News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by arkades on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @08:29AM (#18920614)
Just to be clear, "brine" isn't "salty water."

> This untreated salt water can’t just hang around in ponds—or, in worst-case scenarios, go into oceans or sewers. Disposal depends on geography, but typically the waste does go into oceans or sewers, if not injected into wells or kept in evaporation ponds. The high concentrations of salt, as well as chemicals like copper and chlorine, can make it toxic to marine life.

> “Brine underflows deplete dissolved oxygen in the receiving waters,” said lead author Edward Jones, who worked at the institute and is now at Wageningen University in the Netherlands, in a press release. “High salinity and reduced dissolved oxygen levels can have profound impacts on benthic organisms, which can translate into ecological effects observable throughout the food chain.”

It's an actual waste product that has to actually be responsibly handled. It's not "just the salty water from the ocean that we can dump back in however we want."

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by endorphone on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @09:50AM (#18921264)
Just to be clear, "brine" isn't "salty water."

It mostly is, and the additional chemicals they mention are already in the sea water, not that were added somehow in the process. It's just concentrated.

That it's concentrated is a problem, obviously -- very high-saline water (e.g. brine) and concentrated toxins are a problem, and would cause environmental problems if just dumped. The most common way to deal with brine is simply diluting it before discharge, ensuring that the salt content isn't high enough that it sinks and forms a brine pool.

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by mirimir on Thursday January 17, 2019 @07:16AM (#18930166)
True. Basically, the brine is just sea water with some of the water removed. Based on the numbers in TFA, 2.5L of sea water becomes 1.0L of fresh water and 1.5L of brine. And so the brine is just 67% more salty than the sea water was.

And it doesn't seem like diluting the brine with sea water before discharge would increase cost very much. From a 2010 presentation by Carlos Campos ("The Economics of Desalination for Various Uses") I get that seawater pumping and screening accounts for just 2-6% of the energy used in reverse osmosis.[0]

0) http://www.rac.es/ficheros/doc/00731.pdf at p 24

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by Jeff_Brown on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @12:36PM (#18922876)
Diluting it with ... fresh water?
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by endorphone on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @01:51PM (#18923717)
You churn it with a large volume of sea water and then discharge it when the salinity is only acceptably above the natural amount. I believe France limits it to 10% above the natural salinity.

e.g. take 3 gallons of sea water and extract 1 gallon of fresh water. You have 2 gallons of +50% salinity brine. Churn it with 8 gallons of seawater and you're back to +10% salinity. Wash it out into the ocean.

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by mcv on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:01AM (#18929605)
> the additional chemicals they mention are already in the sea water, not that were added somehow in the process.

Are you sure? The article made it sound like they were added. If they're natural to sea water, simply diluting it with more sea water or possibly sewage that's headed for the ocean anyway, sounds like the obvious solution.

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by dahfizz on Thursday January 17, 2019 @07:46AM (#18930332)
Yup, desalination doesn't require adding "chemicals" to the water. It works using heat, electricity, and osmosis membranes[1]. I'm not sure why the article took the tone that it did.

[1] http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2011/ph240/parise2/

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by alistairSH on Thursday January 17, 2019 @08:54AM (#18930747)
Don't they add copper and other chemicals to prevent fouling of the pipes? Not strictly required for desalination, but required to keep the desalination plant running with minimum manual cleaning.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by sunstone on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @11:25AM (#18922174)
Yes, just like exhaled breath is a waste product full of C02 and containing very little oxygen. If other people had to breath that they would become very sick or even die.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by dredmorbius on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:53AM (#18929575)
Exhaled air consists of 78 percent nitrogen, 16 percent oxygen, 4 percent carbon dioxide.

https://sciencing.com/chemical-composition-exhaled-air-human...

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by a-saleh on Thursday January 17, 2019 @06:55AM (#18930073)
The minimum oxygen concentration in the air required for human breathing is 19.5 percent. ... hen oxygen concentrations drop from 19.5 to 16 percent, and you engage in physical activity, your cells fail to receive the oxygen needed to function correctly. Mental functions become impaired and respiration intermittent at oxygen concentrations that drop from 10 to 14 percent; at these levels with any amount of physical activity, the body becomes exhausted. Humans won't survive with levels at 6 percent or lower. https://sciencing.com/minimum-oxygen-concentration-human-bre...
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by dredmorbius on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:51PM (#18974586)
You're not going to thrive or compete athletically on second-hand air.

But if you're not breathing on your own, it can save your life. That's what rescue breathing (what used to be called "artificial respiration") is.

