News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by im_down_w_otp on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @03:36PM (#18667516)
I look at it through the lens of what they had available to them in terms of adjacent technology and capability compared to the present day.

For example, when I stand in front of an SR-71 Blackbird and consider that it was created w/ slide rules & Friden mechanical calculators. When sophisticated automated design and analysis tools like FEA and CFD were still far, far away. It conjures a narrative for me, true or not, that they seemed to do so much with so little, and by contrast we seem to do so little with so much. Which results in a crude emotional response that is some hybrid of awe & despair.

Then a few days goes by, and I snap out of it.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by exoesquitur on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @03:55PM (#18667677)
I think the newish perception that risk is unacceptable plays a part. I'm glad to see the "safety above exploration" mindset giving way a bit. Accidents are going to happen. Pioneers in dangerous endeavors understand this. It's good to see society remembering it as well.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @06:09PM (#18668518)
Whose risk? If we're talking risk of astronauts and test pilots, certainly--they know the dangers and they've decided it's worth it.

My worry is that people who think "move fast and break things" is a good business strategy are now starting to move into transport, medicine, and other fields where the lives of random citizens are on the line.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:10PM (#18669106)
>Whose risk?

Anyone's risk, even if there's no risk at all. Post on Reddit about how you replaced your own water heater and people will wag their finger at you for not having a licensed plumber do it all (as if the plumber would stop by the next day to check for leaks). People get off on trying to score virtue points virtue signaling about risk (not just on the internet, in real life too).

The Christmas tree (or do I have to call it a holiday tree because the "risk" of offending someone is too great) across the room from me might spontaneously catch fire. It probably won't happen so I don't care, that won't stop some anonymous stranger on the internet telling me I should use modern LED lights because they run cooler.

I understand not playing fast and loose with people's lives but the likelihood and magnitude of a possible bad outcome required to stall things has been getting smaller and smaller over the years and it makes getting anything and everything done more time consuming and costly. Before you could just put up a Christmas tree in the office if everyone wanted to, now you have to figure out if anyone could hypothetically be offended. Before you could just build a road or a bridge and deal with the environmental impact as it happens, now you have to do a study and account for the whereabouts of every drop of rainwater that will fall on whatever you're building before you even break ground.

There is a risk of a potential bad outcome inherit to everything. Somehow society has perverted itself into thinking that risk is a binary and all risk is bad and not work it.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by chopin on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:19AM (#18671767)
When I was a child we had a Christmas tree with real candles.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by squarefoot on Thursday December 13, 2018 @03:36AM (#18670789)
"If we're talking risk of astronauts and test pilots, certainly--they know the dangers and they've decided it's worth it."

Sensationalist journalism coupled with ability of the Internet to amplify the worst. If an astronaut died back then, maybe a few tabloids could have screamed in horror, while every other media would have depicted the tragedy as what it was: a highly trained professional who lost his life while doing something amazing but very dangerous whose risks he was well aware of. Today a tragic event like that one would produce such a level of trash that its effects could undermine political campaigns or have perfectly healthy businesses go belly up. It's just too risky.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by kibibu on Thursday December 13, 2018 @02:37AM (#18670519)
Like Uber killing somebody, for example.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by moftz on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:44PM (#18668024)
Things like the Blackbird seem really amazing but whats out there now is even more amazing. It's crazy they were able to do all of that back then with just hand tools. But now you could design the same thing sooner, cheaper, and make the thing perform much better. Computers have really advanced what we can make. Just the software from 10 years ago seems crude to what you can do now. Not everything needs to be a big black stealth plane to appreciate technological progress.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by borkt on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:53PM (#18668069)
Why is the F-35 program such a disaster then? Honest question though I am sure the answer is feature creep and poor management
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by ljf on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @05:18PM (#18668222)
IMHO - because it wasn't built with a goal or a reason. The amazing tech builds of the 60s were each made to fill a need or meet a goal. The F-35, how many goals it that supposed to meet? Easily more than 10. And it isn't great at any of them, in its quest to be OK for all of them...
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by cco on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @10:34PM (#18669682)
That's a major component and harbinger of a Dark Age, the loss of a functioning bureaucracy.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by tk75x on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:23PM (#18674678)
> functioning bureaucracy

Isn't that an oxymoron?

