This obviously isn't a binary, but I've been consistently fascinated with the inability of the people I know (generally middle- to upper-middle class) to shift their consumption downwards to meet a goal. Not everyone wants as much leisure time as I do, but I know tons of people with all sorts of reasons they'd like to save more, and every one of them consumes more while making less than me (when I'm working). I used to think the issue was that I grew up without a lot of disposable income, but now I know people with similar backgrounds whose floor on consumption rises in lockstep with their income.
That is to say, I don't disagree with your analysis here, but for God's sake _why_ do people do it?
[1] Contracting is obviously possible, but it often constrains the type of work you can do.
My ideal doesn’t change when my income rises, I’m just finally able to pay for the things I’ve wanted all along.
At least, that was true before. I guess I’m finally at a level where something remains for saving.
Note that I'm also talking about a _floor_, not about discretionary income. What you consider "must-have basics" is different from what I would consider to be so, which is different from what a billionaire or a villager below the global poverty line would. To some degree this is normal, but the degree to which it gets in the way of the other goals of the people I'm talking about, I don't understand it.
I'm specifically talking about the many, _many_ friends of mine who have goals other than immediate consumption, and for whom immediate consumption is preventing those goals even when those other goals are higher-priority. Yes, I know revealed preferences are a thing, but in extremis the concept relies on a completely unrealistic Homo Economicus model of people. Hyperbolic discounting, innumeracy, an innate desire to keep up with the Joneses even when you disavow any such desire: these are all surely contributors, but I guess I'm surprised at the degree to which their sum skews consumption behavior.
Real estate is limited by the supply of desirable land. Location, location, location.
I'm fairly sure that student loans do not scale with locale. That payment is the same no matter where you move to after graduation but it's easier to earn it in a high cost of living (unless housing costs are so high that your free cash flow is less).
You don't need that car. A car half the price would have been plenty good enough. But you did it anyhow.
You don't need fancy breakfast cereal that costs twice what the generic stuff at Aldi costs.
You don't need all those electronics and toys. You don't need to eat out that much.
If you made less money, you'd do less of the above right until you simply couldn't afford any of it.
And you'd continue to be about as happy as with all that money, assuming you were still paying for the necessities.
I'm not trying to convince you to give up those fancy drinks. I'm just explaining that you could choose to live more frugally without almost no repercussions, but you won't.