News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by cjensen on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:41PM (#18685560)
UCLA can't walk out and Elsivier knows it. A University which lacks a library containing the currently published scholarship is going to have a really tough time attracting PhD students. How are they supposed to cite relevant work without being able to read the work?

The UC System should work with other schools to mandate open publishing. The only way to fix this is by removing Elsevier's power.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by ramraj07 on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:11PM (#18685771)
I doubt any PhD student would consider that as a potential drawback when choosing an institution.

I did my phd in an institution with very minimal access to some of these publishers and while it was annoying I would not take it among the top 50 problems I had in my academic life. I can always request an ILL, or ask one of my friends in other universities if I wanted a paper badly. If however the paper is fairly replaceable as a citation I'd just get some other paper that's sufficient and cite that.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by gerdesj on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:42PM (#18686249)
"I doubt any PhD student would consider that as a potential drawback when choosing an institution."

Absolutely. I would be rather unimpressed if someone studying to that level was unable to find alternative routes to the "source". It should be at worse a bit of a pain and at best helping to fix a sodding great travesty that has afflicted publication for decades.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by exergy on Friday December 14, 2018 @10:43PM (#18686909)
You guys must exist in some alternative universe. In mechanical engineering, no access to journals is definitely a top 5 problem, not top 50.

How do you guys do goose chase research if only one out of five paper titles that catch your interest are immediately available. Inter library loan is bullshit that takes at least one full day to appear. What do you do until then?

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by sterlind on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:03PM (#18686975)
Sci-hub. You use sci-hub. That's what I've been doing for years; I'm not affiliated with an institution so I can't afford subscriptions, and I need the articles so I can treat my illness.

When the system's broken beyond repair and the stakes are high, there's no point playing by the rules. That's why sci-hub was founded in the first place.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by exergy on Saturday December 15, 2018 @04:02AM (#18687702)
That's exactly the thing though. My field is niche enough, and it's applied science anyway, meaning that even the seminal papers are missing from scihub, let alone more modern and less-cited research papers. And no way for me to upload my stash.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by betterunix2 on Saturday December 15, 2018 @09:08AM (#18688432)
Let's say your school's subscription ended. Would you throw your hands in the air and give up, or would you and others in your field work out a way to get the papers you need? Maybe you would just email each other asking for papers at first (at least in my field it is not uncommon for papers to be passed around by email despite the ease with which papers are accessed), and eventually someone with the time would just create some kind of unauthorized archive for your niche field (which new grad students would learn about from more senior grad students). There are plenty of other ways it might play out, but I doubt your ability to publish research would be seriously impacted by a lack of subscriptions to journals.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by exergy on Saturday December 15, 2018 @12:18PM (#18689239)
The question isn't so much whether life will move on. I agree with you that it will. The point is that it will be a top 5 problem. All the stuff that you say will almost undoubtedly be a massive impediment in the face of the kind of "I'm not sure what I'm looking for, but I'll know it when I see it" types of research that PhD often involves.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by ramraj07 on Saturday December 15, 2018 @01:14PM (#18689554)
I was always fascinated how people used to get access to articles from uncommon journals back in the days before the internet.

In fact I asked a researcher in India that question. He said that they will write a letter to the biggest library in India and attach a check for 10 rupees (like ten cents today) and they will eventually mail a copy of the article after a month.

We are all super used to having instant gratification access to whatever article we need that it can be quite surprising how people used to do (arguably better) research in older days.

For a year or two my University library was particularly bad at getting access to articles and in that time while it was annoying that I couldn't instantly check references I just learned to read the abstract very carefully and only request articles that I really need to read fully.

Besides, if the university is truly trying to be ranked among the best I'm sure they will at least make sure that alternative options are smoother. That's what my uni did - it made ILLs free.

I'm in no way saying that the older days were better. Of course, scientists should have ready access to all the literature they can consume. I'm just saying again that reform in the Grant and tenure process, discrimination, overworking, the graduate student system, lack of mental health support for stressful jobs, lack of permanent jobs other than professorship, shitty metrics by which researchers are evaluated, research misconduct, impact factor based dick measurements, etc are far more important problems for me than journal access.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by fyrabanks on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:42PM (#18686253)
> ask one of my friends in other universities if I wanted a paper badly

Surely, you see the problem here?

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by tzakrajs on Friday December 14, 2018 @08:23PM (#18686414)
Maybe it is a self correcting problem. Perhaps the moment Elsevier is so out of vogue that you can’t find a library or peer at another university with access is also the inflection point where Elsevier loses its network effect. Why would you license your work to a journal for which your peers and their institutions have no direct access?
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by fyrabanks on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:42PM (#18686710)
If it were ever to reach that point, sure, I'll give you that.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by Larrikin on Friday December 14, 2018 @08:18PM (#18686389)
That would only be a problem if sci-hub also didn't exist
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by fyrabanks on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:41PM (#18686707)
First of all, piracy is a workaround and not a legitimate solution to any problem. Second, it doesn't solve the root issue here--somebody has to have paid the inflated cost of an Elsevier subscription. Sci-hub doesn't exist in a vacuum.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by stickfigure on Friday December 14, 2018 @10:11PM (#18686811)
piracy is a workaround and not a legitimate solution

Why not?

Piracy is a problem for content generation because somebody needs to get paid to generate the content. Elsevier does not generate content, it's a (parasitic?) gatekeeper using network effects to extract rents.

If content generation would be healthier and more vibrant without Elsevier, then piracy seems an appropriate and just solution. I don't see content creators lining up to defend Elsevier; quite the opposite.

