Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by apo on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:22PM
(#18701346)
The interview cites this passage from the 2007 book Insurance and Its Secrets:
Everyone remembers Jeanne Calment, who has officially died at age 122 on August 4, 1997. It was said at the time that this lady had benefited from having a life annuity, which was true. This was paid by a large French company that was not happy at all with this exceptional longevity. The company was even more upset as it knew that it had been paying not Jeanne Calment, but her daughter. In reality, after the death of the real Jeanne Calment, her daughter who obviously was no longer a child, had taken her mother’s identity to keep receiving the annuity. The insurance company had discovered identity theft, but in agreement with – or on the demand of? – the public authorities, it had not wished to reveal the truth, given how much the character of the “grandmother of the French” had become legendary.
It seems that any investigation into this case should involve the insurance company. It would be surprising if Valery Novoselov had not at least started interviewing those involved with the insurance company.
Could it be that these investigations actually were made but turned up nothing to support the claim made in the book?
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by fanfantm on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:44PM
(#18702014)
However something from this book passage does not seem to fit: most sources indicate that the "viager" annuity started to be paid in 1965 (by a local notary, not by a large French company), while Yvonne (or Jeanne?)'s death was in 1934, so if fraud happened at that time it was not to keep receiving the annuity.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by mahkeiro on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:42PM
(#18702486)
Exactly the house was sold to a notary (which and this history was well known in France as he died a few years before her, and had to pay it for 32 years. Here an article from the main French economical newspaper in 1995 about it: https://www.lesechos.fr/27/12/1995/LesEchos/17052-109-ECH_l-...)
This article contains so many basic error on know fact, like naming Arles as a big city which it is clearly not, that it question just how serious it really is.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by ernesth on Monday December 17, 2018 @11:06AM
(#18699767)
> [Yvonne's] kid, by the way, was calling Jeanne “mamzanne”, that is, Mom Jeanne.
Most french children call their grandmother mamie + something differentiating from their other grandmother. Mamie Jeanne? No child use mom + first name.
> Arles was one of the biggest French communes at that time with 38 thousand people (even now, not every Moscow satellite city has that many people)
Arles was and still is far from being one of the biggest french communes. It is not among the 100 most crowded cities in France.
> Jeanne was the first (by birth date) validated supercentenarian in France and that she is also the most long-lived person in the world. It is a very unlikely combination of events from the point of view of statistics.
Isn't it exactly as unlikely that the 1st is the most long-lived, as the 17th being the longest-lived?
This hypothesis of Jeanne Calment dying in 1934 may be true, but this article does not really convince me.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by btilly on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:16PM
(#18701291)
The most convincing point to me is that she doesn't fit in the statistical models. After people get to a certain age, their odds of surviving should be describable with an exponential curve. We can fit these curves to people who survive past an old age, like 105 or 110 or 115. And most of the distribution fits just fine. But Jeanne Calment and Sarah Knauss don't. They are both extremely unlikely outliers.
At which point you have to ask the question. What theory do you consider most likely? That the model is wrong, that we happen to be lucky enough to have seen these two extraordinary data points very early, or that these two data points are fraudulent?
From a Bayesian point of view, this is a very strong argument in support of fraud. And when specific evidence emerges, including from photos, that there was fraud, it should be instantly believable.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by littlestymaar on Monday December 17, 2018 @05:55PM
(#18703023)
The statistical model only makes sense if we consider the people to have an homogeneous genetic “potential”. Of course that make sense in average, but that makes no sense for outliers.
Jeanne Calment and Sarah Knauss could share a specific (and really rare) individual mutation that makes their expected lifespan way higher than the average human and comparing them to others just doesn't make sense.
If you look at the distribution of human sizes, Robert Wadlow and John F Carroll are also outliers but nobody is questioning their size ;).
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by btilly on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:47PM
(#18703353)
You are arguing that the model is wrong. Which is not impossible, and is a theory that the statistical evidence also supports. You gave as an example human size.
It could also be a non-linear interaction effect between genes. Kind of like how most waves follow the linear wave model, but there is a separate distribution of very rare non-linear waves called rogue waves. (Very rare as in one every several months at a given spot.) When you combine rogue waves and a heavy sea, you get waves with a size that should be seen only once every 10,000 years or so anywhere on Earth.
