News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by vorpalhex on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:31AM (#18845346)
As always, this begs the question between hate speech and disfavored political speech. I think Britain First is doing their best to actively revert the UK back 50 years, but I struggle to see why it is they're simply hate speech and not a valid political movement.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by baddox on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:38AM (#18845406)
> Ads for a Britain First petition to stop a mosque being built in Maidstone, Kent, appeared on Facebook over the Christmas period, despite the group being banned by the social network.

> The three ads and the page on which they originated have now been removed, after BBC News contacted Facebook.

I think it’s safe to say that the “to stop a mosque being built” is the important phrase here.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by alkibiades on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:40AM (#18845420)
why is that hate speech? i don’t want more churches built, is that hate speech?
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:47AM (#18845504)
It depends, why don't you want more churches built?

Because it's a Muslim church and you don't like them?

Because you're an anti-theist?

Because you don't like the noise?

Because you think their application for a zoning exception is shaky?

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by asdkhadsj on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:56AM (#18845578)
Curiously, is it better to be anti-theist than anti-Muslim? I have a feeling like I can be against religion, but not one religion.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drb311 on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:07AM (#18845683)
Britain First is not for or against any religion. It's for traditional white British culture against anything new or brown. They're full of hate.

They should be allowed to speak but they ain't borrowing my megaphone. Good on Facebook for feeling the same (at last).

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:07AM (#18845682)
You can be against the the faith tied to your ethnicity. So if you're ethnically Christian you can rail against the Catholic church specifically all day long. Not trying to say whether this is right or wrong, just that you can hate a particular religion with impunity as long as you're part of the in-group.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by alkibiades on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:32AM (#18846604)
that’s really racist. what race is associated with Islam? Only someone whose never traveled and been to malaysia or pakistan or iran or turkey could lump them all as one ethnic group.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @01:40PM (#18848450)
Would you prefer the term culturally Muslim/Jewish/Christian? It's not that they're the same, it's that they share a lot of similar moral values, traditions, cultural elements, and have a shared ancestry. It is closely related to, but not defined by, their faith.

I mean the French, British, Russians, Spanish, Germans, Americans, Italians, etc. are all extremely different but they nonetheless get lumped into 'White (which is damn-near the same thing as ethnically Christian).

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by type0 on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:08PM (#18850088)
There's no such thing as culturally muslim or christian, you could argue about jewish faith sometimes since it's ethnocentric, but just because these are abrahamitic religions doesn't mean you could lump those together.

> nonetheless get lumped into 'White (which is damn-near the same thing as ethnically Christian).

you said it yourself, it's lumping everything together. This never leads to anything good, just look at Jugoslavian war, same people or at least closely related ethnically and nevertheless so atrocious; that's what religion, hate and envy for patches of lands could lead to.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by andybak on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:34AM (#18845911)
So how does this rule work if there's multiple faiths tied to your ethnicity?
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:05AM (#18846281)
You can be against all of them I would think. I'm not trying to make a comment on whether any of this is 'right' just that there is an example where you can dislike a particular religion with impunity because you're part of the in-group.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by rdtsc on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:42AM (#18846727)
> So if you're ethnically Christian

How does that work? Russians are ethnically Christian I presume, but they are Orthodox Christians so do they get a license to rail against the Catholic church or would that be "hate speech". What about railing against Mormons? Or does that only extend to the religious sect that is traditionally associated with that ethnic group in that particular area?

I see the idea I think, but it seem it needs to be defined a bit more precisely to be useful.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by fxfan on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:09AM (#18845703)
I don't agree with Christianity's stand on gays. Hence no more churches.

I don't agree with islam's stance on gays and women and adultery. Hence no more mosques.

Am I a hater?

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by toomuchtodo on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:12AM (#18845724)
> Am I a hater?

No, you are intolerant of hate and prioritize human rights about superstition, custom, and tribalism.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by toomuchtodo on Monday January 07, 2019 @08:19PM (#18852081)
s/about/above
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by saint_fiasco on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:35AM (#18846638)
Yes.

Preventing the construction of mosques and churches does not actually help women and gay people. All it does is hurt their enemies, and that is not the same thing.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by xolorg on Monday January 07, 2019 @12:22PM (#18847316)
You are a hater for saying he is a hater.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by growlist on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:22AM (#18845819)
..and this is the problem with hate speech - it involves perceived intent and thus the criminalisation of thought.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by dragonwriter on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:52PM (#18850550)
Intent is also an element of murder, so I guess that's criminalization of thought, too.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Buldak on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:59AM (#18846975)
This could be said of many more crimes than hate speech.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by ABCLAW on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:49PM (#18850521)
Wait until you find out that mens rea exists.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by growlist on Friday January 11, 2019 @06:52AM (#18882822)
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by irb on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:44AM (#18845457)
is your campaign against more churches being built part of an overall plan to drive christians out of your area?
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by lclarkmichalek on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:13AM (#18846376)
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/mar/14/facebook-bans-...

