News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by naringas on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:36PM (#18603793)
digital property should not work under exclusive principles (unlike physical property which has to).

to force exclusionary constrains upon digital property means we choose to abandon one of the key advantages of digital information.

it means we favor owning things over being free.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by rayiner on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:54PM (#18603917)
Why not? There is more merit to exclusive ownership of digital property than physical property. My entitlement to my yard is pretty comical—that land was there a billion years before I was born and will be there a billion years after I’m dead. But Captain Marvel? That’s a thing that only exists in the universe due to the labor of certain humans. Why shouldn’t they own it?
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by harryh on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:52PM (#18604268)
A person can enforce ownership of their physical property by themselves. Intellectual property enforcement requires the massive power of the state.

One might argue that we should prefer a world in which that sort of massive power is used sparingly.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by sonnyblarney on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:10PM (#18604965)
"A person can enforce ownership of their physical property by themselves"

Except in reality, you don't. The state very strongly enforces your property rights that's a good chunk of why the police exist, and most people do not own guns.

The OP argument is not unreasonable.

To wit: in Canada, there is actually no enshrined right to own property. The far left party opted to keep it out of the new constitution written in the 1980's so Trudeau Sr. was forced to keep it out if we were to have a new constitution at all. So it's an intellectual concept.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by harryh on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:48PM (#18605143)
I'm not sure if I completely agree with "Except in reality, you don't."

In some sense I enforce ownership of my house just by living here. Someone is here most of the time. The lights are on. There is activity. That keeps others out.

If I just abandoned the place, eventually someone might poke their head in and see if there was anything to take. Sure, that would be illegal, but the cops aren't going to post a guard for me under most circumstances.

You actually see this happen in downtrodden neighborhoods where whole blocks get abandoned. In theory that property is still owned by someone, but without anyone actually there, eventually houses get stripped of valuable goods and in some cases squatters move in.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensible_space_theory is an academic theory of this point of view.

Another good example is house sitters. When traveling for extended periods of time, people will let trusted 3rd parties stay in their house for free. Why? Enforcement of property ownership.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by sonnyblarney on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @11:40AM (#18609857)
If there were no state, your 'occupation' of the residence would be meaningless, guys with guns would take it from you.

It's feudal based on hard power in one way or another.

The way it's set up now is the cops enforce a common set of rules we agree upon.

You don't have the power to enforce your property rights. Nobody really does.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by harryh on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @01:16PM (#18610876)
Again, I don't think that's really true historically. Even in pre-state societies or in present day societies with failed or weak states people still have homes that they live in consistently from day to day.

Sure, sometimes the dudes with guns show up and force them out, but that isn't a constant occurrence.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by elefanten on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:59PM (#18605381)
Yeah but well before your presence is a relevant factor in preventing squatters, everyone in the whole equation has long been socialized to understand that you can't take other people's stuff without dire physical consequences. That is 100% the power of the state and 0% you.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by harryh on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @08:00AM (#18607810)
I don't think that's true either.

When my 3yo kid takes a toy from another kid without asking and I tell him he has to give it back, that's socialization and that's not the state.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by boombust on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @11:28AM (#18609714)
dude, how hard is this to understand? if a group of dudes with guns were to rock up to your house and say 'get out, this is our house now', you would not be able to do shit unless you somehow go john wick on them. the monopoly of violence and enforcement of rules within a territory (a state) is the foundation necessary for property rights.

