News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by schizoidboy on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:28AM (#18678668)
Actual quote from Linus as opposed to the click-bait title:

> I still wish we were better at having a standardized desktop that goes across all the distributions. There's been some progress there. I mean, this is not a kernel issue, so this is just more of a personal annoyance how the fragmentation of the different vendors have, I think, held the desktop back a bit. But there has been some progress on that front too with Flatpak and things like that, so I'm still optimistic, but it's been 25 years. It's going to be another few years at least.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by msiyer on Friday December 14, 2018 @01:52AM (#18678968)
Considering what KDE has achieved with Plasma 5, I am really happy. I use Plasma 5 on all my machines that are capable enough to handle it. Gnome 3, consequently, has never found a place. On old machines, I use Xfce only. Xfce is, in no way, for the masses. Plasma 5 could easily be the Desktop Environment that everyone loves, if they continue to improve.

I have helped people migrate from Windows to Plasma 5. They loved it. However, getting\installing software and general system management is still not straightforward enough. We also need system management tools that are solid. No terminal gymnastics at all for the common user on distros targeted at the masses.

Flatpak is all cool, but we need core user-space applications to be standardized. LibreOffice, for example, needs to become the industry standard office-suite. How can we achieve that? People I know just do not want to move away from MS Office. Even government agencies invest heavily in MS Office. This might just be the most important impediment.

I think, the Linux ecosystem shows us what a real "free market" looks like. Lots of small players and no monopoly. People love choices and they have. You want a minimal Window Manager, you got many to choose from. You want a full-blown Desktop Environment, you are spoilt for choice. Not a bad thing in an ideal world, but...

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by Chyzwar on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:49AM (#18679204)
Why every Linux related topic needs to end with KDE vs Gnome discussion. The problem is not DE fragmentation but the packaging.

Every distribution spends more time on packaging and integration testing than developing useful functionality. When developing for Linux you need to package your application in a few different formats. We also have different init systems to make it more difficult. Every distro has own store and repositories. For GUI there are different frameworks and display servers.

If Linux world standardizes around snap/flatpak, systemd and wayland then we stand a chance.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by msiyer on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:31AM (#18679361)
First impression is the...

DE being the first thing a common user interfaces with, it holds a very important position, in my opinion. KDE and Gnome are very different w.r.t design principles, hence the polarization and debate. KDE and Xfce are not so different. I like Gnome, but have no use for it.

I agree with all else.

Also, I think, a real "free market" would resemble Linux ecosystem. No monopoly, small players and lots of choices. However, if we wish to compete in "real world", we need to do something similar to what you say.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:53AM (#18680448)
Linux has hundreds of DEs to suit all tastes and styles, yet it has always languished in a distant third place.

Consider the possibility that your idea of what "the common user" wants is something you made up.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by creviere on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:09AM (#18680864)
Most non-technical users aren't going to remain interested long enough to try even a few desktop environments. The first one they use will leave a strong impression.

I would argue that having a choice between hundreds of DE's is a bad thing for the more casual user.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:49AM (#18681135)
Please stop this. "Casual user", "average user", "normal user", it's all just so much bullshit people tell themselves to feel superior. Stop creating this strawman and using it as an excuse for why things have to keep sucking!
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by pjmlp on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:59AM (#18697959)
ChromeOS and Android adoption prove otherwise.

The large majority of their users don't even know what kernel is running the runtimes of their apps.

One of the reasons of netbooks failure, besides the cheap Windows XP licenses move from MS, was that each netbook Linux was its own little silo.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by WalterLuigi on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:58AM (#18682302)
If we standardize we also have a central point of failure and a lack of variety/choice for users. At this point, in what way would using a GNU/Linux system be different than using an OSX or Windows system?
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by VvR-Ox on Friday December 14, 2018 @04:16AM (#18679534)
Because discussions are good? :-P

The big players tend to be compared, isn't that reasonable?

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by lstamour on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:18AM (#18679099)
I bet Linux for the desktop will actually start when Microsoft ports Chromium-based Edge and Office apps to Linux for specialty users, primarily developers. I mean, if you want developer mindshare and apparently improving or replacing cmd.exe will never happen... it’s not like these proprietary apps aren’t possible to ship for Linux to run at least as well as they do on an Android phone...
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by pjmlp on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:08AM (#18679269)
Those proprietary apps on Android have two things working for them that GNU/Linux lacks.

In spite of piracy, a large set of population actually pays for them, versus bashing the authors for considering to charge money for their work while suggesting free alternatives.

A full stack framework that in spite of OEM customization is relatively standard across all devices with an Android label on them.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by smacktoward on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:00AM (#18679008)
there has been some progress on that front too with Flatpak

Don’t worry Linus, with Snaps and AppImages we’re hard at work fragmenting that front too!

