News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:48AM (#18845514)
I struggle to see why it is they're simply hate speech and not a valid political movement.

A quick look at their "No More Mosques!" campaign should suffice to provide the insight you seek.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by ramblerman on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:52AM (#18845547)
Explain to me why that is not something people can vote on?

What if I don't want Saudi funded mosques in particular, is there any nuance allowed. There is no racism or exclusion based on a person's ethnicity here.

Should we lock up Richard Dawkins for being anti catholic?

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:24AM (#18845830)
Explain to me why that is not something people can vote on?

Because there's this thing known as "freedom of religion" which is recognized both in UK and European law (to which the UK is still bound) as fundamental and inviolable.

Meaning: no you can not "vote" on the question of whether a certain group is allowed to practice their religion (yes, in your neighborhood) -- and advertise this fact. The size of the building, or the width of the signage can be regulated perhaps... but the very fact of that house of worship being built -- sorry, no.

What if I don't want Saudi funded mosques in particular, is there any nuance allowed?

The "No More Mosques!" campaign clearly is not limited to foreign-funded mosques (or those funded by nasty regimes); it is explicitly aimed against building mosques in general. That's why there's basically no way to look at it as fundamentally anti-Muslim.

Should we lock up Richard Dawkins for being anti-Catholic?

No, and no one is saying anyone should be "locked up" for carrying those banners, or running those ads.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:00AM (#18845621)
Of course there's nuance allowed. We're talking about human speech, it's basically all nuance.

If you say that Saudi funding churches, businesses, housing, etc. is not good for Britain for a reason other than you have something against Saudis as a people then you're fine.

If you say you're against all churches because you're an anti-theist then you're fine.

There is absolutely exclusion based on ethnicity. It's extremely important to recognize that there is a difference between someone who is religiously Muslim and ethnically Muslim -- same with Judaism -- and same with Christianity too as well but we don't call it that because we're the default in the West. Saying there is no such thing ignores the dominating cultural impact of religious institutions.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by bluecalm on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:21AM (#18845809)
What's wrong about being against one religion in particular. I think it's very reasonable to be against Islam because of its stance on gay rights, women rights, penalty for apostasy and their holy book which if interpretet literally (which is how vast majority of Muslims believe it should be interpreted) is full of hate and calls for violence.

Not wanting any more of that or institutions promoting that is reasonable political view.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:32AM (#18845896)
What's wrong about being against one religion in particular.

You can be "against" a particular religion all you want.

But you have absolutely no right to prohibit anyone from practicing that religion simply because you don't like it. Including the "practice" of getting together with friends in a room or a building, and posting a sign outside the door saying this is what you do.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by bluecalm on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:41AM (#18846003)
Churches have special status given by the government. This means I should absolutely have a say how many, what kind and where they are built. It's not about home meetings to read the Bible after dinner. It's about special status institutions which influencen the areas they are built in.
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @12:32PM (#18847477)
Churches have special status given by the government.

Then maybe the problem is the messed up laws providing that "special status" then. But that doesn't mean you can (even under those laws) category ban a certain group from building any churches, anywhere.

Which is exactly what Britain First is advocating.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:52AM (#18846856)
Plenty of countries regulate public religious practice. Take France, for instance, which even regulates public display of religious symbols . Does it follow that it is hate speech to say, "the government should handle religion more like France."?
Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @12:30PM (#18847436)
Does it follow that it is hate speech to say, "the government should handle religion more like France."?

You'll note that France does not, by any stretch, attempt to ban mosques outright.

So obviously there's not much of a comparison here.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @01:08PM (#18847994)
Note that while France is a secular country, secularism is not the same thing as freedom of religion. Plenty of secular countries seek freedom from religion. This can entail restrictions that prevent people from practicing religious customs, like the burka ban. The degree of magnitude between something like that and halting the construction of mosques is debatable. A good argument can be made that the former is more restrictive than the latter: the former actually prevents people from practicing religious customs, the latter only prevents formal religious establishments. In other words, banning mosques means people can be practicing Muslims that pray in their home, while the latter prevents people from being practicing Muslims at all (if adhering to dress codes is considered part of practicing the religion).

