I think both you and the author would agree that in the absence of a reliable, versatile mass transit network, many people with access to cars will use cars instead. But you and the author appear to disagree on the viability and transformative power of self-driving cars and whether they serve as a meaningful instrument of mobility for all with the kind and amount of transport infrastructure available to us now.
I believe that the form factor of a 2-to-7 person car common today isn't sufficiently dense to provide appropriate amounts of throughput to high traffic routes to completely replace something like a subway, commuter rail, or the like. Although the experience of the (figurative) first and last mile would be superior, the sheer number of such vehicles would clog the arterial roads and freeways where the point-to-point routing converges, the same way this happens with cars today.
With computer control, you eliminate the gap needed between cars - just hook it directly to the car in front, let them draft for better aerodynamics, and detach when you need to make a turn, saving 70-100 feet of road space. With electric motors, you eliminate the hood, engine, and transmission, saving another 5 feet or so - independent electric motors can go directly onto the wheels. In an urban environment, electrify the streets (as with trolleys) and eliminate the battery pack - that's another 4 feet and 1200 pounds or so. Once everything moves to car services and people don't own their own cars, you can eliminate the trunk, saving another 4-5 feet - in the majority of trips you aren't carrying anything big, and you can hail a different model pod for those road trips or grocery runs where you need the cargo space (or just summon the groceries and forget about driving it yourself). For trips without the kids, eliminate the other seats as well - you can just summon a different vehicle when you need to take a family trip.
Pretty soon the vehicle is just a thin shell around its occupant, taking up no more room than the personal space they would've taken up on a bus.
“How many people’s doors can a driver get to in an hour, including the minute or two that the customer spends grabbing their things and boarding? The intuitively obvious answer is the right one: not very many. An Eno Foundation report promoting microtransit could not cite a case study doing better than four boardings an hour of service. John Urgo, the planner of demand-responsive service for AC Transit in Oakland, California, has said that seven boardings an hour is “the best we hope to achieve.” Few fixed-route buses perform that poorly. Across sprawling Silicon Valley, for example, fixed-route buses carried 12 to 45 people an hour in 2015. In a dense city such as Philadelphia, the number can exceed 80”
Door-to-door transit simply cannot achieve the throughput of buses! Which is not to say door-to-door would not be profitable or even have a role in a mass system. It's probably an improvement over the current dominant mode (although my suspicion is that it's simply a slightly less bad local minimum).
But the point of the original article is to argue that certain groups of people (decision makers in cities, mostly), should not extrapolate from their own needs and preferences when designing a system designed for mass use, because they're by definition unusual and they're each N=1
The boarding issue in the article is mostly in reference to the driver's time, but there's a simple solution for the rider: docking, not board. Board a pod once, at your door, and travel inside it until you reach your destination. If you need to switch modalities - like latching a number of pods together into a train for long road trips, or putting them on an aircraft - you load the pods onto the plane, you don't transfer the people between pods. It's like intermodal containers for passengers, with the nice benefit that you can continue working on your laptop or watching a movie or sleeping throughout modality switches.
You will still need a way to turn off at speed, leaving you with interchanges at each potential detachment point taking up a lot of space.
Grand Central Terminal in NYC has 44 platforms in 48 acres. Tens of Thousands of people per hour can switch between subway, regional rail, and bus lines, as well as access the surrounding city on foot, and access the on-site amenities and offices above. 700,000 people pass through daily. 10,000 people visit each day just to have lunch there. It works because the most space-efficient way to route people is to have them get out and walk. A tiny person-carrying vehicle will always need more space and supporting infrastructure than a person walking.
Clearly we don't ride the same bus. A lot of the urban elites on my bus route are heading downtown to service jobs in hotels, restaurants, and perhaps day-care centers.
FWIW, my home city's bus service (Charlotte NC) is exactly like the commenter above describes. There is a city-wide bus service that runs about every hour or half-hour if you're lucky, but it's terrible (unreliable, slow, poorly maintained) and mostly used by people too poor to own a car or those who can't drive due to disability or DUI.
Then there's the nice "commuter" bus for a buck more, which only runs during peak commute times, only picks up from park-and-rides in the suburbs, and is mostly occupied by people who work nice office jobs in the big high-rises downtown.
The middle-of-the road workers all pretty much have to drive everywhere.
But that makes the "transit is for the rich" argument rather, uh, rich. Transit is for the rich ... now. Make a decent bus service and it wouldn't be.
The new light rail service though is starting to change things though. I've noticed more young professionals and college students who are open to using the light rail and ride shares for their travels, regardless of whether they already own a car, due to convenience and it's ability to get through traffic faster.
Well, if we look at an example, like the NYC metro area, we see that car-owners have a higher annual income on average than non-car-owners, regardless of whether they live in Manhattan, the outer boroughs, or the suburbs:
Latency and efficiency matter. Take two extremes. Air vs rail. Air (chopper) is wildly inefficient (maintenance and energy). Rail has twice the efficiency of a hybrid car.
