News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by hammock on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @02:40PM (#18809368)
I don't understand why you are suggesting that autonomous cars will make buses and trams obsolete. They are the closest to autonomous vehicles out of everything on your list (they run around on meta-organized and efficient routes, you don't drive them yourself, etc).
Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by nostrademons on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:04PM (#18809635)
They have the huge disadvantage of not always taking you to your exact destination and not doing so on your schedule. Neither is really necessary in the world of computerized autonomous transport and small electric motors, since computerized transport could easily get you from your destination to a moving transporter without it having to slow down.
Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by didibus on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:21PM (#18809801)
It would need to slow down due to traffic.

I'm totally sympathetic to the cause. But I also agree with the author, we can't ignore the fundamental of transit, or we will just build something even worse.

Assuming everyone could have a single passenger autonomous vehicle, ideally as small as possible, while still spacious enough to satisfy our elitism desires. And it were to pick you up and drop you off at your exact destinations.

How would traffic jams not be as huge an issue as they are today? If not more, assuming you got rid of mass transit?

Are we suggesting to massively increase the size of roads, or tunnel roads and layer them, but still, there's gonna be point of contention within the network, causing traffic again.

I feel that's pretty much the author's claim. That unless a radical idea to this problem is figured out, which I guess hasn't, then its just foolish to think we can all be picked up and dropped off wherever, riding solo at that. It won't scale. That's why its elites projection. From the problem itself, you can show it can only work for a small number of individual. But if you are that individual, you might think, I can just give this to everyone else, and problem will be solved. Forgetting the main purpose of why mass transit exists in the first place. Which isn't affordability of a car. But scale of efficiently moving large number of people around in limited space.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by nostrademons on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:56PM (#18810106)
You're still assuming a human driver. Most of the carrying capacity of roads is dictated by human reaction times.

A human takes 150-250ms to perceive a change in the environment and react to it. A car travels about 15 feet/second for every 10 mph of speed. Hence the rule of thumb to stay one car length apart for every 10 mph of speed; that gives you about a second of reaction time, a safety factor of 4. It would be suicidal to drive one foot away from the car in front of you at 60 mph, as a human.

It takes a computer maybe 10ms to detect and react to a change in front of it, and that's assuming fancy computer-vision algorithms (it's much easier if you just put a laser beacon on all vehicles that rapidly flashes an encoded representation of the vehicle's ID, velocity, and acceleration). And computers are much better at measuring velocity, acceleration, and position with the help of a LIDAR or doppler radar. In 10ms, the vehicle will move roughly 2 inches per 10mph of speed. Suddenly it's reasonable to drive 60mph with 2-3 feet of separation between vehicles.

At that range, though, you might as well just put down a hook and latch the vehicles together. And I think that's what the OP means by cars <=> buses <=> trams <=> trains existing on a continuum, and autonomous vehicles making this clear. We'll likely get something that works like a scooter for last-mile transit, and works like a train for long-distance trips. As it enters a main road, the computers will automatically adjust speed so that they can "dock", and we'll fit an order of magnitude more vehicles onto the road.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by didibus on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:21PM (#18812295)
Such an idea sounds like it would be pretty easy to simulate, and know its capacity. I'm still not convinced until I see data. You're optimizing the road network to its maximum, but that might still not be enough to prevent traffic given a point to point system. But, maybe it is, I think we'd need to see data. Also, I'm not sure all the assumptions make sense, I'd be surprised if safety was all about reaction time, there seems to be an upper cap here, where even if you had instantaneous reaction times, you still need a good distance between the vehicles to avoid a collision.
Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by martythemaniak on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @02:53PM (#18809501)
They are, which is why I'm suggesting that instead of thinking of "transit vs private cars" everything will essentially melt together. IE, if you take a bus with 30 riders today and replace it with 5 AV-minivans each with 6 occupants driving behind each other, is it any different? What if instead of the city, I own one of these minivans? What if I pay 6 fares and have the minivan take my family to somewhere? What if 6 passengers split a minivan, but pay extra to use a dedicated lane?
Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by hammock on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:06PM (#18809647)
>IE, if you take a bus with 30 riders today and replace it with 5 AV-minivans each with 6 occupants driving behind each other, is it any different?

