"Sure, the government can send men with guns. But that's because they have the backing of the people. The police and the military. If they lose that, they can't."
A gun would have to be put to every individual miner's head to force the majority to upgrade. Even then, if it caused a fork, individual users have the freedom to continue using the old version, new miners can choose the old version. Miners can even switch back to the old version after the gun is gone. Everything will still work.
Equally police/military have probably been used when there would not be democratic support.
Did you have some examples in mind?
The analogy applies to this, too. Governments have long shown that you don't have to put a gun to each individual's head - murder a small amount of dissidents in a nasty manner and it quite effectively squashes dissent in a lot of cases.
A lot of miners are in China, which has lots of practice doing this.
If your currency forks, and you are now in the minority, chances are your values will fall, and become harder to make liquid, as the market shrinks.
With cryptocurrencies, anyone at any time can fork for any reason.
This can't be done with the government. The government will prevent you from doing so.
A cryptocurrency can't prevent another cryptocurrency from existing, though.
I understand that it is not describing a good situation but my understanding was that the miners are a part of the decentralizing infrastructure in the way that was described in the quote.
Also, if you wouldn't mind, could you suggest some other reading for me on creating decentralized applications not using blockchain. I've wondered myself if it makes much sense that everything would be built on blockchains in the future.
Another issue that I see with these projects that claim to be decentralized, for example ipfs.io is that they do not consider worst case scenarios so they cannot have a service level agreements on their service. Most of the customer networks are asymmetric, you have much more bandwidth to download content than to upload so if you are providing services than you are going to saturate your uplink. Nodes can also be turned off, worst case scenario is that all of the nodes are off that has a piece of data that you can't recover from anywhere else.
As of everything going to be built on the blockchain in the future, most definitely not. I think 2019 going to wipe out most of the cryptocurrencies and we are going to see very few successful blockchain (or more like distributed ledger) projects succeeding in the corporate space. Maybe there will be some use cases for blockchain/DLT like food traceability (one project i have contributed to) and customer warranty for example but all this hype that everything will be running on blockchain will just fade.
> If someone puts a gun to my head & tells me to write a hardfork patch, I will definitely write it. If I publish a patch to delete a bunch of accounts, how many people here would download & install the update & switch to that chain? I see few raised hands. This is called decentralization.
Sure, the Ethereum Foundation has substantial influence in the sense that their proposed changes tend to be adopted, but that's because they tend to propose good changes. If they propose a bad change, chances are the community will reject it. If they propose a questionable/controversial change, chances are the community will fork, as with the DAO fork.