News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by LeanderK on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:08AM (#18960829)
50M euros seems far too little to me. It's a major violation against a fundamental regulation in their core product and compared to their revenue, 50M is nothing. A magnitude more will probably get google thinking, but I doubt this will.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by Despegar on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:39AM (#18961030)
As always with these cynical comments about fines, it misunderstands the nature of them. Google or any other company does not get to just continue their practices as usual, the fine is purely "punishment" for the bad behavior in the past. The real teeth is in the changes they will be forced to make.

The EC's three antitrust cases against Google don't end with the billions of dollars in fines they have to pay. Google would gladly pay them if it meant they could continue their anti-competitive practices, it would just be a cost of doing business. But that's not the point of them.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by synctext on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:53AM (#18961125)
CNIL: "Therefore, it is of its utmost responsibility to comply with the obligations on the matter."
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by LeanderK on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:50AM (#18961109)
but wouldn't a fine that's actually sizable send a different signal?

I don't get how google can violate somthing like this and the only results is the enforecement of existing law and some fine? Or I am not getting something?

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by pgeorgi on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:21AM (#18961347)
> the only results is the enforcement of existing law and some fine?

The job of European data protection agencies isn't to be punitive, but to ensure compliance.

If the issue was tiny, an honest mistake that was promptly fixed when it was brought to the offender's attention, and they show that they implement safeguards so that something like that won't happen again, there may be no fine at all.

Compared to this, EUR 50M is rather heavy handed, but given that Google has approximately $infinity at their disposal, no value would "ensure compliance".

What this does is ensure that the topic will be discussed by the board of directors (50M is probably beyond the discretionary spending budget of the not-quite-top level manager who handled this) with the outlook that there may be more fines like that.

OTOH it's still far from that "4% of global revenue" figure, so it gives room for escalation. Hopefully it's also small enough that it won't be disfigured too much into "the evil EU is being protectionist again!" US press cycle that comes up every time a US company is fined by some EU body.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by luckylion on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:35AM (#18961440)
> The job of European data protection agencies isn't to be punitive, but to ensure compliance.

Wouldn't larger fines ensure compliance though?

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by ldng on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:50AM (#18961558)
Well next fine, if nothing is done to comply, will be heavier. For better or worse, that's how it is intended to work.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by SpicyLemonZest on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:33AM (#18961432)
It would send a different signal that France doesn't necessarily want to send. If the fine for having a bad UX over passable data privacy configurations is billions of dollars, and the fine for not making an effort at all is also billions of dollars, that doesn't really encourage the right behavior.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by LanceH on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:24PM (#18962279)
Larger fines can tell companies at large that it is unsafe to do business in that jurisdiction.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by Despegar on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:53AM (#18961133)
GDPR would have allowed fines of up to 4% of Google's global turnover. That's a bazooka you don't use for every infraction. If Google is found to be a repeat offender or fails to comply, that's probably when regulators will use that particular tool in their toolbox.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by luckylion on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:40AM (#18961477)
> That's a bazooka you don't use for every infraction.

Use it once, and you won't have to use it again. I don't know the usual english translation of a quote attributed to Mao: punish one, teach one hundred.

Handing out fines that actually hurt will not only teach those that receive it but also everybody else. Making knuddels.de pay €20k for leaking the data (including clear text passwords) of millions of users just says "do as you please, here's a symbolic fine, we don't mind".

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by SpicyLemonZest on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:46AM (#18961530)
I mean, there's a reason that quote is attributed to Mao. When regulators fire off ruinous fines as a first resort, the lesson companies learn is not that everything will be okay if they follow the rules.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by luckylion on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:41PM (#18961962)
You're probably right, they don't want to hurt the actors on the first offence. We shall see whether it will turn into a three-strikes system, or remain in a rather pedagogical western european fashion.

It does remind me off Google vs SEO-Black-Hat-Spammers. They get caught, the get a manual penalty, they remove the worst, say they're sorry, the penalty gets lifted, they continue on.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by notahacker on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:54AM (#18961594)
The $50bn fine gets paid and steps taken to comply in future. The $4bn fine gets more appeals and politicians dragged in.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by amelius on Monday January 21, 2019 @07:00PM (#18964809)
Ok, but can you translate this line of thought to a fine at the scale of an individual, for example a speeding ticket?
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by kcorbitt on Monday January 21, 2019 @09:00PM (#18965414)
"Here is a $100 fine because we caught you speeding in a poorly-marked zone. Of course, now that you unambiguously know what the speed limit is here, if we catch you speeding again, we will take your house."
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by acct1771 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:51AM (#18966709)
Why does Goldman Sachs, HSBC, etc have houses...?
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by seszett on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:49AM (#18966699)
A speeding fine is the punishment, and the limited amount of points on the driving licence, some of which are taken away at each infraction, are the incentive for changing behaviour.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by jellicle on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:21AM (#18961343)
"You should definitely make these major changes to your lifestyle, and if you don't, in about ten years or so we will fine you $25."