If you make everything a "car" you end up with a world where the ambulance and the big rig are both stuck in rush hour traffic.
Maintenance of vehicle? Doubt it. Especially if its an electric train.
Land acquisition for lane? Doubt it. The dedicated lanes also have full station stops.
Energy usage? Doubt it. Electric trains dont have round trip energy loss in batteries.
Operations? Doubt it. Its an electric train is usually autonomous.
Flexibility? Ya its far more flexible than a train that requires rails. Also you can reroute buses.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I'm totally sympathetic to the cause. But I also agree with the author, we can't ignore the fundamental of transit, or we will just build something even worse.
Assuming everyone could have a single passenger autonomous vehicle, ideally as small as possible, while still spacious enough to satisfy our elitism desires. And it were to pick you up and drop you off at your exact destinations.
How would traffic jams not be as huge an issue as they are today? If not more, assuming you got rid of mass transit?
Are we suggesting to massively increase the size of roads, or tunnel roads and layer them, but still, there's gonna be point of contention within the network, causing traffic again.
I feel that's pretty much the author's claim. That unless a radical idea to this problem is figured out, which I guess hasn't, then its just foolish to think we can all be picked up and dropped off wherever, riding solo at that. It won't scale. That's why its elites projection. From the problem itself, you can show it can only work for a small number of individual. But if you are that individual, you might think, I can just give this to everyone else, and problem will be solved. Forgetting the main purpose of why mass transit exists in the first place. Which isn't affordability of a car. But scale of efficiently moving large number of people around in limited space.
A human takes 150-250ms to perceive a change in the environment and react to it. A car travels about 15 feet/second for every 10 mph of speed. Hence the rule of thumb to stay one car length apart for every 10 mph of speed; that gives you about a second of reaction time, a safety factor of 4. It would be suicidal to drive one foot away from the car in front of you at 60 mph, as a human.
It takes a computer maybe 10ms to detect and react to a change in front of it, and that's assuming fancy computer-vision algorithms (it's much easier if you just put a laser beacon on all vehicles that rapidly flashes an encoded representation of the vehicle's ID, velocity, and acceleration). And computers are much better at measuring velocity, acceleration, and position with the help of a LIDAR or doppler radar. In 10ms, the vehicle will move roughly 2 inches per 10mph of speed. Suddenly it's reasonable to drive 60mph with 2-3 feet of separation between vehicles.
At that range, though, you might as well just put down a hook and latch the vehicles together. And I think that's what the OP means by cars <=> buses <=> trams <=> trains existing on a continuum, and autonomous vehicles making this clear. We'll likely get something that works like a scooter for last-mile transit, and works like a train for long-distance trips. As it enters a main road, the computers will automatically adjust speed so that they can "dock", and we'll fit an order of magnitude more vehicles onto the road.
Yeah, it is different. You have five engines instead of one, and 20 tires instead of four, meaning maintenance and fuel costs are some multiple higher, and wear-and-tear on the road surface is higher, noise and air pollution are higher. Among other things.
>What if instead of the city, I own one of these minivans?
Then you have to go through an additional middleman, the city, to find parking for your 1/5-of-a-bus and permission to drive on certain roads, in certain lanes, etc. Among other things.
So, instead of envisioning it as "5 minivans vs 1 bus", it's a system that smoothly transfers you from street to car to bus to train to plane and back. You get the "now" of low latency, and then you transfer up a step to get speed and efficiency.
Right now we have very primitive notions of multi-mode: every transfer is time consuming and difficult on the psyche, often involving new fare systems, security checks, navigating transfer points, delays, tolls, parking, and so on. This is a big factor in our tendency to bias towards a single mode and overbuild infrastructure for that mode.
Portable electrics are a big step forward in moving up the baseline: they're roughly person-sized without too much additional weight. An imagined standard for docking them in a larger vehicle or running them in a convoy is not too far-fetched, but will probably still take a lifetime to be realized with all the involved political factors.
We don't need autonomous vehicles to do that. Valet parking exists.
Yes, we do.
> Valet parking exists.
Valet parking is labor intensive, doesn't scale on-demand easily, (because it is labor intensive), ands a lot more latency on both ends than autonomous (or chauffered, but that's also labor intensive) drop off/pickup even if the labor is provisioned optimally (and gets worse very fast with slightly underprovisioned labor.)
It's decent for providing an up-charged lower-latency option for an elite, higher paying subset of customers, or optimizing parking density with less concern for latency for a larger customer base, but it's not nearly as good as on-demand last-mile transport for reducing endpoint transfer latency.