So yes, we can come up with all sorts of possibilities. However when you combine statistical models with specific photographic evidence pointing towards fraud, the fraud theory is a lot more believable than it would otherwise be.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by littlestymaar on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @12:29AM
(#18704716)
I find the whole article quite convincing actually (including the picture thing). I was just arguing that the statistical model isn't a strong evidence per se.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by btilly on Monday December 17, 2018 @08:04PM
(#18703731)
If you don't find that convincing, I don't know what to tell you other than the obvious fact that you must not understand statistics very well.
But I'll try. Yes, there should be extreme outliers. But the statistical model predicts how many extreme outliers there should be, and how extreme they are likely to be. When you encounter data points that are more extreme than the model thinks should exist anywhere, it is extremely likely that something different is going on with those examples that is not captured in the rest of the model.
Given the photographic evidence, what is going on was fraud. But if it was something else, we'd definitely want to be digging in to figure it out.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by cortesoft on Monday December 17, 2018 @11:13AM
(#18699821)
> Isn't it exactly as unlikely that the 1st is the most long-lived, as the 17th being the longest-lived?
No, because lifespan is not some completely random thing. It is continually improving over time.
This would be like if the fastest 100m time was set 30 years ago, and hasn’t been broken since. This would be very strange, since the record actually keeps improving over time. It is not impossible (the long jump record stood for many years) but is at least not probable.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by Bartweiss on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:16PM
(#18701292)
This is generally a good point, but I'm not entirely sure it applies to high-end outliers for aging?
We've improved medicine in a lot of ways, but rising lifespans (even measured from adulthood) are almost entirely driven by preventing certain premature deaths and increasing life expectancy for other terminal conditions. Very elderly people have generally escaped a lot of common mortality risks already (heart disease onset is 85% by age 80 in the US, implying that someone who doesn't have it at age 100 isn't likely to). Meanwhile, they rarely benefit from our improving treatments for other risks - we can substantially improve life expectancy for even incurable cancers in adulthood, but centenarians can't tolerate the sort of aggressive treatments we use for that result.
(Interestingly, I had thought Alzheimer's was similar to heart disease, but annual onset rates at 90+ are almost as high as at 65-89 combined - it appears to simply be a steadily rising risk. Of course, we can't treat it well and incidents rates haven't changed much, so it's not really a factor in which cohort should have the longest lifespans.)
The best visualization I've found is a bit messy, but nicely breaks down life expectancy by age over time. Since 1850, 70-year-olds appear to have gained about 7 years of expectancy, and I'm guessing 100-year-olds have gained substantially less. https://ourworldindata.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Life-e...
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by scj on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:21PM
(#18701344)
She died about 20 years ago, which means we're only one generation away since her record was set.
But there's a simple explanation: all of the people represented on the top 10 eldest list were contemporary to WW1, the Spanish Flu, the Depression, and WW2. In general, one side of the list would have been middle aged by the time WW1 started, and the other just barely met drafting age by the time the war was over.
The people who would have been born in the early 1890s were hit hard by world events, their absence on the top 10 is likely a temporary dip that we're now just starting to come out of.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by rockinghigh on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @11:15AM
(#18707675)
I don’t know how the author decided that mamzanne meant mom Jeanne. It sounds like mamie Jeanne and is consistent with how French people refer to their grandmother.
The guy was apparently an > 6 sigma (insert joke here) batter.
As for how the outlier happens, it's pretty hard to make a case. If it were easy to bat 100 more people would have done it. Same goes with anything at the extremes of a distribution. Who's to say that whatever ageing process occurs in the body did not simply slow for JC? Any evidence to the contrary ("it can't happen") is supported by observations of averages. All you'd be saying is "we haven't seen this happen".
Of course I'm not saying everything that's unlikely actually happened the way it was purported to.
Put together with some of the circumstantial evidence, I might be convinced. The fact that there was a pension involved is certainly incentive.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by bluedevil2k on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:01AM
(#18699312)
I had always found it fascinating/suspicious that she outlived the next closest long-lifers by so much. Beginning at age 105, there's a 50/50 chance you'll make it to your next birthday (1). So Jeanne was a super outlier in this model, a 2^17 outlier (1:131,072)
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by btilly on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:41PM
(#18701507)
She doesn't fit, but it isn't as extreme as you might think.
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_verified_oldest_pe... there are 43 people who reached 115, and we know how old 40 of them turned out to be. 9 of those made it to 117.