The point I'm ultimately making is that the statement:

> But you have absolutely no right to prohibit anyone from practicing that religion simply because you don't like it.

Is demonstrably incorrect. Relatively liberal and progressive countries at times do prohibit people from practicing their religion, and France's restrictions serve as an example.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @02:05PM (#18848750)
Relatively liberal and progressive countries at times do prohibit people from practicing their religion, and France's restrictions serve as an example.

It's a question of "restrict expression to some extent" v. "prohibit outright". When I said "no right to prohibit" -- it's the latter form that I meant.

France does restrict some aspects of religious expression (such as wearing the burka in public). But this is very far from an outright prohibition of that religion (which we both seem to agree a ban on mosques would basically amount to).

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @02:12PM (#18848835)
> It's a question of "restrict expression to some extent" v. "prohibit outright". When I said "no right to prohibit" -- it's the latter form that I meant.

Then banning mosques is not in the scope of your statement. Muslims can practice their religion without the presence of a mosque. Many do pray in the privacy of their homes or somewhere other than a mosque. Like France's face covering restrictions, it is only a restriction of a specific aspect of the religion. Such a ban does not, in your own words, "prohibit outright" the ability to practice Islam.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by drugme on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:03PM (#18849391)
Then banning mosques is not in the scope of your statement.

Hmm - I disagree, and I suspect most courts in the kinds of countries we're talking about would also.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:17PM (#18849540)
Do Muslims that don't live within commuting distance of a mosque cease to be Muslims? Of course not, they pray in their homes. The existence of Muslims that practice religions without mosques makes the claim that a ban on mosques prohibits the practice of Islam outright an objectively false statement. You're the one that put the threshold at "prohibit outright".

US courts would likely agree that it is unjustly curbing religion - they'd find the bans on head coverings unlawful as well.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by Spivak on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:37PM (#18852605)
Do gay couples that aren't allowed to be married cease to be gay? Of course not, they keep their sexuality in the privacy of their own homes. The existence of gays that live without recognition and rights by the state makes the claim that a ban on gay marriage prohibites homosexuality an objectively false statement...

Like yes you're technically right but only by seemingly purposely missing the point -- that having a community center to gather and worship is central to most religions. The times when chruchmembers gather in housechurches are typically times when they're being opressed.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by manfredo on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @12:35AM (#18853472)
I'm not missing any point, I'm well aware of the fact that centers of worship are important to many, or even most, religions. You've jumped into this comment chain pretty late, and the original point I'm making is probably difficult to glean from these later comments. My whole point is that the above poster's claim that

> you have absolutely no right to prohibit anyone from practicing that religion simply because you don't like it.

is just straight up not true. Several countries, including liberal democracies such as France with its laws that prohibit face coverings even when worn for religious purposes, do indeed prohibit religious practices. Attire and appearance is important to many religions, and liberal democracies do indeed prohibit those. drugme's claim that people (I assume people in liberal democracies is what's being referenced here) do not have the right to prohibit anyone from practicing religion is not correct. There are plenty of instances were people's religious practice is restricted by law.

Then the commenter tried to pull a pretty blatant moat and bailey by trying to claim that their comments only referred to those that want to "prohibit [a religion] outright" as opposed to only prohibiting certain aspects. In response to which, I pointed out that a ban on religious centers is does not "prohibit outright" a religion either.

Re:Facebook takes down Britain First ads by type0 on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:24PM (#18850275)
> It's extremely important to recognize that there is a difference between someone who is religiously Muslim and ethnically Muslim

You mean arab right? Not all arabs are muslims so please stop this bs spreading. Yes christian arabs and jews from middle east have a lot in common (culturally) with their neighbors who are predominantly muslim. Saying that one could be ethnically muslim means you are expressing support for religious (as well as ehtnic) cleansing that has been going on in the middle east for decades. I did say ethnic because there has been some other ethnicities (non-arabs) that suffered tremendously as well.