News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by bussierem on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:21PM (#18590548)
When there have already been numerous well-documented instances of people making false accusations that absolutely RUIN THE LIVES of the defendants, it can hardly be a surprise that people with a lot to lose would take drastic, if ill-though-out, measures to protect themselves from that possibility. As another comment said, even when the false accusations are found to be false, it's usually too late for the defendant, and their life has already been ruined. The only way this gets fixes is if we stop implicitly believing people who accuse someone of a crime, just because of the nature of that crime. Innocent until proven guilty applies globally, not based on context or scandals.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by jklinger410 on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:28PM (#18590654)
"It is better 100 guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer"
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by danesparza on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:25PM (#18590611)
Numerous? Well-documented? I don't mean to be inflammatory -- but I must reading different news that you are. Can you please cite your sources?

To be clear: Numerous (to me) means approaching 20% of all accusations. That's only 1 in every 5 accusations. Does numerous mean something else to you?

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by wrs on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:29PM (#18590679)
I’m wondering if this is something like the numerous and well-documented instances of child kidnapping that have kept a generation of kids from being allowed outside by themselves.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by YorkshireSeason on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:38PM (#18590807)

    Can you please cite your sources?
There is no serious, solid research on this question. "News" is certainly not where you can get serious figures on this matter.

Even the very definitions of what counts as sexual harassment / assault / rape / hate speech etc are deeply controversial. A most prominent example are radical feminists like Dworkin who essentially say that all heterosexual intercourse is rape.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by repolfx on Monday December 03, 2018 @02:36PM (#18592146)
There is such research actually. Look at the studies by Kanin, Jan, and their replications. The topic of what proportion of allegations are false is studied from time to time, but not often, because the studies that are done usually report eye-wateringly high figures.

In the UK, official government research put the figure at 10% of all (rape) accusations being false. But if you read the reports, you'll see that the true figure must be much higher, as the methodology reclassifies lots of data points to avoid them being considered false.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by YorkshireSeason on Monday December 03, 2018 @03:12PM (#18592453)
This is interesting, and coheres with my working hypotheses about this subject. I'm planning to write a paper about this subject.

Which paper do you mean by Jan and what replications have you got in mind? And where do you recommend I look for the UK figures?

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by repolfx on Monday December 03, 2018 @04:25PM (#18593221)
Sure. Here are some citations if you want to do further research.

A word of warning. I've found that there is a shocking rate of lying about these studies, both in other academic papers and the media. Moreover you have to read the papers carefully because they're often written by people with an explicit agenda (to minimise the false reporting rate - exception is Kanin who appers to have no agenda). You really have to watch out and not take any claims at face value, even when they'd appear to be in credible reports from credible sources. It's very sad but it appears that in a rather meta way, the topic of false reports of rape is dogged by false reports about studies of false reports about rape!

The idea that the rate of false reporting is very high is probably once of the most controversial and dangerous topics in our society today. If you write your paper you are very likely to be attacked for it, at least if your paper is based on police report data. Good luck!

Kanin, 1994

https://ia800209.us.archive.org/4/items/FalseRapeAllegations...

He reviews police reports for every single rape allegation in an unnamed American town, selected because the police department had the time and resources to investigate every allegation thoroughly. In 41% of the cases, the allegation was false. In this study, for a report to be considered false the accuser had to agree it was false. Thus the true rate must be higher, as there was no real incentive for the women to admit they lied to the police. The study provides data on the motives for why the false allegations were made.

Note the appendix. The original Kanin study was done on an unnamed American town. In the appendix they replicate the findings in a US university. Actually the percentage there is slightly higher at exactly 50% false reports (admitted false by the accuser).

The data Kanin provides on why false allegations are made has been replicated by the Dutch police:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/313830325_Motives_f...

This Dutch replication doesn't examine the percentage of all claims that are false, just the motives for cases proven false.

Jan Jordan, 2004

http://www.d.umn.edu/cla/faculty/jhamlin/3925/4925HomeComput...