just because we don't walk on all fours and smell urine for information doesn't mean that we would not revert back to aggression and dominance if you remove all manmade recourses for settling disputes and enforcing property rights. why on earth would you think people would respect ownership of goods when you can just take what you want through intimidation? all ordered systems are at the mercy of entropy and it takes effort (i.e. the state) to maintain such order. it only takes one person to step out of line in times of anarchy for others to realise that it makes no sense to cooperate and follow rules when there is no one to enforce them, sending the whole system back into chaos.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by mLuby on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:05PM (#18604330)
Seems awfully close to "might makes right".
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by fungi on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:02PM (#18604646)
bc you are manufacturing scarcity and enabling rent seeking which is a pointless tax on humanity as a whole for the benefit of a few.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by rayiner on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:03PM (#18605191)
"Rent seeking" is by definition trying to extract payments ("rent") from value you didn't create. Charging for access to value that results solely from your act of creation (like "Captain Marvel") is literally the opposite of rent seeking.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by fjsolwmv on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:31PM (#18605696)
Aren't you a lawyer? Copyright is a textbook example of rent seeking. After the first copy is sold, restricting re-copying is rent seeking: extracting money without adding more value.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by rayiner on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @01:24AM (#18606082)
Show me a textbook that uses that example, because it would be a shitty textbook. You’re not creating additional value after the first sale, but you’re also not recovering the full market value of the creation from the first sale. Imagine painting the Sistene Chapel and charging $10 a pop to see it. Is that rent seeking?
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by fjsolwmv on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:25PM (#18605680)
You are conflating physical property with real property (aka real estate, land)
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by naringas on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:58PM (#18603959)
because it's a slippery slope that seems to constantly slide away from liberty and towards property for most of civilization's history.

there's gotta be some equilibrium, which is precisely why copyright was originally intended to be a temporary thing.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by cestith on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:06PM (#18604671)
Temporary, yes, and it should also have certain exceptions.

Exceptions should include things like reverse engineering for making compatible accessories or compatible competitive products. They should include fair use for critique and criticism. They should include the right to resell your property and to repair or customize your own copy of a property. There are probably valid and important exceptions I'm not listing.

During that limited term and subject to those exceptions though copyright should be solidly enforced. Otherwise the people creating things will just be ripped off wholesale by people who do nothing but rip them off and relabel things.

Now, I think the copyright term is far too long. It is especially too long for abandoned works. I'd like to see something akin to trademark rules applied to copyright, in which if you're not offering a work or a work directly derived from it for X years the term ends early. The maximum term should be a bit shorter than it is for the specific work, too, but I think suing people for copying or modifying something you are no longer willing to sell them is asinine.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by wpietri on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:30PM (#18604160)
It's an interesting principle, but if you want people to adopt it, I think you have to show how the benefits are greater than the costs.

America's first copyright law goes back to 1790, or about 200 years before most people owned computers. It was adopted because people saw benefit in rewarding the people who created books and maps. We've extended IP protection over the years for reasons bad and good.

If you want to get rid of that, you need to explain how we'll get the same or better benefits with your approach. Because from my perspective supporting the current system means means I favor writers and musicians and researchers and artists getting paid for the good things they create over abstract principles.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by waddlesworth on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:49PM (#18604251)
I don't necessarily agree with the parent, but the current system supports publishers, journals and rights-holders far more than it does artists and researchers.

Until we have a popular means of paying artists directly, or self-publishing, this will continue to be the case.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by wpietri on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @09:40AM (#18608531)
Sure. Some of that's illegitimate, but some of it definitely isn't. Publishers do valuable things too. For example, writer John Scalzi here answers the question of why he doesn't self-publish:

https://whatever.scalzi.com/2015/05/25/about-that-deal/

(See under "Why are you sticking with traditional publishing!")

And I'll note that in addition to the obvious functions of editing, marketing, talent development, and vendor management, they also provide capital. One could say correctly that it's perfectly possible for software to all be sold by single individuals. But most software is produced by companies, quite a lot of whom take up-front investment.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by TimJYoung on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @12:21PM (#18610311)
We do have ways of self-publishing or paying creators directly: the internet. Anyone can pop up a web site and start selling their wares with minimal fuss. It costs a couple of thousand bucks to set up an internet-based company in the US, with the majority of the money going to incorporation. Payment processing services, payroll services, tax/accounting services, hosting services, etc. are all super-cheap and don't require a lot of work.