That fits pretty well with the 50% odds of dying each year. She supposedly lived about 7.5 more years after that point. What would her odds be? 0.5^7.5 = 0.0055242717280199 are pretty bad. But with a pool of 40, the odds that SOMEONE lived that long turn are 40x that, which is around 22%.
When you combine worse healthcare, challenges around record keeping, and specific evidence of fraud, I am inclined to believe that she was fraud. But the statistical case for it isn't as overwhelming as I would naively guess.
(That said, access to a larger data set could easily make the odds against her existence much more extreme.)
But even at that scale you'd expect there to be one or two people reach that age and the article claims this case is actually well outside any of the statistical models. So the 50/50 statistic probably understates the odds as I'm sure those percentages keep getting worse every year.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by bluedevil2k on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:05PM
(#18700208)
Agreed, cause the article states the 50/50 statistic only really applies to ages 105-110. After that, I suspect they would start getting worse, but there's probably not enough of a sample size to provide an accurate estimate.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by bluedevil2k on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:08PM
(#18700234)
If you just used the 50/50 method (which was only proven for 105-110), then you'd expect 2 of today's 105 year olds to make it to 122. But, Jeanne died some 20 years ago, when medicine wasn't where it is today, and she was humorously 105 in 1980!
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by mr_overalls on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:22AM
(#18699450)
> You see, there are Blue Zones where there are many centenarians, and the data about their lifestyle can probably explain their longevity. However, most of Russia is located in a totally different climate zone, and what is known about the life-extending lifestyles of, say, Mediterranean countries cannot be applied to our latitude.
The book "Blue Zones" referenced nine lifestyle factors that were associated with longevity. They are:
1. Moderate, regular physical activity.
2. Life purpose.
3. Stress reduction.
4. Moderate caloric intake.
5. Plant-based diet.
6. Moderate alcohol intake, especially wine.
7. Engagement in spirituality or religion.
8. Engagement in family life.
9. Engagement in social life.
I find it pretty incredible that a researcher would reject these very general principles out of hand, simply because Russia's landmass is located at higher latitudes.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by chongli on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:35PM
(#18700476)
6. Moderate alcohol intake, especially wine.
The position that moderate alcohol consumption promotes health has been overturned [1]. Data now shows that the only safe level of alcohol consumption is zero. Every single drink increases your risks of alcohol-related disease. The previous data showing a benefit to moderate alcohol use may have been a result of some confounder such as social economic status or reverse causation (diseased people quit drinking).
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by vokep on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:31PM
(#18702394)
Does this control for benefit from social anxiety reduction?
Or benefit from experiences which wouldn't have even begun to occur (due to social anxiety)?
"The only safe level of driving is 0" and yet its trivially clear that someone who chooses not to drive due to fear of the risks, may experience stress and other factors equal to or outweighing the risks that would result from driving.
I'd guess a more accurate statement would be that there is no risk-free level of alcohol consumption. Because, ultimately, there isn't a safe level of being alive.
When your metric of "safety" applies similarly to what makes life even worth living at all, and decries life "unsafe", it doesn't seem very useful.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by jayalpha on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @06:06AM
(#18705722)
ONE Study? I am sure I can google you a dozen other studies that show that moderate alcohol consumption, red wine consumption oder resveratrol consumption (must be the resveratrol, can't be the alcohol) is healthy.
And had you actually read the article and not just vomited here into the forum then you would have realized that Pele cites and discusses many studies in the article.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by littlestymaar on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @08:32AM
(#18706268)
That's obviously how science works: just counting how many studies there is on each side, without paying attention to the publication or the methodology (preferably without even reading the abstract), and the truth is the one with the higher score…
I've read your article (as well as the study cited above, did you ?) And it doesn't discuss several studies: it cherry-picks some that go in his direction and dismisses the others … Had you read the study, you'd have realized that:
- the study came 4 years after the opinion post you shared.
- the main argument of the post “a little amount of red wine is beneficial”, which is what we though in the past, has been refuted since: it's an artifact due to a co-founder (social status) and if you control for it, this surprising effect disappear (an so does the argument).
On a historical note, you can find scores of this kind of article published in the 50s but talking about the absence of health impact of tobacco. Including many big scientific names of the time, most of them were smokers btw :).