This study examines New Zealand police reports and replicates Kanin, by finding a 41% false reporting rate. The paper is horrendously biased, but nonetheless contains useful ground truth data about the NZ police conclusions in a large number of rape reports. The breakdown is:

- Genuine cases, 21%

- Uncertain/insufficient evidence, 38%

- Police investigated and concluded the complaint was false, 33%

- The complainant themselves said their own report was false, 8%

If we add together 33% and 8% we get 41%.

The paper goes into a lot of detail if you're looking for material.

Finally, the UK study is here:

https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110218141141/ht...

It states that in 9% of cases the claims were considered false by the police. This is quite far off Kanin and Jan, so what's going on? Again, it requires careful reading. About 20% of all reports are "no crimed", that is, the police classify the report as "no crime occurred". This classification is intended for very narrow and unusual situations like the original report being made accidentally, but the prevalence shows it's not being used like that. The UK has put considerable pressure on its police to always 'believe the victim' etc, and they appear to have come up with this way to minimise the number of reports classified as false. It should be clear that if someone files a report of rape (which can't really be accidentally reported), and the police conclude no crime occurred, this is the same thing as a false report. These two categories take the UK to 29%. Lower than Jan and Kanin but still very high. The missing chunk is probably the category where the accuser withdrew their police report so investigation did not continue. These reports may or may not be false. This study also contains some data on motives.

One theme that crops up in quite a few of these papers is that when police officers are interviewed and asked to estimate the rate of false reports, they give rates in the 40-50% range. In media reports you will frequently see a rate of 2% being quoted, so this is an exceptionally large difference in perception between journalists writing about the topic and police who deal with it. The UK study has some anonymised quotes from police talking about the problem.

There are many posts in this discussion thread stating that men are wrong to worry because "the statistics prove false allegations are not a problem". That claim appears to be false: replicated studies show the problem is vastly larger for rape than any other crime (false report rate for murder is ~2%). Men are probably right to be wary.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by YorkshireSeason on Monday December 03, 2018 @05:02PM (#18593559)
Thanks. That's super useful. I had not seen the UK studies you mention.

Shockingly, the UK government document you cite explicitly suggests "Expanding the concept of ‘real rape’".

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by CiPHPerCoder on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:49PM (#18590955)
> A most prominent example are radical feminists like Dworkin who essentially say that all heterosexual intercourse is rape.

That's a stupid argument. Can we please not equivocate exceptionally dumb arguments with serious ones?

(Also, while we basically live in a post-satire society, I still like to call Poe's Law on exceptionally dumb arguments.)

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by neaden on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:25PM (#18590618)
Hey, can you show me some of these well documented instances? The Duke Lacross case gets brought up a lot, but all those guys were exonerated and as far as I'm aware doing fine. Kavanaugh just got appointed to the Supreme Court and Lois C.K is popping up to do comedy sets, so I'm curious to see these many well documented cases you refer to.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by jerf on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:30PM (#18590686)
Even accepting your cited cases as the limit (which they are not), I can't accept being nationally and universally condemned and smeared for months or years on end despite being innocent as a perfectly acceptable outcome for a baseless accusation. I suspect you'd be a lot less flippant about how everything turned out fine if you'd be in any of their positions.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by tomp on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:30PM (#18590689)
A few outhers are: Oxford Union president, Jian Gomeshi, "The Mattress Girl".
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by neaden on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:35PM (#18590764)
I'm not familiar with the Oxford Union president. Jian Gomeshi was credibly accused, the fact that he was found not guilty does not mean his accuser was false. I don't know why you include Emma Sulkowicz, I know of no evidence at all that she falsely accused someone. Also Jian Gomeshi is writing articles for the New York Review of Books and the man Emma Sulkowicz accused graduated, so neither of their lives were ruined.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by SpicyLemonZest on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:47PM (#18590927)
The idea that Ghomeshi was “credibly accused” is rather the point. In the only cases that went to court, he was found not guilty, and the judge went on quite a tangent about how the witnesses had lied to and hid evidence from the court.