There are few, if any efficiency gains in one vs many electric motors. They don't produce noise or air pollution. Wear and tear on road surface is actually much worse for heavy busses than cars, they actually deform the asphalt and can cause accidents: https://www.thestar.com/news/2007/07/05/road_ridges_made_by_...
> Then you have to go through an additional middleman, the city, to find parking for your 1/5-of-a-bus and permission to drive on certain roads, in certain lanes, etc. Among other things.
I already have parking for my 1/n-th of a bus. Running an exchange would be a much more valuable use of a city's resources rather than operating bus depots, etc.
Road wear and tear per vehicle-mile scales with something like the fourth power of vehicle weight, so many small vehicles actually have less impact that one large vehicle even with the fact that they tend to be heavier per passenger.
OTOH, land use impacts are higher since you need more lane capacity for many small vehicles than one large one.
He makes the argument the reason that doesn't work is geometry and utilisation of limited city space.
What city are you talking about?
In cities such as Amsterdam, Utrecht, Aachen, and various others it is very difficult or expensive to park your car. Using your car in such cities is therefore elitist, but because most people just use bicycle and public transport it is of high quality (due to high demand, becoming a circular reasoning).
This is kind of bizarre reasoning. Suppose there's mass starvation in a nation and I were to say "I find it unintentionally funny to call for more food, as people who are able to eat regularly are the urban elites. Thus, 'more food' is itself the elite projection, as it supposes that what's good for the urban elite, must be good for everyone else."
Sure, suburban transit is terrible but that's argument for "transit only matters to people who already have."
Busses as we know them today will become obsolete, as they are functionally equivalent to a heterogenous mix of autonomous vehicles driving in the same direction.
"My imaginary solution is obviously better than something that's been tried and with proper planning and funding work now".
So everyone not living in a big city center in the US are now considered the poor. And everyone living in a big city center with a car is now the Elite?
Clearly we don't ride the same bus. A lot of the urban elites on my bus route are heading down to service jobs in hotels, restaurants, and perhaps day-care centers.
But think about what a tram is - typically, several linked cars attached to a wire running on tracks. Why are they linked? Because you need a driver to keep costs low, otherwise you'd unlink those cars and have more frequent service. Why are they attached to a wire? Because batteries are expensive. Why are they on a track? A bit cheaper, but in many places (Lyon, Montreal) they are not.
What is changing is the price of battery and soon, the price of driver. Trams are built on assumptions that are changing, so would they not as well?
This is not an opinion any experts on mass transit share (including those who are bullish on autonomous vehicles).
For an outline of just one of the arguments why this is a naive view (at best!), please read the author's "The Bus Is Still The Best" (https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/10/bus-b...) and an interview with him in the Financial Times "A conversation about how public transport really works" (https://ftalphaville.ft.com/2018/01/26/2198114/a-conversatio..., free FT account required, but not paywalled).
Some relevant quotes from those articles:
“How many people’s doors can a driver get to in an hour, including the minute or two that the customer spends grabbing their things and boarding? The intuitively obvious answer is the right one: not very many. An Eno Foundation report promoting microtransit could not cite a case study doing better than four boardings an hour of service. John Urgo, the planner of demand-responsive service for AC Transit in Oakland, California, has said that seven boardings an hour is “the best we hope to achieve.” Few fixed-route buses perform that poorly. Across sprawling Silicon Valley, for example, fixed-route buses carried 12 to 45 people an hour in 2015. In a dense city such as Philadelphia, the number can exceed 80”
“No, of course, the driverless car people will say, no, cars will fit closer together and they’ll be smaller and so we’ll fit more of them over the bridge but that’s a linear solution to an exponential problem. The other dimension of this problem that you must keep in mind is the problem of what we, in the business, call induced demand. And induced demand is the very simply idea that when you make something easier, people are more likely to do it and this is why, for example, when you widen a motorway, the traffic gets worse or it fills up to the same level of congestion that you had before. It’s because when you actually create new capacity, people use the capacity and you end up back in the same point.”
It would help if you thought of transit as a continuum:
- the private single-occupancy car
- shared car
- shared mini bus
- bus
- tram (ie, n linked busses)
- subway (ie n linked trams, underground)
This is hard to see today, but autonomous cars will essentially bring this about. Everybody will be riding in autonomous vehicles. If you're well-off, you'll pay for more privacy and space and time (vehicle comes to you, goes to your destination), if you're not so well off, you'll share the vehicle with other people and will have to spend more time as the vehicles makes more stops (and each stop will be further from your desired source/destination). Busses as we know them today will become obsolete, as they are functionally equivalent to a heterogenous mix of autonomous vehicles driving in the same direction. Trams will become obsolete, as they are functionally equivalent to the heterogeneous-autonomous-vehicle-chain paying a premium to use a dedicated lane.
Basically, everything should be a battery skateboard riding on asphalt by way of rubber. The more you pay, the more privacy you have, the more the mobile battery goes towards your personal destinations.