewing it doesn't catch it? Do these changes by committing directly to master (assuming you even can do that), and just hope no one notices? What commit message do you use?

Even if you don't put this in source control, how do you get it deployed? Do you just tell your ops team "uh, don't use the automated deployment or the artifacts the build server produced, instead install from this zip file I made on my machine"? What happens if they are deploying a new version on a day you happen to not be there?

Even assuming you manage to do all this, what happens when you're eventually caught? For example, someone finds a remote exploit bug in the code, does a blame, sees your name next to an innocent-sounding-but-clearly-misleading commit message and injection of an apparent deliberate exploit... are you allowed to explain? I would assume, especially if you can't/won't explain, that the employer could fire you on the spot, so do you just have to go along with that?

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by justinclift on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:22PM (#18975375)
> I'm very curious about how this will actually work, in practice, anywhere that uses any form of source control and even a modicum of process.

A capable ;) agency wouldn't target the developers. They'd target the SysAdmin's who look after the build servers.

With agency backed er... malware added to the build servers, they'd be capable of adding on-the-fly exploit code to the shipped binaries.

Things like reproducible builds - gaining popularity among some OSS Communities for few years now - help to at least detect this.

Could be very difficult to detect for lots of situations. eg side loaded mobile apps, proprietary desktop apps, likely others too

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by baroffoos on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @09:06PM (#18975024)
>This means every Jihadi with half a brain will be using XMPP with OTR or something like that.

Or they could just use SMS and still be fine because the government has no idea how to actually identify problem data in the sea of data they have.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by lokopodium on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:29PM (#18975416)
In this case it doesn't appear that the government intends to mass-decrypt data, but rather only tap into targeted individuals' communications.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by acct1771 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:21AM (#18976372)
Today.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by toufiqbarhamov on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @09:12PM (#18975058)
As I said, I don’t agree with either their methods or their goals. It’s because I don’t want these kinds of laws in the world that I want to see shallow dismissals of them replaced by effective arguments. No one here needs convincing, what they need is to improve their ability to communicate beyond the tech bubble.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by brandonjm on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:07PM (#18973633)
Meanwhile the same guy wanted Australia to become an "innovation nation" [1]. You can not innovate technology without mathematics and when you can not export due to fear of it being compromised.

[1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-07-17/innovation-nation-tak...

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:14PM (#18974324)
During the same tenure as he and his party were promoting innovation, they were also talking down renewable and talking up the future of coal whilst also stopping the rollout of fiber infrastructure, opting to maintain the existing infrastructure which was primarily copper plus some coax.

Australians ran out of faces for the palming.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by NamTaf on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:05PM (#18974684)
It's worth noting that he also rode into power on the back of a reputation of being a 'progressive conservative', partly due to his business ties wherein he invested in an ISP in the 90s and early 2000s and made a large sum of money. Supporters paraded it as evidence for why he'd do the innovation and tech 'right', but any more than a cursory glance at his credentials for this revealed that it was purely a business decision not one of interest in the industry.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by dwd on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:36PM (#18974886)
Turned out the progressives were very wrong and he basically sold his soul to the big coal/climate change denying/religious right faction of the Liberals to become PM. In saying that Peter Garrett in Labor was not the Midnight Oil firebrand everyone expected.

Turnbull's replacement of FTTP with FTTN in deference to Telstra was shameful and showed how much weight he gave innovation. One year on NBN and I've already had a week offline (and no landline phone) due to faulty copper.

His appearance in the Panama Papers and alleged ties to Russian oligarchs bear out the reality of his world view: Malcolm is in it for Malcolm. I'd even question his Republican stance as being nothing more than posturing.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by baroffoos on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @09:07PM (#18975034)
>One year on NBN and I've already had a week offline (and no landline phone) due to faulty copper.

The copper at my street aged away and instead of laying a fiber optic, they put in new copper.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by dwd on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @09:48PM (#18975221)
Probably saved them a few cents. The sooner we can all go to wireless mesh the better.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by clouddrover on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:30PM (#18973916)
What Turnbull means is that the technical measures don't matter when you can compel people with threats of fines and jail time. And he's right.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by nixpulvis on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:37PM (#18973972)
Well there's a difference between holding a gun to someone's head to force them to tell you their secret, and baking secret selling backdoors into the secrets themselves.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by harry8 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:32PM (#18974861)
I think the policy is wrong but this is ridiculous.

Physics laws exist and are fairly insurmountable. You throw an animal in a sack into a river and the law will get you arrested for it. This for not make the physics "fail to apply." And so it is with math, which software does.

What are good laws to have with respect software?

I'm wildly pro strong encryption myself. Software is not a law free zone, never has been, never will be. Saying otherwise is a little silly, just like the proposed (enacted) encryption laws are (imho) silly... In the US, Britain, Australia.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by lvs on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:42PM (#18973389)
If John Clarke were still alive, this would make for one hell of an interview.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by balabaster on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:44PM (#18974053)
"Is this where new math comes from?"