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by jayalpha on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:15AM
(#18716649)
"That's obviously how science works: just counting how many studies there is on each side, without paying attention to the publication or the methodology (preferably without even reading the abstract), and the truth is the one with the higher score…"
The truth. Obviously. Kary Banks Mullis hast still the rejection letters from Nature and Science and kept them for his Noble price winning works. I don't know how much you know about science but looks to me you can't tell your ass from your elbow.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by scottlocklin on Monday December 17, 2018 @05:51PM
(#18702991)
That study seems ... wrong. Estimating actual alcohol drunk from estimates of sales? Separate model for tourist consumption? Non linear spline model for distribution of drinking at 0-12.5 a day rates? No accounting for differences between cultures which binge drink (Northern europe) and countries with steady, consistent alcohol consumption with meals (southern europe). Yeah, seems legit. Not.
And then figure 5 basically tells us the common wisdom ... a drink a day is harmless or good for you.
I think it's pretty well established that drinking a whole lot is pretty bad for your health, and not drinking so much is at least not real harmful. Anything that gives totalitarian proscriptions of booze, particularly when accompanied by figure 5; well, that reminds me of back in the day when they insisted smoking a joint would poke giant wholes in my pre-frontal cortex and make dying of a heroin overdose inevitable.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by nonbel on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:32PM
(#18702401)
These types of studies (correlate [common behaviour] with [common health issue(s)] will "discover" whatever the prevailing opinion is of the day.
The structure of the statistical models and what features get included is totally arbitrary, so they just play with it until the "right" result appears. In some cases you can even code male = 1, female = 0 and see (for example) alcohol is positively correlated with a health issue, but then reverse it to be male = 0, female = 1 and see alcohol is negatively correlated (see a simple example in [1]) Totally arbitrary.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by phreeza on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:59PM
(#18700659)
I have seen this reference before, but if you look at Figure 5, it does not seem to agree with the statement that 0 is the only safe amount. Am I missing something?
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by mxwsn on Monday December 17, 2018 @01:24PM
(#18700844)
From the paper
> In estimating the weighted relative risk curve, we found that consuming zero (95% UI 0·0–0·8) standard drinks daily minimised the overall risk of all health loss (figure 5). The risk rose monotonically with increasing amounts of daily drinking.
Yet as you point out, from figure 5, 1 drink/day has an exceedingly minor increased risk from 0 drinks/day. Statistically, the health risk is increased, but the impact may be low enough that people may find it worthwhile to continue to drink a modest amount due to social, emotional, or other benefits.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by chongli on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:44PM
(#18702500)
Yes. My point wasn't to suggest that all drinking is unsafe. My point was to refute the claim that moderate drinking is actually better for your health than no drinking. The study I linked does an excellent job of that. The conclusion that each drink carries a small but monotonically increasing risk with it completely contradicts the prior claim.
And that only makes sense. If alcohol is a carcinogen, then every time you expose your cells to it you run the (very tiny) risk of producing the 'perfect storm' of mutations that causes cancer.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by zeveb on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:32AM
(#18699518)
> I find it pretty incredible that a researcher would reject these very general principles out of hand, simply because Russia's landmass is located at higher latitudes.
I suspect that the article has its own motives, based on the odd statement you noticed as well as this line:
>> In Russia, Valery Novoselov is mostly known for his studies of medical documents of historic persons such as Vladimir Lenin. His review of medical archives dedicated to shedding light on the real causes of death of this great Russian politician is ready
There are many phrases one might apply to Lenin, but 'great politician' isn't one which leaps readily to mind.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by jl6 on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:54PM
(#18701596)
Am I the only one creeped out by the “interview” style where the interviewer is just facilitating the viewpoint of the investigator? Like it’s all a setup paid for by someone with an agenda?
“I have a crazy friend who says it’s wrong to eat meat...”
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by gumby on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:42PM
(#18700534)
What great work. In addition I like the scientist's view of the result: "You see, the current buzz around longevity records can be easily distracting us from the goals that are truly important." The interviewer is looking for drama and moral clarity. The actual clarity is the scientist's interest in the larger, human, goal.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by learc83 on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:26AM
(#18699485)
This is interesting, but I get the feeling that the investigator decided that his hypothesis was true and then went searching for proof.