They got banned a while back, not relating to this specific advert.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by geofft on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:43AM (#18845449)
Yes.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:50AM (#18845533)
I don’t want more churches built, is that hate speech?

Yes. What business is it of yours what people do behind closed doors?

(EDIT: assuming that behavior is otherwise law-abiding, in compliance with building codes, etc).

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Cthulhu_ on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:52AM (#18845549)
Depends. If they diddle kids behind closed doors it's very much the law's business (for example). I'm not saying that's happening here, I'm making an example. Churches are not exempt from the law, neither is any kind of private property for that matter.

Besides, there are valid reasons to be against the building of a church near your house - noise for example (church bells, prayer songs).

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by rootusrootus on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:55AM (#18845573)
Churches get de facto public financing to support their proselytizing. It's okay to have an opinion on whether we should subsidize more of them.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by YorkshireSeason on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:00AM (#18845625)
What people do behind closed doors tends to affect what they do openly.

Religion has historically always been used as a tool to assert political power. Mosques often get financed by undemocratic regimes, in particular Mohammad bin Salman's Saudi-Arabia, which most definitely funds Mosques in a political influence operation.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by asdkhadsj on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:00AM (#18845620)
Objectively, lots of our business. Mainly because what is done behind closed doors rarely stays behind closed doors, and also because of said crimes that can occur behind closed doors.

Ie, I can't sit behind closed doors and commit horrible crimes against humans and then claim "What business is it of yours?".

That of course is not to say that we don't have some right to privacy, to independence and etc. Yet, standing behind a claim of "what happens behind closed doors is none of your business" seems to willfully ignore so much.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by nemo44x on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:52AM (#18845543)
The irony is their countries flag depicts a Christian cross and they have a national religion. I can see why people are confused.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by ben_w on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:09AM (#18845705)
That’s the first I’ve heard that the Union Jack or any part of it is a Christian cross. Proportions all seem wrong for that.

I agree with the point about state religion though.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by davweb on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:15AM (#18845754)
The Union Jack comprises the cross of St George, the cross of St Andrew and the cross of the St Patrick. It's nothing but Christian crosses.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by nemo44x on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:13AM (#18845747)
It’s St. George’s Cross and a symbol of the Crusades. The Union Jack is a combination of flags. England is its own country among the UK, remember.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by detaro on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:47AM (#18845495)
> I think it’s safe to say

Why do you think it's that and not the fact they were banned before?

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by xolorg on Monday January 07, 2019 @12:21PM (#18847297)
How is that hate speech...
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:37AM (#18845395)
The disagreement isn't really between those two things. It's whether such speech is actually political or a proxy for hate speech.

"We don't hire ethnic Muslims" vs. "We don't think you're a good culture-fit for this company."

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by xfitm3 on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:35AM (#18845382)
I agree with you here. Details of this particular issue aside - the chilling effects are likely to have a significant impact in the future. I don’t generally agree with censorship, but in cases where it’s needed I think it must be objective and not subjective. Eg. “i’ll know it when i see it”.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:44AM (#18845467)
This is always going to be subjective because it has everything to do with the speaker's intent, not the actual words. Determining hate speech is almost always about fishing out intent that the speaker is very protective of.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by mc32 on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:37AM (#18845398)
Does this mean countries with nascent independence movements will be able to declare these movements "hate speech"? I don't see much difference. Let's say Chiapas rebels or Puerto Rico or Scotts’ Independence movement want to seek independence, can the government declare that hate speech and have all that taken down? If this argument sticks, I can’t see why the above isn’t in similar vein.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by pjc50 on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:51AM (#18845540)
The distinguishing factor is the promotion of hatred and implied violence.

I remember when the UK banned Sinn Fein from appearing on TV, including their actual elected MPs, resulting in the ridiculous "words read by an actor" workaround.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by guitarbill on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:16AM (#18845759)
While I've had the pleasure of not interacting much with Britain First, and it's possible they do engage in "promotion of hatred" or "implied violence", really that could be anything these days. Like CNN's overreaction to a GIF/meme, or the internet reacting badly to an awful interview.

And talking about actual elected MPs being replaces by actors, this is a fairly common tactic since you can't use footage from the House of Commons for comedy or satire. So it's worth remembering censorship doesn't need a reason once rules or laws are put in place.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by pjc50 on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:30AM (#18845879)
I'm very specifically referring to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988%E2%80%9394_British_broadc... in re Gerry Adams.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by growlist on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:11AM (#18845720)
> the ridiculous "words read by an actor" workaround

parodied beautifully by Steve Coogan in The Day Today: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UOUeauLWEaE

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by mc32 on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:13AM (#18845741)
Ok, looks like it’s a fascist group which engages in violence. It’s still tricky though because there are independence groups which while they have legitimate goals also engage in violence.

