I would very much prefer if companies just flat out came out and said they don't want someone on their platform instead of trying to twist both their rules and past events to create some kind of coherent narrative. I wouldn't be happier but if I had to choose between being lied to or not being lied to, I prefer honesty.
Regardless, it is very relevant that a payments platform has arbitrary subjective rules for taking people’s living away. Especially when those reasons are ideological.
Not that our society is all that great at free thinking, but I don’t think we should be setting it up to continue making free thought harder. Even if it comes with some things we don’t like, we need to honor the pursuit of intellectual curiosity and exploration.
The fact that it's not state censorship and thus not aided by state repressive apparatus makes it less abhorrent, but still harmful enough. Especially given that this censorship effort is not solely done by Patreon: most major providers - each of them enjoying near-monopoly in their field - are currently engaged in a concentrated effort to suppress speech they deem offensive. Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Google, Apple, Patreon, Paypal, Visa, Mastercard - they all take concerted and persistent effort to make views and expressions they dislike unavailable on the Internet, or at least very, very hard to reach.
The effect, while not as drastic as censorship in a totalitarian state - you won't get jailed or shot for sharing a spicy joke, though you could lose your business, your job and your career - is definitely of the same kind and direction as the efforts of any totalitarian state. The goal is to make only conformant expression possible and to make people who do not conform, who want to challenge the reigning dogmas, feel afraid and be excluded from any Internet platform of notice. And until we have viable alternative to censorship platforms, the effects of this would be similar - though, obviously, less drastic - to the effects of state censorship.
But the fact that we are not in North Korea yet is not the reason to continue on the road to this direction - it's a wakeup call to turn around and walk away from it. Including walking away - as much as possible - from censorship platforms.
If you want to fight that, you have to fight capitalism.
> If you want to fight that, you have to fight capitalism.
Bullshit. People regularly fight legal actions by private corporations, and regularly win. Society has hundreds of ways for corporations to stop doing something that is legal but is seen by society as harmful. Capitalism is still alive and well.
MATT: Are you telling me that this was Patreon’s decision then, or someone pressured you into this?
PATREON: No - this was entirely Patreon’s decision.
MATT: Well then I don’t understand passing the buck off to somebody else.
PATREON: No, I’m not passing the buck off. The thing is we have guidelines, but I’m trying to explain, #1 it is our mission to fund the creative class and obviously some people may not want to be associated.
[1] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1U0mQjUA0T5INc_GDkwPJ2mfh...
I have seen zero actual evidence for MasterCard, and no speculation for Visa, so I would love to see citation for your evidence?
There was Speculation for MC in the JihadWatch banning, but MC has publicly said they were not behind it I believe.
PayPal on the other hand probably is, PayPal has been on a moral Authoritarian left war for over a decade now
[1] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1U0mQjUA0T5INc_GDkwPJ2mfh...
Mastercard / Visa / Paypal pretty much control the entire system. Wikileaks was "deplatformed" years ago.
Don’t get me wrong - racists are not something I tolerate in my personal life. Not at all. There’s no need for that kind of crap in our society and I’m not going to go down the rabbit hole of trying to change someone’s mind when rationality isn’t the basis of their thinking. But there’s a hell of a lot of grey area between racism and simply thinking about things in a different way. And right now it seems like the freedom to think differently, even if it’s just to come to a valid conclusion instead of believing what you’re told, is under a lot of fire. Somehow a lot of people (or maybe just the noisy people) are all too willing to throw away freedom to enact a totalitarian view of how they think the world should work.
That’s not right. Humans need freedom. And sometimes that means the freedom to make mistakes. The people imposing this censorship aren’t perfect. They aren’t better than the rest of us nor are they more moral. So to me, it’s totally unacceptable that they’ve established themselves as moral chaperones.
If you want to fight corporate control over speech, you have to fight against capitalism.
Our society has a separation between a secular state and religious practice for this purpose, and we must restrict social justice abuses using those tools.
See Areo article here for a more in depth argument for this: https://areomagazine.com/2018/12/18/postmodern-religion-and-...
I see no racism not calling for enforced monogamy or the taking of rights away from trans people or minorities, or anything of the sort.
That's a good thing, that kind of stuff should be called out.
They also openly call for violence, including executions, of people that they don't like (although those tweets seem to have been deleted now): https://www.redstate.com/brandon_morse/2018/12/13/patreon-al...
(Please excuse that source, like I said they have deleted the most offensive tweets recently. Originally this was part of a discussion surrounding Sam Harris leaving patreon, which is where I read about it.)
Why would this have anything to do with ideology?
Supposedly context doesn’t matter if you violate social justice beliefs, because somehow sharing the platform with someone that does wrongthink also taints you. It is a very dangerous way of thinking and we should not tolerate it from tech platforms.
Payment processing is hard. I'm not saying it should be so, but Patreon isn't to blame for that.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1U0mQjUA0T5INc_GDkwPJ2mfh...
Matt Christiansen had a call [1] with Patreon to discuss their banning of Sargon of Akkad. Sargon was notified of the banning by his patrons, not Patreon, and had no recourse to challenge the decision. In the call Patreon made it clear that their platform is;
1) explicitly anti free-speech
2) is not a free market (they can ban you for arbitrary reasons, for things posted anywhere including leaked private messages)
3) their rules are enforced in a subjective manner by design
Considering that they have banned many people that disagree with progressive PC ideology, which seems to be a moving target of increasing religious [2] fervor, I can't see why anyone would trust their platform at this point and rely on it to build their income.
Even progressives might like the so-called TERFs fall on the wrong side of the party-line at some point, so I can't see how anyone can trust their platform as a source of income. Unless you of cause love staking your income on the arbitrary whims of the ideologues at Patreon.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hv7hvZee-PQ&feature=youtu.be
[2] https://areomagazine.com/2018/12/18/postmodern-religion-and-...