News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by nostrademons on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:28PM (#18809866)
But the form factor of the 2-to-7 person car changes significantly with the shift to autonomous electric vehicles.

With computer control, you eliminate the gap needed between cars - just hook it directly to the car in front, let them draft for better aerodynamics, and detach when you need to make a turn, saving 70-100 feet of road space. With electric motors, you eliminate the hood, engine, and transmission, saving another 5 feet or so - independent electric motors can go directly onto the wheels. In an urban environment, electrify the streets (as with trolleys) and eliminate the battery pack - that's another 4 feet and 1200 pounds or so. Once everything moves to car services and people don't own their own cars, you can eliminate the trunk, saving another 4-5 feet - in the majority of trips you aren't carrying anything big, and you can hail a different model pod for those road trips or grocery runs where you need the cargo space (or just summon the groceries and forget about driving it yourself). For trips without the kids, eliminate the other seats as well - you can just summon a different vehicle when you need to take a family trip.

Pretty soon the vehicle is just a thin shell around its occupant, taking up no more room than the personal space they would've taken up on a bus.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by williamsmj on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:18PM (#18810298)
This analysis ignores the fact that the two modes (bus and AVs) load and discharge passengers very differently. The problem is not only the physical space AVs take when in motion on the road. See, e.g. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/10/bus-b...

“How many people’s doors can a driver get to in an hour, including the minute or two that the customer spends grabbing their things and boarding? The intuitively obvious answer is the right one: not very many. An Eno Foundation report promoting microtransit could not cite a case study doing better than four boardings an hour of service. John Urgo, the planner of demand-responsive service for AC Transit in Oakland, California, has said that seven boardings an hour is “the best we hope to achieve.” Few fixed-route buses perform that poorly. Across sprawling Silicon Valley, for example, fixed-route buses carried 12 to 45 people an hour in 2015. In a dense city such as Philadelphia, the number can exceed 80”

Door-to-door transit simply cannot achieve the throughput of buses! Which is not to say door-to-door would not be profitable or even have a role in a mass system. It's probably an improvement over the current dominant mode (although my suspicion is that it's simply a slightly less bad local minimum).

But the point of the original article is to argue that certain groups of people (decision makers in cities, mostly), should not extrapolate from their own needs and preferences when designing a system designed for mass use, because they're by definition unusual and they're each N=1

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by nostrademons on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:28PM (#18810414)
That whole Atlantic article is predicated on the main cost of a ride being the driver's time. Get rid of the driver and you get rid of that cost. Get rid of the internal combustion engine (which has large economies of scale - one big engine works more efficiently than many small ones) and you lose the fuel advantage - many small electric engines are just as efficient as one big one.

The boarding issue in the article is mostly in reference to the driver's time, but there's a simple solution for the rider: docking, not board. Board a pod once, at your door, and travel inside it until you reach your destination. If you need to switch modalities - like latching a number of pods together into a train for long road trips, or putting them on an aircraft - you load the pods onto the plane, you don't transfer the people between pods. It's like intermodal containers for passengers, with the nice benefit that you can continue working on your laptop or watching a movie or sleeping throughout modality switches.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by oftenwrong on Thursday January 03, 2019 @11:15AM (#18816172)
>With computer control, you eliminate the gap needed between cars - just hook it directly to the car in front, let them draft for better aerodynamics, and detach when you need to make a turn, saving 70-100 feet of road space

You will still need a way to turn off at speed, leaving you with interchanges at each potential detachment point taking up a lot of space.

Grand Central Terminal in NYC has 44 platforms in 48 acres. Tens of Thousands of people per hour can switch between subway, regional rail, and bus lines, as well as access the surrounding city on foot, and access the on-site amenities and offices above. 700,000 people pass through daily. 10,000 people visit each day just to have lunch there. It works because the most space-efficient way to route people is to have them get out and walk. A tiny person-carrying vehicle will always need more space and supporting infrastructure than a person walking.

Re:The Dangers of Elite Projection (2017) by abeyer on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:14PM (#18810266)
That may be true if you can eliminate human drivers from the picture. I'd be shocked, though, to see numbers that support this being feasible at that kind of scale on public access roads. And that just brings you back to needing some sort of separate right of way for transit -- sure it's potentially interesting and useful, but it's just another alternative form factor for transit as it exists today.