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by cco on Thursday December 13, 2018 @02:03PM (#18675026)
In case you aren't joking, it isn't at all. A highly functional bureaucracy allows a state to leverage scale in a way that less sophisticated governments just can't do. Infrastructure, military, R&D, and trade are all things that are hugely dependent upon a functioning bureaucratic state and crumble in the face of a non-functioning state.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by ghaff on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @05:27PM (#18668275)
And before that people complained about the various services having too many different projects dedicated to their own missions.

The F-35 seems to my non-expert eye to have been poorly conceived but creating a more versatile aircraft instead of a bunch of more specialized ones is not inherently a stupid idea.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by eptcyka on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @09:56PM (#18669544)
When it comes to the military, top gun wins. A specialized gun will top a non-specialized one in a given combat situation, all else being equal. Of course, the F-35 will be a great general purpose weapon against far less advanced targets, but if they are pitted against their Russian and Chinese counterparts, I don't believe they will fare all that great.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by gandhium on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:54AM (#18672667)
F-35 don't have any Russian and Chinese counterparts. They're all in design stage.

China may get to the mass-produced stage, but that's stil debatable, since they have issues with their engines.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by eptcyka on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:50AM (#18673155)
Yes, but is the F-35 a better interceptor than any of the contemporary fast jets that are in use by China or Russia?
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by gandhium on Thursday December 13, 2018 @02:38PM (#18675294)
It's not interceptor, it's a multi-role stealth fighter.

And still I'd say - yes, it's better.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by ljf on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @06:30PM (#18668633)
Yes, but any multi use tool will never be as good as a separate specialised one, so the question is really 'how good do we want to be'.

And for a military aircraft I guess the answer will always be 'really good'.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by mcpherrinm on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:26PM (#18669187)
I think this scene from the movie "Pentagon Wars" (1998) captures the idea. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by ajmurmann on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @09:05PM (#18669358)
Unfortunately the movie is based on real events. If you haven't read it, I recommend "Boyd - The future pilot who changed the art of war". It's entertaining and valuable and full of stories like this we something simple and practical though feature creep was turned into a mess.

Of course the design of the APC in your clip is only the opening of the disaster. Once it got to testing before the actual acquisition things got even more ridiculous to the point that I think people should have clearly been prosecuted for reason. But as Boyd said: You can either do something or be someone.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by bjelkeman-again on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @05:25PM (#18668269)
It is a requirements clusterf*ck
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by simonh on Thursday December 13, 2018 @03:25AM (#18670738)
Survivorship bias.

Did no technology programmes in the 60s fail or have limited success? All of them were complete triumphs?

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by rangibaby on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @10:06PM (#18669575)
it's actually a great success when you consider the true goal of the program, which is to spend taxpayer money
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by jasonparallel on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:08PM (#18669099)
Watch the movie pentagon wars
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by afterburner on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @07:47PM (#18668987)
They were throwing a lot of money at aerospace back in those days. Space race, Cold War, actual hot wars fought with US and Soviet equipment and expertise. The moon landing was a huge project too.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NASA-Budget-Federal.svg

Nowadays money gets thrown at other things, stuff is still happening.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by ajmurmann on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:42PM (#18669266)
I wonder how much of that also has to do with the cold war having lead to wasteful prestige and/or brute force projects. We really badly needed the SR-71. Space projects were often more about prestige and doing better than the enemy than scientific or economic value creation.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by colordrops on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @09:36PM (#18669460)
The SR-71 was classified for a while before the public became aware of it. I wouldn't be surprised if some of the tech that is still classified seems impossibly futuristic.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by FlyMoreRockets on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @11:55PM (#18669927)
I dunno, there are several SR-71s sitting outside with completely unrestricted access.

https://www.sr-71.org/blackbird/locations.php

Of course, they've been gutted of electronics and engines, but still, anybody can walk right up to one with calipers and a tape measure... Good luck affording that much titanium though. It's a PITA to form and weld, too.

Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by kibibu on Thursday December 13, 2018 @02:40AM (#18670528)
Well, from that list you know where to find at least 1 SR-71 worth of titanium.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by FlyMoreRockets on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:11AM (#18672787)
Avoid the pesky forming and welding tasks, too.
Re:Two abandoned Soviet space shuttles left in the Kazakh st... by colordrops on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:47PM (#18677206)
Re-read my comment: "was classified for a while". Not "is currently classified."