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by VvR-Ox on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:59AM (#18679236)
Hahaha YMMD! :-D
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by keyboardmowing on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:02AM (#18679021)
Isn’t flatpak like npm where it just flat stores all the libraries? So it’s a huge waste of space ?
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by jackfraser on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:15AM (#18679087)
There's been a continual oscillation between bring-your-dependencies (ranging from statically compiled executables, to composed things like docker containers, snaps, npm / ruby / php composer apps, etc.) and use-the-systemwide-stuff (like most linux apps).

The tradeoff is pretty obvious: on the one hand you get full control over what code you bring in, but you also get full responsibility of keeping it up to date and it does indeed take up more space. On the other hand you get systemwide updates, but also unpredictability which can break things.

In the former, you have a lot of work to do yourself to maintain your ecosystem between releases. In the latter, a greater amount of effort and responsibility goes onto those who maintain the packages at a distribution level to ensure mutually compatible package selections. This can be done (viz. most of the top tier distributions successfully doing this with occasional problems for decades) but we keep trying new all-in-one mechanisms every few years.

I'm not convinced that there's ever going to be a final answer to this, but it is clear that storage is cheap as chips...

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:51AM (#18680440)
I don't know, I think the answer is pretty obvious: use system-wide shared libraries for things that are very common, like widget toolkits, network libs, cryptography, and other system components. Otherwise it is part of the application, not the system, and should be with the application.

The reason you don't see this on Linux is because there is no such thing as a separation between 'system' and 'application' in its culture. Consequently there has never been a "base system" to target or keep compatibility with so applications have to either target a specific version of a specific distro (waste of time) or include everything above the stable kernel ABI in their product (waste of space).

It is actually a very simple problem to solve, it just isn't one that the Linux community is interested in solving simply, so instead they invent ridiculously complicated tooling like package managers and Flatpak, introducing a bunch of unnecessary limitations and yet more parts to break and ruin your day.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by simonh on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:29AM (#18679132)
Was cheap as chips. The age of flash has dawned.
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:51AM (#18680442)
Still cheap as chips. 1TB name brand flash drives can be had for under $200.
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by IronBacon on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:16AM (#18679093)
FWIK, flatpak applications can share libraries via runtimes. If you instead mean about the host system, then yes, I think they import everything from libc and up.

Edit: clarification.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by alexeiz on Friday December 14, 2018 @01:00PM (#18682899)
I tried to use Flatpak for everything and because various Flatpak apps want their own version of Gnome I ended up with different versions of Gnome runtime installed on my system each consuming several hundred megs of disk space. At that point I decided to screw it and use Flatpak only if native repos didn't have an app I needed.
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by VvR-Ox on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:45AM (#18679187)
He is right with that. There is a few desktop environments that are quite good like: KDE (Plasma), Gnome (with enough options tuning & customizing) and maybe pantheon (see elementary OS)

We'd need something more smoove and better over-all integration because there is still too many shortcomings and tiny bugs that could annoy a day-to-day user that doesn't want to know anything about config files or extended menus with special settings. It should be a great thing out of the box with sane defaults. That includes the icon set as well as a decent file browser and terminal emulator experience (iTerm2 on mac is THE REFERENCE here, I wouldn't want anything less).

Next comes workflows like office /graphics /audio stuff. I like how OSX handles PDFs etc and would love to see that on linux as well.

But I'm afraid this scattering is one of the biggest enemies of adoption and maturity of open source software. There is so many OSes and tools that you often have to research stuff for hours before you start off with a shitty tool that get's the job half done and then you recognize you can start from scratch because it doesn't work as you expected.

Instead many open source projects could live up to their potential if they'd combine efforts to merge the best they did and create ONE super awesome tool.

The reallity is that very often projects are just abandoned because adoption / donations etc. are too low or the 2 maintainers are tired after years of working on a project only 100 ppl on the globe are using.

Unite! At least converge to 2 big streams: Pro-Users (the ppl making jokes about shellscripts) and People (your mom)

Just focus on delivering for these 2 groups and I think most ppl would be glad about the end product. I for myself will try to do my best in putting efforts into projects I hope will have the biggest adoption.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:59AM (#18680488)
> Unite! At least converge to 2 big streams: Pro-Users (the ppl making jokes about shellscripts) and People (your mom)

I couldn't disagree more. As a community, developers and Linux developers in particular need to stop believing in the divide between the Glourious Developer Master Race and Ignorant Users What Think Their CD Tray Is A Cup Holder.

Linux Desktop has been pandering to this imagined notion of an "average user" for decades and it still sucks.