If that’s not enough to clear his name, how can anyone ever escape the stain of a credible accusation? It seems prudent given that problem to ensure that no accusation will be credible.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by dvlsg on Monday December 03, 2018 @01:44PM (#18591599)
Witnesses for which side? Or was it both sides?
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by SpicyLemonZest on Monday December 03, 2018 @02:03PM (#18591791)
For the prosecution. The accusers had all continued flirting with (and in one case sleeping with) Ghomeshi after the alleged assaults. One lied about it, and the other two didn't bring it up until the defense got hold of their emails.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by TomVDB on Monday December 03, 2018 @01:16PM (#18591279)
Ultimately, I don't think the percentage of cases really matter: we have a tendency to have an irrational fear of things that have a very low probability. (Like child abduction etc.)

I don't think this is any different. The chance of being falsely accused is probably very small, but I know I'd absolutely crushed, both mentally and physically (lack of sleep for months in a row) if it happened to me. Even if, a year or two later, they'd clear my name. It's sufficient to have just a few high profile cases to increase that fear.

That doesn't mean that I'd go out of my way to avoid hiring women...

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by ryandrake on Monday December 03, 2018 @03:27PM (#18592579)
This is risk impact 101. Risk = probability x impact. Even when the probability is small (false accusations), the huge potential impact can result in large overall risk.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by xiphias2 on Monday December 03, 2018 @04:16PM (#18593118)
The damage is not simply probability x impact, as it's also important to limit the potential downside. When a person or company pays for insurance, it increases the average damage in return for decreasing the variance.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by gsich on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:33PM (#18590753)
A case in Germany: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J%C3%B6rg_Kachelmann Alice Schwarzer (german feminist) accused him even after he was found not guilty. Had to pay a fine because of that.

Again Germany: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gina-Lisa_Lohfink

The matress stuff: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbia_University_rape_contr...

But we know of those only because they were public figures or have been carried out in public. You don't hear about the private ones.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by neaden on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:49PM (#18590954)
From your wikipedia link on the Columbia case. "Three other complaints have been alleged against Nungesser: a second woman accused him of emotional abuse and nonconsensual sex during a months-long relationship, a third student accused him of non-consensually kissing her and touching her at a party, and a fourth accuser emerged in early 2015, a fourth-year male student who said Nungesser sexually assaulted him after an emotional conversation." Oh yeah, this guy sounds like a real peach whose life was turned upside down by a false accusation.

Also people here really seem to be assuming any case where someone is found not guilty means the accusation was false, which is not how it works. Just ask OJ Simpson.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by gsich on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:56PM (#18591041)
We don't know if those other complaints are true.

>Also people here really seem to be assuming any case where someone is found not guilty means the accusation was false, which is not how it works. Just ask OJ Simpson.

For a third person this is kinda how it works.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by briandear on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:38PM (#18590803)
Duke Lacrosse might be “doing fine” now, but while it was happening they certainly weren’t doing fine. Kavanaugh made it to the court, but for the rest of his term, he’s under a cloud. What happened to Kavanaugh was brutal. Just because someone survived the ordeal does lessen the fact that it happened at all.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by neaden on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:48PM (#18590935)
Just to be clear, you know he almost certainly did it right? Dr. Ford came forward before he was nominated. Also he has full time security guards now and gets welcomed with standing ovations, whereas Dr. Ford keeps having to move because of all the death threats and hasn't been able to go back to her job.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by repolfx on Monday December 03, 2018 @02:35PM (#18592134)
Is that true? I thought her claims were investigated in detail and found to be clearly false, with witnesses she said were there saying they had no clue what she was talking about and remembered no such party, her own testimony contradicted itself, etc. And then the fact that she waited decades to do anything about it.

