News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by rsync on Sunday January 20, 2019 @01:32PM (#18954629)
"Not just the icons, the entire user interface was excellent."

Agreed. I strongly dislike the Windows operating system but I miss very much the Windows user interface which was very well designed, consistent, and optimized for real work.

One of the things I miss the most are the consistent, universal and wide-ranging keyboard shortcuts. Not just key shortcuts for menu items, but keystrokes that allowed you to move around dialog boxes, resize windows, etc. OSX is largely terrible in this regard with even many common menu items without shortcuts ...

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by zapzupnz on Sunday January 20, 2019 @04:40PM (#18955775)
> One of the things I miss the most are the consistent, universal and wide-ranging keyboard shortcuts.

I actually find that's what I miss when I use Windows. Windows' universal keyboard shortcuts seem to be limited to window management and some basics like new files, save, cut, copy, paste, etc.

On the other hand, just about every macOS has the same shortcuts for actions within applications as opposed to without. For items without shortcuts, you can define your own quickly and easily in System Preferences, and those custom shortcuts can apply to just one app or every app.

Not only that, every macOS app puts the shortcuts in the same place, the menu bar. They're all searchable via the Help menu. On Windows, there are more often than not keyboard shortcuts that aren't listed in any menus, so one would have no idea what they are without looking them up. Further, because Windows software tends to be developed in any ol' framework with any ol' user interface, lacking in any consistency, quite a lot of programs don't even implement the standard, universal shortcuts.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by int_19h on Sunday January 20, 2019 @10:41PM (#18957463)
All the things that you list about Windows apps are deficiencies of the modern era of UX design. UX apps of Win98 era were much more consistent, and especially the rule that all commands and shortcuts must be in the main menu was usually adhered to, at least by apps that respected the official platform design guidelines.

The idea of a drop-down main menu with all commands comes from CUA:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Common_User_Access#Descrip...

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by mjevans on Monday January 21, 2019 @05:21AM (#18959268)
They were also self-documenting and training. Do an action and while you're doing it, right there next to the description of the action, is how to do it quickly.

If you realized that, were doing the same thing frequently, and used the keyboard action after the first couple times you learned the memory of how to do it the quick way.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by zapzupnz on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:16AM (#18957834)
> All the things that you list about Windows apps are deficiencies of the modern era of UX design

I was going to say "not on macOS, they aren't" because this isn't true for any apps that use Cocoa or Carbon (which is to say, all of them). The only apps that exhibit any weirdness are ones that use cross-platform frameworks like Qt, GTK+, or wxWidgets.

But nowadays, there are loads of Electron and React Native apps that don't even present anything in the global menu bar; if the developers don't think to add them in themselves, basic functions like copy and paste don't work without secondary clicking!

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by wolrah on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:12AM (#18958049)
> UX apps of Win98 era were much more consistent

Counterpoint: 99.5% of everything ever created with Visual Basic.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by int_19h on Monday January 21, 2019 @02:08AM (#18958307)
99.5% of everything ever created with VB is probably line-of-business apps. Which is to say, most users would only be exposed to 1 or 2 such app, usually at work.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by yoz-y on Monday January 21, 2019 @05:18AM (#18959255)
The one thing I miss from windows is that alt access to the menu. While search menu is great when I don't know what I am looking for, using alt menu and then a chord to access features was great and less painful than some of the macOS shortcuts that require three modifier keys at the same time.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by cesarb on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:51PM (#18955500)
When I bought my first computer (which came with Windows 3.1), it didn't come with a mouse. User interfaces back then were designed to be usable without a mouse, because many people didn't have a mouse - it was optional, and used up one of the serial ports.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by londons_explore on Sunday January 20, 2019 @08:33PM (#18956857)
I gave up trying the get my first mouse working after hours of tweaking win.ini...
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by collinmanderson on Monday January 21, 2019 @09:32AM (#18960575)
Yup, I started out with win 3.1 without a mouse. You could do pretty much anything except use paint.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by fiddlerwoaroof on Sunday January 20, 2019 @01:43PM (#18954712)
What makes up for this, to some extent, is that you can assign a keyboard shortcut to any menu item in OSX: go to System Preferences > Keyboard > Shortcuts > App Shortcuts, click +, select the application (or all applications), type the menu name and set a shortcut.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by fiddlerwoaroof on Sunday January 20, 2019 @01:46PM (#18954740)
The other thing about OS X is that command-shift-/ opens a little search box in the help menu and then you can pick any menu item by typing a few characters and selecting it with the keyboard.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by navs on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:03PM (#18955259)
Very underrated feature. Last I used Ubuntu's Unity it had a similar feature.