Will you make those changes?

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by mtgx on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:51AM (#18961567)
> the fine is purely "punishment" for the bad behavior in the past.

Is it, though? Isn't the punishment supposed to fit the crime?

I think if corporations will continue to do what they want with impunity paying slap on the wrist fines for major illegalities, and passing laws in their favor through lobbying, people will eventually get fed up like they have in France, or worse. Then, more countries' populations will start demanding from their governments to impose the death penalty for corporations (at least in that government's jurisdiction) and mandatory arrests of top executives for serious corporate crimes and harm against consumers.

If the trend continues, I think it's only a matter of time until these demands become reality.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by alangpierce on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:55PM (#18962069)
Certainly, taking a nontrivial percentage of global revenue will force Google's attention, but I'm not convinced that's the best way to think about it.

One thought: if Google had just served non-personalized ads (or personalized ads with much greater restrictions) to all of France, how much money would they have lost due to the ads being lower quality? With some very rough estimates, I'd guess $250 million in revenue resulting in $100 million in profit. ($1 billion revenue from France, $500 million from ads, ads are 2x more effective when personalized, 40% of revenue is profit). All very rough estimates/analysis, but it definitely seems like a significant slice (half the profit) of this part of Google's operations, and likely there's at least someone at Google who's thinking about this specific revenue source who just got a wake-up call. Given the roughness of the estimates, seems possibly at a point where it would have been better for Google to just give up on ad personalization (at least in France) altogether.

Another thought experiment: surely at some point (e.g. fining 100% or more of global revenue), Google will just stop operations in France (or Europe), which is probably not what anyone wants. What is that tipping point? If every country (or city) uses the "significant percentage of global revenue" approach, it's more likely to collectively become unreasonable. That's at least the extreme-case downside to giving a fine that's too big (especially proportional to the unfairly-gained profit in the jurisdiction giving out the fine).

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by ahje on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:43AM (#18966684)
> Google will just stop operations in France (or Europe)

No they won't.

The market is too large, and they are perfectly aware that they have competitors that manage to keep their businesses both legal and profitable.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by alangpierce on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @03:41AM (#18966903)
I guess it's a complex decision, but I feel like if I was running a worldwide business and a single country decided to impose a $100 billion fine (the scenario I was describing), I'd want nothing to do with that country. That's much, much more than the market opportunity that Google has in France. Probably I'd want to avoid operating at all in countries that have a chance of imposing that scale of fine.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by ahje on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @04:05AM (#18967023)
This is not a single country -- as the article mentions, this decision is valid for the entire EU. Obviously, there will still be some kind of limit for individual businesses, but a 50M€ fine is nowhere near enough for a company like Google to stop doing business in the entire European Union.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by ahje on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:29AM (#18960965)
Google will now be expected to do it all over, and follow the rules. If they fail, the fine will most likely be much higher.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by zaldun on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:24AM (#18960941)
There are complaints like this in almost every European countries. If it's 50M fine in France, 50 more in Germany, 50 in The Netherlands and so on, it should start to be a huge amount!
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by eeZah7Ux on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:37AM (#18961020)
To fine the company for merely 5% of their $110 bln revenue it would take 110 countries.

Compared to the average US income, $50M is 15$.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by olivierduval on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:43AM (#18961057)
In case of repeated and obvious offense (not the case of Google for now), the fine may grow up until 4% of the annual revenue... For each case !
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by chillacy on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:59AM (#18961180)
Is that 100 billion from all countries? If fines from EU exceeds profits from EU then that division would be bust, it’s more like 25 billion.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by eeZah7Ux on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:39AM (#18967352)
So many downvotes. Never criticize our corporate overlords.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by trystero on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:15AM (#18961303)
Still more than a 100 times the usual amount for the CNIL fines.