This is a very dangerous approach, particularly when it comes to history--it's very easy to cherry pick your supporting documents, and it's even easier to interpret events in a way that supports your narrative if that's your goal. It's also important to remember that none of this research has been reviewed yet.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by gwern on Monday December 17, 2018 @01:25PM
(#18700849)
Absolutely. Forensics and archaeological DNA recovers DNA from hundreds or hundreds of thousands of years ago easily. The real question is whether the family would cooperate and provide or give permission for samples from themselves and Calment's corpse. It's easy to see why they might decide to ignore this and stonewall.
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by chasingthewind on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:14PM
(#18700297)
It seems to me like the Sagan Standard ("extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence") [0] should be applied here but I'm not sure whether to apply it to the claims of Calment's longevity or this researcher :)
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by jamisteven on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:53AM
(#18699258)
This is why science drives me mad sometimes, the premise of so many different theories in Longevity "based on science" having been rooted in "science" derived from this women, who may turn out to be this woman's daughter, mind blowing. And I can hear it now "Well technically the science itself was correct..."
Re:Investigating Jeanne Calment’s Longevity Record
by JohnJamesRambo on Monday December 17, 2018 @01:22PM
(#18700820)
As a scientist myself, you don’t really want to see how the sausage is made for a lot of science. Which is why I don’t hold it to the almost religious level I see lots of modern people hold it to. Science is still made by humans and humans run a huge spectrum from imbecile to genius. We all work with idiots in our buildings that lie and twist facts or are just generally bad scientists. Your best bet is if the science is replicated in other labs. A great read is Feynman’s Cargo Cult Science essay, to think about how hard it is to design an experiment that answers exactly what you are asking as a scientist.
Everyone remembers Jeanne Calment, who has officially died at age 122 on August 4, 1997. It was said at the time that this lady had benefited from having a life annuity, which was true. This was paid by a large French company that was not happy at all with this exceptional longevity. The company was even more upset as it knew that it had been paying not Jeanne Calment, but her daughter. In reality, after the death of the real Jeanne Calment, her daughter who obviously was no longer a child, had taken her mother’s identity to keep receiving the annuity. The insurance company had discovered identity theft, but in agreement with – or on the demand of? – the public authorities, it had not wished to reveal the truth, given how much the character of the “grandmother of the French” had become legendary.
It seems that any investigation into this case should involve the insurance company. It would be surprising if Valery Novoselov had not at least started interviewing those involved with the insurance company.
Could it be that these investigations actually were made but turned up nothing to support the claim made in the book?
This article contains so many basic error on know fact, like naming Arles as a big city which it is clearly not, that it question just how serious it really is.
Most french children call their grandmother mamie + something differentiating from their other grandmother. Mamie Jeanne? No child use mom + first name.
> Arles was one of the biggest French communes at that time with 38 thousand people (even now, not every Moscow satellite city has that many people)
Arles was and still is far from being one of the biggest french communes. It is not among the 100 most crowded cities in France.
> Jeanne was the first (by birth date) validated supercentenarian in France and that she is also the most long-lived person in the world. It is a very unlikely combination of events from the point of view of statistics.
Isn't it exactly as unlikely that the 1st is the most long-lived, as the 17th being the longest-lived?
This hypothesis of Jeanne Calment dying in 1934 may be true, but this article does not really convince me.
At which point you have to ask the question. What theory do you consider most likely? That the model is wrong, that we happen to be lucky enough to have seen these two extraordinary data points very early, or that these two data points are fraudulent?
From a Bayesian point of view, this is a very strong argument in support of fraud. And when specific evidence emerges, including from photos, that there was fraud, it should be instantly believable.
Jeanne Calment and Sarah Knauss could share a specific (and really rare) individual mutation that makes their expected lifespan way higher than the average human and comparing them to others just doesn't make sense.
If you look at the distribution of human sizes, Robert Wadlow and John F Carroll are also outliers but nobody is questioning their size ;).
It could also be a non-linear interaction effect between genes. Kind of like how most waves follow the linear wave model, but there is a separate distribution of very rare non-linear waves called rogue waves. (Very rare as in one every several months at a given spot.) When you combine rogue waves and a heavy sea, you get waves with a size that should be seen only once every 10,000 years or so anywhere on Earth.
So yes, we can come up with all sorts of possibilities. However when you combine statistical models with specific photographic evidence pointing towards fraud, the fraud theory is a lot more believable than it would otherwise be.
But I'll try. Yes, there should be extreme outliers. But the statistical model predicts how many extreme outliers there should be, and how extreme they are likely to be. When you encounter data points that are more extreme than the model thinks should exist anywhere, it is extremely likely that something different is going on with those examples that is not captured in the rest of the model.
