News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by wpietri on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:06PM (#18801972)
The part I found especially compelling: "Blockchain proponents have a vision of _society_ in which centralized entities are weakened/eliminated. But blockchain tech is a way to build _software_ without centralized servers. Why would the latter enable the former? It’s a leap of logic that’s left unexplained."
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by lawn on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:09PM (#18801992)
How so?

Cryptocurrencies is about divorcing money and state. Seems pretty clear to me.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by hkt on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:31PM (#18802149)
> Cryptocurrencies is about divorcing money and state. Seems pretty clear to me.

No, they don't. There is no technological or cryptographic answer to the state's monopoly on legitimate force, its duty to execute the law, or any of its other functions that create and maintain the business environment.

It occurs to me that much of what crypto-lovers want is actually radically undemocratic. Vestigial states that can't do the bidding of the electorate because they're unable to hold companies to account and so on. People of this inclination are the death throes of the globalist dream: it is a fine thing indeed that the nation state looks to be reasserting itself in the face of one of California's more embarrassing wet dreams.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by koheripbal on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:37PM (#18811023)
If you rob the state of its monopoly over money, it's ability to exert force is greatly diminished.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by hkt on Thursday January 03, 2019 @07:08AM (#18814524)
Except the state can exert force to protect its monopoly over money.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by WalterSear on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:41PM (#18802210)
>It occurs to me that much of what crypto-lovers want is actually radically undemocratic.

It's just the latest iteration of the libertarian fallacy, embodied in code - that a market can exist without a governing body to make sure it doesn't get sold.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by bduerst on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @04:00PM (#18802325)
Basically whenever you create a vacuum of power, it gets filled eventually by a few individual actors - i.e. Bitcoin miners being predominantly Chinese at this point.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by ric2b on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:24AM (#18831300)
And what exactly are they able to do?

People love to talk about how many miners are in China without mentioning that they really can't do much, even if they get over 51%.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by wpietri on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:05PM (#18803236)
Exactly. I used to work for financial traders, so I got to see some highly effective markets up close. Those markets were heavily regulated. Not just by governments, who were from my perspective almost irrelevant, but by the exchanges themselves.

I think markets are amazing, and have a lot of sympathy for the more thoughtful sort of libertarian and their concerns about state power. But there's what I think of as fundamentalist libertarians, who seem to worship an abstract idea of "market" that has very little to do with my real-life experience of markets, financial or otherwise.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by mshron on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:19PM (#18803287)
For anyone interested in this extremely important point (that markets need a lot more than just enforcing contracts to work), two book recommendations:

* Rob Reich, _Saving Capitalism_ [1]

* Steven K Vogel, _Marketcraft_ [2]

What kinds of contracts can be enforced? How much personal liability people should have? Is bankruptcy allowed? and so on. All trade-offs between different groups, and there’s no one “free market” answer to any of them.

[1] https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/227780/saving-capit...

[2] https://global.oup.com/academic/product/marketcraft-97801906...

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by acdha on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:15PM (#18802032)
Because proponents have never demonstrated a viable path to linking those. It always comes back to depending on the state (e.g. courts, police) or reinventing banks, with huge hand-waves about how the details could possibly work for a non-trivial scale.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by lojack on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:21PM (#18802079)
> Cryptocurrencies is about divorcing money and state.

Is it though? I used to think that, but over the past couple years I've seen plenty of politics around governance of the future of cryptocurrency. Seems like everyone tried divorcing the two and ended up just creating a new state.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by tigerBL00D on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:33PM (#18802160)
"Cryptocurrencies is about divorcing money and state."

How so?

Despite the misleading term cryptocurrency is a type of commodity, not money. A heavily speculated one. It's really quite terrible at being a money substitute. With the exception of some very fringe use cases.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by beefield on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:32PM (#18802153)
Just thinking that a success in that might be more likely if the plan did not include giving seigniorage from the state (i.e. people) to a bunch of cryptonerds. Also, a monetary policy not from medieval times might help.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by samastur on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:15PM (#18802029)
Not really. It's a difference between necessary and sufficient. Decentralization might be necessary component, but what is lacking is proof or argument that it is also sufficient for this change to happen.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by ghayes on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:18PM (#18802051)
The original statement: “Why would the latter enable the former” sounds like it’s arguing against necessary as well. If the original post contained “imply” instead of “enable,” this line of reasoning would be sound.
Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by jmfayard on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:39PM (#18802202)
> "Blockchain proponents have a vision of _society_ in which centralized entities are weakened/eliminated. But blockchain tech is a way to build _software_ without centralized servers. Why would the latter enable the former? It’s a leap of logic that’s left unexplained."

The leap of logic is not unexplained, it's called libertarian ideology: government policies that work relatively well (healthcare, social security, Central Banks,...) are the most dangerous because they might (and do) give people the wrong idea. Bitcoin is an incredibly wasteful technology compared to the supposed obsolete paradigm, so you need the ideological element to understand why some take this "leap of logic".

Personal opinion: the crypto currency/Blockchain movement is no less ideologue than say the Free software foundation. But Stallman has the merit to be very explicit about it, instead of hiding it under a tech logorrhea.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by dorgo on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @06:00PM (#18811188)
>Bitcoin is an incredibly wasteful technology

The first computer was also incredibly wasteful. Subsequent iterations proved to be less wasteful and more usefull.

Re:“In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart” by notatcomputer68 on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @03:15PM (#18802030)
Software is eating the world and it's almost finished.

Decentralized software decentralized world