Sometimes I have to stop myself from constantly grumbling "kids these days...", but wow, I'm seeing a lot of young people erecting mental barriers to acting on their dreams and aspirations. It's never been easier to make money in this country, but you have to a) put in the hours, b) stop giving away your stuff for free, and c) manage your expectations - nobody is saying that you're going to win the lottery by becoming the next Google or FB.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by contras1970 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:04PM (#18604660)
> America's first copyright law [...] was adopted because people saw benefit in rewarding the people who created books and maps.

that seems contrary to wikipedia:

The 1790 Act [...] specifically noted that it did not prohibit copying the works of foreign authors.

it seems obvious the act was meant to reward some people. please drop the humanistic angle, it's simply not there.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by elefanten on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:13PM (#18605430)
It can be humanistic and nationalist at the same time. I think that's actually a good way of reconciling the common narrative you hear from either side.

It can be intended to spur creativity and innovation (and do so) while also being captured and circumscribed by different interests (in different ways over time).

This would include big identity-based interests, like nationality or ethnicity, that have been relevant in the history of this country (and every country).

It can be economically productive and unfair at the same time. So, do you work to make it more inclusive and target the benefits better? Or do you give it all up, the good with the bad?

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by kodablah on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:06PM (#18604013)
> it means we favor owning things over being free.

That statement lacks a lot of nuance and presents it as a binary, mutually exclusive choice. Absolutist stances like this don't help the situation which is rife with many use cases that are and aren't valid. You can have this as a general principle you prefer, but it cannot work as an hard-fast rule for all digital properties.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by lghh on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:12PM (#18604060)
Nuance does not make something more right or more wrong. You can be absolution on a topic and still have as much thought and care put into that position as someone with a laundry list of exceptions to either side of the argument.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by kodablah on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:48PM (#18604859)
Well of course, ironically that general statement is true sometimes. But in this case, I think a general, absolute stance on digital ownership is folly.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by naringas on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:11PM (#18604056)
I agree... I really advocate for an equilibrium between property and liberty.

But throurough my short life on earth I've perceived a stronger pull towards property which (again, seeking equlibrium) makes me use a more extreme language in support of the other viewpoint... counterbalance.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by news_to_me on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:15PM (#18604380)
I hope you find, as you get older, that it's better to strongly advocate a balanced and considered message, rather than a simple but extreme one. Extreme positions may be more emotionally satisfying, but they bring a host of long-term disadvantages. An easy example of this is the current division in US politics due to extreme positioning.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by zanny on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:42PM (#18604840)
Copyright is much like serfdom in my reflection - its a system I have tried to consider both sides of, and no matter how I think about it the ends never justify the means.

In my experience its no different than the hyperbolic policy of hiring people to fill in holes someone else dug. Its a market built on fiction to feed the special interests that profit from it.

And my position has just grown more extreme in the last decade - I originally thought compromise had to be right because copyright has become so pervasive so relatively fast in human history it might have had merit. But in the day to day action of actually creating information in myriad forms and interacting with it I can't obscure the reality that none if it is meant to benefit anyone but a select few who built (or in modern times dramatically expanded) their temple to IP to feed their own greed.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by fjsolwmv on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:33PM (#18605703)
How do you propose people be compensated for creative work? Who would spend a year on a project if they could only sell one copy for $15?
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by TimJYoung on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @12:07PM (#18610171)
Yes, I would like someone here to provide an answer to this question.

For example: We're just wrapping up a new release of one of our products that I've been working on since August of 2017. It has over 1400 hours of work dedicated to it (single developer - myself). There's no way that we could possibly dedicate that amount of time to a software project without knowing that we could recoup the costs.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by zanny on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @02:35PM (#18611675)
The trick is almost all creatives are already paid in the model most fitting the production of information - people that want the fruits of their labor pay them to make it. Very few software engineers, for example, are living off copyrighted sold copies of the software they wrote. The company they work for might, or some other knob in the chain, but for 99% of us we are not directly using copyright as our source of income - someone else is.

And that is the trick. People want software. We threw this extra, pointless step in the middle between "people C want X software" and "pay people D to make X" in the form of "have publishers / corporations P pay people D to make X to sell to C".

Every conservation on this always functionally boils down to "but that is so different from the way thing are now!" which of course it is. Its the same reason why the market for prohibited drugs is so much more convoluted, dangerous, and disconnected from regular commerce - you make things more complicated, like criminalizing posesssion of the good, or enabling the profiteering off information, and the market will warp to both meet demand and maximize profit using the framework the government provides to do so.