Hahaha brilliant! Thanks for making me laugh, that's the sharpest quip I've heard all day! :D

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by i_am_proteus on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:30PM (#18973270)
Finally, somewhere I can go without being bound by the law of gravity.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by bori5 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:34PM (#18973951)
“I know this defies the law of gravity, but I never studied law!” Bugs Bunny
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by nixpulvis on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:46PM (#18974076)
Ha, gravity exists with or without the need for math.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by endymi0n on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:32PM (#18973295)
Better respect gravity. It‘s the law.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by quicklime on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:39PM (#18973358)
We will decide whether things should fall in this country, and the direction in which they fall!
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by cmroanirgo on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @03:14AM (#18976574)
As someone living down under, we refuse to fall off the face of the earth and to end up in space. Clearly maths isn't working here. ;-)
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by _bxg1 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:10PM (#18973667)
"Alternative Math"
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by dwd on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @11:06PM (#18975587)
I can imagine Dutton saying that totally straightfaced.(Kellyanne Conway would be proud)

At the same time it reminds me of Tim Minchin talking about alternative medicine.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by yesenadam on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:55PM (#18973490)
'Math' is indeed not allowed in Australia. Here, outside the walls of the USA, we have 'maths' instead - although it's fairly similar.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by tomjakubowski on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:13PM (#18973714)
It's very slightly annoying to me that people stopped properly abbreviating "mathematics" as "math's".
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by chrismorgan on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:27PM (#18974832)
An apostrophe has never been in common use in “maths”, and so “math’s” would be incorrect except for indicating possession (e.g. in the US I can imagine people might say “the math’s sound” where in Australia I’d say “the maths is sound”). Not all abbreviations get an apostrophe just because some letters were dropped.

Very vague, weak citation: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=maths%2Cmath%2...

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by pretendscholar on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:20PM (#18973790)
How does it make sense to tack on the last letter?
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by ggm on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:22PM (#18973829)
Because the plural of lego is lego, does not mean the plural of math is math..
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by pretendscholar on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:40PM (#18974013)
The word mathematics is singular not plural. People say mathematics is hard not mathematics are hard.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by ggggtez on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:58PM (#18974194)
The linguistic way to say that is to note that mathematics is an "uncountable noun", just like "water". It's plural, just you can't have just "one mathematic".
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by Angostura on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:09PM (#18974287)
It's plural just in the way that "history" isn't.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by Varcht on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:42PM (#18974532)
At least we all still put our pants on the same way...
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by yesenadam on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @09:08PM (#18975038)
...over our fannies?! :O
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by toufiqbarhamov on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:10PM (#18975311)
Ah you’re taking me for a ride.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:21PM (#18974381)
> The word mathematics is singular not plural.

It was originally considered plural. That may even by why the transition from “mathematic” to “mathematics” happened in English.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by tanbog on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:21PM (#18975365)
I know plenty of people who say "Legos".

But then I am from Australia.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by ggm on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @04:03AM (#18976792)
Leggos. I mean who can go past pasta sauce advertised by bad Muppets?
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by ggm on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:22PM (#18973820)
Don't get me, or other queens-english speakers started on the american habit of twenty hundred one (notice no "and")
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:15PM (#18974329)
I've been in America for a few years short of five decades now and literally never heard “twenty hundred” (as a number; it is used in military timekeeping.)

The closest pattern to that is consistently not used with numbers of hundreds evenly divisible by ten. (OTOH, it is often used with “and”; the rule of not using and between components within the whole number portion but only to separate the whole number from a fractional part is not consistently applied in that informal alternative to the more formal thousands-hundreds form.)

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by ggm on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @05:31AM (#18977147)
Ok. Ignoring twenty hundred, any hundred AND something had an AND in it. For some reason the septics dropped AND.
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by onewhonknocks on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:13PM (#18980152)
I thought the 'and' was typically used to denote a decimal place.

ex: $270.50 -> Two hundred seventy dollars and fifty cents

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by ggm on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @03:02PM (#18982168)
Two or more and is fine by me mate!
Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by HenryBemis on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:29PM (#18974441)
EVERY time I hear/read of some country wanted to make encryption illegal, the lyrics of Radiohead's Karma Police come to mind:

Karma police, arrest this man

He talks in maths

He buzzes like a fridge

He's like a detuned radio

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by gerdesj on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:11PM (#18974727)
I went to school with the chaps that became Radiohead (Abingdon school aka Royce's). As it turns out posh blokes can strum a bit and come up with some decent lyrics.

Fancy that.

Re:Did Australia Poke a Hole in Your Phone’s Security? by dwd on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @08:20PM (#18974785)
I also have No Surprises in my current rotation.

"Bring down the government. They don't, they don't speak for us."