Throw in the article's [much more speculative] suggestions that pollsters' TV statements about the confidence of their results might have been influenced by their paying customers' strategies, and the suggestion Farage "conceded" whilst expecting to win because he wanted to bet against the people who trusted he was making an honest assessment based on good information. Neither would be likely to be illegal - people aren't obliged to be honest on TV and don't have fiduciary duties to holders of sterling - but both would be difficult to call ethical. That said, it's entirely plausible those individuals did honestly believe what they were saying at the time. Everybody expected it to be close, and as the article acknowledges, one of the reliable big pollsters' exit polls gave the wrong result.
Exit polls are held back not for trading purposes, but so that people go to the polls and vote. If people think they know the result they won't go through the hassle of voting.
If they didn't hold back exit polls (for the reason you've correctly stated) paying for priority access to polls would be a whole lot less useful for trading purposes anyway because instead of the big poll reveal at the close of voting all kinds of [partial] poll results would be accessible during the day. But as you've said all this exit polling data available would affect voter behaviour, especially in elections like the UK's with plenty of "tactical voting" going on
If a specific 800 people had changed their mind the tories wouldn't have been able to form a government even with DUP support
However the exit poll in 2017 was pretty much dead on
'Not permitted to be released, which they then used to trade'
It is impossible to legislate everything. People do things that are immoral, unethical and just plain wrong even if there is no law against it, and it's perfectly OK to call them out for it.
Do you really see this as an ethical issue? As far as I'm aware most laws around what information you can trade on aren't about morality, they're a pragmatic move to ensure a fat financial sector. By restricting the ways in which you can obtain information it opens the field for more players and more speculation. Reducing accuracy of prices in favour of robustness and liquidity.
Sure there's exceptions. One could argue that because they've made an agreement, there's a moral obligation for a company executive to look out for their shareholders interests and front-running trades that hurt them would be a dick move. Other situations though? A hedge fund buying polling information? There's no agreement they're breaking there. They're just beating competitors in a zero sum game, with the externality being that markets are more accurate than they otherwise would have been.
Did we read the same article?
Farage "twice told the world on election night that Leave had likely lost, when he had information suggesting his side had actually won..."
"feeding specious sentiment into markets..."
"he laughed about helping to push the pound higher ahead of its crash, a role he seemed to relish. "'Yeah, and a good thing—good thing'"
The obvious answer is that intentionally spreading disinformation to move markets is unethical.
Certainly, you should complain to the lawmakers because without making it a legal rule, choosing not to do the unethical thing isn't going to stop others from doing it. But that doesn't make it right to do it yourself!
This is Ethics 101...
It's a grey zone whether releasing the private poll data broke the law.
What seems clear is the law hasn't caught up with the technological realities.
Also the other main point of the article was that it is questionable whether it is appropriate to use polling data to influence the markets, like Farage has potentially done.
They claim he knew which way it way going, contrary to public data. It's also clear that he was one of the figureheads of the Leave campaign, and thus his concession would carry weight.
One could see how this might be interpreted as a form of manipulation. It's not claimed in the article, but he could well have talked up Sterling in order to short it at a better level.
How is this a 'technological progress' problem? Exit polls existed before this law as did phones. Polling agencies have been able to release data before polls close for the better part of a century.
This is just a vague poorly-worded law.
They have an incentive to release inaccurate results to the public in order to benefit their private clients even further.
Every few years, polls get verified against reality at the ballot box. If you're running a polling company, would you want to sell your market research as the company whose polls were some way off the votes they'd just seen counted because you were trying to influence the electorate?
The classic example is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0ZZJXw4MTA
Push polls aren’t even polls. They’re just advertising.
However, the utility of a "push" poll goes up closer to the vote, because voters will have less opportunity to review and correct misimpressions that the poll gave them. Hence the time between polls goes to zero as time to the vote approaches zero, and why some governments feel that they have to step in to create a prohibited window before a vote.
Also, a traditional definition of a "push" poll is one that is meant to change the minds of the people taking the poll, but more effective in many circumstances, and definitely more common (because it is cheaper) is a poll which uses strange phrasing to get results that can be reported (after being carefully framed in a press release) in a way that implies far greater support or opposition for something that would be indicated by a more direct questioning. The fact that every vote is to some extent a Keynesian beauty contest, even if that's simply because people are convinced by ad populum and question themselves if they see that the crowd disagrees with them, means that even an "objective" poll would push.
Tracking polls aren’t for informing some secret cabal, or even to inform. It’s the horse race. It sells papers. But there’s nothing biased about “Is the country on the right track, or the wrong track?”
I mean, how expensive was all that Cambridge Analytica stuff in comparison to how much money could be made from this?
EDIT: Also by analysing FX market movements in relation to polling in the weeks and months leading up, it wouldn't be hard to make a correlation between Leave and lower priced GBP. All the economic institutions were saying Leave would be bad for the UK economy, so a leave vote is bound to shake confidence in GBP.
Edit: because the direction of the trades would be publicly visible and highly correlated with the poll results.