Or even AntiFa who bill themselves as anti fascists engage in violence, on occasion. Not sure they buy ads though.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by pjc50 on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:20AM (#18845804)
SF/IRA were a lot of things, and undoubtedly violent, but they were never really fascist. Their only consistent position was Irish nationalism (continuation of the Irish war of independence) and Catholicism. At times they claimed to be Marxist, at other times they got Republican senators to raise money for them.

(or are we talking about Britain First? They are sort of associated with the murder of Jo Cox: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/jo-cox-murde... - while they denied responsibility there's a stochastic terrorism thing going on there, and related group National action is on the ban list: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... )

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by repolfx on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:06PM (#18849423)
I think a more interesting question is what would Facebook do about the European countries where various aspects of Islam are already illegal.

France has banned the veil.

Switzerland banned the construction of minarets (not mosques) via popular referendum in 2009.

Austria bans mosques from receiving foreign funding.

It would appear that Facebook considers the majority of the populations of many important European countries to be engaged in hate speech, and presumably their governments too?

So I'm not sure we need to look to nascent independence movements to encounter difficulties with the consistency of Facebook's position although, it is an interesting thought experiment.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by dao- on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:41AM (#18845439)
Britain First is not an independence movement.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by jenscow on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:38AM (#18845408)
> revert the UK back 50 years

In what way?

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by aaaaaaaaaab on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:53AM (#18845553)
The number of mosques?
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by gwbas1c on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:38AM (#18845399)
Because, with politics, it's impossible to be objective.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:48AM (#18845514)
I struggle to see why it is they're simply hate speech and not a valid political movement.

A quick look at their "No More Mosques!" campaign should suffice to provide the insight you seek.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by ramblerman on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:52AM (#18845547)
Explain to me why that is not something people can vote on?

What if I don't want Saudi funded mosques in particular, is there any nuance allowed. There is no racism or exclusion based on a person's ethnicity here.

Should we lock up Richard Dawkins for being anti catholic?

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:24AM (#18845830)
Explain to me why that is not something people can vote on?

Because there's this thing known as "freedom of religion" which is recognized both in UK and European law (to which the UK is still bound) as fundamental and inviolable.

Meaning: no you can not "vote" on the question of whether a certain group is allowed to practice their religion (yes, in your neighborhood) -- and advertise this fact. The size of the building, or the width of the signage can be regulated perhaps... but the very fact of that house of worship being built -- sorry, no.

What if I don't want Saudi funded mosques in particular, is there any nuance allowed?

The "No More Mosques!" campaign clearly is not limited to foreign-funded mosques (or those funded by nasty regimes); it is explicitly aimed against building mosques in general. That's why there's basically no way to look at it as fundamentally anti-Muslim.

Should we lock up Richard Dawkins for being anti-Catholic?

No, and no one is saying anyone should be "locked up" for carrying those banners, or running those ads.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:00AM (#18845621)
Of course there's nuance allowed. We're talking about human speech, it's basically all nuance.

If you say that Saudi funding churches, businesses, housing, etc. is not good for Britain for a reason other than you have something against Saudis as a people then you're fine.

If you say you're against all churches because you're an anti-theist then you're fine.

There is absolutely exclusion based on ethnicity. It's extremely important to recognize that there is a difference between someone who is religiously Muslim and ethnically Muslim -- same with Judaism -- and same with Christianity too as well but we don't call it that because we're the default in the West. Saying there is no such thing ignores the dominating cultural impact of religious institutions.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by bluecalm on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:21AM (#18845809)
What's wrong about being against one religion in particular. I think it's very reasonable to be against Islam because of its stance on gay rights, women rights, penalty for apostasy and their holy book which if interpretet literally (which is how vast majority of Muslims believe it should be interpreted) is full of hate and calls for violence.

Not wanting any more of that or institutions promoting that is reasonable political view.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:32AM (#18845896)
What's wrong about being against one religion in particular.

You can be "against" a particular religion all you want.

But you have absolutely no right to prohibit anyone from practicing that religion simply because you don't like it. Including the "practice" of getting together with friends in a room or a building, and posting a sign outside the door saying this is what you do.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by bluecalm on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:41AM (#18846003)
Churches have special status given by the government. This means I should absolutely have a say how many, what kind and where they are built. It's not about home meetings to read the Bible after dinner. It's about special status institutions which influencen the areas they are built in.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @12:32PM (#18847477)
Churches have special status given by the government.

Then maybe the problem is the messed up laws providing that "special status" then. But that doesn't mean you can (even under those laws) category ban a certain group from building any churches, anywhere.