Yeah, it is different. You have five engines instead of one, and 20 tires instead of four, meaning maintenance and fuel costs are some multiple higher, and wear-and-tear on the road surface is higher, noise and air pollution are higher. Among other things.

>What if instead of the city, I own one of these minivans?

Then you have to go through an additional middleman, the city, to find parking for your 1/5-of-a-bus and permission to drive on certain roads, in certain lanes, etc. Among other things.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by jungler on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:30PM (#18809881)
When I last did some armchair thinking about transport modes my conclusion was only a little bit removed from parent's basic hypothesis, just with one critical detail: It's not that one mode will rule them all, it's that the friction of switching modes is likely to go further and further down until we have successfully "containerized" or "packet switched" transit.

So, instead of envisioning it as "5 minivans vs 1 bus", it's a system that smoothly transfers you from street to car to bus to train to plane and back. You get the "now" of low latency, and then you transfer up a step to get speed and efficiency.

Right now we have very primitive notions of multi-mode: every transfer is time consuming and difficult on the psyche, often involving new fare systems, security checks, navigating transfer points, delays, tolls, parking, and so on. This is a big factor in our tendency to bias towards a single mode and overbuild infrastructure for that mode.

Portable electrics are a big step forward in moving up the baseline: they're roughly person-sized without too much additional weight. An imagined standard for docking them in a larger vehicle or running them in a convoy is not too far-fetched, but will probably still take a lifetime to be realized with all the involved political factors.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:30PM (#18810962)
But while ganging or docking is nice, you don't really need it to get most of the benefits; low-friction transfers by eliminating the huge parking lots that you half to walk from at the interface of small personal last-mile (or last-few-miles) transport with larger long-distance transport gets you much of the way to the kind of network you seem to want, and only really takes autonomous on-demand vehicles and integrated payment and reservation systems, not ganging/docking. You've got some buffering at transfer points still, but much less friction than in the status quo.
Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by hammock on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:32PM (#18812341)
>eliminating the huge parking lots that you half to walk from at the interface of small personal last-mile

We don't need autonomous vehicles to do that. Valet parking exists.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:48PM (#18812412)
> We don't need autonomous vehicles to do that.

Yes, we do.

> Valet parking exists.

Valet parking is labor intensive, doesn't scale on-demand easily, (because it is labor intensive), ands a lot more latency on both ends than autonomous (or chauffered, but that's also labor intensive) drop off/pickup even if the labor is provisioned optimally (and gets worse very fast with slightly underprovisioned labor.)

It's decent for providing an up-charged lower-latency option for an elite, higher paying subset of customers, or optimizing parking density with less concern for latency for a larger customer base, but it's not nearly as good as on-demand last-mile transport for reducing endpoint transfer latency.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by martythemaniak on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:12PM (#18810795)
Your objections are actually based on ICE car assumptions. ICE cars are going away soon, they're irrelevant when talking about the future of transportation.

There are few, if any efficiency gains in one vs many electric motors. They don't produce noise or air pollution. Wear and tear on road surface is actually much worse for heavy busses than cars, they actually deform the asphalt and can cause accidents: https://www.thestar.com/news/2007/07/05/road_ridges_made_by_...

> Then you have to go through an additional middleman, the city, to find parking for your 1/5-of-a-bus and permission to drive on certain roads, in certain lanes, etc. Among other things.

I already have parking for my 1/n-th of a bus. Running an exchange would be a much more valuable use of a city's resources rather than operating bus depots, etc.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:17PM (#18810840)
> You have five engines instead of one, and 20 tires instead of four, meaning maintenance and fuel costs are some multiple higher, and wear-and-tear on the road surface is higher, noise and air pollution are higher.

Road wear and tear per vehicle-mile scales with something like the fourth power of vehicle weight, so many small vehicles actually have less impact that one large vehicle even with the fact that they tend to be heavier per passenger.

OTOH, land use impacts are higher since you need more lane capacity for many small vehicles than one large one.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by didibus on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:05PM (#18809640)
Read the authors other article: https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2017/12/what-elon-mus...

He makes the argument the reason that doesn't work is geometry and utilisation of limited city space.