https://www.cnil.fr/en/tag/sanctions

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by laurentl on Monday January 21, 2019 @02:51PM (#18963042)
It’s also the first fine to be handed out after the GDPR came into effect (the other fines on the page are for infractions discovered before May 2017). Which is one of the reasons the GDPR was passed: previous laws had much less teeth when it came to fines.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by zaarn on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @04:37AM (#18967151)
Not the first; a german chat app was hit by a minor fine because they stored passwords in cleartext in 2018.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by laurentl on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:32AM (#18967783)
Sorry, I meant "the first by CNIL" (or even more specifically, the first in the list of previous fines that was a couple of posts above)
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by TheRealPomax on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:21AM (#18961341)
It could be a million times higher, but if it's an amount the company in question turns over in less than an hour, it still meaningless. As a fine, it's almost insignificant, but as judicial signal it _is_ important, because it's the first official warning, and ignoring it means the next punitive measure will be orders of magnitude higher.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by onetimemanytime on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:29AM (#18960967)
I think this is just for France and for this case. If they continue, they'll be new fines. Also other EU countries, I think, can jump in. Changing behavior is what hurts them, and apparently here no need for 5 year investigations. Matter of months and the verdict is in.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by bryanrasmussen on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:15PM (#18962200)
50M euro here, 50M euro there pretty soon you're talking real money.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by CorvusCrypto on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:47AM (#18961074)
Perhaps. Though with GDPR the framework is intentionally vague on a lot of things. You often hear about limits and design requirements and such, well those don't exist. They are just legal "best guesses" with the frameworks inherent goal as a guide. Nobody knows whether default configs are disallowed as long as opt-in is positive action. The current best guesses for that vary and all that's known in GDPR in that regard is that there must be positive user opt-in with a good faith effort of informing the user. In this sense google likely thought they were satisfying this requirement.

It can be argued and should because the arguments laid out in this discussion set precedence that acts as a more concrete requirement that sits on top of GDPR. Basically imo this could be a very interesting set of arguments that mean changes to a huge amount of websites.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by mehrdadn on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:00PM (#18962107)
> Nobody knows whether default configs are disallowed as long as opt-in is positive action.

Isn't it just common sense based on everything in GDPR? I find it hard to believe that someone familiar with GDPR and without incentives to the contrary could legitly come away thinking the legislation intended to allow defaults to be anti-user-privacy.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by CorvusCrypto on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:57AM (#18966507)
Why would it be common sense? Literally nothing is written about design details. At a certain point burden will fall on the user and no it's not common sense where that point lies. Legal arguments such as this case are what concretely define expectations. I get the data protection part and it's easy to just say "anyone that does X is against data protection", but implementing stuff to satisfy GDPR is a mess of grey areas. It's just as likely a company sets defaults to streamline the UI experience for a user as is the case they did it to maliciously trick users (Yeah yeah google is evil etc. Etc. But remember these decisions affect all companies). This is not to mention the fact that many companies dont even offer customized settings and simply have only blanket opt-in checkboxes.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by jiveturkey on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:22PM (#18970744)
It's a fair penalty.

> Moreover, the violations are continuous breaches of the Regulation as they are still observed to date. It is not a one-off, time-limited, infringement.

It's a warning notice, you see. Formal notice to Google, to fix this, or face real consequences.

One doesn't want to come down too heavy handed on these things. It will backfire. This light penalty and explicit notice that it requires immediate action to address, is a good move.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by agumonkey on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:32PM (#18961899)
Felt like a ridicule amount, but also a sum that Google will not think a lot before paying which may serve as an admission/precedent for future laws.
Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by chrismeller on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:59AM (#18961176)
Similarly to raising taxes you also have to keep in mind that governments walk a tight rope: too little and it doesn't accomplish what you wanted but too much and you could then be dealing with a lot of unemployed people. Neither is good, so you have to be careful.

This is also the first offense and (one of) the first major fines to be handed out over GDPR, so it's not totally unsurprising that they might fire a warning shot to everyone that they can and will be cracking down, it wasn't an empty threat.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by PaulHoule on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:56AM (#18961151)
The way the GDPR is written it seems that big co's will be able to pay their way out of noncompliance, the percentage of revenues that they charge in fees is a lot but it won't erase their margin.

I wonder if this will lead to a situation like cigarette taxes in U.S. states where the "punitive" taxes wind up being a huge source of revenue that the states can't live without.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by the_duke on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:01AM (#18961190)
Not really.

Fines aren't a one-off and everything is forgotten. If they don't establish compliance, they can be fined again continually, with increasing amounts.

It will depend on if the enforcement agencies follow through.

Re:CNIL imposes a financial penalty of 50M euros against Google by icebraining on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:16AM (#18961308)
> the percentage of revenues that they charge in fees is a lot but it won't erase their margin.

I don't see how; the GDPR allows member states to fine up to 4% of worldwide revenue. If just five states fine that amount, that's 20% of revenue. Even for Google, that's practically all of their profit, and way more than what they make in the EU. And there are complaints filed with seven regulatory agencies already.