You don't need that car. A car half the price would have been plenty good enough. But you did it anyhow.
You don't need fancy breakfast cereal that costs twice what the generic stuff at Aldi costs.
You don't need all those electronics and toys. You don't need to eat out that much.
If you made less money, you'd do less of the above right until you simply couldn't afford any of it.
And you'd continue to be about as happy as with all that money, assuming you were still paying for the necessities.
I'm not trying to convince you to give up those fancy drinks. I'm just explaining that you could choose to live more frugally without almost no repercussions, but you won't.
This obviously isn't a binary, but I've been consistently fascinated with the inability of the people I know (generally middle- to upper-middle class) to shift their consumption downwards to meet a goal. Not everyone wants as much leisure time as I do, but I know tons of people with all sorts of reasons they'd like to save more, and every one of them consumes more while making less than me (when I'm working). I used to think the issue was that I grew up without a lot of disposable income, but now I know people with similar backgrounds whose floor on consumption rises in lockstep with their income.
That is to say, I don't disagree with your analysis here, but for God's sake _why_ do people do it?
[1] Contracting is obviously possible, but it often constrains the type of work you can do.
My ideal doesn’t change when my income rises, I’m just finally able to pay for the things I’ve wanted all along.
At least, that was true before. I guess I’m finally at a level where something remains for saving.
Note that I'm also talking about a _floor_, not about discretionary income. What you consider "must-have basics" is different from what I would consider to be so, which is different from what a billionaire or a villager below the global poverty line would. To some degree this is normal, but the degree to which it gets in the way of the other goals of the people I'm talking about, I don't understand it.
I'm specifically talking about the many, _many_ friends of mine who have goals other than immediate consumption, and for whom immediate consumption is preventing those goals even when those other goals are higher-priority. Yes, I know revealed preferences are a thing, but in extremis the concept relies on a completely unrealistic Homo Economicus model of people. Hyperbolic discounting, innumeracy, an innate desire to keep up with the Joneses even when you disavow any such desire: these are all surely contributors, but I guess I'm surprised at the degree to which their sum skews consumption behavior.
Real estate is limited by the supply of desirable land. Location, location, location.
I'm fairly sure that student loans do not scale with locale. That payment is the same no matter where you move to after graduation but it's easier to earn it in a high cost of living (unless housing costs are so high that your free cash flow is less).
My theory, is that life is full of stress, and throwing money at problems can make some causes of stress diminish. Whereas a minimum wage worker will shovel his own driveway, a higher paid office worker may typically have a snow plow contractor on retainer (for them it is worth the trade off, especially with long office hours). Same story with vehicle or home repairs. Which is why you don't really feel stress free until your income exceeds the threshold to handle most stress items with money instead of your own labor.
If we wanted a legitimate middle class, the textbook definition of one, the per-capita incomes in such a class would need to average around 100k for the whole US. Then you would make enough to invest enough to be making an appreciable amount of your money from investments and thus be "middle" class.
The average income is still a bit more than a third that, so the average is still decidedly a member of the working poor.
Money doesn't stop buying happiness until... coincidentally... you start making about enough money to be middle class. I'm not surprised at all that those below that threshold are buying happiness at the expense of future stability or prosperity.
I always assumed it was th middle of the income distribution.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_class
I'm using the academic definition, where if the upper class earns their wealth through investments and the lower class through labor, the middle is a mix of the two.
Humorously even the wikipedia article mentions how the middle class in the US is framed as a political tool of manipulation...
I think that people should both be free to make childish mistakes and still succeed(without putting themselves in the hole) and i also fear for a medical emergency that tosses me back in the hole outside of my own fault.
My only point is that I think healthcare and higher education are necessary to exist in the modern world, therefor they are a right, and our government - and tax payers - should provide these things to everyone.
Not buying a car and riding the bus saves hundreds of dollars per month but costs hours a day. Eating out saves the effort of cooking and washing dishes. Hiring a maid might be used out of laziness or to eek out more family time.
I have to remind myself to try to focus on what really makes my life better. Usually that involves estimating time+money+intangible factors. And if it will still be useful in a year.
The problem is, nobody wants to live like that today. As soon as we have more income, we "need" more - more clothes, more toys, a better car, a nicer house in a better neighborhood. As we get more income, our "needs" change, driving our expenses to almost exactly match out income.
This is especially true when you have kids. If you can afford it, you're tempted to give your kids those ski lessons... that summer camp... that vacation to Disneyland... a car when they turn 16. It feels heartless to say no when you could say yes. But if you say yes to all of it, you'll spend as much as you can afford (and maybe a bit more besides), because there's always something more you could give your kids.
Note well: This is not a criticism of those with low incomes who are struggling to make it. It's a criticism of those of us with fairly high incomes who still struggle to make it.
For a few things a 1950 standard of living is literally illegal. Medical care - no NICUs. Seat belts, leaded gasoline, crumple zones.
There is no certainty that you’d double your money in 10 years.
If not, what’s the difference? The are both offering a good.
at no other time before or since did a working class population have it so good.
I think it's evolved, not designed. A (arguably the) key element of capitalism is that a dollar extracted from an individual transaction is a dollar that can buy capital to scale up the extraction. That means exponential (actually logistic, I suppose) growth scaling with how much an entity can extract.
Yikes. I'm not exactly living paycheck to paycheck, but I can relate to this.
It's really funny - my wife and I make quite a bit of money - whatever twisted form of capitalism we currently live in has been designed in such a way to extract most of it away from us. One begins to wonder what the point of going to work and earning money is other than to line the pockets of corporations that have effectively taken ownership of our government.