Its really no different from how you are told to get started in music or art or even how to get a job programming. You make stuff for free to start out to get a portfolio of work proving you know what you are doing. Once you can prove your ability you ask for money to make more, be it words, art, designs, code... its how the world has worked for all time. It is only in the last two hundred years this model of "make stuff and ask for money later with the backing power of the state" perverted commerce. And all of us commoners never even got to benefit. We still work in classical employment. We still need to do the work for free to prove we can make more information in the future. We still get paid for our time, not the fruits of our labor. Which is fine - its how the whole rest of the economy works!

There is only one scarce thing in the creation of new ideas and that is your time. You should be charging for it. Its all thats worth anything in the equation of creativity. Most people do charge for it with salaries. The world still predominantly runs in tandem with reality. Its only a very few people who get to throw a state backed wrench into economics to rent seek already made ideas.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by TimJYoung on Thursday December 06, 2018 @12:26PM (#18620078)
So, how is getting paid for one's time any different from being paid for the value of one's labor ? Do you think that economic theory doesn't apply in that case, and that, somehow, a person isn't going to just simply demand a huge salary that results in the same compensation ?

And how to you prevent someone from just creating a piece of software, keeping it to themselves, and then charging others if they want a private copy of it ? Are you going to demand that software developers release their code to the public, and enforce that through the state ?

What about live performances ? Are you going to mandate that performers invoice each person in attendance for their time ?

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by naringas on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:48PM (#18604574)
I suppose the tricky thing about advocating a balanced message in this specific topic is that nobody really knows what a good working equilibrium should be regarding these issues.

I mean, it's a contentious issue for China and the USA...

My view on the matter is that us (as global humans in a global civilization) have yet to figure out how to strike a balance in this world with an Internet.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by claudiawerner on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:46PM (#18604554)
On the other hand, plenty of well educated people seem to grow up and reach the opposite conclusion - that the only solution to some endemic problems, which keep occurring despite changes in leadership, is a radical one. Simplicity sometimes is the best solution.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by contras1970 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:55PM (#18604612)
the radical, out-of-balance and ill-considered message was mainstream not that long ago. it's only seen as "extreme" by some because the Overton window has moved considerably. case in point: US politics.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by amelius on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:03PM (#18603992)
> to force exclusionary constrains upon digital property means we choose to abandon one of the key advantages of digital information

You forget that another key advantage of digital information is that we can have a digital economy.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by claudiawerner on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:46PM (#18604559)
I'm skeptical of the idea that this is an advantage.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by naringas on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:06PM (#18604011)
I am more interested in being free than having an economy.

then again, I speak as a human being, not as a profit motivated institution.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by fossuser on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:14PM (#18604081)
These arguments are pretty weak and end up doing more harm than saying nothing.

There are strong arguments in favor of limiting copyright as it was originally intended (in the US constitution at least). Where the limited time monopoly exists to incentivize people to create, but where the goal is to promote the progress of science and useful arts for the public benefit.

Long term ownership and control can stifle science and art with owners shutting down tenuously connected derivative work.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by TimJYoung on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @12:28PM (#18610374)
I need to ask you an honest question: have you every run your own business ?

If not, you should try it, it's a really eye-opening experience that will give you really valuable insight into the world that we live in. The one thing that you will learn is that we are all creatures of the environment we operate in, and very few of us actually have economic/political power that extends very far, so one should always be very careful about ascribing ulterior motives to other people. Most of the time, people just want to make a decent amount of money so that they can have a nice life with their families.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by TimJYoung on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @11:51AM (#18610001)
Which is fine, but don't be surprised if the majority of the people choose to do other things and not produce the very thing that you want produced.

Jaron Lanier talks about this a lot in his books and speaking engagements, and I would highly recommend his books for a better perspective.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by hopefulengineer on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:51PM (#18603898)
why would any company invest in R&D if it could just be immediately taken for free?
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by kingraoul3 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:54PM (#18603916)
Because their competitors are doing so, and would be able to outcompete them at the point of sale based on price.
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by wetpaws on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:54PM (#18603918)
Something something open source
Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by rudolph9 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:02PM (#18603986)
The idea is stealing is not a black and white concept. Stealing something digital generally has very different effects than stealing something physical.