I wish Alfred had a plugin to do this on Mac OS. I remember Quicksilver had something.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by douglaswlance on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:51PM (#18955498)
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by spdionis on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:57PM (#18955539)
What baffled me is that if you have a mouse with side buttons you just cannot use them in any type of shortcut.

Mouse support is generally terrible in OSX.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by zapzupnz on Sunday January 20, 2019 @04:30PM (#18955732)
There's a lovely piece of software called SensibleSideButtons to deal with that. Back in the day, everybody used USB Overdrive to overcome OS X's shortcomings with the mouse. Alternatively, BetterTouchTool is a nice little piece of software for setting custom shortcuts with any mouse button and/or trackpad gestures.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by ploxiln on Sunday January 20, 2019 @05:04PM (#18955904)
I still use USB Overdrive to make a physical scroll wheel work without crazy acceleration. Without it, macOS seems to scroll just a pixel on the first click of the wheel, maybe two pixes on the second click, but if I scroll a bunch, it jumps half the page. With USB Overdrive I can set it to just always one or two lines of text per click.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by paulie_a on Sunday January 20, 2019 @04:29PM (#18955724)
Mouse support for Macs has been terrible for decades.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by zozbot123 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:38PM (#18956335)
> Mouse support for Macs has been terrible for decades.

I'm kinda out of the loop, do they still sell mice with only one button?

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by MereInterest on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:43PM (#18956350)
Sort of. Their desktop mice have two buttons, but only a single plastic shell. This seems to follow Apple's design guideline of wallpapering over complexity, rather than admitting that it exists.

Image: https://m.media-amazon.com/images/S/aplus-media/vc/75a2caed-...

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by saagarjha on Monday January 21, 2019 @03:07AM (#18958609)
> Their desktop mice have two buttons, but only a single plastic shell.

I'm not sure where you're getting that from, since Magic Mouse only has one button: https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Magic+Mouse+2+Teardown/51058...

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by invalidusernam3 on Monday January 21, 2019 @06:46AM (#18959678)
It may physically only have one button, but functionally it has two (left and right click) as well as gesture support. Magic mouse takes a bit of getting used to (it's very flat), but it is a fantastic mouse once you have.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by saagarjha on Monday January 21, 2019 @06:51AM (#18959706)
Functionally, it has as many buttons as you'd like, since it's a multi-touch mouse. It's like a trackpad in that sense: you can configure it to do certain things when you use it a certain way, but physically, it's nothing more than a multi-touch surface and a single click button.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by IggleSniggle on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:53AM (#18961126)
Shoutout to Shortcat for providing something like "knowledge-free keyboard shortcuts everywhere" on macOS. You hit a search key-chord (I use SHIFT-CMD-SPACE) and it pops up a search modal making all UI elements keyboard selectable. Usually the thing you want is 1 or 2 characters followed by Return.

It honestly reminds me of the experience of navigating Windows menus with Alt- and progressive keyboard shortcut learning, but flexible enough to handle things like Electron applications that don't even have a Menu bar or settable shortcuts.