The reason publishing poll results is forbidden because they could affect the outcome of the election. If you do polls only for private use that's not the case.
I love stuff like this. Finance is an art.
The point of many trading laws is to prevent trading based on non public information. Privately conducted polls on political votes is definately non-public information, and in order for them to trade based on them they should publish first, which would likely also deminish the returns since suddenly they aren’t the only ones aware of the public/poll disconnect.
>prevent trading based on non public information
You completely misunderstand what inside trading means. Inside trading prevents company insiders from trading with the company they work for. Insider trading laws are there to protect shareholders.
It's completely fine to use non public information about world events to trade.
How people voted is not insider information.
Are we talking about unauthorised access of information or something else?
I don't believe it is legal for outsiders to make trades based on non-public information they have acquired from company insiders. For example, if I am the CFO of a publicly traded company, I cannot come to you and whisper in your ear that we just got hit with a massive data breach, because doing so would give you the opportunity to dump your stocks based on that non-public information.
In the US insider trading laws are geared around protecting shareholders from insiders. Solving for the agency problem. In that case an outsider who finds non-public data and trades on it is likely (though the complexity of this is one of the downsides of the regine) not insider trading.
In many European regimes the goal is information parity. In that case outsiders can generate material non-public data, and thus illegally trade on it.
As someone who spent a lot of time under the US regime the European model blows my mind, but in objective terms there isn’t anything bizarre about it.
It does seem (more than) a little bizarre to me.
If I understand your post correctly, in Europe, I could do traffic counts at malls, conclude (correctly) something about a company's sales from that, trade profitably based on that conclusion, and be prosecuted successfully for it?
If that's the case, how should I create my own opinion about the state of a company in order to decide how much to bid (or ask) for the shares of that company? Am I just supposed to blindly make investments since any amount of private research is bound to be deemed illegal? It seems that the entire purpose of research is to generate an informed opinion which differs from the current public opinion.
We've found hedge funds placing orders with the presumed intention of deriving order volume information from sequential IDs that we inadvertently leaked in the shipping process (since fixed). My view is "good on them for thinking of it!" Is trading based on that illegal as well?
As for where the lines are drawn I’d guess there is a whole industry around determining that just like in the States.
It’s definately not ok to trade based on insider information. Doesn’t matter if you just heard from you cousin who’s the CEO of a company that they are about to tank or reach for the moon. You might not work for the company but you are still guilty of trading on non-public insider information.
Polls are information about the environment where companies operate, not non-public fact regarding the plans or condition of a publicly traded company.
Matt Levine (highly recommend) spends time discussing this type of thing.
A recent somewhat relevant article https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-12-03/inside...
The savvy prediction of events exogenous to a company’s operations is very much not insider trading.
[1] It’s a little more complicated, but I think this is as good a succinct formulation as one can hope for.
This is entirely legal. Indeed, there's arguments to be made that this should be encouraged, since it indirectly provides a financial incentive for people to do research into firms and keep the market fully informed. Of course, you have to have a very specific savvy to gain from that kind of scheme, but still.
Fraudulent market manipulation is illegal (such as that based on fabricated or material nonpublic information). Market manipulation when based on good-faith information discovered legally is entirely legal.
And it wasn’t insider trading because the reports didn’t include new non-public information. If he had information about for instance he outcome of a phase 3 drug trial and bought based on it And then released the results early he would have been breaking the law.
In other words, if pharma company A is doing research on a drug and is publishing stuff, and organization B is also doing similar work (and to simplify, let's say they aren't public, they're a private research lab that isn't related to company A), if org B finds evidence that company A is wrong, they can short A then publish. (and this is pretty much exactly what happened with brexit)
I don't know where exactly this gets to when shorting competitors. In other words, if Pfizer and Merck are both rushing to get the same compound/drug trialed and onto the market, and Pfizer is running ahead of Merck, but finds that their drug fails in phase 3, they obviously can't short themselves, but they might be able to short Merck, because they don't actually have any MNP about Merck's trial.
But again, I'm not really sure how that works in general.
So asking a representative subset of Tesla’s employees what their numbers are going to be prior to reveal is not insider trading? If that’s the case then I need to start gathering fundes enough to pay them for the info and make a huge bet.
But, say, inferring that a retailer will do well by counting cars in the parking lot or doing customer polls would be fine in the US. The customers can talk all they want.
(Not legal advice. I get this from Matt Levine, who is also not a lawyer.)
It’s worth noting that if you got that information by virtue of working for a company that did such research, and that company had a policy preventing you from sharing that information, then you could be found guilty of insider trading, under the misappropriation theory.
Laws forbade publishing exit pools until 10pm, so hedge funds conducted their own research independently to have better information.
That's kind of how it is supposed to work.
Bad laws/regulations preventing accurate information dissemination lead to financial incentives for those with the most accurate/up-to-date data.
I know HN isn't the most Hedge Fund friendly forum, but surely there's an appreciation here for these funds' efficiency and ability to seize opportunity.