Which is exactly what Britain First is advocating.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:52AM (#18846856)
Plenty of countries regulate public religious practice. Take France, for instance, which even regulates public display of religious symbols . Does it follow that it is hate speech to say, "the government should handle religion more like France."?
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @12:30PM (#18847436)
Does it follow that it is hate speech to say, "the government should handle religion more like France."?

You'll note that France does not, by any stretch, attempt to ban mosques outright.

So obviously there's not much of a comparison here.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @01:08PM (#18847994)
Note that while France is a secular country, secularism is not the same thing as freedom of religion. Plenty of secular countries seek freedom from religion. This can entail restrictions that prevent people from practicing religious customs, like the burka ban. The degree of magnitude between something like that and halting the construction of mosques is debatable. A good argument can be made that the former is more restrictive than the latter: the former actually prevents people from practicing religious customs, the latter only prevents formal religious establishments. In other words, banning mosques means people can be practicing Muslims that pray in their home, while the latter prevents people from being practicing Muslims at all (if adhering to dress codes is considered part of practicing the religion).

The point I'm ultimately making is that the statement:

> But you have absolutely no right to prohibit anyone from practicing that religion simply because you don't like it.

Is demonstrably incorrect. Relatively liberal and progressive countries at times do prohibit people from practicing their religion, and France's restrictions serve as an example.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @02:05PM (#18848750)
Relatively liberal and progressive countries at times do prohibit people from practicing their religion, and France's restrictions serve as an example.

It's a question of "restrict expression to some extent" v. "prohibit outright". When I said "no right to prohibit" -- it's the latter form that I meant.

France does restrict some aspects of religious expression (such as wearing the burka in public). But this is very far from an outright prohibition of that religion (which we both seem to agree a ban on mosques would basically amount to).

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @02:12PM (#18848835)
> It's a question of "restrict expression to some extent" v. "prohibit outright". When I said "no right to prohibit" -- it's the latter form that I meant.

Then banning mosques is not in the scope of your statement. Muslims can practice their religion without the presence of a mosque. Many do pray in the privacy of their homes or somewhere other than a mosque. Like France's face covering restrictions, it is only a restriction of a specific aspect of the religion. Such a ban does not, in your own words, "prohibit outright" the ability to practice Islam.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:03PM (#18849391)
Then banning mosques is not in the scope of your statement.

Hmm - I disagree, and I suspect most courts in the kinds of countries we're talking about would also.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:17PM (#18849540)
Do Muslims that don't live within commuting distance of a mosque cease to be Muslims? Of course not, they pray in their homes. The existence of Muslims that practice religions without mosques makes the claim that a ban on mosques prohibits the practice of Islam outright an objectively false statement. You're the one that put the threshold at "prohibit outright".

US courts would likely agree that it is unjustly curbing religion - they'd find the bans on head coverings unlawful as well.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:37PM (#18852605)
Do gay couples that aren't allowed to be married cease to be gay? Of course not, they keep their sexuality in the privacy of their own homes. The existence of gays that live without recognition and rights by the state makes the claim that a ban on gay marriage prohibites homosexuality an objectively false statement...

Like yes you're technically right but only by seemingly purposely missing the point -- that having a community center to gather and worship is central to most religions. The times when chruchmembers gather in housechurches are typically times when they're being opressed.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @12:35AM (#18853472)
I'm not missing any point, I'm well aware of the fact that centers of worship are important to many, or even most, religions. You've jumped into this comment chain pretty late, and the original point I'm making is probably difficult to glean from these later comments. My whole point is that the above poster's claim that

> you have absolutely no right to prohibit anyone from practicing that religion simply because you don't like it.

is just straight up not true. Several countries, including liberal democracies such as France with its laws that prohibit face coverings even when worn for religious purposes, do indeed prohibit religious practices. Attire and appearance is important to many religions, and liberal democracies do indeed prohibit those. drugme's claim that people (I assume people in liberal democracies is what's being referenced here) do not have the right to prohibit anyone from practicing religion is not correct. There are plenty of instances were people's religious practice is restricted by law.

Then the commenter tried to pull a pretty blatant moat and bailey by trying to claim that their comments only referred to those that want to "prohibit [a religion] outright" as opposed to only prohibiting certain aspects. In response to which, I pointed out that a ban on religious centers is does not "prohibit outright" a religion either.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by type0 on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:24PM (#18850275)
> It's extremely important to recognize that there is a difference between someone who is religiously Muslim and ethnically Muslim

You mean arab right? Not all arabs are muslims so please stop this bs spreading. Yes christian arabs and jews from middle east have a lot in common (culturally) with their neighbors who are predominantly muslim. Saying that one could be ethnically muslim means you are expressing support for religious (as well as ehtnic) cleansing that has been going on in the middle east for decades. I did say ethnic because there has been some other ethnicities (non-arabs) that suffered tremendously as well.