Does anyone else use this or something similar?

https://shortcatapp.com/

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by Piskvorrr on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:35AM (#18961441)
Jetbrains' IDEA has the "Search everywhere" feature that...well...searches everywhere - menus, commands, project files, etc. I'd love to have that for every app in the OS.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by trm42 on Monday January 21, 2019 @02:08PM (#18962682)
Actually, that would be really, really awesome once you get used to Jetbrains' way of working. It's so unusual to be able to search for all the configuration, functionality, code and files in the same place.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by explainplease on Monday January 21, 2019 @04:43PM (#18963879)
Emacs is much like that, as everything the user can do is an interactive command, which is typically a named function. So tools like Helm, Ivy/Counsel, as well as the built-in completion for M-x, let the user find and execute commands by name. And, e.g. `helm-M-x` display any bound keys next to the command name.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by daxelrod on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @08:58PM (#19031921)
Thank you for teaching me about Shortcat!
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by gerash on Sunday January 20, 2019 @07:41PM (#18956645)
One UX issue with the cascading menus in Start menu was when you had to navigate several levels deep to open a program. Since the menus expanded and collapsed on mouse hover every once in a while accidentally moving the mouse in the wrong direction meant all my menu navigation progress was lost and I had to start over.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by rkagerer on Sunday January 20, 2019 @02:27PM (#18955017)
Dang right! It's like half the programmers of today have forgotten keyboards are a thing.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by squarefoot on Sunday January 20, 2019 @05:25PM (#18956010)
And many others don't even realize that investing a bit of research on better keyboards would bring us to much better use experience. I don't mean changing the typewriter style keys, those are ok, I mean all other keys; why there is no standard for a reduced keypad with the bare minimum for menu navigation and data entry? Unfortunately the arrow keys are a half solution by not implementing yes/no and other control keys. Why there's no contextual Info key to show information/help pertaining the current task? The computer keyboard as we know it has to be extended, not taken away as the WIMP culture before and touch screen after attempted to do, with disastrous results so far.

I would welcome a kit made of say 120 key modules (one key per module, real clicky keys, please!) all with the same pinout, and normal+2x/3x/4x keycaps, special "key" modules such as trackballs, Thinkpad "nipples", analog knobs etc. then a breadboard-style carrier board where i can stick them as I want, plus a decoder board. Then, once the keyboard is ready, I can send a file describing its details to some high quality 3D printing assembly to purchase a pcb and case for my prototype keyboard and turn it into a real one.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by jmiserez on Sunday January 20, 2019 @07:39PM (#18956640)
>The computer keyboard as we know it has to be extended(...)yes/no and other control keys.

The Macbook Touchbar is pretty much exactly this, it shows e.g. dialog options as keys. I know it's not what you want (I like mechanical keys too), but it's the first actual extension of keyboards in a long time and it's convenient sometimes.

There is also the Optimus keyboard that sounds more or less like what you want built.

>Why there's no contextual Info key to show information/help pertaining the current task?

Usually F1 brings up relevant help on Windows. The actual implementation in most apps is useless though.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by setr on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:21AM (#18961340)
>Optimus keyboard

I’ve had that page bookmarked for like 5 years now, and its never changed/stopped being out of stock. I’m starting to doubt it ever physically existed..

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by tobr on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:28AM (#18958123)
> Unfortunately the arrow keys are a half solution by not implementing yes/no and other control keys.

Wouldn't "yes" and "no" be redundant with "enter" and "escape"? Most situations I can think of where you can confirm or abort an action, those actions will map to enter and escape.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by squarefoot on Monday January 21, 2019 @06:42PM (#18964707)
Yes and no. Functionally yes because every keyboard has them but I'd like specific function keys to be part of the "arrow keys section" so that users become accustomed to them and one day if I have space constraints I can implement just the arrow keys section and expect the user to be able to input anything without looking elsewhere, including text if I implement a virtual keyboard the user can navigate using arrow keys. I'd like keyboards to have sections that can be snapped together, say the typewriter section on the left, then the arrow keys section, then the numeric keypad, all independent each other. In this context we could envision keyboard addons such as for example customized function keys for very specific operations and or modifier keys which aren't mapped to the usual shift/alt etc. If every key (sensor/knob/transducer, etc) was a module which initializes itself according to its capabilities and once snapped in with others uses a common bus for communication, we could build on the fly haptic interfaces a hundred time more powerful than any "modern" touch screen out there.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by ddingus on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:02PM (#18955250)
For growing numbers of people they aren't.

