Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by retroplasma on Sunday January 13, 2019 @11:39PM
(#18900694)
That project seems to use some other kind of API. It does not handle real octree/3d data AFAIK. I've only seen quadtree and terrain elevation stuff there.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by tylerl on Monday January 14, 2019 @04:09AM
(#18901712)
That's an interesting TOS.
I've never before seen "fair use" called out as an explicit allowance in terms of copyright restrictions by the part of the copyright holder. It's not entirely clear to me what that would even imply.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by userbinator on Monday January 14, 2019 @07:17AM
(#18902460)
I suspect they're trying to give more reassurance to "personal, non-commercial use is allowed as long as you don't hit our servers too hard" --- which seems to be their stance on a lot of their other services too.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by userbinator on Sunday January 13, 2019 @10:59PM
(#18900530)
I hope this gets mirrored somewhere else, because I don't trust GitHub to not cave in to legal demands despite RE being legal regardless of EULA in parts of the world, and the extra attention this gets may otherwise kill it.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by kodablah on Sunday January 13, 2019 @11:08PM
(#18900563)
From what I've seen, GitHub will only respond to a DMCA request for takedown, and Google very rarely files those (I think I saw one in the GitHub DMCA notice repo for an entire internal published source repo once, could be misremembering). Google doesn't usually fight with lawyers instead of tech (e.g. making scraping more difficult).
Not saying you shouldn't fork or fear, but GitHub and Google are generally good actors compared to others.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by ashleyn on Monday January 14, 2019 @08:26AM
(#18902745)
Definitely had the same observation that Google prefers subterfuge through obscurity/difficulty as opposed to legal methods. Their open source projects are notoriously impossible to build.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by tribby on Monday January 14, 2019 @01:33AM
(#18901104)
I can't speak for OP, but microsoft hasn't had the best relationship with open source in the past,[1] and they are a pretty litigious company.[2] however, their strategy seems to have changed significantly in recent years and I seriously doubt they will change how github operates. if anything, github has improved since it was acquired.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by cronix on Monday January 14, 2019 @07:30PM
(#18907927)
MS has traditionally been a software company, and has a LOT of court experience over the last 40 years regarding copyright and lawsuits when it comes to code and IP. I just think they might have a different viewpoint than GH has traditionally had, since GH's business is completely different than traditional MS businesses. The post I was responding to was talking about GH in the past and what they might do based on that. I'm just saying there's a recently new owner who might look at it differently, so past behavior might not be the best indicator for this since it's being run by a different corporation now.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by johannes1234321 on Monday January 14, 2019 @10:06AM
(#18903467)
Since they are a different sort of company, with another legal attack surface.
Going after GitHub means that GitHub has to shut down and the opponent sticks with their legal costs.
When attacking Microsoft they have enough cash to pay you out (in case they lose or they accept a payment to make you shut up) and the case might disrupt Microsoft enough to give you an advantage in a different field.
Not saying that Google would sue Microsoft. Would be very bad for their image. But a risk evaluation is different.
TL;DR: They shut down an open source GEarth clone called Gaia a decade ago, although they managed to not to lose a lot of karma over that due to graceful handling.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by automatoney on Sunday January 13, 2019 @10:52PM
(#18900500)
I'm so glad that this has been made, I tried working on something like this a while ago but gave up after struggling for a bit. At the time I was surprised it didn't exist yet.
I'm wondering though if Google'll eventually patch things so this doesn't work, or if they're not too bothered by people grabbing data like this.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by paganel on Monday January 14, 2019 @01:03AM
(#18901002)
In the “old”, initial days (circa 2005-2006) they weren’t bothered by this, I remember they released the GMaps public API back then as a result (among other factors) of some people reverse engineering the public-facing interface. If I’m not mistaken one of the first projects that was using the reverse-engineered version (before the API was made public) was the former Chicago Crime website, one of the first Django installations.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by mtmail on Monday January 14, 2019 @07:42AM
(#18902539)
The book 'Never Lost Again' (2018) tells the keyhole/Google Maps story line. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/35820393-never-lost-agai... Actually I left with the impression nobody involved had a good plan what Google Maps should be after launch. API was an afterthought.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by retroplasma on Sunday January 13, 2019 @11:13PM
(#18900581)
Can be done, although high LOD takes a while and the current implementation might eat up all memory. You can run it in parallel though. Shard by octants :)
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by retroplasma on Sunday January 13, 2019 @11:48PM
(#18900741)
Mainly lived inside Chrome's dev tools for many nights. Its deobfuscator and debugger is very handy. Still scratched my head lots of times along the way.
Some interesting stuff is still missing, e.g. no idea yet how they get octant paths from geo coordinates.
Re:Google Earth Reverse Engineering
by lima on Monday January 14, 2019 @08:33AM
(#18902788)
The obfuscation isn't necessarily a deliberate attempt at hindering reverse engineering, but a result of their optimizing JS compiler and Protobuf-to-JSON-bridge.
https://github.com/google/earthenterprise
(Update: The client was not open sourced, just the server.)
However, this doesn't give you carte blanche to use Google's own imagery:
https://maps.google.com/help/terms_maps.html
I've never before seen "fair use" called out as an explicit allowance in terms of copyright restrictions by the part of the copyright holder. It's not entirely clear to me what that would even imply.
Not saying you shouldn't fork or fear, but GitHub and Google are generally good actors compared to others.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halloween_documents
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_litigation
Going after GitHub means that GitHub has to shut down and the opponent sticks with their legal costs.
When attacking Microsoft they have enough cash to pay you out (in case they lose or they accept a payment to make you shut up) and the case might disrupt Microsoft enough to give you an advantage in a different field.
Not saying that Google would sue Microsoft. Would be very bad for their image. But a risk evaluation is different.
And if they do that, nobody will have a copy of this source code?
Wouldn't be the first time, either: https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-shuts-down-gaia-efforts...
TL;DR: They shut down an open source GEarth clone called Gaia a decade ago, although they managed to not to lose a lot of karma over that due to graceful handling.
I do that for anything that looks predictably hot
docs - https://worldwind.arc.nasa.gov/web/
https://all3dp.com/1/obj-file-format-3d-printing-cad/
If you want a 3D model of your office building or something.
I'm wondering though if Google'll eventually patch things so this doesn't work, or if they're not too bothered by people grabbing data like this.
"DeprecationWarning: Buffer() is deprecated due to security and usability issues"
Opened an issue: https://github.com/retroplasma/earth-reverse-engineering/iss...