This is something I hear a lot and I just don't get. Are the people on the other side of those deals just...not greedy? After all, you are implying that the deal has better expected returns than what people are buying on margin in public markets, so why doesn't the person on the other side of the deal take a little more for themselves by selling there instead (at a slightly more favorable interest rate)?
Is it because the rich investors are needed to bring some level of expertise or connections to the investment to make it work? If that's the case, and it seems likely, I would not say they are getting "access to better deals" per se. More like they are getting a normal rate of return and they have a valuable asset that they are renting out as well (their expertise or connections), and it all gets rolled into one number. But complaining about the rich having valuable assets is different from complaining about them having access to better investment opportunities.
You'd be surprised how many deals like that are out there. Many entrepreneurs do business with a few solid partners during their lifetime.
Aside from that, there are other reasons:
1. You don't want to invest everything in the public markets, i.e. acquiring an interesting existing business and growing from there could be a good idea.
2. Some of these businesses might be less prone to losses during a recession or stock market correction, so they might serve as a buffer for cashflow and income.
3. These deals might have higher upside, because of information asymmetry or something that isn't blatantly obvious to other people. Alternatively, you might have access to different channels that could easily grow the business.
Once you’re big enough, IPOing makes sense, unless you just want to maintain control or those pesky compliance requirements will reveal some harsh secrets.
This type of deal can get you huge returns but is also very risky.
My first thought was regulation. See: accredited investor. One can sell to accredited investors, and caveat emptor, or get buried in a whole new ass-load of paperwork and butt-microscopes selling to retail.
My second thought was scaling, or selling in volume. Why do companies sell wholesale? Because they don't want to deal with nickel-and-dime buyers, there's a whole new set of infrastructure and process needed for that. Take a little less profit to sell one big block rather than doling it out to retail investors.
They’re called “bought deals”. An investment bank has a public-traded equity desk that will buy, up-front, $x billion of your stock at $Y. Then they’ll email blast/call their retail investors to buy it up over the next few weeks.
The banks take the risk of not filling the order with retail buyers, which happens occasionally.
[1] https://qz.com/67052/heres-how-warren-buffett-made-3-1-billi...
Now of course, buffet also needed timing and the ability to act fast, but lots of people had money to invest then.
One such a deal that surfaced somewhat recently was that cum-ex trading. If you put that in the public market, you would essentially be killing the goose that's laying golden eggs since there would be outcry to make it illegal. If instead you just offered it to select few (people with enough capital & no moral qualms about using it), you could keep it under the wraps for longer time and get better long term return.
It's often about preservation of wealth more than gains for these people.
That said I've discussed some returns they make and it's incredible. I don't want to say what I recall, as it was a couple years back and it sounds like an exaggeration. They said this is partly because they get access to deals that don't hit the wider market and you need serious cash to get in the room to have that chat. And I guess these manager have a bunch of the right people attached to them so it makes an easy stop.