As an exercize, I very seriously embraced touch a few years back.

I will not give up keyboard plus mouse, but I am also amazed at what really can be done with touch keyboard and pen.

Lots of people want to expand on that because it expands on phones and tablets.

I have a Note 8, and can content create on it to a level I did not think possible a few years ago.

I use touch keyboard, voice and pen.

At times I carry a small bluetooth keyboard with touch mouse pad. It is not as fast, but is more robust.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by ori_b on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:18PM (#18955335)
I put up with touch keyboards because real ones are not very portable. It's good enough to get by, but it's not good. The same with touch interaction -- selecting a range of text is an exercise in frustration. I don't want that interface on my desktop.

Just because a thing has a CPU and operating system does not mean it needs to have a unified user experience.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by weliketocode on Sunday January 20, 2019 @05:16PM (#18955975)
Yes! yes! 1000x yes!

Have spent the vast majority of my time on OSX for the past several years, but still reminisce about the wonderful keyboard shortcuts from Windows.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by city41 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @05:17PM (#18955977)
I'd argue MacOS classic was the real winner here, especially keyboard shortcuts. For example cmnd+q always quits an app, where as in Windows you had ctrl+q, alt+f4, ctrl+w, and sometimes you just had to do the menu navigation (alt f, then e I think? and sometimes it was alt f, x), and yet other times there was no keyboard shortcut at all.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by rtpg on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:07PM (#18956199)
It’s funny to mention ctrl+q , because it is one consistency in MacOS that I find unbearable to the point of having set it to spotlight instead

Right next to ctrl+q (something I end up hitting once per session of an app, by definition) is ctrl+a (select all, something I hit tens of times a session), ctrl+w (hit in the browser a good amount), ctrl+1, ctrl+2 (also good browser shortcuts)

I actually don’t need to close the entire program that often! Please don’t make it so easy to accidentally hit at such a high frequency. Bonus points: I switch between QWERTY and AZERTY keyboards a lot. That’s just me but it makes me have a lot of extra pain

Alt-F4 is very nice in that regard.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by thedaemon on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:49AM (#18961096)
Select all in MacOS should be CMD+A, not CTRL+A. Try swapping your muscle memory :)
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by int_19h on Sunday January 20, 2019 @10:46PM (#18957486)
Alt+F4 is a shortcut that closes the current top-level window.

Ctrl+F4 is a shortcut that closes the current child window/tab. For apps with tabs, this was often duplicated as Ctrl+W.

There's no standard shortcut for exit. I believe that this is deliberate, to avoid people hitting it accidentally. However, the accelerator keys to do it via the File menu are always Alt+F ("File") -> X ("eXit").

These are all platform UX guidelines, or at least they were back in the day. Of course, apps can and did ignore them, but that was also possible on macOS.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by saagarjha on Monday January 21, 2019 @03:09AM (#18958624)
> Of course, apps can and did ignore them, but that was also possible on macOS.

This is much less likely, given that they are set up by default for every new application.

Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by yhoiseth on Sunday January 20, 2019 @05:42PM (#18956091)
I find SizeUp to be a lifesaver. Good example of a finished app. It does what it’s supposed to and is incredibly stable and reliable.
Re:Windows 98 Icons are Great (2015) by paulcole on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:57PM (#18955535)
Both your comment and the article use the phrase “real work”. What do you meany by that? And is there “fake work” that Windows fails at?