Here's what needs to be done: make the system simple (not easy) enough that it can be reasoned about, something that someone can look at and comprehend and build a model of its functioning so they can conform how it functions to their needs without reading C source code and 40 different text-based file formats and out of date man pages. Stop being a Rube Goldberg machine of interconnected disparate components.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by greenbacon on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:05AM (#18679255)
I have a macbook pro at work since last year, OS X is slow as hell and iTerm2 (my main app usage) is very sluggy when you are used to Konsole (KDE terminal). But yes the laptop is pretty.

I'm impatient to be able to update my laptop for a X1 carbon and a speedy KDE.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by VvR-Ox on Friday December 14, 2018 @04:05AM (#18679476)
That is strange but I heard about apple products and software getting worse every day. (users seem to become beta-testers)

I have an old MBP (the one that has all the ports you'd including a standard HDMI, don't know what year) and never upgraded beyond osx mavericks - it runs fine until today.

A friend told me they use new MBPs @work and they seem to break much too often. I also tried the keyboard on his working machine to find out how bad it is nowadays! I prefer the oldschool thinkpad keyboard but was surprised by the keyboard on the old MBP. The new one's on the other hand are just a tool for torturing users who like to write much.

iTerm2 was my favourite because of the features (like intuitive tmux usage without learning it's CLI-foo). I also like how it is integrated with the rest of the desktop (searching, copy&paste, url-clicking etc.) but can't really compare to the default terminal emulator as I haven't used it much after trying iTerm2 when it was recommended by the whole world.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by lathiat on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:33AM (#18679372)
Have you considered just using the OSX Terminal?

It's been very good since like at least OSX 10.5 (when they added tabs) or so.

I always wonder why people use other terminals (but don't seem to use any of it's special features).

I'd be curious to see if you think it performs better.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by speedplane on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:49AM (#18679202)
> There is a few desktop environments that are quite good ... Unite!

This is happening. The web is becoming the de-facto desktop environment.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by js8 on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:11AM (#18679284)
Oh god no. It's one step forward, ten steps back.

Take a trivial example of desktop application integration, which is with us since Windows 3.11 - common file and printing dialog. Nothing standard like that on the web. Most web applications won't let you even export the data in editable format.

UI - horrible. Desktops had standard menus and shortcuts since 1980s. In fact, many SPAs are trying to invent their own desktop.

I could go on.. the fragmentation of web apps is so much larger than fragmentation of desktop apps.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by mirimir on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:53AM (#18679435)
Funny story.

So a few weeks ago, I'm sitting in the waiting room at my doctor's offices. And they seem to be running late. And the waiting room is filling up. So I go to the receptionist's window, and ask what's up.

Turns out that their ISP was having problems. And they were totally dead in the water. They had no local backup. And knew nothing. No patient data. No schedule. Nothing.

So hey, I just left, and rescheduled. But damn.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by pjmlp on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:05AM (#18679254)
Thing is, the Web as de-facto desktop environment is one reason less to even care about Linux's existence.

A browser could run bare metal for what I care.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by VvR-Ox on Friday December 14, 2018 @04:15AM (#18679528)
How exactly do you think you'll get your drivers working?

What do you do when the internet is crashed / your app is down?

I like the data-sync & backup part of web apps - you don't have to save etc. and your whole machine can just fall into a river but you still have your work. But I'd rather do this with a seperate solution and keep stuff on my PC so I can access it without a network.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by pjmlp on Friday December 14, 2018 @04:25AM (#18679564)
The same way that webOS, ChromeOS, FireFox OS and a couple of other attempts do.

By providing a minimal kernel for juggling browser instances, local file system and browser specific "native" APIs.

Welcome back to the timesharing days, just with prettier UIs.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by Piskvorrr on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:41AM (#18679869)
Um...well...can't say I'm overjoyed about that - the Good Old Times, whenever invoked, were rarely good if you happened to actually live in them^$#%$#NO CARRIER
Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by pjmlp on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:41AM (#18681085)
I should have placed a sarcastic remark.

It is however the pace how things are going, even most mobile apps are modern versions of those 2-tier apps during the 90s.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by VvR-Ox on Friday December 14, 2018 @04:10AM (#18679505)
I don't know... Besides big and tech savvy companies like the big G no one seems to be able to create a decent UI with consistent UX as you'd expect it from a good desktop environment.

I prefer using apps with ncurses interface to many web apps. Also the standards are not good enough for my demands. I've worked in web development and I know how tedious it is to re-implement the wheel for each and every user (at least it feels that way) because you have to ensure everything is rendered and works on 10 different browsers (different versions of course because who want's to update?). Also you have the devices (I don't even want to think about that) etc...

It is nearly 2k19 and still centering stuff with CSS seems to be a huge deal. That's just not very assuring for me.

Re:Fragmentation Is Why Desktop Linux Failed [video] by marmot777 on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:56AM (#18678755)
Yes, he essentially says we're on our way there but we have a few more years or so to go. The headline hyperbolic click bait.