(It's possible that someone could argue that Elsevier adds significant value for their cut, but I haven't heard anyone make that claim)

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by betterunix2 on Saturday December 15, 2018 @09:17AM (#18688459)
Why is it not a legitimate solution? Sometimes laws fail to catch up with technology, and copyright is a good example of that. Copyright law is based on the assumption that mass distribution is an industrial activity; today mass distribution can be done by ordinary people using common tools that we carry in our pockets.

I get the idea that skirting the law is not something we should generally encourage as the solution, but let's not get carried away and act like copyrights are some divine commandment and grad students using scihub are a bunch of evildoers.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by ixacto on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:31PM (#18686679)
This is what scihub & libgen are for.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by lixtra on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:47PM (#18685607)
Does UCLA filter scihub?

A better solution to the closed access problem would be to only cite open access articles. Sometimes that would mean not citing the original article but some open access meta article that made the findings publicly accessible.

I actually think it’s fair to not cite articles that you cannot reach with reasonable effort. It’s the authors choice to make it inaccessible.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by ansible on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:53PM (#18685647)
Moreover, it is my understanding that if there's a good paper you want to get, you can often just contact one of the authors and get sent a copy.

It is slower and less convenient, but maybe not $10 million a year less convenient...

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by new299 on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:42PM (#18685932)
People regularly don’t respond to those emails. For older publications it might be hard to even find the email.

In the UK, you can order a photocopy of any journal paper via inter library loans. These often come from the British library, which has everything. I’d assume elsewhere similar solutions exist.

Spending money on automating that process, and you might put most journals out of business.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by gerdesj on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:12PM (#18686604)
"In the UK, you can order a photocopy of any journal paper via inter library loans. These often come from the British library, which has everything. I’d assume elsewhere similar solutions exist."

I'm sure I saw a device called a scanner somewhere. It seemed to transcend the worlds of paper and electronics.

I'm also from the UK and am old enough to remember life before "Brentrance" (newly minted term by me - meaning should be obvious) This issue of publication freedom is way more important or at least comparable, to Brexit in my opinion.

I'm not too sure what the perfect knowledgebase would look like but it probably is not the current one. For me it might be something like a curated MediaWiki (the software behind WikiPedia) - for me the killer feature is that an article in a wiki is just text and a few formatting hints. Text is first, formatting and other distractions come second.

I studied Civil Engineering in the UK around 1990ish. We had lots of closed off sources and refs (ISIS and others - from memory) - rubbish!

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by pfranz on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:58PM (#18686025)
I've heard of many scenarios where the author loses access to their own paper. After moving on from a project it's easy to leave stuff on a school's server or on some hard drive in a closet.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by 4thaccount on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:36PM (#18686215)
I've asked several professors for scientific research and always got a paper back, although it was sometimes very slow.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by secabeen on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:45PM (#18685959)
> Does UCLA filter scihub?

I work at another UC, and we don't filter Scihub in any way.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by stenl on Friday December 14, 2018 @08:02PM (#18686328)
Sweden, all of it, walked out in July and we’re doing fine. I doubt any PhD students avoid our institutions because of it, and we somehow manage to get the papers we need anyway. Asking on twitter is effective, or directly from authors. And there’s always scihub...
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by guelo on Friday December 14, 2018 @08:09PM (#18686356)
Is scihub openly encouraged by faculty or librarians?
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by shmel on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:43PM (#18685576)
>>How are they supposed to cite relevant work without being able to read the work?

Sci-hub?

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by betterunix2 on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:58AM (#18688398)
"A University which lacks a library containing the currently published scholarship"

When I was a PhD student I don't think I used the university's library to access a single paper. It is not at all hard to find papers on the Internet and the money paid for subscriptions is basically a waste. Even in fields where this is a shocking concept I suspect people would figure it out if they needed to do so.

UCLA can and absolutely should walk out of the negotiations, and put Elsevier in their place (the dustbin of history). The academic publishing system that exists today is based on the premise that wide distribution of scientific writing is something that requires industrial equipment, and that is just not true these days. Elsevier's power is an illusion; they are part of an obsolete industry that future generations will have forgotten and they know it.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by HarryHirsch on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:50PM (#18685629)
How are they supposed to cite relevant work without being able to read the work?

#icanhazpdf? It's perfectly good manners to ask a colleague for a reprint.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by claudiawerner on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:08PM (#18685752)
This is what's getting to me at the moment; I'm a student at a university, so I'm thankful to be getting a lot of the stuff I search for quickly available through my university (Shibboleth login etc.) but what I don't like is the fact that for anyone else, they literally can't see what I'm talking about. Before I was a student, I gave up trying to learn about my area of interest just because every single article was behind a paywall. Maybe it let me read the abstract and see a diagram.

I may have fallen out of touch with what sci-hub offers, since I only ever use it to find books now (books which contain articles which one can't find outside the books) but the last time I used it, it didn't have many of the articles I wanted to see.

I hate to think that there are others like me who want to get into diverse research only to be stumped at not even being able to read it. This problem seems to be larger in philosophy/Marxian economics/etc. in which you really do have to read the paper to get the argument, simply knowing the results provided isn't nearly enough, because the results often can't be condensed down to data.

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by paulie_a on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:48PM (#18685975)
On the flip side elsiver wouldn't be getting papers published from UCLA right? I don't know how that situation works. But UCLA is pretty big, so I would think they would be losing access to papers also.
Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by stale2002 on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:04PM (#18686045)
> How are they supposed to cite relevant work without being able to read the work?

With sites like sci-hub, of course!

Pirating is basically never enforced against the downloaders. (It is more the uploaders that companies go after).

Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El... by buboard on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:49PM (#18685620)
this has barely anything to do with the lack of library access. The point is that if they refuse reviews emphatically it might reflect badly in future submissions they make to elsevier's journals.