For example, if someone the software I own without my permission and doesn’t give it back; I loose out on revenue I would have otherwise received from them. If someone uses the car I own without my permission and doesn’t give it back; I am out thousands of dollars, I have no means to get to work, and no means of purchasing groceries.

Stealing is not black and white and rules and regulations should reflect that.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by mLuby on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:15PM (#18604382)
What?! Stealing is a super simple concept: what the owner will not give, the thief takes anyway.

You could try to argue theft in contexts where the owner's willingness to give is ambiguous is not clear-cut (eg taking one piece of candy from the jar is fine but taking all the candy is theft), but that's ambiguity in communication and cultural convention, not in the concept of theft itself.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by Nasrudith on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:18PM (#18605007)
Really it isn't stealing in intellectual content period - it is infringement. There are many groups conflating the two but they have very distinct meanings.

In order for something to be stolen it must be taken away. If you make an award winning painting and hang it on your mantleplace and I paint a perfect copy of it that doesn't mean that it is suddently missing from your house. I may have devalued it and I certainly would have infringed but not stolen anything.

Even ownership has such radically different meanings between the two they probably shouldn't have the same word. There is a vast space of things that nobody owns called the public domain. Saying you can't own a chair would be a bizarre invasion of rights. It doesn't matter how long chairs have been around - the fact it existed in the wood age doesn't mean you can no longer own one.

Saying that you own the concept of all chairs and all must pay tribute is a downright bizarre megalomania. They have existed from the wood age and long before any current civilizations were even alive - to claim exclusive ownership of something so universal and ancient is absurd.

Intellectual property isn't a natural right by any means - it is a pragmatic policy granted by governments meant to serve a purpose. It operates based upon treaties in the first place.

A hypothetical newly discovered underwater civilization copying from our airwaves would not be cause for military intervention. The same underwater civilization robbing freighters for cargo would be cause for intervention.

Re:China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft by readbeard on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @12:13AM (#18605826)
You’re right—the use of the term “intellectual property” has muddled public discourse on this important issue.

Society as a whole benefits from a robust system of copyright, trademarks and patents to incentivize art and innovation. But just as too weak a system will slow innovation by making it less financially viable, too strong a system will slow innovation by making it harder and more expensive to build new things out of old ones. We need to strike a balance, but the popular notion that ideas and expressions are strongly analogous to real property will likely lead to policies that are, on balance, harmful.


That IP law in the U.S. was conceived of as an economic incentive issue—and not an ethical one—is strongly suggested in the “copyright clause” of the U.S. Constitution, which grants Congress the power “To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.” [0]

Thomas Jefferson elaborated on his own views on IP in a letter to Isaac McPherson in 1813 [1]:

“He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me. That ideas should freely spread from one to another over the globe, for the moral and mutual instruction of man, and improvement of his condition, seems to have been peculiarly and benevolently designed by nature, when she made them, like fire, expansible over all space, without lessening their density in any point, and like the air in which we breathe, move, and have our physical being, incapable of confinement or exclusive appropriation. Inventions then cannot, in nature, be a subject of property. Society may give an exclusive right to the profits arising from them, as an encouragement to men to pursue ideas which may produce utility, but this may or may not be done, according to the will and convenience of the society, without claim or complaint from anybody.”

To reiterate a bit of what you said, if “intellectual property” is not property at all, it cannot be stolen—only infringed upon. And the difference is important because whereas theft is a violation of natural law, infringement is a violation of the rules of a specific society.

China is a different society and it has different rules. If we want to make respecting our country’s copyrights, trademarks and patents a precondition of trade, that seems like a good idea—but we should just say that. The drama of calling it “theft” is unnecessary and wrong.

By the way, I recently read and recommend “Intellectual Property: A Very Short Introduction” [2] by Siva Vaidhyanathan for an all-around introduction to intellectual property.

[0] https://fairuse.stanford.edu/law/us-constitution/

[1] http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_8s12....

[2] https://global.oup.com/academic/product/intellectual-propert...