There is more than enough oxygen in exhaled air to support life. At least until medical care arrives.

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by kiriakasis on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:24AM (#18929470)
Actual question, how many time can air be breathed? I think you can live on second-hand breath.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by masklinn on Thursday January 17, 2019 @06:27AM (#18929969)
I'd be quite dangerous and very uncomfortable: exhaled air contains ~4% CO₂, 16% O₂ and is at roughly 100% humidity.

* at 4% CO₂ you'll be suffering from moderate CO₂ toxicity (narcosis, dizzy spells, increased heart rate & blood pressure, mild shortness of breath, exaggerated response to effort)

* at only 16% O₂ (but assuming atmospheric pressure), you're well into chronic hypoxia land, not quite sure lethal but not far, the hyperventilation from CO₂ poisoning will make this slightly better but nowhere near good

* the combination of hypoxia and CO₂ poisoning will make effort (let alone exercise) possibly to probably lethal

* the extreme levels of humidity will make the entire thing even worse as you'll have a hard time cooling down

You can probably live in this situation for a few days, but the CO₂ levels alone would make it lethal past a few weeks, the combination of all factors means likely no more than a pair thereof, at best.

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by hamilyon2 on Thursday January 17, 2019 @08:52AM (#18930729)
Can you please provide sources? I am very interested
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by rusk on Thursday January 17, 2019 @06:18AM (#18929936)
Well that's how CPR works ... I can't remember the details ... it's many many years ago I studied first aid but I think it's something like 1/3 of the Oxegen gets used, so when you're giving the kiss of life you're imparting the remaining 2/3
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by rocqua on Thursday January 17, 2019 @07:46AM (#18930337)
I thought that CPR was largely about getting CO2 into the lungs to trigger a breath reflex.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by rusk on Thursday January 17, 2019 @08:11AM (#18930482)
It could well be. I’m just recalling something an instructor taught me about 25 years ago ...
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by eitland on Thursday January 17, 2019 @08:17AM (#18930524)
Can't answer the question, but I can say that when I did HUET we'd breathe into a bag in the suit and back again. This worked surprisingly well for the time we needed to stay underwater before we could escape. I'd still warn against implementing ones own version of this without studying the topic well, there's a number of pitfalls that one might not be obvious of up front.

I've briefly considered if there might be something to remove CO2 inside the bag, but decided against it since this was training equipment so not sealed and probably reused multiple times.

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by darkpuma on Thursday January 17, 2019 @08:59AM (#18930770)
Chemically scrubbing the CO2 from exhaled air so it can be breathed again is the principle rebreathers work on.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by short_sells_poo on Thursday January 17, 2019 @06:29AM (#18929978)
CO2 concentrations above 7% are enough to suffocate you even if there is otherwise ample oxygen.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by frobozz on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:29AM (#18929718)
Yet somehow, we don't typically do Sylvester Brosch or Holger Nielsen any more. Instead, we favour the direct transmission of exhaled air as a method of artificial respiration.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by tim333 on Thursday January 17, 2019 @07:08AM (#18930123)
The dictionary definition of brine is "water strongly impregnated with salt." ie salty water.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by pdpi on Thursday January 17, 2019 @08:13AM (#18930494)
When in technical contexts, the technical definition matters more than the dictionary definition. Clearly the plant isn’t discharging the stuff I season my chicken with!
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by manicdee on Thursday January 17, 2019 @01:05PM (#18932954)
No. You can’t take the dictionary definition, ignore the important word, then claim two things are equal.

Salty water is not water strongly impregnated with salt.

To simplify, the difference between salty water and brine is that brine is very salty water. The concentration of salt completely changes the environmental impact. Dumping post-desalination brine back into the ocean is an environmental disaster.

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by nickthemagicman on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @09:27AM (#18921083)
Is there any use for it at all?
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by jpfed on Thursday January 17, 2019 @01:41AM (#18928858)
It's possible to use salt water and limestone to capture CO2; I wonder whether brine could be used for this purpose.
Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by mcv on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:04AM (#18929618)
That would be really interesting. Two birds with one stone: clean water and capture CO2.

Though I assume you then still have a waste product you need to do something with, and how fast are we going to run out of limestone if we start doing this on a large scale?

Re:The Dirty Truth About Turning Seawater into Drinking Water by otikik on Thursday January 17, 2019 @07:41AM (#18930310)
I guess you could use it to extract salt - one could place evaporation pools next to the water extraction plant. It would evaporate faster than regular seawater.