The last I heard about Kavanaugh he'd been totally exonerated. There's no reason to believe he did anything to this woman.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by neaden on Monday December 03, 2018 @03:42PM (#18592749)
No, that is not what happened. Her claims were briefly investigated, there was only one other witness, Mike Judge, and he was not questioned. No one else remembers that specific party but they all agreed that it was the kind of thing get together they would have gone too, her testimony was consistent, and lots of assault victims wait a long time before coming forward. So you managed to be wrong about everything.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by sk4rekr0w on Monday December 03, 2018 @04:20PM (#18593161)
This is an entirely unfair representation of what happened.

First, his name was Mark Judge not "Mike" Judge - so get off the high horse about being factually correct when you can't even get one name right.

Zero corroborating eyewitnesses, zero recollection of the location of the "party" from 35 years ago.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by SpicyLemonZest on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:55PM (#18591022)
If you were in Kavanaugh’s position, and you didn’t do it, how would you go about clearing your name?
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by neaden on Monday December 03, 2018 @01:03PM (#18591130)
Well to start I wouldn't have gone up and said a bunch of easily verifiable lies where I claiming boofing meant farting and that I threw up a lot during beach week because I have a sensitive stomach. I wouldn't have had a temper tantrum where I complain about how the Clinton's were somehow behind it. I would have encouraged an FBI investigation into things and encouraged them to speak to the only other witness, Mark Judge.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by FilterSweep on Monday December 03, 2018 @01:47PM (#18591631)
You’d have to start under the presumption that he didn’t do it.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by votepaunchy on Monday December 03, 2018 @02:39PM (#18592157)
> Dr. Ford came forward before he was nominated.

You know that Kavanaugh was shortlisted by Romney during the 2012 presidential campaign? Predating Dr. Ford's timeline for documenting the alleged abuse during therapy.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by neaden on Monday December 03, 2018 @03:41PM (#18592731)
I mean if your theory is that she just randomly picked someone from Romney's shortlist of Supreme Court judges and decided to expose herself to a whole bunch of death threats, vileness, and potentially lose her job in the thought that it would discredit him I guess that's theoretically possible. It goes against logic and human nature and compared to the alternate hypothesis of a drunk teenager did something inappropriate it's very unlikely.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by votepaunchy on Saturday December 08, 2018 @09:32PM (#18638881)
You do realize that she went public with accusations after Trump’s nomination of Kavanaugh? What happened years ago was only privately documented.
Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by sk4rekr0w on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:32PM (#18590736)
The Duke Lacrosse players were crucified - 88 professors signed a letter vilifying them before any meaningful evidence. PROFESSORS - the arbiters of the scientific standard. Imagine if there wasn't exonerating evidence.

People refer to Kavanaugh as a rapist when he wasn't even accused of rape. 50% (or more) of the country still thinks of him as such. His family and children received death threats.

The case of Brian Banks is an example that should meet your standard. Black man with a potential professional football career goes to jail, DNA evidence exonerates years later.

Your past is still vital to who you are, both in your own eyes and in the eyes of others. Your comment is ignorant of the trauma that these circumstances bring to the accused - if you can have empathy for the victim, you should be able to carry the same empathy for the accused.

Re:Wall Street Rule for the #MeToo Era: Avoid Women at All Cost by CelestialTeapot on Monday December 03, 2018 @12:39PM (#18590828)
"When there have already been numerous well-documented instances of people making false accusations that absolutely RUIN THE LIVES of the defendants"

*Citation needed on that claim.

The reality is that "false" sexual assault/harassment claims are around 2% to 10%. And that number is likely higher than reality because some law enforcement agencies will call a claim "false" simply because they could not find enough corroborating evidence. [1]

If anything, there is a disincentive to report sexual harassment/assault, because the victim has HISTORICALLY been victimized again in the media. The vast majority of sexual assault crimes go unreported because of this and other reasons. [2, 3]

[1] https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/03/health/sexual-assault-false-r...

[2] https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/vnrp0610.pdf

[3] https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-compassion-chron...