Dear God, what's your power bill? There's no way a LED lights heat is as efficient as just using the furnace.
edit: I meant cheap, not efficient.
If they have a gas furnace it might be different but that would also depend on how their electricity is generated.
According to http://web.archive.org/web/20180822025250/https://portfoliom... heating with grid electricity would require 2-3 times as much primary energy as heating with water/oil/gas.
Now, converting electricity to heat may not be as cheap as converting, say, natural gas to heat (thus making the heat pump un-economical when not pumping any heat)... but you do get heat out of it.
The average is 30 BTU / 1000 sq feet. That's 10 kW / 1,000.
Certainly not an efficient way to heat the house, but the main concern is oxygen and not generating co2 with the furnace, then air filtration (SLC nasty air), then humidity, then food, THEN heating.
edit: we vent the tents directly at our beds
I guess the water heater might cost some money, since it produces heat, but a lot of that heat just goes down the drain with the water.
I have also seen some pretty cool looking "passive" houses that, due to excellent insulation, are able to heat the entire house with a 3kW furnace [2]. And these are in very cold locations (e.g. Alberta, Canada).
Electric heating is the future!
[1] https://learn.compactappliance.com/mini-split-heat-pumps/
Mitsubishi has some that can extract heat from the outside air even down to -30C.
Most though only work down to about +5C (they're used in more temperate climates). So check the specs.
They also work for AC.
It's possible to design house that need almost zero BTUs:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_house
When looking at bang-for-buck / value / ROI, better insulation and air sealing should be done first. If you can reduce the number of your blower door test, then you'll have to spend less on running capacity (and their related costs).
I don't have any sensors to get a real idea of the difference in CO2 it makes, but it allows us to run the furnace less at night (heat from the lights), and makes a noticeable difference in humidity ( very dry air here ).
Also, we get about 1-2 family meals / week of food at full capacity ( total 4x8 grow space and 800 watts of light running only at night ).
Not economical and takes a lot of maintenance, but it's a fun hobby from which we all feel the benefits.