This also broke Bingo Card Creator something fierce when I rolled out SSL support. It was the reason I hadn't had it previously, and I knew it was going to be a problem going in, and I tested for it, and I still managed to hose two pages which were critical to my business for most of a week.
Figure on a 40~50% drop in conversion from a non-technical audience on IE if they get one of those popups, by the way. It is the worst possible place to be: not enough to trigger an automated "Oh cripes!" from the website, but big enough to murder business results.
I asked how they deal with the unlocked icon and warning dialogs for mixed protocol content on the page and the response was that people are so used to the popups and the lock being unlocked, that they (Google) don't consider it to be a problem. The response was really short and curt and I felt it was kind of a cop-out.
But the answer is that permitting mixed content was probably a mistake in the first place, but it's one that we have to live with. The ease of mixing content means that many sites get it wrong (including Google sites, to our shame) and the lack of ubiquitous SSL (again, including some Google sites) imposes that on others.
So, I suppose that `we don't consider it a problem' is roughly correct regarding warning dialogs: the answer is not to mix content. The problem is that it's clearly too difficult to do that. (The inability of networks to cache public resources over HTTPS is also an issue and possibly one which we'll address.)
Lack of SSL on the Chart's API is a new one, but I'll look into it now that I know that it's a problem.
As for the rest of the problem: fixing stuff is hard. Miraculous answers invariably tend to be so only in the eyes of the conceiver. We'll keep plugging away.
I mean, when I went back and summarized my experience at Velocity to the rest of my team, that this question was glossed over as it was led to some audible guffaws. Because we've all been dealing with users for years who don't know how to deal with the UX of this problem.
Lack of complaint != contentment. I am pretty annoyed to hear of this indifference to users' peace of mind.
It seems like they may have thought better of this change, since my current version of Chrome (6.0.472.63) seems to have gone back to the padlock-and-cross.
Also unfortunately, when there is mixed protocol content, especially with email, you're not asserting trust of the page origin, but of the additional assets loaded. Google has no control over the content referenced in emails. Encouraging people to ignore the warnings doesn't make anyone safer, if people are not informed enough to care or not.
One of the suggestions was to use shorter key lengths to make SSL less expensive to process, this wasn't considered a welcome suggestion by many of the more security conscious and vocal folks in the room.
That being said the second part of your argument is completely wrong. You can just as easily inject evil JS using an https server and never get the mixed content warnings.
The warning serves to indicate to users that some assets (think important-financial-graph.jpg) aren't being served over the same encryption as the rest of the page. But then again, browsers like Safari have no problem with this. Other browsers like Firefox (correctly) cache these assets on disk if Cache-Control:public is set, thereby un-encrypting the asset.
The error may not be spurious, but it sure doesn't mean the page is secure or not.
Only if the user ignores the "invalid certificate" warning.
2. hot-new-metrics-startup gets hacked. Sends over malicious js
3. Your page is no longer secure. https certificate remains.
We can argue semantics, but I guess I'm more concerned about the end result than semantics.
It certainly might be possible for the attacker to compromise a specific server that you have chosen to trust - but that's a much higher barrier to an attacker than performing MITM on an open Wifi connection which doesn't require them to compromise any server.
1. You include http://google.com/trusted.js on a https page
2. Someone goes to a cafe, opens up your website with Safari while someone is performing a MiTM attack on that file.
3. No warnings, your user is compromised.
EDIT: I do take your point in that I think IE is the only browser that actually blocks the content. The others warn about it but still load it, by which time, of course, the damage is done.
What is the purpose of warning more prominently in the scenario described, than in the scenario where the user goes to a non-SSL site in the first page, or is redirected from an SSL login form to a non-SSL page?
If you don't trust a company and their competency at security you probably shouldn't be using their service for anything sensitive. You can't assume that your users aren't on hostile networks vulnerable to MITM attacks, etc.
The mixed content warning helps to warn the developer of the site of the problem, and let users of browsers that support it know that they are not fully protected.
Hint: People sell out-of-the-box solutions to the problem.