Given the photographic evidence, what is going on was fraud. But if it was something else, we'd definitely want to be digging in to figure it out.
Incidentally, this is not the only case where fraud has been suspected among records of old people. See https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-11258071 for a much larger case in Japan.
No, because lifespan is not some completely random thing. It is continually improving over time.
This would be like if the fastest 100m time was set 30 years ago, and hasn’t been broken since. This would be very strange, since the record actually keeps improving over time. It is not impossible (the long jump record stood for many years) but is at least not probable.
We've improved medicine in a lot of ways, but rising lifespans (even measured from adulthood) are almost entirely driven by preventing certain premature deaths and increasing life expectancy for other terminal conditions. Very elderly people have generally escaped a lot of common mortality risks already (heart disease onset is 85% by age 80 in the US, implying that someone who doesn't have it at age 100 isn't likely to). Meanwhile, they rarely benefit from our improving treatments for other risks - we can substantially improve life expectancy for even incurable cancers in adulthood, but centenarians can't tolerate the sort of aggressive treatments we use for that result.
(Interestingly, I had thought Alzheimer's was similar to heart disease, but annual onset rates at 90+ are almost as high as at 65-89 combined - it appears to simply be a steadily rising risk. Of course, we can't treat it well and incidents rates haven't changed much, so it's not really a factor in which cohort should have the longest lifespans.)
The best visualization I've found is a bit messy, but nicely breaks down life expectancy by age over time. Since 1850, 70-year-olds appear to have gained about 7 years of expectancy, and I'm guessing 100-year-olds have gained substantially less. https://ourworldindata.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Life-e...
But there's a simple explanation: all of the people represented on the top 10 eldest list were contemporary to WW1, the Spanish Flu, the Depression, and WW2. In general, one side of the list would have been middle aged by the time WW1 started, and the other just barely met drafting age by the time the war was over.
The people who would have been born in the early 1890s were hit hard by world events, their absence on the top 10 is likely a temporary dip that we're now just starting to come out of.
https://www.statslife.org.uk/sports/1989-did-don-bradman-s-c...
The guy was apparently an > 6 sigma (insert joke here) batter.
As for how the outlier happens, it's pretty hard to make a case. If it were easy to bat 100 more people would have done it. Same goes with anything at the extremes of a distribution. Who's to say that whatever ageing process occurs in the body did not simply slow for JC? Any evidence to the contrary ("it can't happen") is supported by observations of averages. All you'd be saying is "we haven't seen this happen".
Of course I'm not saying everything that's unlikely actually happened the way it was purported to.
Put together with some of the circumstantial evidence, I might be convinced. The fact that there was a pension involved is certainly incentive.
The case of Bradman is really interesting, thanks.
1 - https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/speaking-of-science/wp/2...
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_verified_oldest_pe... there are 43 people who reached 115, and we know how old 40 of them turned out to be. 9 of those made it to 117. That fits pretty well with the 50% odds of dying each year. She supposedly lived about 7.5 more years after that point. What would her odds be? 0.5^7.5 = 0.0055242717280199 are pretty bad. But with a pool of 40, the odds that SOMEONE lived that long turn are 40x that, which is around 22%.
When you combine worse healthcare, challenges around record keeping, and specific evidence of fraud, I am inclined to believe that she was fraud. But the statistical case for it isn't as overwhelming as I would naively guess.
(That said, access to a larger data set could easily make the odds against her existence much more extreme.)
https://www.populationpyramid.net/
But even at that scale you'd expect there to be one or two people reach that age and the article claims this case is actually well outside any of the statistical models. So the 50/50 statistic probably understates the odds as I'm sure those percentages keep getting worse every year.
First one I heard of were the Japanese, who actually weren't long-lived but scamming the state for pensions:
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-11258071
And so of course the health benefits of the Japanese diet turned out to be, not as beneficial. Still delicious, though.
Last I checked there were similar issues with the so-called Mediterranean diet, though I can't find the reference now.
Sixth Sense, anyone?
The book "Blue Zones" referenced nine lifestyle factors that were associated with longevity. They are:
1. Moderate, regular physical activity. 2. Life purpose. 3. Stress reduction. 4. Moderate caloric intake. 5. Plant-based diet. 6. Moderate alcohol intake, especially wine. 7. Engagement in spirituality or religion. 8. Engagement in family life. 9. Engagement in social life.