It's trivial to get certs that browsers won't choke on. You have to more than check for the cert not being "invalid", you have to actually examine it carefully, knowing which cert sellers are trustworthy and which are not. Your SSL lock icon is useless.
http://chart.apis.google.com/chart?chs=200x200&cht=qr&chl=http://www.adperium.com/ (normal)
https://www.google.com/chart?chs=200x200&cht=qr&chl=http://www.adperium.com/ (HTTPS)
It's probably not what Google prefers, but this works for us.http://groups.google.com/group/google-chart-api/msg/85186f74...
However, I agree with you that we need some good free CAs. The difference between free and $10/year is bigger than most of us think it is. Fortunately, there are registrars such as Gandi which will give you free certificates with every domain.
Right now, browsers are accepting any unencrypted old HTTP connection without any warning, while non-verified securely encrypted connections are actively prevented. Tech people can circumvent the block, but normal users cannot. Nor do they have any reason to because the warning they are being shown sounds like the end of the world, while any unsecured connection looks perfectly fine to them. This is something that could be done right now to make everybody more secure, at no cost, but it threatens the business model of companies like Verisign.
Nobody is suggesting that browser makers should display the much-sought-after "lock of absolute protection" icon on any random SSL connection, I'd be fine if they reserve that for paid-for-certs. I'm merely suggesting they show free (or even self-signed) certs the same courtesy as basic HTTP, the most permissive protocol of all time, instead of actively preventing users from using encryption.
I agree with you about the threat of "Firesheep FX" and believe Wifi connections should probably all use WPA2, even at coffee shops where internet access is free. The threat of MITM is real, but the attack can be made more difficult using a number of schemes, and it even includes free certs that offer way more protection than any unencrypted link ever could. Yet, we are currently encouraging unencrypted connections while actively blocking encrypted ones.
If HTTPS could have the same UI mechanisms as, say, an SSH connection I'm convinced the online world would be a much safer place.
if you just write the password on the wall, it defeats the purpose - everyone who logs in is on the same network again, just like a public network
Every device negotiates its own keys with the access point.
> I agree with you that we need some good free CAs
https://www.startssl.com/ Supported by just about every browser. Entirely free. A fellow Hacker News user linked to it in a similar thread. I was impressed :)
*-------.com uses an invalid security certificate.
The certificate is not trusted because no issuer chain was provided.
(Error code: sec_error_unknown_issuer)*
StartSSL does not work for me. Unless I did something wrong, which happens from time to time. I verified that the StartSSL cert I installed was downloaded by FF, it just doesn't recognize StartCom as a trusted cert authority (apparently). Can anyone confirm this?Edit2: You guys were right, thanks! I did paste the intermediate certificate into the wrong file, my bad! It works!
[1]: http://blog.dembowski.net/2010/02/25/startssl-and-nginx/
ERROR: cannot verify [site]'s certificate, issued by `/C=IL/O=StartCom Ltd./OU=Secure Digital Certificate Signing/CN=StartCom Class 1 Primary Intermediate Server CA':
Self-signed certificate encountered.
To connect to [site] insecurely, use `--no-check-certificate'.The verification is the same, there is no good reason it shouldn't be the same price.
The google maps api for example will not work behind https. Google has publicly said that this is because they want their maps free and open, not behind some page where the user needs to be logged in. This create a huge problem for any site that uses google maps. They do offer a solution though, for $10,000 a year they will let you use the map api behind https.
Other than Google Analytics I can't think of a single other widget/embed/analytics app that has supported SSL out of the box. It's a real shame, but on the other hand I'd bet good money that the web will be 99% SSL within the next 24 months.
It's a damn shame because it was a really cool integration.
Forcing the requests to be serial sucks, but if you only do it for privileged actions (as opposed to public page GETs) it should be manageable.
The worst is that the default selected choice in the modal box is to not load anything.
I think a lot of developers underestimate how big of an impact this warning is on users, especially on browsers like IE that throw up a dialog on every page that has this warning. Developers understand that it's not that big of a deal — but to a user, it looks like the site is full of viruses, malware and is going to steal all your bank account information.