I find it pretty incredible that a researcher would reject these very general principles out of hand, simply because Russia's landmass is located at higher latitudes.
The position that moderate alcohol consumption promotes health has been overturned [1]. Data now shows that the only safe level of alcohol consumption is zero. Every single drink increases your risks of alcohol-related disease. The previous data showing a benefit to moderate alcohol use may have been a result of some confounder such as social economic status or reverse causation (diseased people quit drinking).
[1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
"The only safe level of driving is 0" and yet its trivially clear that someone who chooses not to drive due to fear of the risks, may experience stress and other factors equal to or outweighing the risks that would result from driving.
I'd guess a more accurate statement would be that there is no risk-free level of alcohol consumption. Because, ultimately, there isn't a safe level of being alive.
When your metric of "safety" applies similarly to what makes life even worth living at all, and decries life "unsafe", it doesn't seem very useful.
The Truth We Won’t Admit: Drinking Is Healthy
https://psmag.com/social-justice/truth-wont-admit-drinking-h...
(Before you downvote, google the author Stanton Peele)
An the argument of authority never holds, we've seen Nobel prize winners beeing fond of conspiracy theories or other bullshit before…
And had you actually read the article and not just vomited here into the forum then you would have realized that Pele cites and discusses many studies in the article.
I've read your article (as well as the study cited above, did you ?) And it doesn't discuss several studies: it cherry-picks some that go in his direction and dismisses the others … Had you read the study, you'd have realized that:
- the study came 4 years after the opinion post you shared.
- the main argument of the post “a little amount of red wine is beneficial”, which is what we though in the past, has been refuted since: it's an artifact due to a co-founder (social status) and if you control for it, this surprising effect disappear (an so does the argument).
On a historical note, you can find scores of this kind of article published in the 50s but talking about the absence of health impact of tobacco. Including many big scientific names of the time, most of them were smokers btw :).
The truth. Obviously. Kary Banks Mullis hast still the rejection letters from Nature and Science and kept them for his Noble price winning works. I don't know how much you know about science but looks to me you can't tell your ass from your elbow.
And then figure 5 basically tells us the common wisdom ... a drink a day is harmless or good for you.
I think it's pretty well established that drinking a whole lot is pretty bad for your health, and not drinking so much is at least not real harmful. Anything that gives totalitarian proscriptions of booze, particularly when accompanied by figure 5; well, that reminds me of back in the day when they insisted smoking a joint would poke giant wholes in my pre-frontal cortex and make dying of a heroin overdose inevitable.
The structure of the statistical models and what features get included is totally arbitrary, so they just play with it until the "right" result appears. In some cases you can even code male = 1, female = 0 and see (for example) alcohol is positively correlated with a health issue, but then reverse it to be male = 0, female = 1 and see alcohol is negatively correlated (see a simple example in [1]) Totally arbitrary.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16714522#16719754
> In estimating the weighted relative risk curve, we found that consuming zero (95% UI 0·0–0·8) standard drinks daily minimised the overall risk of all health loss (figure 5). The risk rose monotonically with increasing amounts of daily drinking.
Yet as you point out, from figure 5, 1 drink/day has an exceedingly minor increased risk from 0 drinks/day. Statistically, the health risk is increased, but the impact may be low enough that people may find it worthwhile to continue to drink a modest amount due to social, emotional, or other benefits.
And that only makes sense. If alcohol is a carcinogen, then every time you expose your cells to it you run the (very tiny) risk of producing the 'perfect storm' of mutations that causes cancer.
I suspect that the article has its own motives, based on the odd statement you noticed as well as this line:
>> In Russia, Valery Novoselov is mostly known for his studies of medical documents of historic persons such as Vladimir Lenin. His review of medical archives dedicated to shedding light on the real causes of death of this great Russian politician is ready
There are many phrases one might apply to Lenin, but 'great politician' isn't one which leaps readily to mind.
“I have a crazy friend who says it’s wrong to eat meat...”
This is a very dangerous approach, particularly when it comes to history--it's very easy to cherry pick your supporting documents, and it's even easier to interpret events in a way that supports your narrative if that's your goal. It's also important to remember that none of this research has been reviewed yet.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sagan_standard
I quite enjoyed Valery Novoselov's speaking style.
http://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm